{"id":"total-chess-budapest-2026/van-foreest-vs-aronian-round-1","slug":"van-foreest-vs-aronian-round-1","title":"Van Foreest vs Aronian, Round 1","h1":"Van Foreest vs Aronian, Total Chess Budapest 2026 Round 1: Aronian beats Van Foreest with Black in 31 moves","pgn":"[Event \"2026 Total Chess World Championship Tour Pilot Group A\"]\n[Site \"Budapest, HU\"]\n[Date \"2026.11.11\"]\n[Round \"01\"]\n[White \"Van Foreest, Jorden\"]\n[Black \"Aronian, Levon\"]\n[Result \"0-1\"]\n[WhiteElo \"2715\"]\n[BlackElo \"2719\"]\n[WhiteTitle \"GM\"]\n[BlackTitle \"GM\"]\n[WhiteFideId \"1039784\"]\n[BlackFideId \"13300474\"]\n[TimeControl \"2700+30\"]\n[Board \"2\"]\n[ECO \"C26\"]\n[Opening \"Vienna Game: Falkbeer Variation\"]\n\n1. e4 e5 2. Nc3 Nf6 3. d4 exd4 4. Qxd4 Nc6 5. Qd3 d5 6. Bf4 dxe4 7. Qxd8+ Nxd8 8. Bxc7 Ne6 9. Be5 Ng4 10. Bg3 f5 11. Bb5+ Bd7 12. Bxd7+ Kxd7 13. O-O-O+ Kc6 14. Nge2 Bc5 15. Nd5 Rad8 16. Nec3 Rhe8 17. b4 Bd4 18. f3 Nf6 19. fxe4 Nxe4 20. Nxe4 fxe4 21. c4 b5 22. Kc2 bxc4 23. Nc3 e3 24. Ne2 Bf6 25. a4 h5 26. Rhf1 h4 27. Be1 Rxd1 28. Kxd1 Rd8+ 29. Kc2 Rd3 30. b5+ Kb6 31. Nf4 Nd4+ 0-1","review":{"white":"Jorden van Foreest","black":"Levon Aronian","event":"Total Chess World Championship Tour Pilot 2026","site":"Budapest, Hungary","date":"2026.11.11","round":"1","result":"0-1","whiteelo":"2715","blackelo":"2719","opening":"Vienna Game: Falkbeer Variation"},"intro":"Round 1, Group A: Aronian beat Van Foreest with Black in 31 moves, turning an early queen trade in the Vienna Game into a winning endgame.","summary":"Welcome to Budapest for round 1 of Group A at Total Chess, where Jorden van Foreest has White against Levon Aronian. The game starts as a Vienna Game, and the queens come off as early as move 7. Aronian wins with Black, and the way Black's pieces slowly take over a level-looking endgame is well worth following.","evals":[19,22,20,8,8,-10,11,-10,-10,-10,0,0,18,24,10,21,17,16,23,6,3,0,8,0,0,9,10,0,3,-27,-51,-253,-173,-272,-385,-291,-376,-396,-405,-422,-420,-236,-416,-253,-279,-443,-482,-531,-539,-577,-581,-643,-567,-652,-364,-613,-417,-624,-674,-677,-628,-851,-1015],"moments":[{"ply":31,"san":"16. Nec3","kind":"inaccuracy","drop":17},{"ply":54,"san":"27...Rxd1","kind":"inaccuracy","drop":12},{"ply":55,"san":"28. Kxd1","kind":"inaccuracy","drop":11}],"notes":[{"ply":1,"san":"1.e4","quality":"good","text":"Van Foreest opens with 1.e4, the most direct start: the pawn grabs the centre and frees the queen and the light-squared bishop. Black's most natural answer is...e5.","best":"c2c4","script":{"say":"Van Foreest opens with 1.e4, the most direct start: the pawn grabs the centre and frees the queen and the light-squared bishop. Black's most natural answer is...e5.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":158,"until":164,"brush":"green","from":"e7","to":"e5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"1.c4","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 1","depth":65,"score_cp":19,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"c4","uci":"c2c4","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/2P5/8/PP1PPPPP/RNBQKBNR b KQkq - 0 1","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"e5","uci":"e7e5","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pppp1ppp/8/4p3/2P5/8/PP1PPPPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 2","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"g3","uci":"g2g3","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pppp1ppp/8/4p3/2P5/6P1/PP1PPP1P/RNBQKBNR b KQkq - 0 2","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/4p3/2P5/6P1/PP1PPP1P/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 1 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bg2","uci":"f1g2","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/4p3/2P5/6P1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK1NR b KQkq - 2 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bc5","uci":"f8c5","fen_after":"rnbqk2r/pppp1ppp/5n2/2b1p3/2P5/6P1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK1NR w KQkq - 3 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"1.Nf3","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 1","depth":65,"score_cp":14,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g1f3","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/8/5N2/PPPPPPPP/RNBQKB1R b KQkq - 1 1","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"e6","uci":"e7e6","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pppp1ppp/4p3/8/8/5N2/PPPPPPPP/RNBQKB1R w KQkq - 0 2","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"e4","uci":"e2e4","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pppp1ppp/4p3/8/4P3/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQKB1R b KQkq - 0 2","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"d5","uci":"d7d5","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/4p3/3p4/4P3/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQKB1R w KQkq - 0 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"exd5","uci":"e4d5","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/4p3/3P4/8/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQKB1R b KQkq - 0 3","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"exd5","uci":"e6d5","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/8/3p4/8/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQKB1R w KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":2,"san":"1...e5","quality":"best","text":"Aronian answers 1...e5, the classical reply. Black claims an equal share of the centre straight away, and White's usual next step is to bring out a knight to c3.","best":"e7e5","script":{"say":"Aronian answers 1...e5, the classical reply. Black claims an equal share of the centre straight away, and White's usual next step is to bring out a knight to c3.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":155,"until":161,"brush":"green","from":"b1","to":"c3"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"1...c6","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/4P3/8/PPPP1PPP/RNBQKBNR b KQkq - 0 1","depth":60,"score_cp":27,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"c6","uci":"c7c6","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pp1ppppp/2p5/8/4P3/8/PPPP1PPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 2","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"d4","uci":"d2d4","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pp1ppppp/2p5/8/3PP3/8/PPP2PPP/RNBQKBNR b KQkq - 0 2","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"d5","uci":"d7d5","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pp2pppp/2p5/3p4/3PP3/8/PPP2PPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"e5","uci":"e4e5","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pp2pppp/2p5/3pP3/3P4/8/PPP2PPP/RNBQKBNR b KQkq - 0 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"c5","uci":"c6c5","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pp2pppp/8/2ppP3/3P4/8/PPP2PPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g1f3","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pp2pppp/8/2ppP3/3P4/5N2/PPP2PPP/RNBQKB1R b KQkq - 1 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"1...c5","score":"White is a little better","line":{"fen":"rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/4P3/8/PPPP1PPP/RNBQKBNR b KQkq - 0 1","depth":60,"score_cp":32,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"c5","uci":"c7c5","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pp1ppppp/8/2p5/4P3/8/PPPP1PPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 2","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g1f3","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pp1ppppp/8/2p5/4P3/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQKB1R b KQkq - 1 2","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nc6","uci":"b8c6","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/pp1ppppp/2n5/2p5/4P3/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQKB1R w KQkq - 2 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bb5","uci":"f1b5","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/pp1ppppp/2n5/1Bp5/4P3/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQK2R b KQkq - 3 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"e6","uci":"e7e6","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/pp1p1ppp/2n1p3/1Bp5/4P3/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQK2R w KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"O-O","uci":"e1h1","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/pp1p1ppp/2n1p3/1Bp5/4P3/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQ1RK1 b kq - 1 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":3,"san":"2.Nc3","quality":"good","text":"2.Nc3 is the Vienna Game. White develops the queenside knight first and keeps the f-pawn free for later ideas. Black will answer by developing the other knight.","best":"g1f3","script":{"say":"2.Nc3 is the Vienna Game. White develops the queenside knight first and keeps the f-pawn free for later ideas. Black will answer by developing the other knight.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":132,"until":160,"brush":"green","from":"g8","to":"f6"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"2.Nf3","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"rnbqkbnr/pppp1ppp/8/4p3/4P3/8/PPPP1PPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 2","depth":55,"score_cp":20,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g1f3","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pppp1ppp/8/4p3/4P3/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQKB1R b KQkq - 1 2","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nc6","uci":"b8c6","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/pppp1ppp/2n5/4p3/4P3/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQKB1R w KQkq - 2 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bb5","uci":"f1b5","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/pppp1ppp/2n5/1B2p3/4P3/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQK2R b KQkq - 3 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/1B2p3/4P3/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQK2R w KQkq - 4 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"O-O","uci":"e1h1","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/1B2p3/4P3/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQ1RK1 b kq - 5 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":6,"san":"Nxe4","uci":"f6e4","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n5/1B2p3/4n3/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQ1RK1 w kq - 0 5","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"2.Bc4","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"rnbqkbnr/pppp1ppp/8/4p3/4P3/8/PPPP1PPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 2","depth":55,"score_cp":11,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bc4","uci":"f1c4","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pppp1ppp/8/4p3/2B1P3/8/PPPP1PPP/RNBQK1NR b KQkq - 1 2","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/4p3/2B1P3/8/PPPP1PPP/RNBQK1NR w KQkq - 2 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nc3","uci":"b1c3","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/4p3/2B1P3/2N5/PPPP1PPP/R1BQK1NR b KQkq - 3 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nc6","uci":"b8c6","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/2B1P3/2N5/PPPP1PPP/R1BQK1NR w KQkq - 4 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"d3","uci":"d2d3","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/2B1P3/2NP4/PPP2PPP/R1BQK1NR b KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bb4","uci":"f8b4","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/1bB1P3/2NP4/PPP2PPP/R1BQK1NR w KQkq - 1 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":4,"san":"2...Nf6","quality":"best","text":"2...Nf6 develops and puts pressure on the pawn on e4 at once. A healthy, active choice, and White now wants to open the centre with d4.","best":"g8f6","script":{"say":"2...Nf6 develops and puts pressure on the pawn on e4 at once. A healthy, active choice, and White now wants to open the centre with d4.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":26,"until":135,"brush":"red","from":"f6","to":"e4"},{"type":"arrow","at":132,"until":135,"brush":"green","from":"d2","to":"d4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"2...Nc6","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"rnbqkbnr/pppp1ppp/8/4p3/4P3/2N5/PPPP1PPP/R1BQKBNR b KQkq - 1 2","depth":60,"score_cp":10,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nc6","uci":"b8c6","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/pppp1ppp/2n5/4p3/4P3/2N5/PPPP1PPP/R1BQKBNR w KQkq - 2 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g1f3","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/pppp1ppp/2n5/4p3/4P3/2N2N2/PPPP1PPP/R1BQKB1R b KQkq - 3 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/4P3/2N2N2/PPPP1PPP/R1BQKB1R w KQkq - 4 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"d4","uci":"d2d4","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/3PP3/2N2N2/PPP2PPP/R1BQKB1R b KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"exd4","uci":"e5d4","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/8/3pP3/2N2N2/PPP2PPP/R1BQKB1R w KQkq - 0 5","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nxd4","uci":"f3d4","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/8/3NP3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R1BQKB1R b KQkq - 0 5","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"2...Bc5","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"rnbqkbnr/pppp1ppp/8/4p3/4P3/2N5/PPPP1PPP/R1BQKBNR b KQkq - 1 2","depth":60,"score_cp":23,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bc5","uci":"f8c5","fen_after":"rnbqk1nr/pppp1ppp/8/2b1p3/4P3/2N5/PPPP1PPP/R1BQKBNR w KQkq - 2 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g1f3","fen_after":"rnbqk1nr/pppp1ppp/8/2b1p3/4P3/2N2N2/PPPP1PPP/R1BQKB1R b KQkq - 3 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"d6","uci":"d7d6","fen_after":"rnbqk1nr/ppp2ppp/3p4/2b1p3/4P3/2N2N2/PPPP1PPP/R1BQKB1R w KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"d4","uci":"d2d4","fen_after":"rnbqk1nr/ppp2ppp/3p4/2b1p3/3PP3/2N2N2/PPP2PPP/R1BQKB1R b KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"exd4","uci":"e5d4","fen_after":"rnbqk1nr/ppp2ppp/3p4/2b5/3pP3/2N2N2/PPP2PPP/R1BQKB1R w KQkq - 0 5","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nxd4","uci":"f3d4","fen_after":"rnbqk1nr/ppp2ppp/3p4/2b5/3NP3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R1BQKB1R b KQkq - 0 5","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":5,"san":"3.d4","quality":"good","text":"3.d4 is a rare and direct idea: Van Foreest opens the centre right away instead of building slowly. Black can simply take the pawn.\n\nOn the board: The quieter way.","best":"f1c4","script":{"say":"3.d4 is a rare and direct idea: Van Foreest opens the centre right away instead of building slowly. Black can simply take the pawn.","show":[{"title":"The quieter way","line":{"fen":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/4p3/4P3/2N5/PPPP1PPP/R1BQKBNR w KQkq - 2 3","depth":55,"score_cp":8,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White could also have developed calmly with 3.Bc4 instead of opening the centre.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bc4","uci":"f1c4","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/4p3/2B1P3/2N5/PPPP1PPP/R1BQK1NR b KQkq - 3 3","comment":"3.Bc4 develops the bishop to an active diagonal and keeps the tension.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nc6","uci":"b8c6","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/2B1P3/2N5/PPPP1PPP/R1BQK1NR w KQkq - 4 4","comment":"3...Nc6 brings out the other knight.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"d3","uci":"d2d3","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/2B1P3/2NP4/PPP2PPP/R1BQK1NR b KQkq - 0 4","comment":"4.d3 supports the pawn on e4 and keeps the game solid.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White could also have developed calmly with 3.Bc4 instead of opening the centre.","takeaway":"Opening the centre with d4 is sharper; the calm bishop move keeps more pieces in play."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":117,"until":131,"brush":"green","from":"e5","to":"d4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"3.Bc4","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/4p3/4P3/2N5/PPPP1PPP/R1BQKBNR w KQkq - 2 3","depth":55,"score_cp":8,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bc4","uci":"f1c4","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/4p3/2B1P3/2N5/PPPP1PPP/R1BQK1NR b KQkq - 3 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nc6","uci":"b8c6","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/2B1P3/2N5/PPPP1PPP/R1BQK1NR w KQkq - 4 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"d3","uci":"d2d3","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/2B1P3/2NP4/PPP2PPP/R1BQK1NR b KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Na5","uci":"c6a5","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/n3p3/2B1P3/2NP4/PPP2PPP/R1BQK1NR w KQkq - 1 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bb3","uci":"c4b3","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/n3p3/4P3/1BNP4/PPP2PPP/R1BQK1NR b KQkq - 2 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bb4","uci":"f8b4","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/pppp1ppp/5n2/n3p3/1b2P3/1BNP4/PPP2PPP/R1BQK1NR w KQkq - 3 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"3.Nf3","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/4p3/4P3/2N5/PPPP1PPP/R1BQKBNR w KQkq - 2 3","depth":55,"score_cp":3,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g1f3","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/4p3/4P3/2N2N2/PPPP1PPP/R1BQKB1R b KQkq - 3 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nc6","uci":"b8c6","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/4P3/2N2N2/PPPP1PPP/R1BQKB1R w KQkq - 4 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/4P3/2N2N1P/PPPP1PP1/R1BQKB1R b KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bb4","uci":"f8b4","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/1b2P3/2N2N1P/PPPP1PP1/R1BQKB1R w KQkq - 1 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nd5","uci":"c3d5","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/3Np3/1b2P3/5N1P/PPPP1PP1/R1BQKB1R b KQkq - 2 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nxd5","uci":"f6d5","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/pppp1ppp/2n5/3np3/1b2P3/5N1P/PPPP1PP1/R1BQKB1R w KQkq - 0 6","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"3.a3","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/4p3/4P3/2N5/PPPP1PPP/R1BQKBNR w KQkq - 2 3","depth":55,"score_cp":0,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a3","uci":"a2a3","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/4p3/4P3/P1N5/1PPP1PPP/R1BQKBNR b KQkq - 0 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nc6","uci":"b8c6","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/4P3/P1N5/1PPP1PPP/R1BQKBNR w KQkq - 1 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g1f3","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/4P3/P1N2N2/1PPP1PPP/R1BQKB1R b KQkq - 2 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"d5","uci":"d7d5","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/3pp3/4P3/P1N2N2/1PPP1PPP/R1BQKB1R w KQkq - 0 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"exd5","uci":"e4d5","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/3Pp3/8/P1N2N2/1PPP1PPP/R1BQKB1R b KQkq - 0 5","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nxd5","uci":"f6d5","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n5/3np3/8/P1N2N2/1PPP1PPP/R1BQKB1R w KQkq - 0 6","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":null},{"ply":6,"san":"3...exd4","quality":"best","text":"3...exd4 takes the offered pawn, the computer's top choice. Now White has to win it back, and the queen does it at once.\n\nOn the board: The grabbing reply.","best":"e5d4","script":{"say":"3...exd4 takes the offered pawn, the computer's top choice. Now White has to win it back, and the queen does it at once.","show":[{"title":"The grabbing reply","line":{"fen":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/4p3/3PP3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R1BQKBNR b KQkq - 0 3","depth":50,"score_cp":86,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black also had the central strike 3...d5, which the computer rates less well.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"d5","uci":"d7d5","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/ppp2ppp/5n2/3pp3/3PP3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R1BQKBNR w KQkq - 0 4","comment":"3...d5 hits the pawn on e4 at once.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"dxe5","uci":"d4e5","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/ppp2ppp/5n2/3pP3/4P3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R1BQKBNR b KQkq - 0 4","comment":"4.dxe5 takes a pawn, but Black has a tactic ready.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nxe4","uci":"f6e4","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/ppp2ppp/8/3pP3/4n3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R1BQKBNR w KQkq - 0 5","comment":"4...Nxe4 takes back and attacks the knight on c3.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Qxd5","uci":"d1d5","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/ppp2ppp/8/3QP3/4n3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR b KQkq - 0 5","comment":"5.Qxd5 grabs a pawn, but White's queen is out early and Black's pieces are quickly developed.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Black also had the central strike 3...d5, which the computer rates less well.","takeaway":"A quick strike in the centre only works when your pieces are ready for the trades that follow."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":112,"until":120,"brush":"green","from":"d1","to":"d4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"3...d6","score":"White is a little better","line":{"fen":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/4p3/3PP3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R1BQKBNR b KQkq - 0 3","depth":50,"score_cp":42,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"d6","uci":"d7d6","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/ppp2ppp/3p1n2/4p3/3PP3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R1BQKBNR w KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g1f3","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/ppp2ppp/3p1n2/4p3/3PP3/2N2N2/PPP2PPP/R1BQKB1R b KQkq - 1 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nbd7","uci":"b8d7","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppn1ppp/3p1n2/4p3/3PP3/2N2N2/PPP2PPP/R1BQKB1R w KQkq - 2 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rg1","uci":"h1g1","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppn1ppp/3p1n2/4p3/3PP3/2N2N2/PPP2PPP/R1BQKBR1 b Qkq - 3 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"g6","uci":"g7g6","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppn1p1p/3p1np1/4p3/3PP3/2N2N2/PPP2PPP/R1BQKBR1 w Qkq - 0 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Be3","uci":"c1e3","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppn1p1p/3p1np1/4p3/3PP3/2N1BN2/PPP2PPP/R2QKBR1 b Qkq - 1 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"3...Bd6","score":"White is a little better","line":{"fen":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/4p3/3PP3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R1BQKBNR b KQkq - 0 3","depth":50,"score_cp":58,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bd6","uci":"f8d6","fen_after":"rnbqk2r/pppp1ppp/3b1n2/4p3/3PP3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R1BQKBNR w KQkq - 1 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bg5","uci":"c1g5","fen_after":"rnbqk2r/pppp1ppp/3b1n2/4p1B1/3PP3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R2QKBNR b KQkq - 2 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"h6","uci":"h7h6","fen_after":"rnbqk2r/pppp1pp1/3b1n1p/4p1B1/3PP3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R2QKBNR w KQkq - 0 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bh4","uci":"g5h4","fen_after":"rnbqk2r/pppp1pp1/3b1n1p/4p3/3PP2B/2N5/PPP2PPP/R2QKBNR b KQkq - 1 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"O-O","uci":"e8h8","fen_after":"rnbq1rk1/pppp1pp1/3b1n1p/4p3/3PP2B/2N5/PPP2PPP/R2QKBNR w KQ - 2 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":6,"san":"Nge2","uci":"g1e2","fen_after":"rnbq1rk1/pppp1pp1/3b1n1p/4p3/3PP2B/2N5/PPP1NPPP/R2QKB1R b KQ - 3 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":7,"san":"4.Qxd4","quality":"best","text":"4.Qxd4 recaptures with the queen. Material is level again, but the queen stands in the open early, and Black can gain time with a knight move.","best":"d1d4","script":{"say":"4.Qxd4 recaptures with the queen. Material is level again, but the queen stands in the open early, and Black can gain time with a knight move.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":128,"until":142,"brush":"red","from":"b8","to":"c6"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"4.Nd5","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/8/3pP3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R1BQKBNR w KQkq - 0 4","depth":34,"score_cp":-52,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nd5","uci":"c3d5","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/3N4/3pP3/8/PPP2PPP/R1BQKBNR b KQkq - 1 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxd5","uci":"f6d5","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/8/3n4/3pP3/8/PPP2PPP/R1BQKBNR w KQkq - 0 5","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"exd5","uci":"e4d5","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/8/3P4/3p4/8/PPP2PPP/R1BQKBNR b KQkq - 0 5","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bb4+","uci":"f8b4","fen_after":"rnbqk2r/pppp1ppp/8/3P4/1b1p4/8/PPP2PPP/R1BQKBNR w KQkq - 1 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bd2","uci":"c1d2","fen_after":"rnbqk2r/pppp1ppp/8/3P4/1b1p4/8/PPPB1PPP/R2QKBNR b KQkq - 2 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bxd2+","uci":"b4d2","fen_after":"rnbqk2r/pppp1ppp/8/3P4/3p4/8/PPPb1PPP/R2QKBNR w KQkq - 0 7","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"4.Nb5","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/8/3pP3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R1BQKBNR w KQkq - 0 4","depth":34,"score_cp":-102,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nb5","uci":"c3b5","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/1N6/3pP3/8/PPP2PPP/R1BQKBNR b KQkq - 1 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bb4+","uci":"f8b4","fen_after":"rnbqk2r/pppp1ppp/5n2/1N6/1b1pP3/8/PPP2PPP/R1BQKBNR w KQkq - 2 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bd2","uci":"c1d2","fen_after":"rnbqk2r/pppp1ppp/5n2/1N6/1b1pP3/8/PPPB1PPP/R2QKBNR b KQkq - 3 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bxd2+","uci":"b4d2","fen_after":"rnbqk2r/pppp1ppp/5n2/1N6/3pP3/8/PPPb1PPP/R2QKBNR w KQkq - 0 6","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Qxd2","uci":"d1d2","fen_after":"rnbqk2r/pppp1ppp/5n2/1N6/3pP3/8/PPPQ1PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 0 6","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"a6","uci":"a7a6","fen_after":"rnbqk2r/1ppp1ppp/p4n2/1N6/3pP3/8/PPPQ1PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":8,"san":"4...Nc6","quality":"best","text":"4...Nc6 develops with a gain of time, because the knight attacks the queen on d4. The queen has to move, probably to d3.","best":"b8c6","script":{"say":"4...Nc6 develops with a gain of time, because the knight attacks the queen on d4. The queen has to move, probably to d3.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":57,"until":120,"brush":"red","from":"c6","to":"d4"},{"type":"arrow","at":114,"until":120,"brush":"green","from":"d4","to":"d3"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"4...a6","score":"White is a little better","line":{"fen":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/8/3QP3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR b KQkq - 0 4","depth":40,"score_cp":47,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a6","uci":"a7a6","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/1ppp1ppp/p4n2/8/3QP3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR w KQkq - 0 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bg5","uci":"c1g5","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/1ppp1ppp/p4n2/6B1/3QP3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 1 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nc6","uci":"b8c6","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/1ppp1ppp/p1n2n2/6B1/3QP3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 2 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Qe3","uci":"d4e3","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/1ppp1ppp/p1n2n2/6B1/4P3/2N1Q3/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 3 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"h6","uci":"h7h6","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/1ppp1pp1/p1n2n1p/6B1/4P3/2N1Q3/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bxf6","uci":"g5f6","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/1ppp1pp1/p1n2B1p/8/4P3/2N1Q3/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 0 7","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"4...d6","score":"White is a little better","line":{"fen":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/8/3QP3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR b KQkq - 0 4","depth":40,"score_cp":57,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"d6","uci":"d7d6","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/ppp2ppp/3p1n2/8/3QP3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR w KQkq - 0 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bf4","uci":"c1f4","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/ppp2ppp/3p1n2/8/3QPB2/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 1 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nc6","uci":"b8c6","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2np1n2/8/3QPB2/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 2 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Qd2","uci":"d4d2","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2np1n2/8/4PB2/2N5/PPPQ1PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 3 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"a6","uci":"a7a6","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/1pp2ppp/p1np1n2/8/4PB2/2N5/PPPQ1PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"O-O-O","uci":"e1a1","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/1pp2ppp/p1np1n2/8/4PB2/2N5/PPPQ1PPP/2KR1BNR b kq - 1 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":9,"san":"5.Qd3","quality":"best","text":"5.Qd3 steps back to a safer square, where the queen still guards the pawn on e4. Aronian will strike in the centre with d5.","best":"d4d3","script":{"say":"5.Qd3 steps back to a safer square, where the queen still guards the pawn on e4. Aronian will strike in the centre with d5.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":77,"until":123,"brush":"yellow","square":"e4"},{"type":"arrow","at":120,"until":123,"brush":"green","from":"d7","to":"d5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"5.Qc4","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/8/3QP3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR w KQkq - 1 5","depth":42,"score_cp":-12,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Qc4","uci":"d4c4","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/8/2Q1P3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR b KQkq - 2 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bb4","uci":"f8b4","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/8/1bQ1P3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR w KQkq - 3 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Ne2","uci":"g1e2","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/8/1bQ1P3/2N5/PPP1NPPP/R1B1KB1R b KQkq - 4 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"O-O","uci":"e8h8","fen_after":"r1bq1rk1/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/8/1bQ1P3/2N5/PPP1NPPP/R1B1KB1R w KQ - 5 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":5,"san":"Bg5","uci":"c1g5","fen_after":"r1bq1rk1/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/6B1/1bQ1P3/2N5/PPP1NPPP/R3KB1R b KQ - 6 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"h6","uci":"h7h6","fen_after":"r1bq1rk1/pppp1pp1/2n2n1p/6B1/1bQ1P3/2N5/PPP1NPPP/R3KB1R w KQ - 0 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"5.Qa4","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/8/3QP3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR w KQkq - 1 5","depth":42,"score_cp":-23,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Qa4","uci":"d4a4","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/8/Q3P3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR b KQkq - 2 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bb4","uci":"f8b4","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/8/Qb2P3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR w KQkq - 3 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bd3","uci":"f1d3","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/8/Qb2P3/2NB4/PPP2PPP/R1B1K1NR b KQkq - 4 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"d5","uci":"d7d5","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/3p4/Qb2P3/2NB4/PPP2PPP/R1B1K1NR w KQkq - 0 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Ne2","uci":"g1e2","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/3p4/Qb2P3/2NB4/PPP1NPPP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 1 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"dxe4","uci":"d5e4","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/8/Qb2p3/2NB4/PPP1NPPP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 0 8","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":10,"san":"5...d5","quality":"good","text":"5...d5 strikes back in the centre. The pawn on e4 is now attacked by both the pawn and the knight on f6, and the game is about level.\n\nOn the board: Developing instead.","best":"f8c5","script":{"say":"5...d5 strikes back in the centre. The pawn on e4 is now attacked by both the pawn and the knight on f6, and the game is about level.","show":[{"title":"Developing instead","line":{"fen":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/8/4P3/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR b KQkq - 2 5","depth":45,"score_cp":-10,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black could also have developed the bishop first.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bc5","uci":"f8c5","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/2b5/4P3/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR w KQkq - 3 6","comment":"5...Bc5 puts the bishop on its natural diagonal.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bf4","uci":"c1f4","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/2b5/4PB2/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 4 6","comment":"6.Bf4 develops with an eye on the pawn on c7.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"d6","uci":"d7d6","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/ppp2ppp/2np1n2/2b5/4PB2/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 7","comment":"6...d6 shuts the bishop's line and defends the pawn.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Black could also have developed the bishop first.","takeaway":"Pushing d5 is more ambitious: Black fights for the centre at once."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":74,"until":133,"brush":"red","from":"d5","to":"e4"},{"type":"arrow","at":101,"until":133,"brush":"red","from":"f6","to":"e4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"5...Bc5","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/8/4P3/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR b KQkq - 2 5","depth":45,"score_cp":-10,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bc5","uci":"f8c5","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/2b5/4P3/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR w KQkq - 3 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bf4","uci":"c1f4","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/2b5/4PB2/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 4 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"d6","uci":"d7d6","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/ppp2ppp/2np1n2/2b5/4PB2/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bg3","uci":"f4g3","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/ppp2ppp/2np1n2/2b5/4P3/2NQ2B1/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 1 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Be6","uci":"c8e6","fen_after":"r2qk2r/ppp2ppp/2npbn2/2b5/4P3/2NQ2B1/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 2 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"O-O-O","uci":"e1a1","fen_after":"r2qk2r/ppp2ppp/2npbn2/2b5/4P3/2NQ2B1/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR b kq - 3 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"5...Bb4","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/8/4P3/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR b KQkq - 2 5","depth":45,"score_cp":20,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bb4","uci":"f8b4","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/8/1b2P3/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR w KQkq - 3 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bd2","uci":"c1d2","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/8/1b2P3/2NQ4/PPPB1PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 4 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"O-O","uci":"e8h8","fen_after":"r1bq1rk1/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/8/1b2P3/2NQ4/PPPB1PPP/R3KBNR w KQ - 5 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":4,"san":"O-O-O","uci":"e1a1","fen_after":"r1bq1rk1/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/8/1b2P3/2NQ4/PPPB1PPP/2KR1BNR b - - 6 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":5,"san":"Re8","uci":"f8e8","fen_after":"r1bqr1k1/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/8/1b2P3/2NQ4/PPPB1PPP/2KR1BNR w - - 7 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nge2","uci":"g1e2","fen_after":"r1bqr1k1/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/8/1b2P3/2NQ4/PPPBNPPP/2KR1B1R b - - 8 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":11,"san":"6.Bf4","quality":"best","text":"6.Bf4 develops the bishop to an active diagonal, where it eyes the pawn on c7. Black will not wait and takes on e4 first.","best":"c1f4","script":{"say":"6.Bf4 develops the bishop to an active diagonal, where it eyes the pawn on c7. Black will not wait and takes on e4 first.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":75,"until":121,"brush":"green","from":"f4","to":"c7"},{"type":"arrow","at":115,"until":121,"brush":"red","from":"d5","to":"e4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"6.exd5","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/3p4/4P3/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR w KQkq - 0 6","depth":30,"score_cp":-8,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"exd5","uci":"e4d5","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/3P4/8/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR b KQkq - 0 6","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nb4","uci":"c6b4","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/5n2/3P4/1n6/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR w KQkq - 1 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Qe2+","uci":"d3e2","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/5n2/3P4/1n6/2N5/PPP1QPPP/R1B1KBNR b KQkq - 2 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Qe7","uci":"d8e7","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/ppp1qppp/5n2/3P4/1n6/2N5/PPP1QPPP/R1B1KBNR w KQkq - 3 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Be3","uci":"c1e3","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/ppp1qppp/5n2/3P4/1n6/2N1B3/PPP1QPPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 4 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nfxd5","uci":"f6d5","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/ppp1qppp/8/3n4/1n6/2N1B3/PPP1QPPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 9","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"6.Nxd5","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/3p4/4P3/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR w KQkq - 0 6","depth":30,"score_cp":-18,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nxd5","uci":"c3d5","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/3N4/4P3/3Q4/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR b KQkq - 0 6","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxd5","uci":"f6d5","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n5/3n4/4P3/3Q4/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR w KQkq - 0 7","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Qxd5","uci":"d3d5","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n5/3Q4/4P3/8/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR b KQkq - 0 7","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Qxd5","uci":"d8d5","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/ppp2ppp/2n5/3q4/4P3/8/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR w KQkq - 0 8","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"exd5","uci":"e4d5","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/ppp2ppp/2n5/3P4/8/8/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR b KQkq - 0 8","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nb4","uci":"c6b4","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/ppp2ppp/8/3P4/1n6/8/PPP2PPP/R1B1KBNR w KQkq - 1 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":12,"san":"6...dxe4","quality":"good","text":"6...dxe4 takes the pawn and opens the d-file, so now the two queens stare straight at each other. White can't leave the queen hanging, and a queen trade is coming.\n\nOn the board: Keeping the queens.","best":"d5d4","script":{"say":"6...dxe4 takes the pawn and opens the d-file, so now the two queens stare straight at each other. White can't leave the queen hanging, and a queen trade is coming.","show":[{"title":"Keeping the queens","line":{"fen":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/3p4/4PB2/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 1 6","depth":30,"score_cp":13,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black could also have kept the queens on with a developing move.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Be6","uci":"c8e6","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n1bn2/3p4/4PB2/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 2 7","comment":"6...Be6 develops the bishop and keeps the pawn tension.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"O-O-O","uci":"e1a1","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n1bn2/3p4/4PB2/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR b kq - 3 7","comment":"7.O-O-O puts the rook on the same file as the black queen.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":3,"san":"dxe4","uci":"d5e4","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n1bn2/8/4pB2/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR w kq - 0 8","comment":"7...dxe4 still takes the pawn, now with the bishop already developed.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Black could also have kept the queens on with a developing move.","takeaway":"Taking the pawn at once forces the queen trade, which is what makes the endgame so simple."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":68,"until":163,"brush":"red","from":"d3","to":"d8"},{"type":"arrow","at":139,"until":163,"brush":"green","from":"d3","to":"d8"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"6...d4","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/3p4/4PB2/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 1 6","depth":30,"score_cp":0,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"d4","uci":"d5d4","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/8/3pPB2/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nb5","uci":"c3b5","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/1N6/3pPB2/3Q4/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 1 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bb4+","uci":"f8b4","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/1N6/1b1pPB2/3Q4/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 2 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"c3","uci":"c2c3","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/1N6/1b1pPB2/2PQ4/PP3PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 0 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"dxc3","uci":"d4c3","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/1N6/1b2PB2/2pQ4/PP3PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 9","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"bxc3","uci":"b2c3","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/1N6/1b2PB2/2PQ4/P4PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 0 9","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"6...Be6","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/3p4/4PB2/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 1 6","depth":30,"score_cp":13,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Be6","uci":"c8e6","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n1bn2/3p4/4PB2/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 2 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"O-O-O","uci":"e1a1","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n1bn2/3p4/4PB2/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR b kq - 3 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":3,"san":"dxe4","uci":"d5e4","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n1bn2/8/4pB2/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR w kq - 0 8","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Qg3","uci":"d3g3","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n1bn2/8/4pB2/2N3Q1/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR b kq - 1 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Qe7","uci":"d8e7","fen_after":"r3kb1r/ppp1qppp/2n1bn2/8/4pB2/2N3Q1/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR w kq - 2 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Be2","uci":"f1e2","fen_after":"r3kb1r/ppp1qppp/2n1bn2/8/4pB2/2N3Q1/PPP1BPPP/2KR2NR b kq - 3 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":3},{"ply":13,"san":"7.Qxd8+","quality":"best","text":"This was a real moment of choice. The queen on d3 was attacked, and Van Foreest could trade or retreat. The knight will recapture afterwards. The knight will recapture afterwards. The knight will recapture afterwards. The computer is clear: only 7.Qxd8+ keeps the balance. Every retreat, such as 7.Qe3, leaves Black clearly better.\n\nOn the board: Keeping the queens.","best":"d3d8","script":{"say":"This was a real moment of choice. The queen on d3 was attacked, and Van Foreest could trade or retreat. The knight will recapture afterwards. The knight will recapture afterwards. The knight will recapture afterwards. The computer is clear: only 7.Qxd8+ keeps the balance. Every retreat, such as 7.Qe3, leaves Black clearly better.","show":[{"title":"Keeping the queens","line":{"fen":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/8/4pB2/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 7","depth":25,"score_cp":-133,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Here is what happens if White avoids the trade with 7.Qe3.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Qe3","uci":"d3e3","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/8/4pB2/2N1Q3/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 1 7","comment":"7.Qe3 keeps the queens on, but spends another move with the queen.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bb4","uci":"f8b4","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/8/1b2pB2/2N1Q3/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 2 8","comment":"7...Bb4 develops with a pin: the knight on c3 can't move without exposing the king on e1.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bc4","uci":"f1c4","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/8/1bB1pB2/2N1Q3/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR b KQkq - 3 8","comment":"8.Bc4 brings out the last minor piece on the kingside.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"O-O","uci":"e8h8","fen_after":"r1bq1rk1/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/8/1bB1pB2/2N1Q3/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR w KQ - 4 9","comment":"8...O-O tucks Black's king away, and Black is clearly better with quicker development.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Here is what happens if White avoids the trade with 7.Qe3.","takeaway":"When your queen has already moved several times, trading it can be the safest way out."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":130,"until":331,"brush":"green","from":"c6","to":"d8"},{"type":"arrow","at":168,"until":331,"brush":"green","from":"c6","to":"d8"},{"type":"arrow","at":206,"until":331,"brush":"green","from":"c6","to":"d8"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"7.Qe3","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/8/4pB2/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 7","depth":25,"score_cp":-133,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Qe3","uci":"d3e3","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/8/4pB2/2N1Q3/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 1 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bb4","uci":"f8b4","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/8/1b2pB2/2N1Q3/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 2 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bc4","uci":"f1c4","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/8/1bB1pB2/2N1Q3/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR b KQkq - 3 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"O-O","uci":"e8h8","fen_after":"r1bq1rk1/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/8/1bB1pB2/2N1Q3/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR w KQ - 4 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":5,"san":"a3","uci":"a2a3","fen_after":"r1bq1rk1/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/8/1bB1pB2/P1N1Q3/1PP2PPP/R3K1NR b KQ - 0 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Ba5","uci":"b4a5","fen_after":"r1bq1rk1/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/b7/2B1pB2/P1N1Q3/1PP2PPP/R3K1NR w KQ - 1 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"7.Qd2","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/8/4pB2/2NQ4/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 7","depth":25,"score_cp":-153,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Qd2","uci":"d3d2","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/8/4pB2/2N5/PPPQ1PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 1 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Qxd2+","uci":"d8d2","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/8/4pB2/2N5/PPPq1PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 8","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bxd2","uci":"f4d2","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/8/4p3/2N5/PPPB1PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 0 8","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bc5","uci":"f8c5","fen_after":"r1b1k2r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/2b5/4p3/2N5/PPPB1PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 1 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nge2","uci":"g1e2","fen_after":"r1b1k2r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/2b5/4p3/2N5/PPPBNPPP/R3KB1R b KQkq - 2 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bg4","uci":"c8g4","fen_after":"r3k2r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/2b5/4p1b1/2N5/PPPBNPPP/R3KB1R w KQkq - 3 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":14,"san":"7...Nxd8","quality":"best","text":"7...Nxd8 recaptures with the knight. Taking with the king would allow White to castle queenside with check down the open d-file. Now the pawn on c7 is loose, and the bishop will take it.","best":"c6d8","script":{"say":"7...Nxd8 recaptures with the knight. Taking with the king would allow White to castle queenside with check down the open d-file. Now the pawn on c7 is loose, and the bishop will take it.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":145,"until":186,"brush":"red","square":"c7"},{"type":"arrow","at":162,"until":186,"brush":"green","from":"f4","to":"c7"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"7...Kxd8","score":"White is a little better","line":{"fen":"r1bQkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/8/4pB2/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 0 7","depth":30,"score_cp":34,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Kxd8","uci":"e8d8","fen_after":"r1bk1b1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/8/4pB2/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQ - 0 8","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"O-O-O+","uci":"e1a1","fen_after":"r1bk1b1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/8/4pB2/2N5/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR b - - 1 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":3,"san":"Bd7","uci":"c8d7","fen_after":"r2k1b1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/8/4pB2/2N5/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR w - - 2 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nge2","uci":"g1e2","fen_after":"r2k1b1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/8/4pB2/2N5/PPP1NPPP/2KR1B1R b - - 3 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kc8","uci":"d8c8","fen_after":"r1k2b1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/8/4pB2/2N5/PPP1NPPP/2KR1B1R w - - 4 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Ng3","uci":"e2g3","fen_after":"r1k2b1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/8/4pB2/2N3N1/PPP2PPP/2KR1B1R b - - 5 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":15,"san":"8.Bxc7","quality":"best","text":"8.Bxc7 wins the pawn back, since the queen no longer guards c7. Material is level again in a queenless middlegame. The knight on d8 will come out to e6 with tempo.\n\nOn the board: The other retreat.","best":"f4c7","script":{"say":"8.Bxc7 wins the pawn back, since the queen no longer guards c7. Material is level again in a queenless middlegame. The knight on d8 will come out to e6 with tempo.","show":[{"title":"The other retreat","line":{"fen":"r1bnkb1r/ppp2ppp/5n2/8/4pB2/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 8","depth":24,"score_cp":-32,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White could also have answered by moving the bishop to the centre instead of winning the pawn.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Be5","uci":"f4e5","fen_after":"r1bnkb1r/ppp2ppp/5n2/4B3/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 1 8","comment":"8.Be5 puts the bishop in the middle of the board.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"e3","uci":"e4e3","fen_after":"r1bnkb1r/ppp2ppp/5n2/4B3/8/2N1p3/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 9","comment":"8...e3 pushes the pawn, and White has to reply.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"f3","uci":"f2f3","fen_after":"r1bnkb1r/ppp2ppp/5n2/4B3/8/2N1pP2/PPP3PP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 0 9","comment":"9.f3 holds the pawn on e3 in place and keeps the position closed.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White could also have answered by moving the bishop to the centre instead of winning the pawn.","takeaway":"Winning the pawn on c7 was simpler and better: material is level and the pieces get free."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":146,"until":163,"brush":"green","from":"d8","to":"e6"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"8.Be5","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"r1bnkb1r/ppp2ppp/5n2/8/4pB2/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 8","depth":24,"score_cp":-32,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Be5","uci":"f4e5","fen_after":"r1bnkb1r/ppp2ppp/5n2/4B3/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 1 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"e3","uci":"e4e3","fen_after":"r1bnkb1r/ppp2ppp/5n2/4B3/8/2N1p3/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"f3","uci":"f2f3","fen_after":"r1bnkb1r/ppp2ppp/5n2/4B3/8/2N1pP2/PPP3PP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 0 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Ne6","uci":"d8e6","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/ppp2ppp/4nn2/4B3/8/2N1pP2/PPP3PP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 1 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"O-O-O","uci":"e1a1","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/ppp2ppp/4nn2/4B3/8/2N1pP2/PPP3PP/2KR1BNR b kq - 2 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":6,"san":"Bd7","uci":"c8d7","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pppb1ppp/4nn2/4B3/8/2N1pP2/PPP3PP/2KR1BNR w kq - 3 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"8.O-O-O","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"r1bnkb1r/ppp2ppp/5n2/8/4pB2/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 8","depth":24,"score_cp":-41,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"O-O-O","uci":"e1a1","fen_after":"r1bnkb1r/ppp2ppp/5n2/8/4pB2/2N5/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR b kq - 1 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":2,"san":"Ne6","uci":"d8e6","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/ppp2ppp/4nn2/8/4pB2/2N5/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR w kq - 2 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Be5","uci":"f4e5","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/ppp2ppp/4nn2/4B3/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR b kq - 3 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Ng4","uci":"f6g4","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/ppp2ppp/4n3/4B3/4p1n1/2N5/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR w kq - 4 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bg3","uci":"e5g3","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/ppp2ppp/4n3/8/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR b kq - 5 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"e3","uci":"e4e3","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/ppp2ppp/4n3/8/6n1/2N1p1B1/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR w kq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":16,"san":"8...Ne6","quality":"good","text":"8...Ne6 develops the knight and at once attacks the bishop on c7. White must move it again, and e5 is the natural square.","best":"f8c5","script":{"say":"8...Ne6 develops the knight and at once attacks the bishop on c7. White must move it again, and e5 is the natural square.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":64,"until":121,"brush":"red","from":"e6","to":"c7"},{"type":"arrow","at":96,"until":121,"brush":"green","from":"c7","to":"e5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"8...Bc5","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1bnkb1r/ppB2ppp/5n2/8/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 0 8","depth":27,"score_cp":21,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bc5","uci":"f8c5","fen_after":"r1bnk2r/ppB2ppp/5n2/2b5/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 1 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"O-O-O","uci":"e1a1","fen_after":"r1bnk2r/ppB2ppp/5n2/2b5/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR b kq - 2 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":3,"san":"Nc6","uci":"d8c6","fen_after":"r1b1k2r/ppB2ppp/2n2n2/2b5/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR w kq - 3 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bg3","uci":"c7g3","fen_after":"r1b1k2r/pp3ppp/2n2n2/2b5/4p3/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR b kq - 4 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"O-O","uci":"e8h8","fen_after":"r1b2rk1/pp3ppp/2n2n2/2b5/4p3/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR w - - 5 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":6,"san":"Nge2","uci":"g1e2","fen_after":"r1b2rk1/pp3ppp/2n2n2/2b5/4p3/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/2KR1B1R b - - 6 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"8...Nc6","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1bnkb1r/ppB2ppp/5n2/8/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 0 8","depth":27,"score_cp":21,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nc6","uci":"d8c6","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/ppB2ppp/2n2n2/8/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 1 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"O-O-O","uci":"e1a1","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/ppB2ppp/2n2n2/8/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR b kq - 2 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":3,"san":"Bc5","uci":"f8c5","fen_after":"r1b1k2r/ppB2ppp/2n2n2/2b5/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR w kq - 3 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bb5","uci":"f1b5","fen_after":"r1b1k2r/ppB2ppp/2n2n2/1Bb5/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/2KR2NR b kq - 4 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bg4","uci":"c8g4","fen_after":"r3k2r/ppB2ppp/2n2n2/1Bb5/4p1b1/2N5/PPP2PPP/2KR2NR w kq - 5 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"f3","uci":"f2f3","fen_after":"r3k2r/ppB2ppp/2n2n2/1Bb5/4p1b1/2N2P2/PPP3PP/2KR2NR b kq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"8...Bd7","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1bnkb1r/ppB2ppp/5n2/8/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 0 8","depth":27,"score_cp":28,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bd7","uci":"c8d7","fen_after":"r2nkb1r/ppBb1ppp/5n2/8/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 1 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"O-O-O","uci":"e1a1","fen_after":"r2nkb1r/ppBb1ppp/5n2/8/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR b kq - 2 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":3,"san":"Ne6","uci":"d8e6","fen_after":"r3kb1r/ppBb1ppp/4nn2/8/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR w kq - 3 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Be5","uci":"c7e5","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1b1ppp/4nn2/4B3/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR b kq - 4 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Ng4","uci":"f6g4","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1b1ppp/4n3/4B3/4p1n1/2N5/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR w kq - 5 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bg3","uci":"e5g3","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1b1ppp/4n3/8/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR b kq - 6 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":null},{"ply":17,"san":"9.Be5","quality":"good","text":"9.Be5 retreats to a central square, where the bishop also eyes the knight on f6. Aronian's reply is to move that knight with a threat.\n\nOn the board: A different retreat.","best":"c7g3","script":{"say":"9.Be5 retreats to a central square, where the bishop also eyes the knight on f6. Aronian's reply is to move that knight with a threat.","show":[{"title":"A different retreat","line":{"fen":"r1b1kb1r/ppB2ppp/4nn2/8/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 1 9","depth":25,"score_cp":17,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White had another bishop square, one step back.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bg3","uci":"c7g3","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp3ppp/4nn2/8/4p3/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 2 9","comment":"9.Bg3 keeps the bishop out of reach of the knight.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"a6","uci":"a7a6","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/1p3ppp/p3nn2/8/4p3/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 10","comment":"9...a6 stops White's knight from using b5.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"O-O-O","uci":"e1a1","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/1p3ppp/p3nn2/8/4p3/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR b kq - 1 10","comment":"10.O-O-O brings the rook to the open file.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White had another bishop square, one step back.","takeaway":"Moving the bishop twice cost time; Aronian gained a tempo with the knight."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":77,"until":134,"brush":"red","from":"e5","to":"f6"},{"type":"arrow","at":120,"until":134,"brush":"green","from":"f6","to":"g4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"9.Bg3","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1b1kb1r/ppB2ppp/4nn2/8/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 1 9","depth":25,"score_cp":17,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bg3","uci":"c7g3","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp3ppp/4nn2/8/4p3/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 2 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"a6","uci":"a7a6","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/1p3ppp/p3nn2/8/4p3/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"O-O-O","uci":"e1a1","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/1p3ppp/p3nn2/8/4p3/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR b kq - 1 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":4,"san":"b5","uci":"b7b5","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/5ppp/p3nn2/1p6/4p3/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR1BNR w kq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"f3","uci":"f2f3","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/5ppp/p3nn2/1p6/4p3/2N2PB1/PPP3PP/2KR1BNR b kq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"exf3","uci":"e4f3","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/5ppp/p3nn2/1p6/8/2N2pB1/PPP3PP/2KR1BNR w kq - 0 12","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"9.Bb5+","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1b1kb1r/ppB2ppp/4nn2/8/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 1 9","depth":25,"score_cp":-6,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bb5+","uci":"f1b5","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/ppB2ppp/4nn2/1B6/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR b KQkq - 2 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bd7","uci":"c8d7","fen_after":"r3kb1r/ppBb1ppp/4nn2/1B6/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR w KQkq - 3 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bxd7+","uci":"b5d7","fen_after":"r3kb1r/ppBB1ppp/4nn2/8/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR b KQkq - 0 10","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nxd7","uci":"f6d7","fen_after":"r3kb1r/ppBn1ppp/4n3/8/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR w KQkq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bg3","uci":"c7g3","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1n1ppp/4n3/8/4p3/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR b KQkq - 1 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"f5","uci":"f7f5","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1n2pp/4n3/5p2/4p3/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR w KQkq - 0 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":18,"san":"9...Ng4","quality":"best","text":"9...Ng4 hits the bishop on e5 again. Aronian keeps chasing it and gains a little time. The bishop will drop back to g3.","best":"f6g4","script":{"say":"9...Ng4 hits the bishop on e5 again. Aronian keeps chasing it and gains a little time. The bishop will drop back to g3.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":35,"until":119,"brush":"red","from":"g4","to":"e5"},{"type":"arrow","at":113,"until":119,"brush":"green","from":"e5","to":"g3"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"9...Bd7","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1b1kb1r/pp3ppp/4nn2/4B3/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 2 9","depth":23,"score_cp":18,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bd7","uci":"c8d7","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1b1ppp/4nn2/4B3/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 3 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bxf6","uci":"e5f6","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1b1ppp/4nB2/8/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 0 10","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"gxf6","uci":"g7f6","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1b1p1p/4np2/8/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nxe4","uci":"c3e4","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1b1p1p/4np2/8/4N3/8/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"O-O-O","uci":"e8a8","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pp1b1p1p/4np2/8/4N3/8/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQ - 1 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":6,"san":"Rd1","uci":"a1d1","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pp1b1p1p/4np2/8/4N3/8/PPP2PPP/3RKBNR b K - 2 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"9...Nd7","score":"White is a little better","line":{"fen":"r1b1kb1r/pp3ppp/4nn2/4B3/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 2 9","depth":23,"score_cp":54,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nd7","uci":"f6d7","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp1n1ppp/4n3/4B3/4p3/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 3 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bg3","uci":"e5g3","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp1n1ppp/4n3/8/4p3/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 4 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"f5","uci":"f7f5","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp1n2pp/4n3/5p2/4p3/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nh3","uci":"g1h3","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp1n2pp/4n3/5p2/4p3/2N3BN/PPP2PPP/R3KB1R b KQkq - 1 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nb6","uci":"d7b6","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp4pp/1n2n3/5p2/4p3/2N3BN/PPP2PPP/R3KB1R w KQkq - 2 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"a4","uci":"a2a4","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp4pp/1n2n3/5p2/P3p3/2N3BN/1PP2PPP/R3KB1R b KQkq - 0 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":19,"san":"10.Bg3","quality":"good","text":"10.Bg3 drops back to safety, and it also guards the pawn on f2 from the knight on g4. Note what White did not play: the natural knight move to f3 simply loses a piece.\n\nOn the board: The natural move that fails.","best":"f1b5","script":{"say":"10.Bg3 drops back to safety, and it also guards the pawn on f2 from the knight on g4. Note what White did not play: the natural knight move to f3 simply loses a piece.","show":[{"title":"The natural move that fails","line":{"fen":"r1b1kb1r/pp3ppp/4n3/4B3/4p1n1/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 3 10","depth":23,"score_cp":-330,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Developing the king's knight to f3 looks normal, but watch the pawn on e4.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g1f3","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp3ppp/4n3/4B3/4p1n1/2N2N2/PPP2PPP/R3KB1R b KQkq - 4 10","comment":"10.Nf3 looks like the most natural developing move.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"exf3","uci":"e4f3","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp3ppp/4n3/4B3/6n1/2N2p2/PPP2PPP/R3KB1R w KQkq - 0 11","comment":"10...exf3 and the pawn on e4 simply takes the knight.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bg3","uci":"e5g3","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp3ppp/4n3/8/6n1/2N2pB1/PPP2PPP/R3KB1R b KQkq - 1 11","comment":"11.Bg3 has to save the bishop from the knight on g4.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g4f6","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp3ppp/4nn2/8/8/2N2pB1/PPP2PPP/R3KB1R w KQkq - 2 12","comment":"11...Nf6 retreats, and White is a piece down for a pawn at best.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Developing the king's knight to f3 looks normal, but watch the pawn on e4.","takeaway":"The black pawn on e4 controls f3, so White's knight must find another road, such as e2."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":84,"until":167,"brush":"red","from":"g4","to":"f2"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"10.Bb5+","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1b1kb1r/pp3ppp/4n3/4B3/4p1n1/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 3 10","depth":23,"score_cp":23,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bb5+","uci":"f1b5","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp3ppp/4n3/1B2B3/4p1n1/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR b KQkq - 4 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bd7","uci":"c8d7","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1b1ppp/4n3/1B2B3/4p1n1/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR w KQkq - 5 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bxd7+","uci":"b5d7","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1B1ppp/4n3/4B3/4p1n1/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR b KQkq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kxd7","uci":"e8d7","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp1k1ppp/4n3/4B3/4p1n1/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR w KQ - 0 12","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bg3","uci":"e5g3","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp1k1ppp/4n3/8/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR b KQ - 1 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"f5","uci":"f7f5","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp1k2pp/4n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR w KQ - 0 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"10.f4","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"r1b1kb1r/pp3ppp/4n3/4B3/4p1n1/2N5/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 3 10","depth":23,"score_cp":-192,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"f4","uci":"f2f4","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp3ppp/4n3/4B3/4pPn1/2N5/PPP3PP/R3KBNR b KQkq f3 0 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"f6","uci":"f7f6","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp4pp/4np2/4B3/4pPn1/2N5/PPP3PP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"f5","uci":"f4f5","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp4pp/4np2/4BP2/4p1n1/2N5/PPP3PP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nxe5","uci":"g4e5","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp4pp/4np2/4nP2/4p3/2N5/PPP3PP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 12","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"fxe6","uci":"f5e6","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp4pp/4Pp2/4n3/4p3/2N5/PPP3PP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 0 12","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bxe6","uci":"c8e6","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp4pp/4bp2/4n3/4p3/2N5/PPP3PP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 13","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":20,"san":"10...f5","quality":"best","text":"10...f5 is the computer's top choice. The pawn supports the advanced pawn on e4 and gives Black space on the kingside. White will now check on b5.","best":"f7f5","script":{"say":"10...f5 is the computer's top choice. The pawn supports the advanced pawn on e4 and gives Black space on the kingside. White will now check on b5.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":77,"until":146,"brush":"yellow","square":"e4"},{"type":"arrow","at":140,"until":146,"brush":"green","from":"f1","to":"b5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"10...Bb4","score":"White is a little better","line":{"fen":"r1b1kb1r/pp3ppp/4n3/8/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 4 10","depth":22,"score_cp":36,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bb4","uci":"f8b4","fen_after":"r1b1k2r/pp3ppp/4n3/8/1b2p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 5 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bb5+","uci":"f1b5","fen_after":"r1b1k2r/pp3ppp/4n3/1B6/1b2p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR b KQkq - 6 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Ke7","uci":"e8e7","fen_after":"r1b4r/pp2kppp/4n3/1B6/1b2p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR w KQ - 7 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Ne2","uci":"g1e2","fen_after":"r1b4r/pp2kppp/4n3/1B6/1b2p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/R3K2R b KQ - 8 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rd8","uci":"h8d8","fen_after":"r1br4/pp2kppp/4n3/1B6/1b2p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/R3K2R w KQ - 9 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rd1","uci":"a1d1","fen_after":"r1br4/pp2kppp/4n3/1B6/1b2p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/3RK2R b K - 10 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"10...Bd7","score":"White is a little better","line":{"fen":"r1b1kb1r/pp3ppp/4n3/8/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 4 10","depth":22,"score_cp":53,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bd7","uci":"c8d7","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1b1ppp/4n3/8/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 5 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxe4","uci":"c3e4","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1b1ppp/4n3/8/4N1n1/6B1/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bc6","uci":"d7c6","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp3ppp/2b1n3/8/4N1n1/6B1/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 1 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp3ppp/2b1n3/8/4N1n1/6BP/PPP2PP1/R3KBNR b KQkq - 0 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nh6","uci":"g4h6","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp3ppp/2b1n2n/8/4N3/6BP/PPP2PP1/R3KBNR w KQkq - 1 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nd2","uci":"e4d2","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp3ppp/2b1n2n/8/8/6BP/PPPN1PP1/R3KBNR b KQkq - 2 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":21,"san":"11.Bb5+","quality":"good","text":"11.Bb5+ gives check along the diagonal to e8 and offers to trade the light-squared bishops. Black has a simple block ready.","best":"h2h3","script":{"say":"11.Bb5+ gives check along the diagonal to e8 and offers to trade the light-squared bishops. Black has a simple block ready.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":39,"until":123,"brush":"red","from":"b5","to":"e8"},{"type":"arrow","at":117,"until":123,"brush":"green","from":"c8","to":"d7"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"11.h3","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1b1kb1r/pp4pp/4n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 11","depth":42,"score_cp":3,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp4pp/4n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/R3KBNR b KQkq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g4f6","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp4pp/4nn2/5p2/4p3/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/R3KBNR w KQkq - 1 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"O-O-O","uci":"e1a1","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp4pp/4nn2/5p2/4p3/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/2KR1BNR b kq - 2 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":4,"san":"Bd7","uci":"c8d7","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1b2pp/4nn2/5p2/4p3/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/2KR1BNR w kq - 3 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"f3","uci":"f2f3","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1b2pp/4nn2/5p2/4p3/2N2PBP/PPP3P1/2KR1BNR b kq - 0 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Be7","uci":"f8e7","fen_after":"r3k2r/pp1bb1pp/4nn2/5p2/4p3/2N2PBP/PPP3P1/2KR1BNR w kq - 1 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"11.Nh3","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1b1kb1r/pp4pp/4n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 11","depth":42,"score_cp":0,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nh3","uci":"g1h3","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp4pp/4n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3BN/PPP2PPP/R3KB1R b KQkq - 1 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp5p/4n3/5pp1/4p1n1/2N3BN/PPP2PPP/R3KB1R w KQkq - 0 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"O-O-O","uci":"e1a1","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp5p/4n3/5pp1/4p1n1/2N3BN/PPP2PPP/2KR1B1R b kq - 1 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":4,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp5p/4n3/6p1/4ppn1/2N3BN/PPP2PPP/2KR1B1R w kq - 0 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nxg5","uci":"h3g5","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp5p/4n3/6N1/4ppn1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR1B1R b kq - 0 13","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nxg5","uci":"e6g5","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp5p/8/6n1/4ppn1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR1B1R w kq - 0 14","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"11.Nd5","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1b1kb1r/pp4pp/4n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 11","depth":42,"score_cp":0,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nd5","uci":"c3d5","fen_after":"r1b1kb1r/pp4pp/4n3/3N1p2/4p1n1/6B1/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 1 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bd7","uci":"c8d7","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1b2pp/4n3/3N1p2/4p1n1/6B1/PPP2PPP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 2 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"f3","uci":"f2f3","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1b2pp/4n3/3N1p2/4p1n1/5PB1/PPP3PP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 0 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1b2pp/4n3/3N4/4ppn1/5PB1/PPP3PP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 0 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nxf4","uci":"d5f4","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1b2pp/4n3/8/4pNn1/5PB1/PPP3PP/R3KBNR b KQkq - 0 13","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Ne3","uci":"g4e3","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1b2pp/4n3/8/4pN2/4nPB1/PPP3PP/R3KBNR w KQkq - 1 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":null},{"ply":22,"san":"11...Bd7","quality":"best","text":"11...Bd7 is the best way to block. Moving the king instead would hand White a lasting edge. White will trade on d7.","best":"c8d7","script":{"say":"11...Bd7 is the best way to block. Moving the king instead would hand White a lasting edge. White will trade on d7.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":109,"until":115,"brush":"green","from":"b5","to":"d7"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"11...Kf7","score":"White is a little better","line":{"fen":"r1b1kb1r/pp4pp/4n3/1B3p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR b KQkq - 1 11","depth":32,"score_cp":77,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Kf7","uci":"e8f7","fen_after":"r1b2b1r/pp3kpp/4n3/1B3p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR w KQ - 2 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bc4","uci":"b5c4","fen_after":"r1b2b1r/pp3kpp/4n3/5p2/2B1p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR b KQ - 3 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"e3","uci":"e4e3","fen_after":"r1b2b1r/pp3kpp/4n3/5p2/2B3n1/2N1p1B1/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR w KQ - 0 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"f4","uci":"f2f4","fen_after":"r1b2b1r/pp3kpp/4n3/5p2/2B2Pn1/2N1p1B1/PPP3PP/R3K1NR b KQ - 0 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bc5","uci":"f8c5","fen_after":"r1b4r/pp3kpp/4n3/2b2p2/2B2Pn1/2N1p1B1/PPP3PP/R3K1NR w KQ - 1 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"O-O-O","uci":"e1a1","fen_after":"r1b4r/pp3kpp/4n3/2b2p2/2B2Pn1/2N1p1B1/PPP3PP/2KR2NR b - - 2 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"11...Ke7","score":"White is better","line":{"fen":"r1b1kb1r/pp4pp/4n3/1B3p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR b KQkq - 1 11","depth":32,"score_cp":163,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Ke7","uci":"e8e7","fen_after":"r1b2b1r/pp2k1pp/4n3/1B3p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR w KQ - 2 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nge2","uci":"g1e2","fen_after":"r1b2b1r/pp2k1pp/4n3/1B3p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/R3K2R b KQ - 3 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"h5","uci":"h7h5","fen_after":"r1b2b1r/pp2k1p1/4n3/1B3p1p/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/R3K2R w KQ - 0 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"h4","uci":"h2h4","fen_after":"r1b2b1r/pp2k1p1/4n3/1B3p1p/4p1nP/2N3B1/PPP1NPP1/R3K2R b KQ - 0 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kf7","uci":"e7f7","fen_after":"r1b2b1r/pp3kp1/4n3/1B3p1p/4p1nP/2N3B1/PPP1NPP1/R3K2R w KQ - 1 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bc4","uci":"b5c4","fen_after":"r1b2b1r/pp3kp1/4n3/5p1p/2B1p1nP/2N3B1/PPP1NPP1/R3K2R b KQ - 2 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":23,"san":"12.Bxd7+","quality":"best","text":"12.Bxd7+ makes the trade, and the position gets simpler still. Black recaptures with the king.","best":"b5d7","script":{"say":"12.Bxd7+ makes the trade, and the position gets simpler still. Black recaptures with the king.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":80,"until":94,"brush":"green","from":"e8","to":"d7"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"12.h3","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r3kb1r/pp1b2pp/4n3/1B3p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR w KQkq - 2 12","depth":21,"score_cp":-7,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1b2pp/4n3/1B3p2/4p1n1/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/R3K1NR b KQkq - 0 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bxb5","uci":"d7b5","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp4pp/4n3/1b3p2/4p1n1/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/R3K1NR w KQkq - 0 13","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nxb5","uci":"c3b5","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp4pp/4n3/1N3p2/4p1n1/6BP/PPP2PP1/R3K1NR b KQkq - 0 13","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g4f6","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp4pp/4nn2/1N3p2/4p3/6BP/PPP2PP1/R3K1NR w KQkq - 1 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"O-O-O","uci":"e1a1","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp4pp/4nn2/1N3p2/4p3/6BP/PPP2PP1/2KR2NR b kq - 2 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":6,"san":"Kf7","uci":"e8f7","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp3kpp/4nn2/1N3p2/4p3/6BP/PPP2PP1/2KR2NR w - - 3 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"12.Nge2","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r3kb1r/pp1b2pp/4n3/1B3p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR w KQkq - 2 12","depth":21,"score_cp":-24,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nge2","uci":"g1e2","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1b2pp/4n3/1B3p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/R3K2R b KQkq - 3 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bxb5","uci":"d7b5","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp4pp/4n3/1b3p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/R3K2R w KQkq - 0 13","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nxb5","uci":"c3b5","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp4pp/4n3/1N3p2/4p1n1/6B1/PPP1NPPP/R3K2R b KQkq - 0 13","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rd8","uci":"a8d8","fen_after":"3rkb1r/pp4pp/4n3/1N3p2/4p1n1/6B1/PPP1NPPP/R3K2R w KQk - 1 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"3rkb1r/pp4pp/4n3/1N3p2/4p1n1/6BP/PPP1NPP1/R3K2R b KQk - 0 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g4f6","fen_after":"3rkb1r/pp4pp/4nn2/1N3p2/4p3/6BP/PPP1NPP1/R3K2R w KQk - 1 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":24,"san":"12...Kxd7","quality":"best","text":"12...Kxd7 recaptures. With the queens gone, the king on d7 is not in danger; it is an active piece now.","best":"e8d7","script":{"say":"12...Kxd7 recaptures. With the queens gone, the king on d7 is not in danger; it is an active piece now.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":56,"until":103,"brush":"yellow","square":"d7"}]},"alternatives":[],"playedRank":1},{"ply":25,"san":"13.O-O-O+","quality":"good","text":"13.O-O-O+ castles with check, because the rook lands on the open d-file facing the king on d7. The king must step aside, and c6 is the spot.","best":"g1e2","script":{"say":"13.O-O-O+ castles with check, because the rook lands on the open d-file facing the king on d7. The king must step aside, and c6 is the spot.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":72,"until":140,"brush":"red","from":"d1","to":"d7"},{"type":"arrow","at":125,"until":140,"brush":"green","from":"d7","to":"c6"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"13.Nge2","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r4b1r/pp1k2pp/4n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR w KQ - 0 13","depth":22,"score_cp":0,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nge2","uci":"g1e2","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp1k2pp/4n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/R3K2R b KQ - 1 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kc6","uci":"d7c6","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp4pp/2k1n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/R3K2R w KQ - 2 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"O-O-O","uci":"e1a1","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp4pp/2k1n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/2KR3R b - - 3 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":4,"san":"g6","uci":"g7g6","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp5p/2k1n1p1/5p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/2KR3R w - - 0 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp5p/2k1n1p1/5p2/4p1n1/2N3BP/PPP1NPP1/2KR3R b - - 0 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g4f6","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp5p/2k1nnp1/5p2/4p3/2N3BP/PPP1NPP1/2KR3R w - - 1 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"13.h3","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r4b1r/pp1k2pp/4n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/R3K1NR w KQ - 0 13","depth":22,"score_cp":-1,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp1k2pp/4n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/R3K1NR b KQ - 0 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g4f6","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp1k2pp/4nn2/5p2/4p3/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/R3K1NR w KQ - 1 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Be5","uci":"g3e5","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp1k2pp/4nn2/4Bp2/4p3/2N4P/PPP2PP1/R3K1NR b KQ - 2 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Be7","uci":"f8e7","fen_after":"r6r/pp1kb1pp/4nn2/4Bp2/4p3/2N4P/PPP2PP1/R3K1NR w KQ - 3 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"O-O-O+","uci":"e1a1","fen_after":"r6r/pp1kb1pp/4nn2/4Bp2/4p3/2N4P/PPP2PP1/2KR2NR b - - 4 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":6,"san":"Kc6","uci":"d7c6","fen_after":"r6r/pp2b1pp/2k1nn2/4Bp2/4p3/2N4P/PPP2PP1/2KR2NR w - - 5 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":26,"san":"13...Kc6","quality":"best","text":"Aronian had to choose where the king should go. 13...Kc6 is the computer's top choice: the king leaves the d-file and heads for the queenside. 13...Ke7 or 13...Kc8 would leave White clearly better.\n\nOn the board: The wrong king step.","best":"d7c6","script":{"say":"Aronian had to choose where the king should go. 13...Kc6 is the computer's top choice: the king leaves the d-file and heads for the queenside. 13...Ke7 or 13...Kc8 would leave White clearly better.","show":[{"title":"The wrong king step","line":{"fen":"r4b1r/pp1k2pp/4n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR2NR b - - 1 13","depth":21,"score_cp":120,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"See how White gains time if the king goes to e7.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Ke7","uci":"d7e7","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp2k1pp/4n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR2NR w - - 2 14","comment":"13...Ke7 steps towards the kingside instead.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"f3","uci":"f2f3","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp2k1pp/4n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N2PB1/PPP3PP/2KR2NR b - - 0 14","comment":"14.f3 attacks both the knight on g4 and the pawn on e4.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Ne3","uci":"g4e3","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp2k1pp/4n3/5p2/4p3/2N1nPB1/PPP3PP/2KR2NR w - - 1 15","comment":"14...Ne3 jumps forward and attacks the rook on d1.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nd5+","uci":"c3d5","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp2k1pp/4n3/3N1p2/4p3/4nPB1/PPP3PP/2KR2NR b - - 2 15","comment":"15.Nd5+ gives check and challenges the knight on e3.","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nxd5","uci":"e3d5","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp2k1pp/4n3/3n1p2/4p3/5PB1/PPP3PP/2KR2NR w - - 0 16","comment":"15...Nxd5 takes the annoying knight.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rxd5","uci":"d1d5","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp2k1pp/4n3/3R1p2/4p3/5PB1/PPP3PP/2K3NR b - - 0 16","comment":"16.Rxd5 recaptures, and the rook takes over the centre.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"See how White gains time if the king goes to e7.","takeaway":"With the king on e7, White gains time with every move; the computer rates it clearly better for White."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":57,"until":197,"brush":"green","from":"g1","to":"e2"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"13...Ke8","score":"White is a little better","line":{"fen":"r4b1r/pp1k2pp/4n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR2NR b - - 1 13","depth":21,"score_cp":31,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Ke8","uci":"d7e8","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp4pp/4n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR2NR w - - 2 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp4pp/4n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/2KR2NR b - - 0 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g4f6","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp4pp/4nn2/5p2/4p3/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/2KR2NR w - - 1 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Be5","uci":"g3e5","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp4pp/4nn2/4Bp2/4p3/2N4P/PPP2PP1/2KR2NR b - - 2 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nd7","uci":"f6d7","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1n2pp/4n3/4Bp2/4p3/2N4P/PPP2PP1/2KR2NR w - - 3 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bh2","uci":"e5h2","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pp1n2pp/4n3/5p2/4p3/2N4P/PPP2PPB/2KR2NR b - - 4 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"13...Ke7","score":"White is better","line":{"fen":"r4b1r/pp1k2pp/4n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR2NR b - - 1 13","depth":21,"score_cp":120,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Ke7","uci":"d7e7","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp2k1pp/4n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR2NR w - - 2 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"f3","uci":"f2f3","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp2k1pp/4n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N2PB1/PPP3PP/2KR2NR b - - 0 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Ne3","uci":"g4e3","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp2k1pp/4n3/5p2/4p3/2N1nPB1/PPP3PP/2KR2NR w - - 1 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nd5+","uci":"c3d5","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp2k1pp/4n3/3N1p2/4p3/4nPB1/PPP3PP/2KR2NR b - - 2 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nxd5","uci":"e3d5","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp2k1pp/4n3/3n1p2/4p3/5PB1/PPP3PP/2KR2NR w - - 0 16","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rxd5","uci":"d1d5","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp2k1pp/4n3/3R1p2/4p3/5PB1/PPP3PP/2K3NR b - - 0 16","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":27,"san":"14.Nge2","quality":"good","text":"14.Nge2 develops the last knight to e2, the safe road, since f3 is covered by the pawn on e4. Black answers by bringing the bishop out.\n\nOn the board: A quiet pawn move.","best":"h2h3","script":{"say":"14.Nge2 develops the last knight to e2, the safe road, since f3 is covered by the pawn on e4. Black answers by bringing the bishop out.","show":[{"title":"A quiet pawn move","line":{"fen":"r4b1r/pp4pp/2k1n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR2NR w - - 2 14","depth":24,"score_cp":10,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White could also have played a small pawn move first.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp4pp/2k1n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/2KR2NR b - - 0 14","comment":"14.h3 takes the square g4 from the black knight.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g4f6","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp4pp/2k1nn2/5p2/4p3/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/2KR2NR w - - 1 15","comment":"14...Nf6 retreats the knight and keeps it defending.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nge2","uci":"g1e2","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp4pp/2k1nn2/5p2/4p3/2N3BP/PPP1NPP1/2KR3R b - - 2 15","comment":"15.Nge2 only then develops the knight.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White could also have played a small pawn move first.","takeaway":"Developing at once was also fine; the position stayed close to level."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":111,"until":135,"brush":"green","from":"f8","to":"c5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"14.h3","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r4b1r/pp4pp/2k1n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR2NR w - - 2 14","depth":24,"score_cp":10,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp4pp/2k1n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/2KR2NR b - - 0 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g4f6","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp4pp/2k1nn2/5p2/4p3/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/2KR2NR w - - 1 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nge2","uci":"g1e2","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp4pp/2k1nn2/5p2/4p3/2N3BP/PPP1NPP1/2KR3R b - - 2 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Be7","uci":"f8e7","fen_after":"r6r/pp2b1pp/2k1nn2/5p2/4p3/2N3BP/PPP1NPP1/2KR3R w - - 3 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Be5","uci":"g3e5","fen_after":"r6r/pp2b1pp/2k1nn2/4Bp2/4p3/2N4P/PPP1NPP1/2KR3R b - - 4 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rhf8","uci":"h8f8","fen_after":"r4r2/pp2b1pp/2k1nn2/4Bp2/4p3/2N4P/PPP1NPP1/2KR3R w - - 5 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"14.Nh3","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r4b1r/pp4pp/2k1n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR2NR w - - 2 14","depth":24,"score_cp":-19,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nh3","uci":"g1h3","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp4pp/2k1n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3BN/PPP2PPP/2KR3R b - - 3 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bc5","uci":"f8c5","fen_after":"r6r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2b2p2/4p1n1/2N3BN/PPP2PPP/2KR3R w - - 4 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Na4","uci":"c3a4","fen_after":"r6r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2b2p2/N3p1n1/6BN/PPP2PPP/2KR3R b - - 5 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Be7","uci":"c5e7","fen_after":"r6r/pp2b1pp/2k1n3/5p2/N3p1n1/6BN/PPP2PPP/2KR3R w - - 6 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nc3","uci":"a4c3","fen_after":"r6r/pp2b1pp/2k1n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3BN/PPP2PPP/2KR3R b - - 7 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"h5","uci":"h7h5","fen_after":"r6r/pp2b1p1/2k1n3/5p1p/4p1n1/2N3BN/PPP2PPP/2KR3R w - - 0 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":28,"san":"14...Bc5","quality":"best","text":"14...Bc5 develops the bishop, and now the bishop and the knight on g4 both aim at the pawn on f2. For now the bishop on g3 guards it, and White looks for activity with Nd5.","best":"f8c5","script":{"say":"14...Bc5 develops the bishop, and now the bishop and the knight on g4 both aim at the pawn on f2. For now the bishop on g3 guards it, and White looks for activity with Nd5.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":94,"until":172,"brush":"red","square":"f2"},{"type":"arrow","at":96,"until":172,"brush":"red","from":"c5","to":"f2"},{"type":"arrow","at":163,"until":172,"brush":"green","from":"c3","to":"d5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"14...g6","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r4b1r/pp4pp/2k1n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/2KR3R b - - 3 14","depth":26,"score_cp":0,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"g6","uci":"g7g6","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp5p/2k1n1p1/5p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/2KR3R w - - 0 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rd5","uci":"d1d5","fen_after":"r4b1r/pp5p/2k1n1p1/3R1p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/2K4R b - - 1 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bc5","uci":"f8c5","fen_after":"r6r/pp5p/2k1n1p1/2bR1p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/2K4R w - - 2 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"r6r/pp5p/2k1n1p1/2bR1p2/4p1n1/2N3BP/PPP1NPP1/2K4R b - - 0 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g4f6","fen_after":"r6r/pp5p/2k1nnp1/2bR1p2/4p3/2N3BP/PPP1NPP1/2K4R w - - 1 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Re5","uci":"d5e5","fen_after":"r6r/pp5p/2k1nnp1/2b1Rp2/4p3/2N3BP/PPP1NPP1/2K4R b - - 2 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"14...b5","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r4b1r/pp4pp/2k1n3/5p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/2KR3R b - - 3 14","depth":26,"score_cp":7,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"b5","uci":"b7b5","fen_after":"r4b1r/p5pp/2k1n3/1p3p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/2KR3R w - - 0 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"r4b1r/p5pp/2k1n3/1p3p2/4p1n1/2N3BP/PPP1NPP1/2KR3R b - - 0 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g4f6","fen_after":"r4b1r/p5pp/2k1nn2/1p3p2/4p3/2N3BP/PPP1NPP1/2KR3R w - - 1 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Be5","uci":"g3e5","fen_after":"r4b1r/p5pp/2k1nn2/1p2Bp2/4p3/2N4P/PPP1NPP1/2KR3R b - - 2 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"b4","uci":"b5b4","fen_after":"r4b1r/p5pp/2k1nn2/4Bp2/1p2p3/2N4P/PPP1NPP1/2KR3R w - - 0 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bxf6","uci":"e5f6","fen_after":"r4b1r/p5pp/2k1nB2/5p2/1p2p3/2N4P/PPP1NPP1/2KR3R b - - 0 17","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":29,"san":"15.Nd5","quality":"good","text":"15.Nd5 puts the knight on a strong central square. The computer slightly preferred the rook move to d5, but the game stays close to level. Black's rook now comes to the open file.\n\nOn the board: The rook plan.","best":"d1d5","script":{"say":"15.Nd5 puts the knight on a strong central square. The computer slightly preferred the rook move to d5, but the game stays close to level. Black's rook now comes to the open file.","show":[{"title":"The rook plan","line":{"fen":"r6r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2b2p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/2KR3R w - - 4 15","depth":20,"score_cp":3,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The computer slightly preferred a rook move to d5.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rd5","uci":"d1d5","fen_after":"r6r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bR1p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/2K4R b - - 5 15","comment":"15.Rd5 puts the rook in the centre, where it eyes the pawn on f5.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"g6","uci":"g7g6","fen_after":"r6r/pp5p/2k1n1p1/2bR1p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/2K4R w - - 0 16","comment":"15...g6 supports the pawn on f5.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"r6r/pp5p/2k1n1p1/2bR1p2/4p1n1/2N3BP/PPP1NPP1/2K4R b - - 0 16","comment":"16.h3 asks the knight on g4 what it wants to do.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"The computer slightly preferred a rook move to d5.","takeaway":"Both knight and rook moves keep the game close to level."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":49,"until":179,"brush":"yellow","square":"d5"},{"type":"arrow","at":162,"until":179,"brush":"green","from":"a8","to":"d8"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"15.Rd5","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r6r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2b2p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/2KR3R w - - 4 15","depth":20,"score_cp":3,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rd5","uci":"d1d5","fen_after":"r6r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bR1p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/2K4R b - - 5 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"g6","uci":"g7g6","fen_after":"r6r/pp5p/2k1n1p1/2bR1p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/2K4R w - - 0 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"r6r/pp5p/2k1n1p1/2bR1p2/4p1n1/2N3BP/PPP1NPP1/2K4R b - - 0 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nh6","uci":"g4h6","fen_after":"r6r/pp5p/2k1n1pn/2bR1p2/4p3/2N3BP/PPP1NPP1/2K4R w - - 1 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rhd1","uci":"h1d1","fen_after":"r6r/pp5p/2k1n1pn/2bR1p2/4p3/2N3BP/PPP1NPP1/2KR4 b - - 2 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rad8","uci":"a8d8","fen_after":"3r3r/pp5p/2k1n1pn/2bR1p2/4p3/2N3BP/PPP1NPP1/2KR4 w - - 3 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"15.Na4","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r6r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2b2p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/2KR3R w - - 4 15","depth":20,"score_cp":-14,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Na4","uci":"c3a4","fen_after":"r6r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2b2p2/N3p1n1/6B1/PPP1NPPP/2KR3R b - - 5 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Be7","uci":"c5e7","fen_after":"r6r/pp2b1pp/2k1n3/5p2/N3p1n1/6B1/PPP1NPPP/2KR3R w - - 6 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"r6r/pp2b1pp/2k1n3/5p2/N3p1n1/6BP/PPP1NPP1/2KR3R b - - 0 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g4f6","fen_after":"r6r/pp2b1pp/2k1nn2/5p2/N3p3/6BP/PPP1NPP1/2KR3R w - - 1 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"c4","uci":"c2c4","fen_after":"r6r/pp2b1pp/2k1nn2/5p2/N1P1p3/6BP/PP2NPP1/2KR3R b - - 0 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rhd8","uci":"h8d8","fen_after":"r2r4/pp2b1pp/2k1nn2/5p2/N1P1p3/6BP/PP2NPP1/2KR3R w - - 1 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"15.Rhf1","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"r6r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2b2p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/2KR3R w - - 4 15","depth":20,"score_cp":-33,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rhf1","uci":"h1f1","fen_after":"r6r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2b2p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/2KR1R2 b - - 5 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rhd8","uci":"h8d8","fen_after":"r2r4/pp4pp/2k1n3/2b2p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP1NPPP/2KR1R2 w - - 6 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"r2r4/pp4pp/2k1n3/2b2p2/4p1n1/2N3BP/PPP1NPP1/2KR1R2 b - - 0 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g4f6","fen_after":"r2r4/pp4pp/2k1nn2/2b2p2/4p3/2N3BP/PPP1NPP1/2KR1R2 w - - 1 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Na4","uci":"c3a4","fen_after":"r2r4/pp4pp/2k1nn2/2b2p2/N3p3/6BP/PPP1NPP1/2KR1R2 b - - 2 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Be7","uci":"c5e7","fen_after":"r2r4/pp2b1pp/2k1nn2/5p2/N3p3/6BP/PPP1NPP1/2KR1R2 w - - 3 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":null},{"ply":30,"san":"15...Rad8","quality":"best","text":"15...Rad8 brings the rook to the open file. Now the knight on d5 is attacked by the rook and the king, and defended only by the rook on d1. White has to deal with it right away.","best":"a8d8","script":{"say":"15...Rad8 brings the rook to the open file. Now the knight on d5 is attacked by the rook and the king, and defended only by the rook on d1. White has to deal with it right away.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":62,"until":177,"brush":"red","square":"d5"},{"type":"arrow","at":77,"until":177,"brush":"red","from":"d8","to":"d5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"15...f4","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r6r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/4p1n1/6B1/PPP1NPPP/2KR3R b - - 5 15","depth":22,"score_cp":-26,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"r6r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN4/4ppn1/6B1/PPP1NPPP/2KR3R w - - 0 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nexf4","uci":"e2f4","fen_after":"r6r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN4/4pNn1/6B1/PPP2PPP/2KR3R b - - 0 16","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nxf4","uci":"e6f4","fen_after":"r6r/pp4pp/2k5/2bN4/4pnn1/6B1/PPP2PPP/2KR3R w - - 0 17","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nxf4","uci":"d5f4","fen_after":"r6r/pp4pp/2k5/2b5/4pNn1/6B1/PPP2PPP/2KR3R b - - 0 17","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bxf2","uci":"c5f2","fen_after":"r6r/pp4pp/2k5/8/4pNn1/6B1/PPP2bPP/2KR3R w - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rdf1","uci":"d1f1","fen_after":"r6r/pp4pp/2k5/8/4pNn1/6B1/PPP2bPP/2K2R1R b - - 1 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"15...Rhf8","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r6r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/4p1n1/6B1/PPP1NPPP/2KR3R b - - 5 15","depth":22,"score_cp":-16,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rhf8","uci":"h8f8","fen_after":"r4r2/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/4p1n1/6B1/PPP1NPPP/2KR3R w - - 6 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"r4r2/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/4p1n1/6BP/PPP1NPP1/2KR3R b - - 0 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nxf2","uci":"g4f2","fen_after":"r4r2/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/4p3/6BP/PPP1NnP1/2KR3R w - - 0 17","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bxf2","uci":"g3f2","fen_after":"r4r2/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/4p3/7P/PPP1NBP1/2KR3R b - - 0 17","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bxf2","uci":"c5f2","fen_after":"r4r2/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/4p3/7P/PPP1NbP1/2KR3R w - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Ne7+","uci":"d5e7","fen_after":"r4r2/pp2N1pp/2k1n3/5p2/4p3/7P/PPP1NbP1/2KR3R b - - 1 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":31,"san":"16.Nec3","quality":"inaccuracy","text":"This is the first real turning point. Van Foreest had to look after the knight on d5, and chose 16.Nec3, simply adding a defender. It looks solid, but it is passive, and the evaluation fell from Black a little better to about minus two and a half. The computer wanted 16.b4, hitting the bishop on c5 at once and fighting for activity.\n\nOn the board: The active pawn push.","best":"b2b4","script":{"say":"This is the first real turning point. Van Foreest had to look after the knight on d5, and chose 16.Nec3, simply adding a defender. It looks solid, but it is passive, and the evaluation fell from Black a little better to about minus two and a half. The computer wanted 16.b4, hitting the bishop on c5 at once and fighting for activity.","show":[{"title":"The active pawn push","line":{"fen":"3r3r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/4p1n1/6B1/PPP1NPPP/2KR3R w - - 6 16","depth":22,"score_cp":-51,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Here is how White could have kept the game close with 16.b4.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"3r3r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/1P2p1n1/6B1/P1P1NPPP/2KR3R b - - 0 16","comment":"16.b4 attacks the bishop on c5 with the pawn.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxf2","uci":"g4f2","fen_after":"3r3r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/1P2p3/6B1/P1P1NnPP/2KR3R w - - 0 17","comment":"16...Nxf2 ignores it and grabs the pawn, attacking both rooks on d1 and h1.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bxf2","uci":"g3f2","fen_after":"3r3r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/1P2p3/8/P1P1NBPP/2KR3R b - - 0 17","comment":"17.Bxf2 removes the knight.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bxf2","uci":"c5f2","fen_after":"3r3r/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P2p3/8/P1P1NbPP/2KR3R w - - 0 18","comment":"17...Bxf2 takes the bishop back, and Black is a pawn up for a moment.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Ne7+","uci":"d5e7","fen_after":"3r3r/pp2N1pp/2k1n3/5p2/1P2p3/8/P1P1NbPP/2KR3R b - - 1 18","comment":"18.Ne7+ jumps in with check on the king on c6.","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kb5","uci":"c6b5","fen_after":"3r3r/pp2N1pp/4n3/1k3p2/1P2p3/8/P1P1NbPP/2KR3R w - - 2 19","comment":"18...Kb5 steps forward out of the check.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":7,"san":"Nxf5","uci":"e7f5","fen_after":"3r3r/pp4pp/4n3/1k3N2/1P2p3/8/P1P1NbPP/2KR3R b - - 0 19","comment":"19.Nxf5 wins the pawn back, and White's pieces are busy again.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Here is how White could have kept the game close with 16.b4.","takeaway":"With 16.b4 White kept active pieces and only a small disadvantage; the quiet defensive move gave Black time."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":273,"until":334,"brush":"yellow","from":"b2","to":"b4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"16.b4","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"3r3r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/4p1n1/6B1/PPP1NPPP/2KR3R w - - 6 16","depth":22,"score_cp":-51,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"3r3r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/1P2p1n1/6B1/P1P1NPPP/2KR3R b - - 0 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxf2","uci":"g4f2","fen_after":"3r3r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/1P2p3/6B1/P1P1NnPP/2KR3R w - - 0 17","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bxf2","uci":"g3f2","fen_after":"3r3r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/1P2p3/8/P1P1NBPP/2KR3R b - - 0 17","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bxf2","uci":"c5f2","fen_after":"3r3r/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P2p3/8/P1P1NbPP/2KR3R w - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Ne7+","uci":"d5e7","fen_after":"3r3r/pp2N1pp/2k1n3/5p2/1P2p3/8/P1P1NbPP/2KR3R b - - 1 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kb5","uci":"c6b5","fen_after":"3r3r/pp2N1pp/4n3/1k3p2/1P2p3/8/P1P1NbPP/2KR3R w - - 2 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"16.c4","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"3r3r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/4p1n1/6B1/PPP1NPPP/2KR3R w - - 6 16","depth":22,"score_cp":-56,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"c4","uci":"c2c4","fen_after":"3r3r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/2P1p1n1/6B1/PP2NPPP/2KR3R b - - 0 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rhf8","uci":"h8f8","fen_after":"3r1r2/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/2P1p1n1/6B1/PP2NPPP/2KR3R w - - 1 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rhf1","uci":"h1f1","fen_after":"3r1r2/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/2P1p1n1/6B1/PP2NPPP/2KR1R2 b - - 2 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"3r1r2/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN4/2P1ppn1/6B1/PP2NPPP/2KR1R2 w - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nexf4","uci":"e2f4","fen_after":"3r1r2/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN4/2P1pNn1/6B1/PP3PPP/2KR1R2 b - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nxf4","uci":"e6f4","fen_after":"3r1r2/pp4pp/2k5/2bN4/2P1pnn1/6B1/PP3PPP/2KR1R2 w - - 0 19","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":3},{"ply":32,"san":"16...Rhe8","quality":"good","text":"16...Rhe8 brings the other rook to the e-file, behind the knight and the advanced e-pawn. A useful move, though 16...Rhf8 was a touch stronger. White's idea now is b4.","best":"h8f8","script":{"say":"16...Rhe8 brings the other rook to the e-file, behind the knight and the advanced e-pawn. A useful move, though 16...Rhf8 was a touch stronger. White's idea now is b4.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":164,"until":167,"brush":"green","from":"b2","to":"b4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"16...Rhf8","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"3r3r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR3R b - - 7 16","depth":30,"score_cp":-253,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rhf8","uci":"h8f8","fen_after":"3r1r2/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR3R w - - 8 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rd2","uci":"d1d2","fen_after":"3r1r2/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPPR1PPP/2K4R b - - 9 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"b5","uci":"b7b5","fen_after":"3r1r2/p5pp/2k1n3/1pbN1p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPPR1PPP/2K4R w - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"3r1r2/p5pp/2k1n3/1pbN1p2/4p1n1/2N3BP/PPPR1PP1/2K4R b - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g4f6","fen_after":"3r1r2/p5pp/2k1nn2/1pbN1p2/4p3/2N3BP/PPPR1PP1/2K4R w - - 1 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nxf6","uci":"d5f6","fen_after":"3r1r2/p5pp/2k1nN2/1pb2p2/4p3/2N3BP/PPPR1PP1/2K4R b - - 0 19","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"16...a5","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"3r3r/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR3R b - - 7 16","depth":30,"score_cp":-104,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a5","uci":"a7a5","fen_after":"3r3r/1p4pp/2k1n3/p1bN1p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR3R w - - 0 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"3r3r/1p4pp/2k1n3/p1bN1p2/4p1n1/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/2KR3R b - - 0 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g4f6","fen_after":"3r3r/1p4pp/2k1nn2/p1bN1p2/4p3/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/2KR3R w - - 1 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nxf6","uci":"d5f6","fen_after":"3r3r/1p4pp/2k1nN2/p1b2p2/4p3/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/2KR3R b - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"gxf6","uci":"g7f6","fen_after":"3r3r/1p5p/2k1np2/p1b2p2/4p3/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/2KR3R w - - 0 19","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bh4","uci":"g3h4","fen_after":"3r3r/1p5p/2k1np2/p1b2p2/4p2B/2N4P/PPP2PP1/2KR3R b - - 1 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":33,"san":"17.b4","quality":"good","text":"17.b4 finally kicks the bishop on c5 and grabs some queenside space. The bishop has a great square waiting on d4.\n\nOn the board: The quiet rook move.","best":"h1f1","script":{"say":"17.b4 finally kicks the bishop on c5 and grabs some queenside space. The bishop has a great square waiting on d4.","show":[{"title":"The quiet rook move","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR3R w - - 8 17","depth":24,"score_cp":-173,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White could also have brought the rook over instead of pushing the b-pawn.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rhf1","uci":"h1f1","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR1R2 b - - 9 17","comment":"17.Rhf1 develops the last rook to the open f-file.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bd4","uci":"c5d4","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/3bp1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR1R2 w - - 10 18","comment":"17...Bd4 still lands on the strong central square.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/3bp1n1/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/2KR1R2 b - - 0 18","comment":"18.h3 asks the knight on g4 to move.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White could also have brought the rook over instead of pushing the b-pawn.","takeaway":"Black's bishop reaches d4 either way; the pawn push at least gained space."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":99,"until":113,"brush":"green","from":"c5","to":"d4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"17.Rhf1","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR3R w - - 8 17","depth":24,"score_cp":-173,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rhf1","uci":"h1f1","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR1R2 b - - 9 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bd4","uci":"c5d4","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/3bp1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR1R2 w - - 10 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/3bp1n1/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/2KR1R2 b - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g4f6","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1nn2/3N1p2/3bp3/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/2KR1R2 w - - 1 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nc7","uci":"d5c7","fen_after":"3rr3/ppN3pp/2k1nn2/5p2/3bp3/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/2KR1R2 b - - 2 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nxc7","uci":"e6c7","fen_after":"3rr3/ppn3pp/2k2n2/5p2/3bp3/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/2KR1R2 w - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"17.a3","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR3R w - - 8 17","depth":24,"score_cp":-210,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a3","uci":"a2a3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/4p1n1/P1N3B1/1PP2PPP/2KR3R b - - 0 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"a5","uci":"a7a5","fen_after":"3rr3/1p4pp/2k1n3/p1bN1p2/4p1n1/P1N3B1/1PP2PPP/2KR3R w - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"3rr3/1p4pp/2k1n3/p1bN1p2/1P2p1n1/P1N3B1/2P2PPP/2KR3R b - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bd4","uci":"c5d4","fen_after":"3rr3/1p4pp/2k1n3/p2N1p2/1P1bp1n1/P1N3B1/2P2PPP/2KR3R w - - 1 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"f3","uci":"f2f3","fen_after":"3rr3/1p4pp/2k1n3/p2N1p2/1P1bp1n1/P1N2PB1/2P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"3rr3/1p4pp/2k1n3/p2N4/1P1bppn1/P1N2PB1/2P3PP/2KR3R w - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"17.h3","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/4p1n1/2N3B1/PPP2PPP/2KR3R w - - 8 17","depth":24,"score_cp":-212,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/4p1n1/2N3BP/PPP2PP1/2KR3R b - - 0 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxf2","uci":"g4f2","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/4p3/2N3BP/PPP2nP1/2KR3R w - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bxf2","uci":"g3f2","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/4p3/2N4P/PPP2BP1/2KR3R b - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bxf2","uci":"c5f2","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/4p3/2N4P/PPP2bP1/2KR3R w - - 0 19","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rhf1","uci":"h1f1","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/4p3/2N4P/PPP2bP1/2KR1R2 b - - 1 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"e3","uci":"e4e3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/8/2N1p2P/PPP2bP1/2KR1R2 w - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":null},{"ply":34,"san":"17...Bd4","quality":"best","text":"17...Bd4 is the computer's top choice. The bishop takes a dominant central post, where it hits the knight on c3 and also looks down towards the pawn on f2. White will hit back with f3.","best":"c5d4","script":{"say":"17...Bd4 is the computer's top choice. The bishop takes a dominant central post, where it hits the knight on c3 and also looks down towards the pawn on f2. White will hit back with f3.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":109,"until":184,"brush":"red","square":"c3"},{"type":"arrow","at":152,"until":184,"brush":"red","from":"d4","to":"f2"},{"type":"arrow","at":181,"until":184,"brush":"green","from":"f2","to":"f3"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"17...Bxf2","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/1P2p1n1/2N3B1/P1P2PPP/2KR3R b - - 0 17","depth":22,"score_cp":-129,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bxf2","uci":"c5f2","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P2p1n1/2N3B1/P1P2bPP/2KR3R w - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P2p1n1/2N3BP/P1P2bP1/2KR3R b - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Be3+","uci":"f2e3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P2p1n1/2N1b1BP/P1P3P1/2KR3R w - - 1 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kb2","uci":"c1b2","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P2p1n1/2N1b1BP/PKP3P1/3R3R b - - 2 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nf2","uci":"g4f2","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P2p3/2N1b1BP/PKP2nP1/3R3R w - - 3 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"b5+","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/1P1N1p2/4p3/2N1b1BP/PKP2nP1/3R3R b - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"17...Bf8","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/2bN1p2/1P2p1n1/2N3B1/P1P2PPP/2KR3R b - - 0 17","depth":22,"score_cp":3,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bf8","uci":"c5f8","fen_after":"3rrb2/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P2p1n1/2N3B1/P1P2PPP/2KR3R w - - 1 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"f3","uci":"f2f3","fen_after":"3rrb2/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P2p1n1/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g4f6","fen_after":"3rrb2/pp4pp/2k1nn2/3N1p2/1P2p3/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 1 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"fxe4","uci":"f3e4","fen_after":"3rrb2/pp4pp/2k1nn2/3N1p2/1P2P3/2N3B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 19","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nxe4","uci":"f6e4","fen_after":"3rrb2/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P2n3/2N3B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nxe4","uci":"c3e4","fen_after":"3rrb2/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P2N3/6B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":35,"san":"18.f3","quality":"best","text":"18.f3 is the best try. The pawn attacks both the knight on g4 and the pawn on e4, trying to break up Black's grip. The knight has to decide where to go next.\n\nOn the board: Taking the bishop.","best":"f2f3","script":{"say":"18.f3 is the best try. The pawn attacks both the knight on g4 and the pawn on e4, trying to break up Black's grip. The knight has to decide where to go next.","show":[{"title":"Taking the bishop","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P1bp1n1/2N3B1/P1P2PPP/2KR3R w - - 1 18","depth":20,"score_cp":-495,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White could have taken the bishop on d4 at once with the rook.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rxd4","uci":"d1d4","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P1Rp1n1/2N3B1/P1P2PPP/2K4R b - - 0 18","comment":"18.Rxd4 takes the bishop with the rook.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxd4","uci":"e6d4","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k5/3N1p2/1P1np1n1/2N3B1/P1P2PPP/2K4R w - - 0 19","comment":"18...Nxd4 takes the rook back with the knight, so White has given up a rook for a bishop.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Ne3","uci":"d5e3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k5/5p2/1P1np1n1/2N1N1B1/P1P2PPP/2K4R b - - 1 19","comment":"19.Ne3 heads for a trade of knights on e3, but White is already clearly worse.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White could have taken the bishop on d4 at once with the rook.","takeaway":"Giving up the exchange rarely helps when you are already behind."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":59,"until":157,"brush":"red","from":"f3","to":"g4"},{"type":"arrow","at":78,"until":157,"brush":"red","from":"f3","to":"e4"},{"type":"arrow","at":152,"until":157,"brush":"green","from":"g4","to":"f6"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"18.h3","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P1bp1n1/2N3B1/P1P2PPP/2KR3R w - - 1 18","depth":20,"score_cp":-397,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P1bp1n1/2N3BP/P1P2PP1/2KR3R b - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g4f6","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1nn2/3N1p2/1P1bp3/2N3BP/P1P2PP1/2KR3R w - - 1 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nxf6","uci":"d5f6","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1nN2/5p2/1P1bp3/2N3BP/P1P2PP1/2KR3R b - - 0 19","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bxf6","uci":"d4f6","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1nb2/5p2/1P2p3/2N3BP/P1P2PP1/2KR3R w - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nb1","uci":"c3b1","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1nb2/5p2/1P2p3/6BP/P1P2PP1/1NKR3R b - - 1 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"3rr3/pp5p/2k1nb2/5pp1/1P2p3/6BP/P1P2PP1/1NKR3R w - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"18.b5+","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P1bp1n1/2N3B1/P1P2PPP/2KR3R w - - 1 18","depth":20,"score_cp":-416,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"b5+","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/1P1N1p2/3bp1n1/2N3B1/P1P2PPP/2KR3R b - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kc5","uci":"c6c5","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/4n3/1PkN1p2/3bp1n1/2N3B1/P1P2PPP/2KR3R w - - 1 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"f3","uci":"f2f3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/4n3/1PkN1p2/3bp1n1/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g4f6","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/4nn2/1PkN1p2/3bp3/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 1 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nxf6","uci":"d5f6","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/4nN2/1Pk2p2/3bp3/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bxf6","uci":"d4f6","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/4nb2/1Pk2p2/4p3/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":36,"san":"18...Nf6","quality":"best","text":"18...Nf6 steps back and adds another attacker to the knight on d5, while still guarding the pawn on e4. White will take on e4 anyway.","best":"g4f6","script":{"say":"18...Nf6 steps back and adds another attacker to the knight on d5, while still guarding the pawn on e4. White will take on e4 anyway.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":63,"until":133,"brush":"red","from":"f6","to":"d5"},{"type":"arrow","at":126,"until":133,"brush":"green","from":"f3","to":"e4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"18...f4","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P1bp1n1/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 18","depth":21,"score_cp":-180,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N4/1P1bppn1/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 0 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bh4","uci":"g3h4","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N4/1P1bppnB/2N2P2/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 1 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rxd5","uci":"d8d5","fen_after":"4r3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3r4/1P1bppnB/2N2P2/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nxd5","uci":"c3d5","fen_after":"4r3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N4/1P1bppnB/5P2/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kxd5","uci":"c6d5","fen_after":"4r3/pp4pp/4n3/3k4/1P1bppnB/5P2/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"fxg4","uci":"f3g4","fen_after":"4r3/pp4pp/4n3/3k4/1P1bppPB/8/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"18...Ne3","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P1bp1n1/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 18","depth":21,"score_cp":-172,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Ne3","uci":"g4e3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P1bp3/2N1nPB1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 1 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxe3","uci":"d5e3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/5p2/1P1bp3/2N1NPB1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 19","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bxe3+","uci":"d4e3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/5p2/1P2p3/2N1bPB1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kb2","uci":"c1b2","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/5p2/1P2p3/2N1bPB1/PKP3PP/3R3R b - - 1 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"exf3","uci":"e4f3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/5p2/1P6/2N1bpB1/PKP3PP/3R3R w - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"gxf3","uci":"g2f3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/5p2/1P6/2N1bPB1/PKP4P/3R3R b - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":37,"san":"19.fxe4","quality":"good","text":"19.fxe4 takes the pawn and opens the position a little. Material is level for now, and the knight can take back.\n\nOn the board: Trading knights first.","best":"d5f6","script":{"say":"19.fxe4 takes the pawn and opens the position a little. Material is level for now, and the knight can take back.","show":[{"title":"Trading knights first","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1nn2/3N1p2/1P1bp3/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 1 19","depth":24,"score_cp":-376,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White could have traded knights before taking the pawn on e4.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nxf6","uci":"d5f6","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1nN2/5p2/1P1bp3/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 19","comment":"19.Nxf6 takes the knight on f6.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bxf6","uci":"d4f6","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1nb2/5p2/1P2p3/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 0 20","comment":"19...Bxf6 recaptures with the bishop.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rxd8","uci":"d1d8","fen_after":"3Rr3/pp4pp/2k1nb2/5p2/1P2p3/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2K4R b - - 0 20","comment":"20.Rxd8 takes the rook on d8, opening up the d-file for a rook trade.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White could have traded knights before taking the pawn on e4.","takeaway":"Both moves keep Black clearly better, so White's choice hardly mattered."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":102,"until":112,"brush":"green","from":"f6","to":"e4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"19.Nxf6","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1nn2/3N1p2/1P1bp3/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 1 19","depth":24,"score_cp":-376,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nxf6","uci":"d5f6","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1nN2/5p2/1P1bp3/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 19","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bxf6","uci":"d4f6","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1nb2/5p2/1P2p3/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rxd8","uci":"d1d8","fen_after":"3Rr3/pp4pp/2k1nb2/5p2/1P2p3/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2K4R b - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rxd8","uci":"e8d8","fen_after":"3r4/pp4pp/2k1nb2/5p2/1P2p3/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2K4R w - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Be1","uci":"g3e1","fen_after":"3r4/pp4pp/2k1nb2/5p2/1P2p3/2N2P2/P1P3PP/2K1B2R b - - 1 21","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"e3","uci":"e4e3","fen_after":"3r4/pp4pp/2k1nb2/5p2/1P6/2N1pP2/P1P3PP/2K1B2R w - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"19.b5+","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1nn2/3N1p2/1P1bp3/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 1 19","depth":24,"score_cp":-397,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"b5+","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1nn2/1P1N1p2/3bp3/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kc5","uci":"c6c5","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/4nn2/1PkN1p2/3bp3/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 1 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nxf6","uci":"d5f6","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/4nN2/1Pk2p2/3bp3/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bxf6","uci":"d4f6","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/4nb2/1Pk2p2/4p3/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rxd8","uci":"d1d8","fen_after":"3Rr3/pp4pp/4nb2/1Pk2p2/4p3/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2K4R b - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rxd8","uci":"e8d8","fen_after":"3r4/pp4pp/4nb2/1Pk2p2/4p3/2N2PB1/P1P3PP/2K4R w - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":38,"san":"19...Nxe4","quality":"only move","text":"19...Nxe4 is the only good move. The knight recaptures and now hits both the knight on c3 and the bishop on g3. White trades it off.","best":"f6e4","script":{"say":"19...Nxe4 is the only good move. The knight recaptures and now hits both the knight on c3 and the bishop on g3. White trades it off.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":87,"until":132,"brush":"red","square":"c3"},{"type":"circle","at":87,"until":132,"brush":"red","square":"g3"},{"type":"arrow","at":125,"until":132,"brush":"green","from":"c3","to":"e4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"19...Bxc3","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1nn2/3N1p2/1P1bP3/2N3B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 19","depth":22,"score_cp":0,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bxc3","uci":"d4c3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1nn2/3N1p2/1P2P3/2b3B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxc3","uci":"d5c3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1nn2/5p2/1P2P3/2N3B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nxe4","uci":"f6e4","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/5p2/1P2n3/2N3B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nxe4","uci":"c3e4","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/5p2/1P2N3/6B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"fxe4","uci":"f5e4","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/8/1P2p3/6B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rxd8","uci":"d1d8","fen_after":"3Rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/8/1P2p3/6B1/P1P3PP/2K4R b - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"19...a5","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1nn2/3N1p2/1P1bP3/2N3B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 19","depth":22,"score_cp":0,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a5","uci":"a7a5","fen_after":"3rr3/1p4pp/2k1nn2/p2N1p2/1P1bP3/2N3B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"b5+","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"3rr3/1p4pp/2k1nn2/pP1N1p2/3bP3/2N3B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Kc5","uci":"c6c5","fen_after":"3rr3/1p4pp/4nn2/pPkN1p2/3bP3/2N3B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 1 21","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nxf6","uci":"d5f6","fen_after":"3rr3/1p4pp/4nN2/pPk2p2/3bP3/2N3B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bxf6","uci":"d4f6","fen_after":"3rr3/1p4pp/4nb2/pPk2p2/4P3/2N3B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"exf5","uci":"e4f5","fen_after":"3rr3/1p4pp/4nb2/pPk2P2/8/2N3B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":39,"san":"20.Nxe4","quality":"best","text":"20.Nxe4 trades knights, the computer's top choice, to get rid of the annoying piece. Black has to recapture with the pawn.","best":"c3e4","script":{"say":"20.Nxe4 trades knights, the computer's top choice, to get rid of the annoying piece. Black has to recapture with the pawn.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":108,"until":122,"brush":"green","from":"f5","to":"e4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"20.b5+","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P1bn3/2N3B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 0 20","depth":20,"score_cp":-480,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"b5+","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/1P1N1p2/3bn3/2N3B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kc5","uci":"c6c5","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/4n3/1PkN1p2/3bn3/2N3B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 1 21","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nxe4+","uci":"c3e4","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/4n3/1PkN1p2/3bN3/6B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"fxe4","uci":"f5e4","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/4n3/1PkN4/3bp3/6B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"c3","uci":"c2c3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/4n3/1PkN4/3bp3/2P3B1/P5PP/2KR3R b - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rxd5","uci":"d8d5","fen_after":"4r3/pp4pp/4n3/1Pkr4/3bp3/2P3B1/P5PP/2KR3R w - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"20.Rd3","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P1bn3/2N3B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 0 20","depth":20,"score_cp":-534,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rd3","uci":"d1d3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P1bn3/2NR2B1/P1P3PP/2K4R b - - 1 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxd5","uci":"d8d5","fen_after":"4r3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3r1p2/1P1bn3/2NR2B1/P1P3PP/2K4R w - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nxd5","uci":"c3d5","fen_after":"4r3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P1bn3/3R2B1/P1P3PP/2K4R b - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kxd5","uci":"c6d5","fen_after":"4r3/pp4pp/4n3/3k1p2/1P1bn3/3R2B1/P1P3PP/2K4R w - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rf1","uci":"h1f1","fen_after":"4r3/pp4pp/4n3/3k1p2/1P1bn3/3R2B1/P1P3PP/2K2R2 b - - 1 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"g6","uci":"g7g6","fen_after":"4r3/pp5p/4n1p1/3k1p2/1P1bn3/3R2B1/P1P3PP/2K2R2 w - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":40,"san":"20...fxe4","quality":"only move","text":"20...fxe4 is again the only good recapture. Black now has a passed pawn on e4, since White has no pawns left on the d- or f-files. And the knight on d5 is attacked by the rook with nothing defending it. White needs c4.","best":"f5e4","script":{"say":"20...fxe4 is again the only good recapture. Black now has a passed pawn on e4, since White has no pawns left on the d- or f-files. And the knight on d5 is attacked by the rook with nothing defending it. White needs c4.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":149,"until":218,"brush":"red","square":"d5"},{"type":"arrow","at":171,"until":218,"brush":"red","from":"d8","to":"d5"},{"type":"arrow","at":215,"until":218,"brush":"green","from":"c2","to":"c4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"20...Rxd5","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P1bN3/6B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 20","depth":20,"score_cp":-22,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rxd5","uci":"d8d5","fen_after":"4r3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3r1p2/1P1bN3/6B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nd6","uci":"e4d6","fen_after":"4r3/pp4pp/2kNn3/3r1p2/1P1b4/6B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 1 21","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rd8","uci":"e8d8","fen_after":"3r4/pp4pp/2kNn3/3r1p2/1P1b4/6B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 2 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"b5+","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"3r4/pp4pp/2kNn3/1P1r1p2/3b4/6B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kb6","uci":"c6b6","fen_after":"3r4/pp4pp/1k1Nn3/1P1r1p2/3b4/6B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 1 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rhe1","uci":"h1e1","fen_after":"3r4/pp4pp/1k1Nn3/1P1r1p2/3b4/6B1/P1P3PP/2KRR3 b - - 2 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"20...f4","score":"White is clearly better","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N1p2/1P1bN3/6B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R b - - 0 20","depth":20,"score_cp":182,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N4/1P1bNp2/6B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"c4","uci":"c2c4","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N4/1PPbNp2/6B1/P5PP/2KR3R b - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"fxg3","uci":"f4g3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N4/1PPbN3/6p1/P5PP/2KR3R w - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"b5+","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/1P1N4/2PbN3/6p1/P5PP/2KR3R b - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kd7","uci":"c6d7","fen_after":"3rr3/pp1k2pp/4n3/1P1N4/2PbN3/6p1/P5PP/2KR3R w - - 1 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"hxg3","uci":"h2g3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp1k2pp/4n3/1P1N4/2PbN3/6P1/P5P1/2KR3R b - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":41,"san":"21.c4","quality":"best","text":"21.c4 is the best answer: the pawn props up the knight on d5. The position is less clear than a moment ago, but Black has a strong reply.","best":"c2c4","script":{"say":"21.c4 is the best answer: the pawn props up the knight on d5. The position is less clear than a moment ago, but Black has a strong reply.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":58,"until":137,"brush":"yellow","square":"d5"},{"type":"arrow","at":122,"until":137,"brush":"green","from":"b7","to":"b5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"21.c3","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N4/1P1bp3/6B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 0 21","depth":21,"score_cp":-438,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"c3","uci":"c2c3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N4/1P1bp3/2P3B1/P5PP/2KR3R b - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxd5","uci":"d8d5","fen_after":"4r3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3r4/1P1bp3/2P3B1/P5PP/2KR3R w - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"cxd4","uci":"c3d4","fen_after":"4r3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3r4/1P1Pp3/6B1/P5PP/2KR3R b - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nxd4","uci":"e6d4","fen_after":"4r3/pp4pp/2k5/3r4/1P1np3/6B1/P5PP/2KR3R w - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kb2","uci":"c1b2","fen_after":"4r3/pp4pp/2k5/3r4/1P1np3/6B1/PK4PP/3R3R b - - 1 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nf5","uci":"d4f5","fen_after":"4r3/pp4pp/2k5/3r1n2/1P2p3/6B1/PK4PP/3R3R w - - 2 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"21.Rxd4","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N4/1P1bp3/6B1/P1P3PP/2KR3R w - - 0 21","depth":21,"score_cp":-499,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rxd4","uci":"d1d4","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N4/1P1Rp3/6B1/P1P3PP/2K4R b - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxd4","uci":"e6d4","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k5/3N4/1P1np3/6B1/P1P3PP/2K4R w - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Ne3","uci":"d5e3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k5/8/1P1np3/4N1B1/P1P3PP/2K4R b - - 1 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"g6","uci":"g7g6","fen_after":"3rr3/pp5p/2k3p1/8/1P1np3/4N1B1/P1P3PP/2K4R w - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"a4","uci":"a2a4","fen_after":"3rr3/pp5p/2k3p1/8/PP1np3/4N1B1/2P3PP/2K4R b - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nf5","uci":"d4f5","fen_after":"3rr3/pp5p/2k3p1/5n2/PP2p3/4N1B1/2P3PP/2K4R w - - 1 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":42,"san":"21...b5","quality":"only move","text":"21...b5 is the only move that keeps Black clearly ahead. The pawn attacks the c4 pawn and tries to knock away the knight's support. White brings the king closer.\n\nOn the board: The slower pawn move.","best":"b7b5","script":{"say":"21...b5 is the only move that keeps Black clearly ahead. The pawn attacks the c4 pawn and tries to knock away the knight's support. White brings the king closer.","show":[{"title":"The slower pawn move","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N4/1PPbp3/6B1/P5PP/2KR3R b - - 0 21","depth":20,"score_cp":0,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black also had a quiet pawn move instead of the b-pawn push.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a5","uci":"a7a5","fen_after":"3rr3/1p4pp/2k1n3/p2N4/1PPbp3/6B1/P5PP/2KR3R w - - 0 22","comment":"21...a5 starts a different pawn plan.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rhe1","uci":"h1e1","fen_after":"3rr3/1p4pp/2k1n3/p2N4/1PPbp3/6B1/P5PP/2KRR3 b - - 1 22","comment":"22.Rhe1 puts the rook on the open e-file.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rxd5","uci":"d8d5","fen_after":"4r3/1p4pp/2k1n3/p2r4/1PPbp3/6B1/P5PP/2KRR3 w - - 0 23","comment":"22...Rxd5 takes the knight with the rook.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Black also had a quiet pawn move instead of the b-pawn push.","takeaway":"The computer shows this slower choice leaves Black far less ahead, so the b-pawn push was the move."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":74,"until":161,"brush":"red","from":"b5","to":"c4"},{"type":"arrow","at":145,"until":161,"brush":"green","from":"c1","to":"c2"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"21...a5","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N4/1PPbp3/6B1/P5PP/2KR3R b - - 0 21","depth":20,"score_cp":0,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a5","uci":"a7a5","fen_after":"3rr3/1p4pp/2k1n3/p2N4/1PPbp3/6B1/P5PP/2KR3R w - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rhe1","uci":"h1e1","fen_after":"3rr3/1p4pp/2k1n3/p2N4/1PPbp3/6B1/P5PP/2KRR3 b - - 1 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rxd5","uci":"d8d5","fen_after":"4r3/1p4pp/2k1n3/p2r4/1PPbp3/6B1/P5PP/2KRR3 w - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"cxd5+","uci":"c4d5","fen_after":"4r3/1p4pp/2k1n3/p2P4/1P1bp3/6B1/P5PP/2KRR3 b - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kxd5","uci":"c6d5","fen_after":"4r3/1p4pp/4n3/p2k4/1P1bp3/6B1/P5PP/2KRR3 w - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"bxa5","uci":"b4a5","fen_after":"4r3/1p4pp/4n3/P2k4/3bp3/6B1/P5PP/2KRR3 b - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"21...e3","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N4/1PPbp3/6B1/P5PP/2KR3R b - - 0 21","depth":20,"score_cp":12,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"e3","uci":"e4e3","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N4/1PPb4/4p1B1/P5PP/2KR3R w - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rhe1","uci":"h1e1","fen_after":"3rr3/pp4pp/2k1n3/3N4/1PPb4/4p1B1/P5PP/2KRR3 b - - 1 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"b5","uci":"b7b5","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/1p1N4/1PPb4/4p1B1/P5PP/2KRR3 w - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kc2","uci":"c1c2","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/1p1N4/1PPb4/4p1B1/P1K3PP/3RR3 b - - 1 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rc8","uci":"d8c8","fen_after":"2r1r3/p5pp/2k1n3/1p1N4/1PPb4/4p1B1/P1K3PP/3RR3 w - - 2 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nxe3","uci":"d5e3","fen_after":"2r1r3/p5pp/2k1n3/1p6/1PPb4/4N1B1/P1K3PP/3RR3 b - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":43,"san":"22.Kc2","quality":"good","text":"22.Kc2 brings the king up towards the action. With so few pieces left, the king is a fighting piece. Black takes the pawn now, and the knight on d5 loses its support.","best":"h1e1","script":{"say":"22.Kc2 brings the king up towards the action. With so few pieces left, the king is a fighting piece. Black takes the pawn now, and the knight on d5 loses its support.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":122,"until":166,"brush":"green","from":"b5","to":"c4"},{"type":"circle","at":145,"until":166,"brush":"yellow","square":"d5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"22.Rhe1","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/1p1N4/1PPbp3/6B1/P5PP/2KR3R w - - 0 22","depth":20,"score_cp":-416,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rhe1","uci":"h1e1","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/1p1N4/1PPbp3/6B1/P5PP/2KRR3 b - - 1 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"bxc4","uci":"b5c4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/3N4/1Ppbp3/6B1/P5PP/2KRR3 w - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Ne3","uci":"d5e3","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/8/1Ppbp3/4N1B1/P5PP/2KRR3 b - - 1 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bc3","uci":"d4c3","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/8/1Pp1p3/2b1N1B1/P5PP/2KRR3 w - - 2 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rf1","uci":"e1f1","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/8/1Pp1p3/2b1N1B1/P5PP/2KR1R2 b - - 3 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bxb4","uci":"c3b4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/8/1bp1p3/4N1B1/P5PP/2KR1R2 w - - 0 25","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"22.Rde1","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/1p1N4/1PPbp3/6B1/P5PP/2KR3R w - - 0 22","depth":20,"score_cp":-420,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rde1","uci":"d1e1","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/1p1N4/1PPbp3/6B1/P5PP/2K1R2R b - - 1 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"bxc4","uci":"b5c4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/3N4/1Ppbp3/6B1/P5PP/2K1R2R w - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Ne3","uci":"d5e3","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/8/1Ppbp3/4N1B1/P5PP/2K1R2R b - - 1 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bc3","uci":"d4c3","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/8/1Pp1p3/2b1N1B1/P5PP/2K1R2R w - - 2 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rd1","uci":"e1d1","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/8/1Pp1p3/2b1N1B1/P5PP/2KR3R b - - 3 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bxb4","uci":"c3b4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/8/1bp1p3/4N1B1/P5PP/2KR3R w - - 0 25","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":3},{"ply":44,"san":"22...bxc4","quality":"best","text":"22...bxc4 takes the pawn. Black is now a pawn up, and the knight on d5 has lost its support again. It must leave for c3, and the pawn on e4 is the target.","best":"b5c4","script":{"say":"22...bxc4 takes the pawn. Black is now a pawn up, and the knight on d5 has lost its support again. It must leave for c3, and the pawn on e4 is the target.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":113,"until":154,"brush":"green","from":"d5","to":"c3"},{"type":"circle","at":137,"until":154,"brush":"red","square":"e4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"22...a6","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/1p1N4/1PPbp3/6B1/P1K3PP/3R3R b - - 1 22","depth":18,"score_cp":-98,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a6","uci":"a7a6","fen_after":"3rr3/6pp/p1k1n3/1p1N4/1PPbp3/6B1/P1K3PP/3R3R w - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nc3","uci":"d5c3","fen_after":"3rr3/6pp/p1k1n3/1p6/1PPbp3/2N3B1/P1K3PP/3R3R b - - 1 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"e3","uci":"e4e3","fen_after":"3rr3/6pp/p1k1n3/1p6/1PPb4/2N1p1B1/P1K3PP/3R3R w - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"cxb5+","uci":"c4b5","fen_after":"3rr3/6pp/p1k1n3/1P6/1P1b4/2N1p1B1/P1K3PP/3R3R b - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"axb5","uci":"a6b5","fen_after":"3rr3/6pp/2k1n3/1p6/1P1b4/2N1p1B1/P1K3PP/3R3R w - - 0 25","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rhe1","uci":"h1e1","fen_after":"3rr3/6pp/2k1n3/1p6/1P1b4/2N1p1B1/P1K3PP/3RR3 b - - 1 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"22...g5","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/1p1N4/1PPbp3/6B1/P1K3PP/3R3R b - - 1 22","depth":18,"score_cp":-94,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"3rr3/p6p/2k1n3/1p1N2p1/1PPbp3/6B1/P1K3PP/3R3R w - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nc3","uci":"d5c3","fen_after":"3rr3/p6p/2k1n3/1p4p1/1PPbp3/2N3B1/P1K3PP/3R3R b - - 1 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":45,"san":"23.Nc3","quality":"best","text":"23.Nc3 is the best move. The knight leaves d5 just in time and attacks the pawn on e4. Black pushes it on.\n\nOn the board: Trading knights.","best":"d5c3","script":{"say":"23.Nc3 is the best move. The knight leaves d5 just in time and attacks the pawn on e4. Black pushes it on.","show":[{"title":"Trading knights","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/3N4/1Ppbp3/6B1/P1K3PP/3R3R w - - 0 23","depth":16,"score_cp":-417,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White could have taken the pawn out of reach by trading knights.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nf4","uci":"d5f4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/8/1PpbpN2/6B1/P1K3PP/3R3R b - - 1 23","comment":"23.Nf4 puts the knight on f4, next to the bishop on g3.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxf4","uci":"e6f4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k5/8/1Ppbpn2/6B1/P1K3PP/3R3R w - - 0 24","comment":"23...Nxf4 takes it with the knight.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bxf4","uci":"g3f4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k5/8/1PpbpB2/8/P1K3PP/3R3R b - - 0 24","comment":"24.Bxf4 recaptures with the bishop.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White could have taken the pawn out of reach by trading knights.","takeaway":"That plan lets the pawn run to e3, and White is worse than in the game."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":83,"until":106,"brush":"red","from":"c3","to":"e4"},{"type":"arrow","at":103,"until":106,"brush":"green","from":"e4","to":"e3"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"23.Nf4","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/3N4/1Ppbp3/6B1/P1K3PP/3R3R w - - 0 23","depth":16,"score_cp":-417,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nf4","uci":"d5f4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/8/1PpbpN2/6B1/P1K3PP/3R3R b - - 1 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxf4","uci":"e6f4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k5/8/1Ppbpn2/6B1/P1K3PP/3R3R w - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bxf4","uci":"g3f4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k5/8/1PpbpB2/8/P1K3PP/3R3R b - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"e3","uci":"e4e3","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k5/8/1Ppb1B2/4p3/P1K3PP/3R3R w - - 0 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bg3","uci":"f4g3","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k5/8/1Ppb4/4p1B1/P1K3PP/3R3R b - - 1 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"e2","uci":"e3e2","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k5/8/1Ppb4/6B1/P1K1p1PP/3R3R w - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"23.Rhe1","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/3N4/1Ppbp3/6B1/P1K3PP/3R3R w - - 0 23","depth":16,"score_cp":-506,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rhe1","uci":"h1e1","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/3N4/1Ppbp3/6B1/P1K3PP/3RR3 b - - 1 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kxd5","uci":"c6d5","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/4n3/3k4/1Ppbp3/6B1/P1K3PP/3RR3 w - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"a4","uci":"a2a4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/4n3/3k4/PPpbp3/6B1/2K3PP/3RR3 b - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rc8","uci":"d8c8","fen_after":"2r1r3/p5pp/4n3/3k4/PPpbp3/6B1/2K3PP/3RR3 w - - 1 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"b5","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"2r1r3/p5pp/4n3/1P1k4/P1pbp3/6B1/2K3PP/3RR3 b - - 0 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"h5","uci":"h7h5","fen_after":"2r1r3/p5p1/4n3/1P1k3p/P1pbp3/6B1/2K3PP/3RR3 w - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":46,"san":"23...e3","quality":"only move","text":"23...e3 is the only move that keeps the big advantage. The pawn was attacked by the knight and had no defender, so Aronian pushes it to e3, where the bishop on d4 guards it. A passed pawn this far up the board is a real force. The knight blocks from e2.\n\nOn the board: Letting the pawn go.","best":"e4e3","script":{"say":"23...e3 is the only move that keeps the big advantage. The pawn was attacked by the knight and had no defender, so Aronian pushes it to e3, where the bishop on d4 guards it. A passed pawn this far up the board is a real force. The knight blocks from e2.","show":[{"title":"Letting the pawn go","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/8/1Ppbp3/2N3B1/P1K3PP/3R3R b - - 1 23","depth":20,"score_cp":-175,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"See what happens if Black plays a slow move and leaves the pawn on e4.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bb6","uci":"d4b6","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/1bk1n3/8/1Pp1p3/2N3B1/P1K3PP/3R3R w - - 2 24","comment":"23...Bb6 moves the bishop but leaves the pawn on e4 without a defender.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxd8","uci":"d1d8","fen_after":"3Rr3/p5pp/1bk1n3/8/1Pp1p3/2N3B1/P1K3PP/7R b - - 0 24","comment":"24.Rxd8 trades a pair of rooks.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rxd8","uci":"e8d8","fen_after":"3r4/p5pp/1bk1n3/8/1Pp1p3/2N3B1/P1K3PP/7R w - - 0 25","comment":"24...Rxd8 recaptures.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nxe4","uci":"c3e4","fen_after":"3r4/p5pp/1bk1n3/8/1Pp1N3/6B1/P1K3PP/7R b - - 0 25","comment":"25.Nxe4 and the knight simply wins the pawn back.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"See what happens if Black plays a slow move and leaves the pawn on e4.","takeaway":"A passed pawn under attack often has to run forward; standing still can cost it."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":136,"until":253,"brush":"green","square":"e3"},{"type":"arrow","at":245,"until":253,"brush":"green","from":"c3","to":"e2"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"23...a5","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/8/1Ppbp3/2N3B1/P1K3PP/3R3R b - - 1 23","depth":20,"score_cp":-181,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a5","uci":"a7a5","fen_after":"3rr3/6pp/2k1n3/p7/1Ppbp3/2N3B1/P1K3PP/3R3R w - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"bxa5","uci":"b4a5","fen_after":"3rr3/6pp/2k1n3/P7/2pbp3/2N3B1/P1K3PP/3R3R b - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Ra8","uci":"d8a8","fen_after":"r3r3/6pp/2k1n3/P7/2pbp3/2N3B1/P1K3PP/3R3R w - - 1 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Ne2","uci":"c3e2","fen_after":"r3r3/6pp/2k1n3/P7/2pbp3/6B1/P1K1N1PP/3R3R b - - 2 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bc5","uci":"d4c5","fen_after":"r3r3/6pp/2k1n3/P1b5/2p1p3/6B1/P1K1N1PP/3R3R w - - 3 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Be1","uci":"g3e1","fen_after":"r3r3/6pp/2k1n3/P1b5/2p1p3/8/P1K1N1PP/3RB2R b - - 4 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"23...Bb6","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/8/1Ppbp3/2N3B1/P1K3PP/3R3R b - - 1 23","depth":20,"score_cp":-175,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bb6","uci":"d4b6","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/1bk1n3/8/1Pp1p3/2N3B1/P1K3PP/3R3R w - - 2 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxd8","uci":"d1d8","fen_after":"3Rr3/p5pp/1bk1n3/8/1Pp1p3/2N3B1/P1K3PP/7R b - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rxd8","uci":"e8d8","fen_after":"3r4/p5pp/1bk1n3/8/1Pp1p3/2N3B1/P1K3PP/7R w - - 0 25","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nxe4","uci":"c3e4","fen_after":"3r4/p5pp/1bk1n3/8/1Pp1N3/6B1/P1K3PP/7R b - - 0 25","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nd4+","uci":"e6d4","fen_after":"3r4/p5pp/1bk5/8/1PpnN3/6B1/P1K3PP/7R w - - 1 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kb2","uci":"c2b2","fen_after":"3r4/p5pp/1bk5/8/1PpnN3/6B1/PK4PP/7R b - - 2 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":47,"san":"24.Ne2","quality":"good","text":"24.Ne2 plants the knight right in front of the pawn on e3. A knight is a fine blocker of a passed pawn. Black retreats the bishop to f6.","best":"h1e1","script":{"say":"24.Ne2 plants the knight right in front of the pawn on e3. A knight is a fine blocker of a passed pawn. Black retreats the bishop to f6.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":55,"until":136,"brush":"yellow","square":"e3"},{"type":"arrow","at":130,"until":136,"brush":"green","from":"d4","to":"f6"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"24.Rhe1","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/8/1Ppb4/2N1p1B1/P1K3PP/3R3R w - - 0 24","depth":22,"score_cp":-482,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rhe1","uci":"h1e1","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/8/1Ppb4/2N1p1B1/P1K3PP/3RR3 b - - 1 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"3rr3/p6p/2k1n3/6p1/1Ppb4/2N1p1B1/P1K3PP/3RR3 w - - 0 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Ne2","uci":"c3e2","fen_after":"3rr3/p6p/2k1n3/6p1/1Ppb4/4p1B1/P1K1N1PP/3RR3 b - - 1 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bg7","uci":"d4g7","fen_after":"3rr3/p5bp/2k1n3/6p1/1Pp5/4p1B1/P1K1N1PP/3RR3 w - - 2 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rf1","uci":"e1f1","fen_after":"3rr3/p5bp/2k1n3/6p1/1Pp5/4p1B1/P1K1N1PP/3R1R2 b - - 3 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nd4+","uci":"e6d4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5bp/2k5/6p1/1Ppn4/4p1B1/P1K1N1PP/3R1R2 w - - 4 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"24.a4","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/8/1Ppb4/2N1p1B1/P1K3PP/3R3R w - - 0 24","depth":22,"score_cp":-482,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a4","uci":"a2a4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/8/PPpb4/2N1p1B1/2K3PP/3R3R b - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bf6","uci":"d4f6","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1nb2/8/PPp5/2N1p1B1/2K3PP/3R3R w - - 1 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nb5","uci":"c3b5","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1nb2/1N6/PPp5/4p1B1/2K3PP/3R3R b - - 2 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nd4+","uci":"e6d4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k2b2/1N6/PPpn4/4p1B1/2K3PP/3R3R w - - 3 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nxd4+","uci":"b5d4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k2b2/8/PPpN4/4p1B1/2K3PP/3R3R b - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bxd4","uci":"f6d4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k5/8/PPpb4/4p1B1/2K3PP/3R3R w - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":48,"san":"24...Bf6","quality":"best","text":"24...Bf6 is the computer's top choice. The bishop steps back to a safe square where it still controls the long diagonal. White tries a queenside plan with a4.","best":"d4f6","script":{"say":"24...Bf6 is the computer's top choice. The bishop steps back to a safe square where it still controls the long diagonal. White tries a queenside plan with a4.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":119,"until":158,"brush":"yellow","from":"f6","to":"a1"},{"type":"arrow","at":155,"until":158,"brush":"green","from":"a2","to":"a4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"24...Rf8","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/8/1Ppb4/4p1B1/P1K1N1PP/3R3R b - - 1 24","depth":24,"score_cp":-440,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rf8","uci":"e8f8","fen_after":"3r1r2/p5pp/2k1n3/8/1Ppb4/4p1B1/P1K1N1PP/3R3R w - - 2 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"a4","uci":"a2a4","fen_after":"3r1r2/p5pp/2k1n3/8/PPpb4/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/3R3R b - - 0 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bf6","uci":"d4f6","fen_after":"3r1r2/p5pp/2k1nb2/8/PPp5/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/3R3R w - - 1 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"b5+","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"3r1r2/p5pp/2k1nb2/1P6/P1p5/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/3R3R b - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kc5","uci":"c6c5","fen_after":"3r1r2/p5pp/4nb2/1Pk5/P1p5/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/3R3R w - - 1 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rhf1","uci":"h1f1","fen_after":"3r1r2/p5pp/4nb2/1Pk5/P1p5/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/3R1R2 b - - 2 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"24...a6","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1n3/8/1Ppb4/4p1B1/P1K1N1PP/3R3R b - - 1 24","depth":24,"score_cp":-405,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a6","uci":"a7a6","fen_after":"3rr3/6pp/p1k1n3/8/1Ppb4/4p1B1/P1K1N1PP/3R3R w - - 0 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bh4","uci":"g3h4","fen_after":"3rr3/6pp/p1k1n3/8/1Ppb3B/4p3/P1K1N1PP/3R3R b - - 1 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rd5","uci":"d8d5","fen_after":"4r3/6pp/p1k1n3/3r4/1Ppb3B/4p3/P1K1N1PP/3R3R w - - 2 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"a4","uci":"a2a4","fen_after":"4r3/6pp/p1k1n3/3r4/PPpb3B/4p3/2K1N1PP/3R3R b - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rf8","uci":"e8f8","fen_after":"5r2/6pp/p1k1n3/3r4/PPpb3B/4p3/2K1N1PP/3R3R w - - 1 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"5r2/6pp/p1k1n3/3r4/PPpb3B/4p2P/2K1N1P1/3R3R b - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":49,"san":"25.a4","quality":"good","text":"25.a4 supports the b-pawn, hoping to push it and create some play against Black's king. Black meanwhile starts on the kingside.\n\nOn the board: Rook first.","best":"h1f1","script":{"say":"25.a4 supports the b-pawn, hoping to push it and create some play against Black's king. Black meanwhile starts on the kingside.","show":[{"title":"Rook first","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1nb2/8/1Pp5/4p1B1/P1K1N1PP/3R3R w - - 2 25","depth":22,"score_cp":-539,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White could also have brought the rook to f1 before pushing the a-pawn.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rhf1","uci":"h1f1","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1nb2/8/1Pp5/4p1B1/P1K1N1PP/3R1R2 b - - 3 25","comment":"25.Rhf1 puts the rook on the f-file.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"h5","uci":"h7h5","fen_after":"3rr3/p5p1/2k1nb2/7p/1Pp5/4p1B1/P1K1N1PP/3R1R2 w - - 0 26","comment":"25...h5 starts the kingside pawn push.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"a4","uci":"a2a4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5p1/2k1nb2/7p/PPp5/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/3R1R2 b - - 0 26","comment":"26.a4 follows with the queenside push.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White could also have brought the rook to f1 before pushing the a-pawn.","takeaway":"The two moves only change order, and Black keeps a big edge."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":45,"until":127,"brush":"yellow","from":"b4","to":"b5"},{"type":"arrow","at":104,"until":127,"brush":"green","from":"h7","to":"h5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"25.Rhf1","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1nb2/8/1Pp5/4p1B1/P1K1N1PP/3R3R w - - 2 25","depth":22,"score_cp":-539,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rhf1","uci":"h1f1","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1nb2/8/1Pp5/4p1B1/P1K1N1PP/3R1R2 b - - 3 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"h5","uci":"h7h5","fen_after":"3rr3/p5p1/2k1nb2/7p/1Pp5/4p1B1/P1K1N1PP/3R1R2 w - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"a4","uci":"a2a4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5p1/2k1nb2/7p/PPp5/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/3R1R2 b - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"a6","uci":"a7a6","fen_after":"3rr3/6p1/p1k1nb2/7p/PPp5/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/3R1R2 w - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"3rr3/6p1/p1k1nb2/7p/PPp5/4p1BP/2K1N1P1/3R1R2 b - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"h4","uci":"h5h4","fen_after":"3rr3/6p1/p1k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p1BP/2K1N1P1/3R1R2 w - - 0 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"25.h4","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1nb2/8/1Pp5/4p1B1/P1K1N1PP/3R3R w - - 2 25","depth":22,"score_cp":-562,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"h4","uci":"h2h4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1nb2/8/1Pp4P/4p1B1/P1K1N1P1/3R3R b - - 0 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nd4+","uci":"e6d4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k2b2/8/1Ppn3P/4p1B1/P1K1N1P1/3R3R w - - 1 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nxd4+","uci":"e2d4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k2b2/8/1PpN3P/4p1B1/P1K3P1/3R3R b - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rxd4","uci":"d8d4","fen_after":"4r3/p5pp/2k2b2/8/1Ppr3P/4p1B1/P1K3P1/3R3R w - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rxd4","uci":"d1d4","fen_after":"4r3/p5pp/2k2b2/8/1PpR3P/4p1B1/P1K3P1/7R b - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bxd4","uci":"f6d4","fen_after":"4r3/p5pp/2k5/8/1Ppb3P/4p1B1/P1K3P1/7R w - - 0 28","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":50,"san":"25...h5","quality":"good","text":"25...h5 starts the kingside pawn rolling. Aronian wants to push it further and chase the bishop on g3.","best":"e6d4","script":{"say":"25...h5 starts the kingside pawn rolling. Aronian wants to push it further and chase the bishop on g3.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":67,"until":102,"brush":"green","from":"h5","to":"h4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"25...Nd4+","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1nb2/8/PPp5/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/3R3R b - - 0 25","depth":20,"score_cp":-577,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nd4+","uci":"e6d4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k2b2/8/PPpn4/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/3R3R w - - 1 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxd4+","uci":"e2d4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k2b2/8/PPpN4/4p1B1/2K3PP/3R3R b - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bxd4","uci":"f6d4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k5/8/PPpb4/4p1B1/2K3PP/3R3R w - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rhe1","uci":"h1e1","fen_after":"3rr3/p5pp/2k5/8/PPpb4/4p1B1/2K3PP/3RR3 b - - 1 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Re4","uci":"e8e4","fen_after":"3r4/p5pp/2k5/8/PPpbr3/4p1B1/2K3PP/3RR3 w - - 2 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bf2","uci":"g3f2","fen_after":"3r4/p5pp/2k5/8/PPpbr3/4p3/2K2BPP/3RR3 b - - 3 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"25...a6","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5pp/2k1nb2/8/PPp5/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/3R3R b - - 0 25","depth":20,"score_cp":-513,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a6","uci":"a7a6","fen_after":"3rr3/6pp/p1k1nb2/8/PPp5/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/3R3R w - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rhe1","uci":"h1e1","fen_after":"3rr3/6pp/p1k1nb2/8/PPp5/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/3RR3 b - - 1 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"h5","uci":"h7h5","fen_after":"3rr3/6p1/p1k1nb2/7p/PPp5/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/3RR3 w - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"h4","uci":"h2h4","fen_after":"3rr3/6p1/p1k1nb2/7p/PPp4P/4p1B1/2K1N1P1/3RR3 b - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nd4+","uci":"e6d4","fen_after":"3rr3/6p1/p1k2b2/7p/PPpn3P/4p1B1/2K1N1P1/3RR3 w - - 1 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nxd4+","uci":"e2d4","fen_after":"3rr3/6p1/p1k2b2/7p/PPpN3P/4p1B1/2K3P1/3RR3 b - - 0 28","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":51,"san":"26.Rhf1","quality":"good","text":"26.Rhf1 puts the rook on the open f-file, where it attacks the bishop on f6. The bishop is protected by the g7 pawn. Black goes on with the h-pawn.\n\nOn the board: The pawn push.","best":"h2h4","script":{"say":"26.Rhf1 puts the rook on the open f-file, where it attacks the bishop on f6. The bishop is protected by the g7 pawn. Black goes on with the h-pawn.","show":[{"title":"The pawn push","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5p1/2k1nb2/7p/PPp5/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/3R3R w - - 0 26","depth":20,"score_cp":-581,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The computer's choice here was a kingside pawn move.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"h4","uci":"h2h4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5p1/2k1nb2/7p/PPp4P/4p1B1/2K1N1P1/3R3R b - - 0 26","comment":"26.h4 stops the h-pawn from advancing.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nd4+","uci":"e6d4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5p1/2k2b2/7p/PPpn3P/4p1B1/2K1N1P1/3R3R w - - 1 27","comment":"26...Nd4+ jumps in with check.","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nxd4+","uci":"e2d4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5p1/2k2b2/7p/PPpN3P/4p1B1/2K3P1/3R3R b - - 0 27","comment":"27.Nxd4+ takes the knight with check.","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bxd4","uci":"f6d4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5p1/2k5/7p/PPpb3P/4p1B1/2K3P1/3R3R w - - 0 28","comment":"27...Bxd4 recaptures with the bishop.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"The computer's choice here was a kingside pawn move.","takeaway":"Stopping the h-pawn early would have slowed Black's kingside plan."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":40,"until":147,"brush":"red","from":"f1","to":"f6"},{"type":"arrow","at":140,"until":147,"brush":"green","from":"h5","to":"h4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"26.h4","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5p1/2k1nb2/7p/PPp5/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/3R3R w - - 0 26","depth":20,"score_cp":-581,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"h4","uci":"h2h4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5p1/2k1nb2/7p/PPp4P/4p1B1/2K1N1P1/3R3R b - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nd4+","uci":"e6d4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5p1/2k2b2/7p/PPpn3P/4p1B1/2K1N1P1/3R3R w - - 1 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nxd4+","uci":"e2d4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5p1/2k2b2/7p/PPpN3P/4p1B1/2K3P1/3R3R b - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bxd4","uci":"f6d4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5p1/2k5/7p/PPpb3P/4p1B1/2K3P1/3R3R w - - 0 28","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"b5+","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"3rr3/p5p1/2k5/1P5p/P1pb3P/4p1B1/2K3P1/3R3R b - - 0 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kc5","uci":"c6c5","fen_after":"3rr3/p5p1/8/1Pk4p/P1pb3P/4p1B1/2K3P1/3R3R w - - 1 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":null},{"ply":52,"san":"26...h4","quality":"best","text":"26...h4 is the computer's top choice. The pawn hits the bishop on g3 and gains more space. The bishop must go back.","best":"h5h4","script":{"say":"26...h4 is the computer's top choice. The pawn hits the bishop on g3 and gains more space. The bishop must go back.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":69,"until":115,"brush":"red","from":"h4","to":"g3"},{"type":"arrow","at":110,"until":115,"brush":"green","from":"g3","to":"e1"}]},"alternatives":[],"playedRank":1},{"ply":53,"san":"27.Be1","quality":"good","text":"27.Be1 retreats the bishop to the back rank, where it keeps an eye on the queenside. Black offers a rook trade.\n\nOn the board: Trading rooks first.","best":"b4b5","script":{"say":"27.Be1 retreats the bishop to the back rank, where it keeps an eye on the queenside. Black offers a rook trade.","show":[{"title":"Trading rooks first","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/3R1R2 w - - 0 27","depth":21,"score_cp":-650,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White could have traded rooks before moving the bishop.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rxd8","uci":"d1d8","fen_after":"3Rr3/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/5R2 b - - 0 27","comment":"27.Rxd8 takes the rook on d8.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxd8","uci":"e8d8","fen_after":"3r4/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/5R2 w - - 0 28","comment":"27...Rxd8 recaptures with the rook from e8.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Be1","uci":"g3e1","fen_after":"3r4/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p3/2K1N1PP/4BR2 b - - 1 28","comment":"28.Be1 then drops the bishop back.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White could have traded rooks before moving the bishop.","takeaway":"Either order leads to a rook ending that is clearly worse for White."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":110,"until":111,"brush":"green","from":"d8","to":"d1"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"27.b5+","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/3R1R2 w - - 0 27","depth":21,"score_cp":-567,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"b5+","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"3rr3/p5p1/2k1nb2/1P6/P1p4p/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/3R1R2 b - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kb6","uci":"c6b6","fen_after":"3rr3/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p4p/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/3R1R2 w - - 1 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bd6","uci":"g3d6","fen_after":"3rr3/p5p1/1k1Bnb2/1P6/P1p4p/4p3/2K1N1PP/3R1R2 b - - 2 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"h3","uci":"h4h3","fen_after":"3rr3/p5p1/1k1Bnb2/1P6/P1p5/4p2p/2K1N1PP/3R1R2 w - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"g3","uci":"g2g3","fen_after":"3rr3/p5p1/1k1Bnb2/1P6/P1p5/4p1Pp/2K1N2P/3R1R2 b - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nd4+","uci":"e6d4","fen_after":"3rr3/p5p1/1k1B1b2/1P6/P1pn4/4p1Pp/2K1N2P/3R1R2 w - - 1 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"27.Rxd8","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/3R1R2 w - - 0 27","depth":21,"score_cp":-650,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rxd8","uci":"d1d8","fen_after":"3Rr3/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/5R2 b - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxd8","uci":"e8d8","fen_after":"3r4/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p1B1/2K1N1PP/5R2 w - - 0 28","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Be1","uci":"g3e1","fen_after":"3r4/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p3/2K1N1PP/4BR2 b - - 1 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rd3","uci":"d8d3","fen_after":"8/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/4BR2 w - - 2 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"b5+","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"8/p5p1/2k1nb2/1P6/P1p4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/4BR2 b - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kb6","uci":"c6b6","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/4BR2 w - - 1 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":54,"san":"27...Rxd1","quality":"best","text":"27...Rxd1 is the computer's top choice. Aronian trades a pair of rooks, and the fewer pieces White has, the stronger Black's extra pawn becomes. The king takes back.","best":"d8d1","script":{"say":"27...Rxd1 is the computer's top choice. Aronian trades a pair of rooks, and the fewer pieces White has, the stronger Black's extra pawn becomes. The king takes back.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":164,"until":165,"brush":"green","from":"c2","to":"d1"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"27...h3","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p3/2K1N1PP/3RBR2 b - - 1 27","depth":22,"score_cp":-445,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"h3","uci":"h4h3","fen_after":"3rr3/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp5/4p2p/2K1N1PP/3RBR2 w - - 0 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"gxh3","uci":"g2h3","fen_after":"3rr3/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp5/4p2P/2K1N2P/3RBR2 b - - 0 28","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rxd1","uci":"d8d1","fen_after":"4r3/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp5/4p2P/2K1N2P/3rBR2 w - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"b5+","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"4r3/p5p1/2k1nb2/1P6/P1p5/4p2P/2K1N2P/3rBR2 b - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kb6","uci":"c6b6","fen_after":"4r3/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p5/4p2P/2K1N2P/3rBR2 w - - 1 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kxd1","uci":"c2d1","fen_after":"4r3/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p5/4p2P/4N2P/3KBR2 b - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"27...Rh8","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3rr3/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p3/2K1N1PP/3RBR2 b - - 1 27","depth":22,"score_cp":-369,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rh8","uci":"e8h8","fen_after":"3r3r/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p3/2K1N1PP/3RBR2 w - - 2 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bc3","uci":"e1c3","fen_after":"3r3r/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/2B1p3/2K1N1PP/3R1R2 b - - 3 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rxd1","uci":"d8d1","fen_after":"7r/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/2B1p3/2K1N1PP/3r1R2 w - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rxd1","uci":"f1d1","fen_after":"7r/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/2B1p3/2K1N1PP/3R4 b - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rf8","uci":"h8f8","fen_after":"5r2/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/2B1p3/2K1N1PP/3R4 w - - 1 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"a5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"5r2/p5p1/2k1nb2/P7/1Pp4p/2B1p3/2K1N1PP/3R4 b - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":55,"san":"28.Kxd1","quality":"inaccuracy","text":"28.Kxd1 takes the rook back. The computer slightly preferred the check 28.b5+ first, but play soon reaches the same position anyway, and Black remains clearly winning. The last rook comes over.\n\nOn the board: The check first.","best":"b4b5","script":{"say":"28.Kxd1 takes the rook back. The computer slightly preferred the check 28.b5+ first, but play soon reaches the same position anyway, and Black remains clearly winning. The last rook comes over.","show":[{"title":"The check first","line":{"fen":"4r3/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p3/2K1N1PP/3rBR2 w - - 0 28","depth":18,"score_cp":-364,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The computer preferred to give the pawn check before taking the rook.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"b5+","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"4r3/p5p1/2k1nb2/1P6/P1p4p/4p3/2K1N1PP/3rBR2 b - - 0 28","comment":"28.b5+ drives the king back to b6.","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kb6","uci":"c6b6","fen_after":"4r3/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p4p/4p3/2K1N1PP/3rBR2 w - - 1 29","comment":"28...Kb6 steps in front of the pawn.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Kxd1","uci":"c2d1","fen_after":"4r3/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p4p/4p3/4N1PP/3KBR2 b - - 0 29","comment":"29.Kxd1 then takes the rook.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"The computer preferred to give the pawn check before taking the rook.","takeaway":"A check at the right time keeps the same position and costs nothing."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":192,"until":193,"brush":"green","from":"e8","to":"d8"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"28.b5+","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"4r3/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p3/2K1N1PP/3rBR2 w - - 0 28","depth":18,"score_cp":-364,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"b5+","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"4r3/p5p1/2k1nb2/1P6/P1p4p/4p3/2K1N1PP/3rBR2 b - - 0 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kb6","uci":"c6b6","fen_after":"4r3/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p4p/4p3/2K1N1PP/3rBR2 w - - 1 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Kxd1","uci":"c2d1","fen_after":"4r3/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p4p/4p3/4N1PP/3KBR2 b - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rd8+","uci":"e8d8","fen_after":"3r4/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p4p/4p3/4N1PP/3KBR2 w - - 1 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kc2","uci":"d1c2","fen_after":"3r4/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p4p/4p3/2K1N1PP/4BR2 b - - 2 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rd3","uci":"d8d3","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/4BR2 w - - 3 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"28.g4","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"4r3/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p3/2K1N1PP/3rBR2 w - - 0 28","depth":18,"score_cp":-699,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"g4","uci":"g2g4","fen_after":"4r3/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp3Pp/4p3/2K1N2P/3rBR2 b - g3 0 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Ra1","uci":"d1a1","fen_after":"4r3/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp3Pp/4p3/2K1N2P/r3BR2 w - - 1 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"g5","uci":"g4g5","fen_after":"4r3/p5p1/2k1nb2/6P1/PPp4p/4p3/2K1N2P/r3BR2 b - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nxg5","uci":"e6g5","fen_after":"4r3/p5p1/2k2b2/6n1/PPp4p/4p3/2K1N2P/r3BR2 w - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nc3","uci":"e2c3","fen_after":"4r3/p5p1/2k2b2/6n1/PPp4p/2N1p3/2K4P/r3BR2 b - - 1 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bxc3","uci":"f6c3","fen_after":"4r3/p5p1/2k5/6n1/PPp4p/2b1p3/2K4P/r3BR2 w - - 0 31","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":56,"san":"28...Rd8+","quality":"best","text":"28...Rd8+ is the computer's top choice. The last black rook takes the open d-file with check and pushes the king away.","best":"e8d8","script":{"say":"28...Rd8+ is the computer's top choice. The last black rook takes the open d-file with check and pushes the king away.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":82,"until":118,"brush":"red","from":"d8","to":"d1"},{"type":"arrow","at":117,"until":118,"brush":"green","from":"d1","to":"c2"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"28...Kd5","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"4r3/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p3/4N1PP/3KBR2 b - - 0 28","depth":20,"score_cp":-477,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Kd5","uci":"c6d5","fen_after":"4r3/p5p1/4nb2/3k4/PPp4p/4p3/4N1PP/3KBR2 w - - 1 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rf5+","uci":"f1f5","fen_after":"4r3/p5p1/4nb2/3k1R2/PPp4p/4p3/4N1PP/3KB3 b - - 2 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Ke4","uci":"d5e4","fen_after":"4r3/p5p1/4nb2/5R2/PPp1k2p/4p3/4N1PP/3KB3 w - - 3 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Ra5","uci":"f5a5","fen_after":"4r3/p5p1/4nb2/R7/PPp1k2p/4p3/4N1PP/3KB3 b - - 4 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"h3","uci":"h4h3","fen_after":"4r3/p5p1/4nb2/R7/PPp1k3/4p2p/4N1PP/3KB3 w - - 0 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"gxh3","uci":"g2h3","fen_after":"4r3/p5p1/4nb2/R7/PPp1k3/4p2P/4N2P/3KB3 b - - 0 31","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"28...a6","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"4r3/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p3/4N1PP/3KBR2 b - - 0 28","depth":20,"score_cp":-448,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a6","uci":"a7a6","fen_after":"4r3/6p1/p1k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p3/4N1PP/3KBR2 w - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nf4","uci":"e2f4","fen_after":"4r3/6p1/p1k1nb2/8/PPp2N1p/4p3/6PP/3KBR2 b - - 1 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rd8+","uci":"e8d8","fen_after":"3r4/6p1/p1k1nb2/8/PPp2N1p/4p3/6PP/3KBR2 w - - 2 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Ke2","uci":"d1e2","fen_after":"3r4/6p1/p1k1nb2/8/PPp2N1p/4p3/4K1PP/4BR2 b - - 3 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nd4+","uci":"e6d4","fen_after":"3r4/6p1/p1k2b2/8/PPpn1N1p/4p3/4K1PP/4BR2 w - - 4 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kxe3","uci":"e2e3","fen_after":"3r4/6p1/p1k2b2/8/PPpn1N1p/4K3/6PP/4BR2 b - - 0 31","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":57,"san":"29.Kc2","quality":"best","text":"29.Kc2 is the best square for the king, close to the queenside pawns. Black's rook can drop down.","best":"d1c2","script":{"say":"29.Kc2 is the best square for the king, close to the queenside pawns. Black's rook can drop down.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":96,"until":97,"brush":"green","from":"d8","to":"d3"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"29.Kc1","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3r4/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p3/4N1PP/3KBR2 w - - 1 29","depth":15,"score_cp":-432,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Kc1","uci":"d1c1","fen_after":"3r4/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p3/4N1PP/2K1BR2 b - - 2 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rd3","uci":"d8d3","fen_after":"8/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/3rp3/4N1PP/2K1BR2 w - - 3 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"b5+","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"8/p5p1/2k1nb2/1P6/P1p4p/3rp3/4N1PP/2K1BR2 b - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kd5","uci":"c6d5","fen_after":"8/p5p1/4nb2/1P1k4/P1p4p/3rp3/4N1PP/2K1BR2 w - - 1 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"a5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"8/p5p1/4nb2/PP1k4/2p4p/3rp3/4N1PP/2K1BR2 b - - 0 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Ra3","uci":"d3a3","fen_after":"8/p5p1/4nb2/PP1k4/2p4p/r3p3/4N1PP/2K1BR2 w - - 1 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"29.Nd4+","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3r4/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p3/4N1PP/3KBR2 w - - 1 29","depth":15,"score_cp":-748,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nd4+","uci":"e2d4","fen_after":"3r4/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPpN3p/4p3/6PP/3KBR2 b - - 2 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxd4","uci":"e6d4","fen_after":"3r4/p5p1/2k2b2/8/PPpn3p/4p3/6PP/3KBR2 w - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rh1","uci":"f1h1","fen_after":"3r4/p5p1/2k2b2/8/PPpn3p/4p3/6PP/3KB2R b - - 1 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kd5","uci":"c6d5","fen_after":"3r4/p5p1/5b2/3k4/PPpn3p/4p3/6PP/3KB2R w - - 2 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kc1","uci":"d1c1","fen_after":"3r4/p5p1/5b2/3k4/PPpn3p/4p3/6PP/2K1B2R b - - 3 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"e2","uci":"e3e2","fen_after":"3r4/p5p1/5b2/3k4/PPpn3p/8/4p1PP/2K1B2R w - - 0 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":58,"san":"29...Rd3","quality":"best","text":"29...Rd3 is the computer's top choice. The rook goes deep into White's camp, guards the pawn on e3 from the side, and eyes the third rank. White can push b5 with check.","best":"d8d3","script":{"say":"29...Rd3 is the computer's top choice. The rook goes deep into White's camp, guards the pawn on e3 from the side, and eyes the third rank. White can push b5 with check.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":137,"until":168,"brush":"yellow","from":"d3","to":"a3"},{"type":"arrow","at":154,"until":168,"brush":"green","from":"b4","to":"b5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"29...Nd4+","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3r4/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p3/2K1N1PP/4BR2 b - - 2 29","depth":27,"score_cp":-532,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nd4+","uci":"e6d4","fen_after":"3r4/p5p1/2k2b2/8/PPpn3p/4p3/2K1N1PP/4BR2 w - - 3 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxd4+","uci":"e2d4","fen_after":"3r4/p5p1/2k2b2/8/PPpN3p/4p3/2K3PP/4BR2 b - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rxd4","uci":"d8d4","fen_after":"8/p5p1/2k2b2/8/PPpr3p/4p3/2K3PP/4BR2 w - - 0 31","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"b5+","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"8/p5p1/2k2b2/1P6/P1pr3p/4p3/2K3PP/4BR2 b - - 0 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kd5","uci":"c6d5","fen_after":"8/p5p1/5b2/1P1k4/P1pr3p/4p3/2K3PP/4BR2 w - - 1 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"a5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"8/p5p1/5b2/PP1k4/2pr3p/4p3/2K3PP/4BR2 b - - 0 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"29...a6","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"3r4/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p3/2K1N1PP/4BR2 b - - 2 29","depth":27,"score_cp":-511,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a6","uci":"a7a6","fen_after":"3r4/6p1/p1k1nb2/8/PPp4p/4p3/2K1N1PP/4BR2 w - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rf5","uci":"f1f5","fen_after":"3r4/6p1/p1k1nb2/5R2/PPp4p/4p3/2K1N1PP/4B3 b - - 1 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rd3","uci":"d8d3","fen_after":"8/6p1/p1k1nb2/5R2/PPp4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/4B3 w - - 2 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Ra5","uci":"f5a5","fen_after":"8/6p1/p1k1nb2/R7/PPp4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/4B3 b - - 3 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kb7","uci":"c6b7","fen_after":"8/1k4p1/p3nb2/R7/PPp4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/4B3 w - - 4 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"b5","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"8/1k4p1/p3nb2/RP6/P1p4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/4B3 b - - 0 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":59,"san":"30.b5+","quality":"best","text":"30.b5+ is White's most active try, a pawn check that drives the king away from c6. The king steps aside.","best":"b4b5","script":{"say":"30.b5+ is White's most active try, a pawn check that drives the king away from c6. The king steps aside.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":98,"until":104,"brush":"green","from":"c6","to":"b6"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"30.g3","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"8/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/4BR2 w - - 3 30","depth":26,"score_cp":-681,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"g3","uci":"g2g3","fen_after":"8/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/3rp1P1/2K1N2P/4BR2 b - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"h3","uci":"h4h3","fen_after":"8/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp5/3rp1Pp/2K1N2P/4BR2 w - - 0 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"b5+","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"8/p5p1/2k1nb2/1P6/P1p5/3rp1Pp/2K1N2P/4BR2 b - - 0 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kd5","uci":"c6d5","fen_after":"8/p5p1/4nb2/1P1k4/P1p5/3rp1Pp/2K1N2P/4BR2 w - - 1 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nc3+","uci":"e2c3","fen_after":"8/p5p1/4nb2/1P1k4/P1p5/2Nrp1Pp/2K4P/4BR2 b - - 2 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bxc3","uci":"f6c3","fen_after":"8/p5p1/4n3/1P1k4/P1p5/2brp1Pp/2K4P/4BR2 w - - 0 33","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"30.Rf5","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"8/p5p1/2k1nb2/8/PPp4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/4BR2 w - - 3 30","depth":26,"score_cp":-688,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rf5","uci":"f1f5","fen_after":"8/p5p1/2k1nb2/5R2/PPp4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/4B3 b - - 4 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rb3","uci":"d3b3","fen_after":"8/p5p1/2k1nb2/5R2/PPp4p/1r2p3/2K1N1PP/4B3 w - - 5 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"b5+","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"8/p5p1/2k1nb2/1P3R2/P1p4p/1r2p3/2K1N1PP/4B3 b - - 0 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kd6","uci":"c6d6","fen_after":"8/p5p1/3knb2/1P3R2/P1p4p/1r2p3/2K1N1PP/4B3 w - - 1 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rxf6","uci":"f5f6","fen_after":"8/p5p1/3knR2/1P6/P1p4p/1r2p3/2K1N1PP/4B3 b - - 0 32","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"gxf6","uci":"g7f6","fen_after":"8/p7/3knp2/1P6/P1p4p/1r2p3/2K1N1PP/4B3 w - - 0 33","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":60,"san":"30...Kb6","quality":"good","text":"30...Kb6 steps right in front of the pawn and blocks it. Black is still winning, and White's knight heads for f4.","best":"c6d5","script":{"say":"30...Kb6 steps right in front of the pawn and blocks it. Black is still winning, and White's knight heads for f4.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":55,"until":113,"brush":"yellow","square":"b5"},{"type":"arrow","at":106,"until":113,"brush":"green","from":"e2","to":"f4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"30...Kd5","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"8/p5p1/2k1nb2/1P6/P1p4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/4BR2 b - - 0 30","depth":25,"score_cp":-677,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Kd5","uci":"c6d5","fen_after":"8/p5p1/4nb2/1P1k4/P1p4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/4BR2 w - - 1 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rf3","uci":"f1f3","fen_after":"8/p5p1/4nb2/1P1k4/P1p4p/3rpR2/2K1N1PP/4B3 b - - 2 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Ke4","uci":"d5e4","fen_after":"8/p5p1/4nb2/1P6/P1p1k2p/3rpR2/2K1N1PP/4B3 w - - 3 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"a5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"8/p5p1/4nb2/PP6/2p1k2p/3rpR2/2K1N1PP/4B3 b - - 0 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nd4+","uci":"e6d4","fen_after":"8/p5p1/5b2/PP6/2pnk2p/3rpR2/2K1N1PP/4B3 w - - 1 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nxd4","uci":"e2d4","fen_after":"8/p5p1/5b2/PP6/2pNk2p/3rpR2/2K3PP/4B3 b - - 0 33","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"30...Kd6","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"8/p5p1/2k1nb2/1P6/P1p4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/4BR2 b - - 0 30","depth":25,"score_cp":-663,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Kd6","uci":"c6d6","fen_after":"8/p5p1/3knb2/1P6/P1p4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/4BR2 w - - 1 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bb4+","uci":"e1b4","fen_after":"8/p5p1/3knb2/1P6/PBp4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/5R2 b - - 2 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Kd5","uci":"d6d5","fen_after":"8/p5p1/4nb2/1P1k4/PBp4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/5R2 w - - 3 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"a5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"8/p5p1/4nb2/PP1k4/1Bp4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/5R2 b - - 0 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nd4+","uci":"e6d4","fen_after":"8/p5p1/5b2/PP1k4/1Bpn3p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/5R2 w - - 1 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nxd4","uci":"e2d4","fen_after":"8/p5p1/5b2/PP1k4/1BpN3p/3rp3/2K3PP/5R2 b - - 0 33","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":61,"san":"31.Nf4","quality":"good","text":"31.Nf4 brings the knight toward the action, but Black's passed pawn on e3 is simply too strong and White has no good way to stop it. Black's knight can jump in with check.\n\nOn the board: Chasing the h-pawn.","best":"g2g3","script":{"say":"31.Nf4 brings the knight toward the action, but Black's passed pawn on e3 is simply too strong and White has no good way to stop it. Black's knight can jump in with check.","show":[{"title":"Chasing the h-pawn","line":{"fen":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/4BR2 w - - 1 31","depth":27,"score_cp":-628,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White had a calmer try: attack the pawn on h4 with a pawn move.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"g3","uci":"g2g3","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p4p/3rp1P1/2K1N2P/4BR2 b - - 0 31","comment":"31.g3 challenges the pawn on h4.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"hxg3","uci":"h4g3","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p5/3rp1p1/2K1N2P/4BR2 w - - 0 32","comment":"31...hxg3 takes it.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"hxg3","uci":"h2g3","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p5/3rp1P1/2K1N3/4BR2 b - - 0 32","comment":"32.hxg3 recaptures and opens the h-file for White's rook.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White had a calmer try: attack the pawn on h4 with a pawn move.","takeaway":"Even this keeps White clearly worse, because the pawn on e3 stays in place."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":71,"until":171,"brush":"green","square":"e3"},{"type":"arrow","at":160,"until":171,"brush":"green","from":"e6","to":"d4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"31.g3","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/4BR2 w - - 1 31","depth":27,"score_cp":-628,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"g3","uci":"g2g3","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p4p/3rp1P1/2K1N2P/4BR2 b - - 0 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"hxg3","uci":"h4g3","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p5/3rp1p1/2K1N2P/4BR2 w - - 0 32","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"hxg3","uci":"h2g3","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p5/3rp1P1/2K1N3/4BR2 b - - 0 32","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Ra3","uci":"d3a3","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p5/r3p1P1/2K1N3/4BR2 w - - 1 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"g4","uci":"g3g4","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p3P1/r3p3/2K1N3/4BR2 b - - 0 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Ra2+","uci":"a3a2","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p3P1/4p3/r1K1N3/4BR2 w - - 1 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"31.Bb4","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/4BR2 w - - 1 31","depth":27,"score_cp":-640,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bb4","uci":"e1b4","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/PBp4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/5R2 b - - 2 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rb3","uci":"d3b3","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/PBp4p/1r2p3/2K1N1PP/5R2 w - - 3 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rb1","uci":"f1b1","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/PBp4p/1r2p3/2K1N1PP/1R6 b - - 4 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rxb1","uci":"b3b1","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/PBp4p/4p3/2K1N1PP/1r6 w - - 0 33","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kxb1","uci":"c2b1","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/PBp4p/4p3/4N1PP/1K6 b - - 0 33","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nc5","uci":"e6c5","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k3b2/1Pn5/PBp4p/4p3/4N1PP/1K6 w - - 1 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"31.Rf5","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/4BR2 w - - 1 31","depth":27,"score_cp":-656,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rf5","uci":"f1f5","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P3R2/P1p4p/3rp3/2K1N1PP/4B3 b - - 2 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Ra3","uci":"d3a3","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P3R2/P1p4p/r3p3/2K1N1PP/4B3 w - - 3 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"a5+","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/PP3R2/2p4p/r3p3/2K1N1PP/4B3 b - - 0 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kb7","uci":"b6b7","fen_after":"8/pk4p1/4nb2/PP3R2/2p4p/r3p3/2K1N1PP/4B3 w - - 1 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bb4","uci":"e1b4","fen_after":"8/pk4p1/4nb2/PP3R2/1Bp4p/r3p3/2K1N1PP/8 b - - 2 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rb3","uci":"a3b3","fen_after":"8/pk4p1/4nb2/PP3R2/1Bp4p/1r2p3/2K1N1PP/8 w - - 3 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":null},{"ply":62,"san":"31...Nd4+","quality":"best","text":"31...Nd4+ gives check with the knight and wins more ground. White is down to a lost position, and Aronian takes the full point. The pawn on e3 will step forward next.\n\nOn the board: Taking on f4.\n\nThe game ended here: Aronian won with Black. The lesson: A far-advanced passed pawn, supported by active pieces, can decide a game on its own. Van Foreest let the e-pawn run and never got his pieces working together, so keep your pieces active early and don't let a passed pawn roll.","best":"e6d4","script":{"say":"31...Nd4+ gives check with the knight and wins more ground. White is down to a lost position, and Aronian takes the full point. The pawn on e3 will step forward next.","show":[{"title":"Taking on f4","line":{"fen":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p2N1p/3rp3/2K3PP/4BR2 b - - 2 31","depth":21,"score_cp":-567,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black could also have simply traded knights.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nxf4","uci":"e6f4","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k3b2/1P6/P1p2n1p/3rp3/2K3PP/4BR2 w - - 0 32","comment":"31...Nxf4 takes the knight on f4.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxf4","uci":"f1f4","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k3b2/1P6/P1p2R1p/3rp3/2K3PP/4B3 b - - 0 32","comment":"32.Rxf4 recaptures with the rook.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Kc5","uci":"b6c5","fen_after":"8/p5p1/5b2/1Pk5/P1p2R1p/3rp3/2K3PP/4B3 w - - 1 33","comment":"32...Kc5 walks the king toward the centre.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Black could also have simply traded knights.","takeaway":"The check is stronger: it keeps the knights on and the e-pawn rolling."}}],"after":"The game ended here: Aronian won with Black. The lesson: A far-advanced passed pawn, supported by active pieces, can decide a game on its own. Van Foreest let the e-pawn run and never got his pieces working together, so keep your pieces active early and don't let a passed pawn roll.","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":38,"until":166,"brush":"red","square":"c2"},{"type":"arrow","at":148,"until":166,"brush":"green","from":"e3","to":"e2"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"31...Nxf4","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p2N1p/3rp3/2K3PP/4BR2 b - - 2 31","depth":21,"score_cp":-567,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nxf4","uci":"e6f4","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k3b2/1P6/P1p2n1p/3rp3/2K3PP/4BR2 w - - 0 32","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxf4","uci":"f1f4","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k3b2/1P6/P1p2R1p/3rp3/2K3PP/4B3 b - - 0 32","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Kc5","uci":"b6c5","fen_after":"8/p5p1/5b2/1Pk5/P1p2R1p/3rp3/2K3PP/4B3 w - - 1 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rf5+","uci":"f4f5","fen_after":"8/p5p1/5b2/1Pk2R2/P1p4p/3rp3/2K3PP/4B3 b - - 2 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kd4","uci":"c5d4","fen_after":"8/p5p1/5b2/1P3R2/P1pk3p/3rp3/2K3PP/4B3 w - - 3 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"a5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"8/p5p1/5b2/PP3R2/2pk3p/3rp3/2K3PP/4B3 b - - 0 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"31...Rd6","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"8/p5p1/1k2nb2/1P6/P1p2N1p/3rp3/2K3PP/4BR2 b - - 2 31","depth":21,"score_cp":-437,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rd6","uci":"d3d6","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k1rnb2/1P6/P1p2N1p/4p3/2K3PP/4BR2 w - - 3 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bb4","uci":"e1b4","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k1rnb2/1P6/PBp2N1p/4p3/2K3PP/5R2 b - - 4 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nd4+","uci":"e6d4","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k1r1b2/1P6/PBpn1N1p/4p3/2K3PP/5R2 w - - 5 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kb1","uci":"c2b1","fen_after":"8/p5p1/1k1r1b2/1P6/PBpn1N1p/4p3/6PP/1K3R2 b - - 6 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rd8","uci":"d6d8","fen_after":"3r4/p5p1/1k3b2/1P6/PBpn1N1p/4p3/6PP/1K3R2 w - - 7 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Re1","uci":"f1e1","fen_after":"3r4/p5p1/1k3b2/1P6/PBpn1N1p/4p3/6PP/1K2R3 b - - 8 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1}],"engine":"Deep computer analysis (median depth 24)","start":{"openPly":26,"keyPly":31,"autoTo":37}}