{"id":"total-chess-budapest-2026/rapport-vs-caruana-round-1","slug":"rapport-vs-caruana-round-1","title":"Rapport vs Caruana, Round 1","h1":"Rapport vs Caruana, Total Chess Budapest 2026 Round 1: Caruana beats Rapport with Black in 53 moves","pgn":"[Event \"2026 Total Chess World Championship Tour Pilot Group B\"]\n[Site \"Budapest, HU\"]\n[Date \"2026.11.11\"]\n[Round \"01\"]\n[White \"Rapport, Richard\"]\n[Black \"Caruana, Fabiano\"]\n[Result \"0-1\"]\n[WhiteElo \"2718\"]\n[BlackElo \"2783\"]\n[WhiteTitle \"GM\"]\n[BlackTitle \"GM\"]\n[WhiteFideId \"738590\"]\n[BlackFideId \"2020009\"]\n[TimeControl \"2700+30\"]\n[Board \"2\"]\n[ECO \"A13\"]\n[Opening \"English Opening: Agincourt Defense\"]\n\n1. c4 e6 2. g3 d5 3. Bg2 Nc6 4. Nf3 dxc4 5. Qa4 Bd7 6. Qxc4 e5 7. Nc3 Nf6 8. Ng5 Qe7 9. O-O h6 10. Nge4 Nxe4 11. Qxe4 O-O-O 12. d3 f5 13. Qa4 Kb8 14. Be3 Nd4 15. Qa5 Qc5 16. Qxc5 Bxc5 17. Rfc1 Rhf8 18. Bxd4 Bxd4 19. e3 Bb6 20. Nd5 Be6 21. Nxb6 axb6 22. Rc3 Rd6 23. a4 Rfd8 24. Bf1 Bd5 25. Be2 g5 26. Kf1 g4 27. Ke1 h5 28. Rac1 c6 29. b4 Rh8 30. a5 bxa5 31. bxa5 h4 32. Rc5 hxg3 33. hxg3 Rh1+ 34. Kd2 Rh2 35. Rf1 Kc7 36. Rc2 Rd8 37. Kc3 Ra8 38. Kb4 f4 39. gxf4 exf4 40. exf4 Rf8 41. Kc3 Rxf4 42. Rb2 Ra4 43. Kd2 Be6 44. Rfb1 Bc8 45. Rb4 Ra2+ 46. R1b2 Rxb2+ 47. Rxb2 Rxf2 48. Ke3 Rh2 49. Rb4 Rh5 50. Rf4 Re5+ 51. Kf2 g3+ 52. Kf3 Rg5 53. Bf1 Be6 0-1","review":{"white":"Richard Rapport","black":"Fabiano Caruana","event":"Total Chess World Championship Tour Pilot 2026","site":"Budapest, Hungary","date":"2026.11.11","round":"1","result":"0-1","whiteelo":"2718","blackelo":"2783","opening":"English Opening: Agincourt Defense"},"intro":"Caruana beat Rapport with Black in 53 moves, slowly outplaying him in a long endgame after a sharp English Opening.","summary":"Welcome to round 1 of Group B in Budapest. Richard Rapport has White against Fabiano Caruana, and the game begins as an English Opening with a sharp early skirmish. Both players seek small advantages rather than quick tactics, and the story of the game is a long, patient squeeze. Caruana wins with Black, so watch how he turns a tiny edge into a full point.","evals":[19,12,26,14,9,15,21,23,42,37,33,26,28,27,26,-1,-3,3,0,-34,-44,-28,-25,-73,-86,-82,-82,-79,-68,-72,-81,-68,-75,-90,-69,-67,-85,-75,-45,-41,-37,-37,-44,-43,-34,-61,-60,-65,-24,-25,-36,-41,-46,-59,-38,-71,-70,-62,-38,-70,-53,-26,-45,-188,-125,-188,-11,-19,-93,0,-3,-29,-34,-62,-60,-23,-6,-48,-42,-242,-302,-241,-215,-298,-359,-395,-333,-172,-179,-287,-235,-264,-300,-313,-461,-491,-208,-335,-456,-352,-491,-657,-442,-755,-649,-669,-813],"moments":[{"ply":63,"san":"32. Rc5","kind":"inaccuracy","drop":13},{"ply":66,"san":"33...Rh1+","kind":"inaccuracy","drop":16},{"ply":79,"san":"40. exf4","kind":"inaccuracy","drop":17},{"ply":96,"san":"48...Rh2","kind":"inaccuracy","drop":18},{"ply":103,"san":"52. Kf3","kind":"inaccuracy","drop":11}],"notes":[{"ply":1,"san":"1.c4","quality":"best","text":"Rapport opens with 1.c4, the English. The pawn grabs space on the queenside and watches the d5 square, a favourite of players who want a game with plenty of subtle manoeuvring.","best":"c2c4","script":{"say":"Rapport opens with 1.c4, the English. The pawn grabs space on the queenside and watches the d5 square, a favourite of players who want a game with plenty of subtle manoeuvring.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":88,"until":176,"brush":"yellow","square":"d5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"1.e4","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 1","depth":65,"score_cp":17,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"e4","uci":"e2e4","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/4P3/8/PPPP1PPP/RNBQKBNR b KQkq - 0 1","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"e5","uci":"e7e5","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pppp1ppp/8/4p3/4P3/8/PPPP1PPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 2","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g1f3","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pppp1ppp/8/4p3/4P3/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQKB1R b KQkq - 1 2","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nc6","uci":"b8c6","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/pppp1ppp/2n5/4p3/4P3/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQKB1R w KQkq - 2 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bb5","uci":"f1b5","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/pppp1ppp/2n5/1B2p3/4P3/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQK2R b KQkq - 3 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pppp1ppp/2n2n2/1B2p3/4P3/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQK2R w KQkq - 4 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"1.Nf3","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 1","depth":65,"score_cp":14,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g1f3","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/8/5N2/PPPPPPPP/RNBQKB1R b KQkq - 1 1","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"e6","uci":"e7e6","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pppp1ppp/4p3/8/8/5N2/PPPPPPPP/RNBQKB1R w KQkq - 0 2","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"e4","uci":"e2e4","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pppp1ppp/4p3/8/4P3/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQKB1R b KQkq - 0 2","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"d5","uci":"d7d5","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/4p3/3p4/4P3/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQKB1R w KQkq - 0 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"exd5","uci":"e4d5","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/4p3/3P4/8/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQKB1R b KQkq - 0 3","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"exd5","uci":"e6d5","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/8/3p4/8/5N2/PPPP1PPP/RNBQKB1R w KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":2,"san":"1...e6","quality":"good","text":"Caruana answers 1...e6, a flexible reply. He keeps the d5 pawn move in reserve and doesn't commit his pieces yet.","best":"e7e5","script":{"say":"Caruana answers 1...e6, a flexible reply. He keeps the d5 pawn move in reserve and doesn't commit his pieces yet.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":51,"until":113,"brush":"yellow","from":"d7","to":"d5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"1...e5","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/2P5/8/PP1PPPPP/RNBQKBNR b KQkq - 0 1","depth":59,"score_cp":12,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"e5","uci":"e7e5","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pppp1ppp/8/4p3/2P5/8/PP1PPPPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 2","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"g3","uci":"g2g3","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pppp1ppp/8/4p3/2P5/6P1/PP1PPP1P/RNBQKBNR b KQkq - 0 2","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/4p3/2P5/6P1/PP1PPP1P/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 1 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bg2","uci":"f1g2","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/5n2/4p3/2P5/6P1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK1NR b KQkq - 2 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bc5","uci":"f8c5","fen_after":"rnbqk2r/pppp1ppp/5n2/2b1p3/2P5/6P1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK1NR w KQkq - 3 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"d3","uci":"d2d3","fen_after":"rnbqk2r/pppp1ppp/5n2/2b1p3/2P5/3P2P1/PP2PPBP/RNBQK1NR b KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"1...c5","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/2P5/8/PP1PPPPP/RNBQKBNR b KQkq - 0 1","depth":59,"score_cp":16,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"c5","uci":"c7c5","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pp1ppppp/8/2p5/2P5/8/PP1PPPPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 2","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nc3","uci":"b1c3","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pp1ppppp/8/2p5/2P5/2N5/PP1PPPPP/R1BQKBNR b KQkq - 1 2","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pp1ppppp/5n2/2p5/2P5/2N5/PP1PPPPP/R1BQKBNR w KQkq - 2 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g1f3","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pp1ppppp/5n2/2p5/2P5/2N2N2/PP1PPPPP/R1BQKB1R b KQkq - 3 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nc6","uci":"b8c6","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pp1ppppp/2n2n2/2p5/2P5/2N2N2/PP1PPPPP/R1BQKB1R w KQkq - 4 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"g3","uci":"g2g3","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/pp1ppppp/2n2n2/2p5/2P5/2N2NP1/PP1PPP1P/R1BQKB1R b KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"1...Nf6","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/2P5/8/PP1PPPPP/RNBQKBNR b KQkq - 0 1","depth":59,"score_cp":17,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppppppp/5n2/8/2P5/8/PP1PPPPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 1 2","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g1f3","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppppppp/5n2/8/2P5/5N2/PP1PPPPP/RNBQKB1R b KQkq - 2 2","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"e6","uci":"e7e6","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/4pn2/8/2P5/5N2/PP1PPPPP/RNBQKB1R w KQkq - 0 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"g3","uci":"g2g3","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/4pn2/8/2P5/5NP1/PP1PPP1P/RNBQKB1R b KQkq - 0 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"d5","uci":"d7d5","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/ppp2ppp/4pn2/3p4/2P5/5NP1/PP1PPP1P/RNBQKB1R w KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bg2","uci":"f1g2","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/ppp2ppp/4pn2/3p4/2P5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK2R b KQkq - 1 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":null},{"ply":3,"san":"2.g3","quality":"good","text":"2.g3 prepares to put the bishop on g2, the long diagonal, where it will eye the queenside and the centre from a safe distance.","best":"b1c3","script":{"say":"2.g3 prepares to put the bishop on g2, the long diagonal, where it will eye the queenside and the centre from a safe distance.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":21,"until":126,"brush":"green","from":"f1","to":"g2"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"2.Nc3","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"rnbqkbnr/pppp1ppp/4p3/8/2P5/8/PP1PPPPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 2","depth":55,"score_cp":26,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nc3","uci":"b1c3","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pppp1ppp/4p3/8/2P5/2N5/PP1PPPPP/R1BQKBNR b KQkq - 1 2","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/4pn2/8/2P5/2N5/PP1PPPPP/R1BQKBNR w KQkq - 2 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"e4","uci":"e2e4","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/4pn2/8/2P1P3/2N5/PP1P1PPP/R1BQKBNR b KQkq - 0 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"d5","uci":"d7d5","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/ppp2ppp/4pn2/3p4/2P1P3/2N5/PP1P1PPP/R1BQKBNR w KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"cxd5","uci":"c4d5","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/ppp2ppp/4pn2/3P4/4P3/2N5/PP1P1PPP/R1BQKBNR b KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"exd5","uci":"e6d5","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/ppp2ppp/5n2/3p4/4P3/2N5/PP1P1PPP/R1BQKBNR w KQkq - 0 5","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"2.d4","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"rnbqkbnr/pppp1ppp/4p3/8/2P5/8/PP1PPPPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 2","depth":55,"score_cp":20,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"d4","uci":"d2d4","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pppp1ppp/4p3/8/2PP4/8/PP2PPPP/RNBQKBNR b KQkq - 0 2","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/4pn2/8/2PP4/8/PP2PPPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 1 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g1f3","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/4pn2/8/2PP4/5N2/PP2PPPP/RNBQKB1R b KQkq - 2 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"d5","uci":"d7d5","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/ppp2ppp/4pn2/3p4/2PP4/5N2/PP2PPPP/RNBQKB1R w KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nc3","uci":"b1c3","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/ppp2ppp/4pn2/3p4/2PP4/2N2N2/PP2PPPP/R1BQKB1R b KQkq - 1 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bb4","uci":"f8b4","fen_after":"rnbqk2r/ppp2ppp/4pn2/3p4/1bPP4/2N2N2/PP2PPPP/R1BQKB1R w KQkq - 2 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":3},{"ply":4,"san":"2...d5","quality":"best","text":"Now 2...d5 plants a pawn in the centre and challenges the c-pawn straight away. Black wants his share of the middle.","best":"d7d5","script":{"say":"Now 2...d5 plants a pawn in the centre and challenges the c-pawn straight away. Black wants his share of the middle.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":43,"until":116,"brush":"red","from":"d5","to":"c4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"2...Nf6","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"rnbqkbnr/pppp1ppp/4p3/8/2P5/6P1/PP1PPP1P/RNBQKBNR b KQkq - 0 2","depth":54,"score_cp":17,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/4pn2/8/2P5/6P1/PP1PPP1P/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 1 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bg2","uci":"f1g2","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/pppp1ppp/4pn2/8/2P5/6P1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK1NR b KQkq - 2 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"d5","uci":"d7d5","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/ppp2ppp/4pn2/3p4/2P5/6P1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK1NR w KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"d4","uci":"d2d4","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/ppp2ppp/4pn2/3p4/2PP4/6P1/PP2PPBP/RNBQK1NR b KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bb4+","uci":"f8b4","fen_after":"rnbqk2r/ppp2ppp/4pn2/3p4/1bPP4/6P1/PP2PPBP/RNBQK1NR w KQkq - 1 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nd2","uci":"b1d2","fen_after":"rnbqk2r/ppp2ppp/4pn2/3p4/1bPP4/6P1/PP1NPPBP/R1BQK1NR b KQkq - 2 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"2...Nc6","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"rnbqkbnr/pppp1ppp/4p3/8/2P5/6P1/PP1PPP1P/RNBQKBNR b KQkq - 0 2","depth":54,"score_cp":23,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nc6","uci":"b8c6","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/pppp1ppp/2n1p3/8/2P5/6P1/PP1PPP1P/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 1 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g1f3","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/pppp1ppp/2n1p3/8/2P5/5NP1/PP1PPP1P/RNBQKB1R b KQkq - 2 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"d5","uci":"d7d5","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/3p4/2P5/5NP1/PP1PPP1P/RNBQKB1R w KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"d4","uci":"d2d4","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/3p4/2PP4/5NP1/PP2PP1P/RNBQKB1R b KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"dxc4","uci":"d5c4","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/8/2pP4/5NP1/PP2PP1P/RNBQKB1R w KQkq - 0 5","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bg2","uci":"f1g2","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/8/2pP4/5NP1/PP2PPBP/RNBQK2R b KQkq - 1 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":5,"san":"3.Bg2","quality":"best","text":"3.Bg2 develops the bishop and eyes the d5 pawn down the long diagonal. It also gets White ready to castle.\n\nOn the board: Trading on d5 at once.","best":"f1g2","script":{"say":"3.Bg2 develops the bishop and eyes the d5 pawn down the long diagonal. It also gets White ready to castle.","show":[{"title":"Trading on d5 at once","line":{"fen":"rnbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/4p3/3p4/2P5/6P1/PP1PPP1P/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 3","depth":55,"score_cp":-14,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White could have released the tension immediately instead of developing the bishop.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"cxd5","uci":"c4d5","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/4p3/3P4/8/6P1/PP1PPP1P/RNBQKBNR b KQkq - 0 3","comment":"3.cxd5 trades the c-pawn at once and gives up the pressure on d5.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"exd5","uci":"e6d5","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/8/3p4/8/6P1/PP1PPP1P/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 4","comment":"3...exd5 recaptures and leaves Black with a pawn in the centre.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g1f3","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/8/3p4/8/5NP1/PP1PPP1P/RNBQKB1R b KQkq - 1 4","comment":"4.Nf3 develops, but White's queenside pressure is gone.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/ppp2ppp/5n2/3p4/8/5NP1/PP1PPP1P/RNBQKB1R w KQkq - 2 5","comment":"4...Nf6 finishes the knight development with an easy game.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White could have released the tension immediately instead of developing the bishop.","takeaway":"The computer rates this a little worse for White than the bishop move, so Rapport kept the tension."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":47,"until":106,"brush":"green","from":"g2","to":"d5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"3.d4","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"rnbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/4p3/3p4/2P5/6P1/PP1PPP1P/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 3","depth":55,"score_cp":9,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"d4","uci":"d2d4","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/4p3/3p4/2PP4/6P1/PP2PP1P/RNBQKBNR b KQkq - 0 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"dxc4","uci":"d5c4","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/4p3/8/2pP4/6P1/PP2PP1P/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g1f3","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/4p3/8/2pP4/5NP1/PP2PP1P/RNBQKB1R b KQkq - 1 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"c5","uci":"c7c5","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pp3ppp/4p3/2p5/2pP4/5NP1/PP2PP1P/RNBQKB1R w KQkq - 0 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bg2","uci":"f1g2","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/pp3ppp/4p3/2p5/2pP4/5NP1/PP2PPBP/RNBQK2R b KQkq - 1 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nc6","uci":"b8c6","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/pp3ppp/2n1p3/2p5/2pP4/5NP1/PP2PPBP/RNBQK2R w KQkq - 2 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"3.Nf3","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"rnbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/4p3/3p4/2P5/6P1/PP1PPP1P/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 3","depth":55,"score_cp":0,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g1f3","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/4p3/3p4/2P5/5NP1/PP1PPP1P/RNBQKB1R b KQkq - 1 3","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"dxc4","uci":"d5c4","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/4p3/8/2p5/5NP1/PP1PPP1P/RNBQKB1R w KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bg2","uci":"f1g2","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/4p3/8/2p5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK2R b KQkq - 1 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nd7","uci":"b8d7","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/pppn1ppp/4p3/8/2p5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK2R w KQkq - 2 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Qa4","uci":"d1a4","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/pppn1ppp/4p3/8/Q1p5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB1K2R b KQkq - 3 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"a6","uci":"a7a6","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/1ppn1ppp/p3p3/8/Q1p5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB1K2R w KQkq - 0 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":6,"san":"3...Nc6","quality":"good","text":"3...Nc6 adds a defender to the centre and heads for a flexible setup. The knight also eyes the d4 square.","best":"d5d4","script":{"say":"3...Nc6 adds a defender to the centre and heads for a flexible setup. The knight also eyes the d4 square.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":91,"until":105,"brush":"yellow","from":"c6","to":"d4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"3...d4","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"rnbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/4p3/3p4/2P5/6P1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK1NR b KQkq - 1 3","depth":54,"score_cp":15,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"d4","uci":"d5d4","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/4p3/8/2Pp4/6P1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK1NR w KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g1f3","fen_after":"rnbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/4p3/8/2Pp4/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK2R b KQkq - 1 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nc6","uci":"b8c6","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/8/2Pp4/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK2R w KQkq - 2 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"O-O","uci":"e1h1","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/8/2Pp4/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQ1RK1 b kq - 3 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":5,"san":"Nh6","uci":"g8h6","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n1p2n/8/2Pp4/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQ1RK1 w kq - 4 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"b3","uci":"b2b3","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n1p2n/8/2Pp4/1P3NP1/P2PPPBP/RNBQ1RK1 b kq - 0 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"3...Nf6","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"rnbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/4p3/3p4/2P5/6P1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK1NR b KQkq - 1 3","depth":54,"score_cp":17,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/ppp2ppp/4pn2/3p4/2P5/6P1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK1NR w KQkq - 2 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g1f3","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/ppp2ppp/4pn2/3p4/2P5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK2R b KQkq - 3 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"dxc4","uci":"d5c4","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/ppp2ppp/4pn2/8/2p5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK2R w KQkq - 0 5","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Qa4+","uci":"d1a4","fen_after":"rnbqkb1r/ppp2ppp/4pn2/8/Q1p5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB1K2R b KQkq - 1 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bd7","uci":"c8d7","fen_after":"rn1qkb1r/pppb1ppp/4pn2/8/Q1p5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB1K2R w KQkq - 2 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Qxc4","uci":"a4c4","fen_after":"rn1qkb1r/pppb1ppp/4pn2/8/2Q5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB1K2R b KQkq - 0 6","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":7,"san":"4.Nf3","quality":"best","text":"4.Nf3 brings out the knight toward the centre and gets ready to castle. Simple, healthy development.","best":"g1f3","script":{"say":"4.Nf3 brings out the knight toward the centre and gets ready to castle. Simple, healthy development.","show":[],"after":""},"alternatives":[{"title":"4.d4","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/3p4/2P5/6P1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK1NR w KQkq - 2 4","depth":28,"score_cp":16,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"d4","uci":"d2d4","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/3p4/2PP4/6P1/PP2PPBP/RNBQK1NR b KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"dxc4","uci":"d5c4","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/8/2pP4/6P1/PP2PPBP/RNBQK1NR w KQkq - 0 5","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g1f3","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/8/2pP4/5NP1/PP2PPBP/RNBQK2R b KQkq - 1 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rb8","uci":"a8b8","fen_after":"1rbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/8/2pP4/5NP1/PP2PPBP/RNBQK2R w KQk - 2 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nc3","uci":"b1c3","fen_after":"1rbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/8/2pP4/2N2NP1/PP2PPBP/R1BQK2R b KQk - 3 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"1rbqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n1pn2/8/2pP4/2N2NP1/PP2PPBP/R1BQK2R w KQk - 4 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"4.cxd5","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/3p4/2P5/6P1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK1NR w KQkq - 2 4","depth":28,"score_cp":5,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"cxd5","uci":"c4d5","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/3P4/8/6P1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK1NR b KQkq - 0 4","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"exd5","uci":"e6d5","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n5/3p4/8/6P1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK1NR w KQkq - 0 5","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g1f3","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n5/3p4/8/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK2R b KQkq - 1 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/3p4/8/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK2R w KQkq - 2 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"O-O","uci":"e1h1","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n2n2/3p4/8/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQ1RK1 b kq - 3 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":6,"san":"Bd6","uci":"f8d6","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/ppp2ppp/2nb1n2/3p4/8/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQ1RK1 w kq - 4 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":8,"san":"4...dxc4","quality":"good","text":"Caruana takes the pawn with 4...dxc4. White will have to spend a move to win it back, and Black gains a little time to arrange his pieces.\n\nOn the board: Keeping the pawn on d5.","best":"a7a6","script":{"say":"Caruana takes the pawn with 4...dxc4. White will have to spend a move to win it back, and Black gains a little time to arrange his pieces.","show":[{"title":"Keeping the pawn on d5","line":{"fen":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/3p4/2P5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK2R b KQkq - 3 4","depth":34,"score_cp":23,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black had a quieter way to deal with the tension, covering the b5 square first.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a6","uci":"a7a6","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/1pp2ppp/p1n1p3/3p4/2P5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK2R w KQkq - 0 5","comment":"4...a6 is a quiet waiting move that covers b5.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"cxd5","uci":"c4d5","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/1pp2ppp/p1n1p3/3P4/8/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK2R b KQkq - 0 5","comment":"5.cxd5 trades the c-pawn for the d-pawn.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"exd5","uci":"e6d5","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/1pp2ppp/p1n5/3p4/8/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK2R w KQkq - 0 6","comment":"5...exd5 recaptures and leaves Black with a pawn on d5.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"O-O","uci":"e1h1","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/1pp2ppp/p1n5/3p4/8/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQ1RK1 b kq - 1 6","comment":"6.O-O castles and the position stays level.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Black had a quieter way to deal with the tension, covering the b5 square first.","takeaway":"Caruana's pawn grab was not among the computer's top four, but it is a perfectly good choice."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":70,"until":138,"brush":"yellow","from":"d1","to":"a4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"4...a6","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/3p4/2P5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK2R b KQkq - 3 4","depth":34,"score_cp":23,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a6","uci":"a7a6","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/1pp2ppp/p1n1p3/3p4/2P5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK2R w KQkq - 0 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"cxd5","uci":"c4d5","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/1pp2ppp/p1n1p3/3P4/8/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK2R b KQkq - 0 5","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"exd5","uci":"e6d5","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/1pp2ppp/p1n5/3p4/8/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK2R w KQkq - 0 6","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"O-O","uci":"e1h1","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/1pp2ppp/p1n5/3p4/8/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQ1RK1 b kq - 1 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":5,"san":"h6","uci":"h7h6","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/1pp2pp1/p1n4p/3p4/8/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQ1RK1 w kq - 0 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"a3","uci":"a2a3","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/1pp2pp1/p1n4p/3p4/8/P4NP1/1P1PPPBP/RNBQ1RK1 b kq - 0 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"4...Nf6","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/3p4/2P5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK2R b KQkq - 3 4","depth":34,"score_cp":25,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n1pn2/3p4/2P5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK2R w KQkq - 4 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"d4","uci":"d2d4","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n1pn2/3p4/2PP4/5NP1/PP2PPBP/RNBQK2R b KQkq - 0 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"dxc4","uci":"d5c4","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n1pn2/8/2pP4/5NP1/PP2PPBP/RNBQK2R w KQkq - 0 6","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Qa4","uci":"d1a4","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n1pn2/8/Q1pP4/5NP1/PP2PPBP/RNB1K2R b KQkq - 1 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bb4+","uci":"f8b4","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/ppp2ppp/2n1pn2/8/QbpP4/5NP1/PP2PPBP/RNB1K2R w KQkq - 2 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bd2","uci":"c1d2","fen_after":"r1bqk2r/ppp2ppp/2n1pn2/8/QbpP4/5NP1/PP1BPPBP/RN2K2R b KQkq - 3 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"4...Rb8","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/3p4/2P5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK2R b KQkq - 3 4","depth":34,"score_cp":26,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rb8","uci":"a8b8","fen_after":"1rbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/3p4/2P5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK2R w KQk - 4 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"b3","uci":"b2b3","fen_after":"1rbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/3p4/2P5/1P3NP1/P2PPPBP/RNBQK2R b KQk - 0 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"d4","uci":"d5d4","fen_after":"1rbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/8/2Pp4/1P3NP1/P2PPPBP/RNBQK2R w KQk - 0 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"e3","uci":"e2e3","fen_after":"1rbqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/8/2Pp4/1P2PNP1/P2P1PBP/RNBQK2R b KQk - 0 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bc5","uci":"f8c5","fen_after":"1rbqk1nr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/2b5/2Pp4/1P2PNP1/P2P1PBP/RNBQK2R w KQk - 1 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"O-O","uci":"e1h1","fen_after":"1rbqk1nr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/2b5/2Pp4/1P2PNP1/P2P1PBP/RNBQ1RK1 b k - 2 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":null},{"ply":9,"san":"5.Qa4","quality":"best","text":"5.Qa4 is the standard way to win the pawn back. The queen pins the knight on c6 against the king and prepares to take on c4.","best":"d1a4","script":{"say":"5.Qa4 is the standard way to win the pawn back. The queen pins the knight on c6 against the king and prepares to take on c4.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":80,"until":124,"brush":"red","from":"a4","to":"c6"},{"type":"circle","at":121,"until":124,"brush":"yellow","square":"c4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"5.O-O","score":"White is a little better","line":{"fen":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/8/2p5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK2R w KQkq - 0 5","depth":24,"score_cp":37,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"O-O","uci":"e1h1","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/8/2p5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQ1RK1 b kq - 1 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":2,"san":"a6","uci":"a7a6","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/1pp2ppp/p1n1p3/8/2p5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQ1RK1 w kq - 0 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Qc2","uci":"d1c2","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/1pp2ppp/p1n1p3/8/2p5/5NP1/PPQPPPBP/RNB2RK1 b kq - 1 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"e5","uci":"e6e5","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/1pp2ppp/p1n5/4p3/2p5/5NP1/PPQPPPBP/RNB2RK1 w kq - 0 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Qxc4","uci":"c2c4","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/1pp2ppp/p1n5/4p3/2Q5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB2RK1 b kq - 0 7","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Be7","uci":"f8e7","fen_after":"r1bqk1nr/1pp1bppp/p1n5/4p3/2Q5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB2RK1 w kq - 1 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"5.Qc2","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/8/2p5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQK2R w KQkq - 0 5","depth":24,"score_cp":15,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Qc2","uci":"d1c2","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/8/2p5/5NP1/PPQPPPBP/RNB1K2R b KQkq - 1 5","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"e5","uci":"e6e5","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n5/4p3/2p5/5NP1/PPQPPPBP/RNB1K2R w KQkq - 0 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Qxc4","uci":"c2c4","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n5/4p3/2Q5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB1K2R b KQkq - 0 6","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"h6","uci":"h7h6","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2pp1/2n4p/4p3/2Q5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB1K2R w KQkq - 0 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nc3","uci":"b1c3","fen_after":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2pp1/2n4p/4p3/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 1 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"r1bqkb1r/ppp2pp1/2n2n1p/4p3/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 2 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":10,"san":"5...Bd7","quality":"best","text":"5...Bd7 breaks the pin at once and adds a defender to the knight. White now simply takes the pawn back.","best":"c8d7","script":{"say":"5...Bd7 breaks the pin at once and adds a defender to the knight. White now simply takes the pawn back.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":89,"until":103,"brush":"green","from":"a4","to":"c4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"5...Bd6","score":"White is a little better","line":{"fen":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/8/Q1p5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB1K2R b KQkq - 1 5","depth":28,"score_cp":42,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bd6","uci":"f8d6","fen_after":"r1bqk1nr/ppp2ppp/2nbp3/8/Q1p5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB1K2R w KQkq - 2 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"O-O","uci":"e1h1","fen_after":"r1bqk1nr/ppp2ppp/2nbp3/8/Q1p5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB2RK1 b kq - 3 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":3,"san":"Bd7","uci":"c8d7","fen_after":"r2qk1nr/pppb1ppp/2nbp3/8/Q1p5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB2RK1 w kq - 4 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Qxc4","uci":"a4c4","fen_after":"r2qk1nr/pppb1ppp/2nbp3/8/2Q5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB2RK1 b kq - 0 7","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"r2qk2r/pppb1ppp/2nbpn2/8/2Q5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB2RK1 w kq - 1 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"d4","uci":"d2d4","fen_after":"r2qk2r/pppb1ppp/2nbpn2/8/2QP4/5NP1/PP2PPBP/RNB2RK1 b kq - 0 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"5...Bd6","score":"White is a little better","line":{"fen":"r1bqkbnr/ppp2ppp/2n1p3/8/Q1p5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB1K2R b KQkq - 1 5","depth":28,"score_cp":42,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bd6","uci":"f8d6","fen_after":"r1bqk1nr/ppp2ppp/2nbp3/8/Q1p5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB1K2R w KQkq - 2 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"O-O","uci":"e1h1","fen_after":"r1bqk1nr/ppp2ppp/2nbp3/8/Q1p5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB2RK1 b kq - 3 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":3,"san":"Bd7","uci":"c8d7","fen_after":"r2qk1nr/pppb1ppp/2nbp3/8/Q1p5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB2RK1 w kq - 4 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Qxc4","uci":"a4c4","fen_after":"r2qk1nr/pppb1ppp/2nbp3/8/2Q5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB2RK1 b kq - 0 7","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"r2qk2r/pppb1ppp/2nbpn2/8/2Q5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB2RK1 w kq - 1 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"d4","uci":"d2d4","fen_after":"r2qk2r/pppb1ppp/2nbpn2/8/2QP4/5NP1/PP2PPBP/RNB2RK1 b kq - 0 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":11,"san":"6.Qxc4","quality":"best","text":"6.Qxc4 wins the pawn back, so material is level. The queen now sits on an active square in the middle of the board, and Black plays for the centre.","best":"a4c4","script":{"say":"6.Qxc4 wins the pawn back, so material is level. The queen now sits on an active square in the middle of the board, and Black plays for the centre.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":132,"until":147,"brush":"yellow","from":"e6","to":"e5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"6.O-O","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r2qkbnr/pppb1ppp/2n1p3/8/Q1p5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB1K2R w KQkq - 2 6","depth":24,"score_cp":10,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"O-O","uci":"e1h1","fen_after":"r2qkbnr/pppb1ppp/2n1p3/8/Q1p5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB2RK1 b kq - 3 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":2,"san":"Nb4","uci":"c6b4","fen_after":"r2qkbnr/pppb1ppp/4p3/8/Qnp5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB2RK1 w kq - 4 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Qd1","uci":"a4d1","fen_after":"r2qkbnr/pppb1ppp/4p3/8/1np5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQ1RK1 b kq - 5 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bd6","uci":"f8d6","fen_after":"r2qk1nr/pppb1ppp/3bp3/8/1np5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNBQ1RK1 w kq - 6 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"a3","uci":"a2a3","fen_after":"r2qk1nr/pppb1ppp/3bp3/8/1np5/P4NP1/1P1PPPBP/RNBQ1RK1 b kq - 0 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nd5","uci":"b4d5","fen_after":"r2qk1nr/pppb1ppp/3bp3/3n4/2p5/P4NP1/1P1PPPBP/RNBQ1RK1 w kq - 1 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"6.Qc2","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r2qkbnr/pppb1ppp/2n1p3/8/Q1p5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB1K2R w KQkq - 2 6","depth":24,"score_cp":-7,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Qc2","uci":"a4c2","fen_after":"r2qkbnr/pppb1ppp/2n1p3/8/2p5/5NP1/PPQPPPBP/RNB1K2R b KQkq - 3 6","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"b5","uci":"b7b5","fen_after":"r2qkbnr/p1pb1ppp/2n1p3/1p6/2p5/5NP1/PPQPPPBP/RNB1K2R w KQkq - 0 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"a3","uci":"a2a3","fen_after":"r2qkbnr/p1pb1ppp/2n1p3/1p6/2p5/P4NP1/1PQPPPBP/RNB1K2R b KQkq - 0 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/p1pb1ppp/2n1pn2/1p6/2p5/P4NP1/1PQPPPBP/RNB1K2R w KQkq - 1 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"O-O","uci":"e1h1","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/p1pb1ppp/2n1pn2/1p6/2p5/P4NP1/1PQPPPBP/RNB2RK1 b kq - 2 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":6,"san":"Rb8","uci":"a8b8","fen_after":"1r1qkb1r/p1pb1ppp/2n1pn2/1p6/2p5/P4NP1/1PQPPPBP/RNB2RK1 w k - 3 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":12,"san":"6...e5","quality":"best","text":"6...e5 grabs space in the centre and gives Black's pieces room. It also stakes a claim on d4 for the knight.","best":"e6e5","script":{"say":"6...e5 grabs space in the centre and gives Black's pieces room. It also stakes a claim on d4 for the knight.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":90,"until":108,"brush":"green","square":"d4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"6...Nf6","score":"White is a little better","line":{"fen":"r2qkbnr/pppb1ppp/2n1p3/8/2Q5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB1K2R b KQkq - 0 6","depth":27,"score_cp":36,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/2n1pn2/8/2Q5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB1K2R w KQkq - 1 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"d4","uci":"d2d4","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/2n1pn2/8/2QP4/5NP1/PP2PPBP/RNB1K2R b KQkq - 0 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bd6","uci":"f8d6","fen_after":"r2qk2r/pppb1ppp/2nbpn2/8/2QP4/5NP1/PP2PPBP/RNB1K2R w KQkq - 1 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"O-O","uci":"e1h1","fen_after":"r2qk2r/pppb1ppp/2nbpn2/8/2QP4/5NP1/PP2PPBP/RNB2RK1 b kq - 2 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":5,"san":"O-O","uci":"e8h8","fen_after":"r2q1rk1/pppb1ppp/2nbpn2/8/2QP4/5NP1/PP2PPBP/RNB2RK1 w - - 3 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":6,"san":"a3","uci":"a2a3","fen_after":"r2q1rk1/pppb1ppp/2nbpn2/8/2QP4/P4NP1/1P2PPBP/RNB2RK1 b - - 0 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"6...Bd6","score":"White is a little better","line":{"fen":"r2qkbnr/pppb1ppp/2n1p3/8/2Q5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB1K2R b KQkq - 0 6","depth":27,"score_cp":39,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bd6","uci":"f8d6","fen_after":"r2qk1nr/pppb1ppp/2nbp3/8/2Q5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB1K2R w KQkq - 1 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nc3","uci":"b1c3","fen_after":"r2qk1nr/pppb1ppp/2nbp3/8/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 2 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"r2qk2r/pppb1ppp/2nbpn2/8/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 3 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"O-O","uci":"e1h1","fen_after":"r2qk2r/pppb1ppp/2nbpn2/8/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 4 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":5,"san":"h6","uci":"h7h6","fen_after":"r2qk2r/pppb1pp1/2nbpn1p/8/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 0 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"d4","uci":"d2d4","fen_after":"r2qk2r/pppb1pp1/2nbpn1p/8/2QP4/2N2NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 0 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":13,"san":"7.Nc3","quality":"good","text":"7.Nc3 develops another piece and eyes the b5 and d5 squares. White is slightly more comfortable in a fairly quiet position.","best":"e1h1","script":{"say":"7.Nc3 develops another piece and eyes the b5 and d5 squares. White is slightly more comfortable in a fairly quiet position.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":38,"until":123,"brush":"yellow","square":"b5"},{"type":"circle","at":38,"until":123,"brush":"yellow","square":"d5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"7.O-O","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r2qkbnr/pppb1ppp/2n5/4p3/2Q5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB1K2R w KQkq - 0 7","depth":26,"score_cp":28,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"O-O","uci":"e1h1","fen_after":"r2qkbnr/pppb1ppp/2n5/4p3/2Q5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB2RK1 b kq - 1 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":2,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/2Q5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB2RK1 w kq - 2 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nc3","uci":"b1c3","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 3 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Be7","uci":"f8e7","fen_after":"r2qk2r/pppbbppp/2n2n2/4p3/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 4 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"d4","uci":"d2d4","fen_after":"r2qk2r/pppbbppp/2n2n2/4p3/2QP4/2N2NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 0 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"exd4","uci":"e5d4","fen_after":"r2qk2r/pppbbppp/2n2n2/8/2Qp4/2N2NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 0 10","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"7.d3","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r2qkbnr/pppb1ppp/2n5/4p3/2Q5/5NP1/PP1PPPBP/RNB1K2R w KQkq - 0 7","depth":26,"score_cp":19,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"d3","uci":"d2d3","fen_after":"r2qkbnr/pppb1ppp/2n5/4p3/2Q5/3P1NP1/PP2PPBP/RNB1K2R b KQkq - 0 7","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/2Q5/3P1NP1/PP2PPBP/RNB1K2R w KQkq - 1 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"O-O","uci":"e1h1","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/2Q5/3P1NP1/PP2PPBP/RNB2RK1 b kq - 2 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":4,"san":"Bd6","uci":"f8d6","fen_after":"r2qk2r/pppb1ppp/2nb1n2/4p3/2Q5/3P1NP1/PP2PPBP/RNB2RK1 w kq - 3 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"d4","uci":"d3d4","fen_after":"r2qk2r/pppb1ppp/2nb1n2/4p3/2QP4/5NP1/PP2PPBP/RNB2RK1 b kq - 0 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"O-O","uci":"e8h8","fen_after":"r2q1rk1/pppb1ppp/2nb1n2/4p3/2QP4/5NP1/PP2PPBP/RNB2RK1 w - - 1 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":14,"san":"7...Nf6","quality":"best","text":"7...Nf6 brings out the last knight and covers the centre. Black's position is solid, and White's next idea is a knight jump.\n\nOn the board: Developing the bishop first.","best":"g8f6","script":{"say":"7...Nf6 brings out the last knight and covers the centre. Black's position is solid, and White's next idea is a knight jump.","show":[{"title":"Developing the bishop first","line":{"fen":"r2qkbnr/pppb1ppp/2n5/4p3/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 1 7","depth":24,"score_cp":33,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black could have met the centre with the bishop instead of the knight.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Be7","uci":"f8e7","fen_after":"r2qk1nr/pppbbppp/2n5/4p3/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 2 8","comment":"7...Be7 develops the bishop and keeps the knight home for now.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"d4","uci":"d2d4","fen_after":"r2qk1nr/pppbbppp/2n5/4p3/2QP4/2N2NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 0 8","comment":"8.d4 strikes at the e5 pawn at once.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"exd4","uci":"e5d4","fen_after":"r2qk1nr/pppbbppp/2n5/8/2Qp4/2N2NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 0 9","comment":"8...exd4 takes the pawn.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nxd4","uci":"f3d4","fen_after":"r2qk1nr/pppbbppp/2n5/8/2QN4/2N3P1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 0 9","comment":"9.Nxd4 recaptures with the knight.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nxd4","uci":"c6d4","fen_after":"r2qk1nr/pppbbppp/8/8/2Qn4/2N3P1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 0 10","comment":"9...Nxd4 trades the knights.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Qxd4","uci":"c4d4","fen_after":"r2qk1nr/pppbbppp/8/8/3Q4/2N3P1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 0 10","comment":"10.Qxd4 puts the queen in the middle, and material is level.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Black could have met the centre with the bishop instead of the knight.","takeaway":"Black has more than one good way to develop; the game move keeps things equally level."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":110,"until":124,"brush":"red","from":"f3","to":"g5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"7...Be7","score":"White is a little better","line":{"fen":"r2qkbnr/pppb1ppp/2n5/4p3/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 1 7","depth":24,"score_cp":33,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Be7","uci":"f8e7","fen_after":"r2qk1nr/pppbbppp/2n5/4p3/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 2 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"d4","uci":"d2d4","fen_after":"r2qk1nr/pppbbppp/2n5/4p3/2QP4/2N2NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 0 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"exd4","uci":"e5d4","fen_after":"r2qk1nr/pppbbppp/2n5/8/2Qp4/2N2NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 0 9","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nxd4","uci":"f3d4","fen_after":"r2qk1nr/pppbbppp/2n5/8/2QN4/2N3P1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 0 9","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nxd4","uci":"c6d4","fen_after":"r2qk1nr/pppbbppp/8/8/2Qn4/2N3P1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 0 10","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Qxd4","uci":"c4d4","fen_after":"r2qk1nr/pppbbppp/8/8/3Q4/2N3P1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 0 10","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"7...h6","score":"White is a little better","line":{"fen":"r2qkbnr/pppb1ppp/2n5/4p3/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 1 7","depth":24,"score_cp":61,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"h6","uci":"h7h6","fen_after":"r2qkbnr/pppb1pp1/2n4p/4p3/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 0 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"O-O","uci":"e1h1","fen_after":"r2qkbnr/pppb1pp1/2n4p/4p3/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 1 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":3,"san":"Nf6","uci":"g8f6","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1pp1/2n2n1p/4p3/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 2 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"d4","uci":"d2d4","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1pp1/2n2n1p/4p3/2QP4/2N2NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 0 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"exd4","uci":"e5d4","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1pp1/2n2n1p/8/2Qp4/2N2NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 0 10","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nb5","uci":"c3b5","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1pp1/2n2n1p/1N6/2Qp4/5NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 1 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":15,"san":"8.Ng5","quality":"good","text":"8.Ng5 is a sharp idea. The knight and the queen both aim at the f7 pawn, so Black must notice the threat right away.\n\nOn the board: The calm central break.","best":"d2d4","script":{"say":"8.Ng5 is a sharp idea. The knight and the queen both aim at the f7 pawn, so Black must notice the threat right away.","show":[{"title":"The calm central break","line":{"fen":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 2 8","depth":26,"score_cp":26,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White had a quiet way to keep the balance by opening the centre.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"d4","uci":"d2d4","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/2QP4/2N2NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 0 8","comment":"8.d4 hits the e5 pawn.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"exd4","uci":"e5d4","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/8/2Qp4/2N2NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 0 9","comment":"8...exd4 captures it.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nxd4","uci":"f3d4","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/8/2QN4/2N3P1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 0 9","comment":"9.Nxd4 recaptures.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nxd4","uci":"c6d4","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/5n2/8/2Qn4/2N3P1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 0 10","comment":"9...Nxd4 trades the knights.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Qxd4","uci":"c4d4","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/5n2/8/3Q4/2N3P1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 0 10","comment":"10.Qxd4 centralises the queen, and material is level.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White had a quiet way to keep the balance by opening the centre.","takeaway":"This road keeps the balance; Rapport chose a sharper knight jump instead."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":60,"until":116,"brush":"red","from":"g5","to":"f7"},{"type":"arrow","at":60,"until":116,"brush":"red","from":"c4","to":"f7"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"8.d4","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 2 8","depth":26,"score_cp":26,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"d4","uci":"d2d4","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/2QP4/2N2NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 0 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"exd4","uci":"e5d4","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/8/2Qp4/2N2NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 0 9","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nxd4","uci":"f3d4","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/8/2QN4/2N3P1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 0 9","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nxd4","uci":"c6d4","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/5n2/8/2Qn4/2N3P1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 0 10","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Qxd4","uci":"c4d4","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/5n2/8/3Q4/2N3P1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 0 10","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"c6","uci":"c7c6","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pp1b1ppp/2p2n2/8/3Q4/2N3P1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"8.O-O","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 2 8","depth":26,"score_cp":25,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"O-O","uci":"e1h1","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 3 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":2,"san":"Be7","uci":"f8e7","fen_after":"r2qk2r/pppbbppp/2n2n2/4p3/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 4 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"d4","uci":"d2d4","fen_after":"r2qk2r/pppbbppp/2n2n2/4p3/2QP4/2N2NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 0 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"exd4","uci":"e5d4","fen_after":"r2qk2r/pppbbppp/2n2n2/8/2Qp4/2N2NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 0 10","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nxd4","uci":"f3d4","fen_after":"r2qk2r/pppbbppp/2n2n2/8/2QN4/2N3P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 0 10","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nxd4","uci":"c6d4","fen_after":"r2qk2r/pppbbppp/5n2/8/2Qn4/2N3P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"8.d3","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 2 8","depth":26,"score_cp":14,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"d3","uci":"d2d3","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/4p3/2Q5/2NP1NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 0 8","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"h6","uci":"h7h6","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1pp1/2n2n1p/4p3/2Q5/2NP1NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 0 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"O-O","uci":"e1h1","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/pppb1pp1/2n2n1p/4p3/2Q5/2NP1NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 1 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":4,"san":"Be7","uci":"f8e7","fen_after":"r2qk2r/pppbbpp1/2n2n1p/4p3/2Q5/2NP1NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 2 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nd5","uci":"c3d5","fen_after":"r2qk2r/pppbbpp1/2n2n1p/3Np3/2Q5/3P1NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 3 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nxd5","uci":"f6d5","fen_after":"r2qk2r/pppbbpp1/2n4p/3np3/2Q5/3P1NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":null},{"ply":16,"san":"8...Qe7","quality":"only move","text":"Caruana had to be careful here, because the f7 pawn is under fire from the queen and knight. Only 8...Qe7 holds everything together, and the queen now guards f7. Moves like 8...Be6 walk into a disaster, as the line shows.\n\nOn the board: The tempting bishop move.","best":"d8e7","script":{"say":"Caruana had to be careful here, because the f7 pawn is under fire from the queen and knight. Only 8...Qe7 holds everything together, and the queen now guards f7. Moves like 8...Be6 walk into a disaster, as the line shows.","show":[{"title":"The tempting bishop move","line":{"fen":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/4p1N1/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 3 8","depth":21,"score_cp":572,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"If Black blocks with the bishop, the f7 pawn becomes a target for a nasty sequence of captures.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Be6","uci":"d7e6","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n1bn2/4p1N1/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 4 9","comment":"8...Be6 looks natural, putting the bishop in front of the pawn.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxe6","uci":"g5e6","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n1Nn2/4p3/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 0 9","comment":"9.Nxe6 takes the bishop and wrecks the pawn cover.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"fxe6","uci":"f7e6","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/ppp3pp/2n1pn2/4p3/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 0 10","comment":"Recapturing with 9...fxe6 is forced, but it leaves the new pawn on e6 open to the queen.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Qxe6+","uci":"c4e6","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/ppp3pp/2n1Qn2/4p3/8/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 0 10","comment":"10.Qxe6+ wins a pawn with check and Black's king is stuck in the middle.","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"If Black blocks with the bishop, the f7 pawn becomes a target for a nasty sequence of captures.","takeaway":"The computer says this is close to lost for Black, so the quiet queen move was the only way to hold."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":158,"until":221,"brush":"green","square":"f7"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"8...Be6","score":"White is winning","line":{"fen":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/4p1N1/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 3 8","depth":21,"score_cp":572,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Be6","uci":"d7e6","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n1bn2/4p1N1/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 4 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxe6","uci":"g5e6","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/ppp2ppp/2n1Nn2/4p3/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 0 9","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"fxe6","uci":"f7e6","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/ppp3pp/2n1pn2/4p3/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 0 10","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Qxe6+","uci":"c4e6","fen_after":"r2qkb1r/ppp3pp/2n1Qn2/4p3/8/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 0 10","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Be7","uci":"f8e7","fen_after":"r2qk2r/ppp1b1pp/2n1Qn2/4p3/8/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 1 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bxc6+","uci":"g2c6","fen_after":"r2qk2r/ppp1b1pp/2B1Qn2/4p3/8/2N3P1/PP1PPP1P/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"8...Qc8","score":"White is winning","line":{"fen":"r2qkb1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/4p1N1/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 3 8","depth":21,"score_cp":573,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Qc8","uci":"d8c8","fen_after":"r1q1kb1r/pppb1ppp/2n2n2/4p1N1/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 4 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Qxf7+","uci":"c4f7","fen_after":"r1q1kb1r/pppb1Qpp/2n2n2/4p1N1/8/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 0 9","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Kd8","uci":"e8d8","fen_after":"r1qk1b1r/pppb1Qpp/2n2n2/4p1N1/8/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R w KQ - 1 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nd5","uci":"c3d5","fen_after":"r1qk1b1r/pppb1Qpp/2n2n2/3Np1N1/8/6P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R b KQ - 2 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nxd5","uci":"f6d5","fen_after":"r1qk1b1r/pppb1Qpp/2n5/3np1N1/8/6P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R w KQ - 0 11","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Qxd5","uci":"f7d5","fen_after":"r1qk1b1r/pppb2pp/2n5/3Qp1N1/8/6P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R b KQ - 0 11","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":17,"san":"9.O-O","quality":"best","text":"9.O-O tucks the king away and gets the rook toward the centre. White keeps his pieces active, and Black's natural reply is to kick the knight.","best":"e1h1","script":{"say":"9.O-O tucks the king away and gets the rook toward the centre. White keeps his pieces active, and Black's natural reply is to kick the knight.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":123,"until":142,"brush":"yellow","from":"h7","to":"h6"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"9.Nb5","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r3kb1r/pppbqppp/2n2n2/4p1N1/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 4 9","depth":25,"score_cp":-17,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nb5","uci":"c3b5","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pppbqppp/2n2n2/1N2p1N1/2Q5/6P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 5 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rc8","uci":"a8c8","fen_after":"2r1kb1r/pppbqppp/2n2n2/1N2p1N1/2Q5/6P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R w KQk - 6 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"O-O","uci":"e1h1","fen_after":"2r1kb1r/pppbqppp/2n2n2/1N2p1N1/2Q5/6P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b k - 7 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":4,"san":"a6","uci":"a7a6","fen_after":"2r1kb1r/1ppbqppp/p1n2n2/1N2p1N1/2Q5/6P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w k - 0 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bxc6","uci":"g2c6","fen_after":"2r1kb1r/1ppbqppp/p1B2n2/1N2p1N1/2Q5/6P1/PP1PPP1P/R1B2RK1 b k - 0 11","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"axb5","uci":"a6b5","fen_after":"2r1kb1r/1ppbqppp/2B2n2/1p2p1N1/2Q5/6P1/PP1PPP1P/R1B2RK1 w k - 0 12","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"9.d3","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r3kb1r/pppbqppp/2n2n2/4p1N1/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 4 9","depth":25,"score_cp":-21,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"d3","uci":"d2d3","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pppbqppp/2n2n2/4p1N1/2Q5/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 0 9","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"h6","uci":"h7h6","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n2n1p/4p1N1/2Q5/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 0 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nge4","uci":"g5e4","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n2n1p/4p3/2Q1N3/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 1 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nxe4","uci":"f6e4","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/2Q1n3/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nd5","uci":"c3d5","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/3Np3/2Q1n3/3P2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R b KQkq - 1 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Qc5","uci":"e7c5","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pppb1pp1/2n4p/2qNp3/2Q1n3/3P2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B1K2R w KQkq - 2 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":18,"san":"9...h6","quality":"best","text":"9...h6 kicks the knight at once. Now White's knight has to decide where to go, perhaps to e4, and Black gains time.","best":"h7h6","script":{"say":"9...h6 kicks the knight at once. Now White's knight has to decide where to go, perhaps to e4, and Black gains time.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":87,"until":115,"brush":"green","from":"g5","to":"e4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"9...a6","score":"White is a little better","line":{"fen":"r3kb1r/pppbqppp/2n2n2/4p1N1/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 5 9","depth":23,"score_cp":53,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a6","uci":"a7a6","fen_after":"r3kb1r/1ppbqppp/p1n2n2/4p1N1/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 0 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"d4","uci":"d2d4","fen_after":"r3kb1r/1ppbqppp/p1n2n2/4p1N1/2QP4/2N3P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 0 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"h6","uci":"h7h6","fen_after":"r3kb1r/1ppbqpp1/p1n2n1p/4p1N1/2QP4/2N3P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bxc6","uci":"g2c6","fen_after":"r3kb1r/1ppbqpp1/p1B2n1p/4p1N1/2QP4/2N3P1/PP2PP1P/R1B2RK1 b kq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bxc6","uci":"d7c6","fen_after":"r3kb1r/1pp1qpp1/p1b2n1p/4p1N1/2QP4/2N3P1/PP2PP1P/R1B2RK1 w kq - 0 12","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g5f3","fen_after":"r3kb1r/1pp1qpp1/p1b2n1p/4p3/2QP4/2N2NP1/PP2PP1P/R1B2RK1 b kq - 1 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"9...Rc8","score":"White is a little better","line":{"fen":"r3kb1r/pppbqppp/2n2n2/4p1N1/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 5 9","depth":23,"score_cp":71,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rc8","uci":"a8c8","fen_after":"2r1kb1r/pppbqppp/2n2n2/4p1N1/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w k - 6 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"b3","uci":"b2b3","fen_after":"2r1kb1r/pppbqppp/2n2n2/4p1N1/2Q5/1PN3P1/P2PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b k - 0 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"h6","uci":"h7h6","fen_after":"2r1kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n2n1p/4p1N1/2Q5/1PN3P1/P2PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w k - 0 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nge4","uci":"g5e4","fen_after":"2r1kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n2n1p/4p3/2Q1N3/1PN3P1/P2PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b k - 1 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nxe4","uci":"f6e4","fen_after":"2r1kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/2Q1n3/1PN3P1/P2PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w k - 0 12","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Qxe4","uci":"c4e4","fen_after":"2r1kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/4Q3/1PN3P1/P2PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b k - 0 12","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":19,"san":"10.Nge4","quality":"good","text":"Rapport retreated with 10.Nge4, offering a trade of knights. The computer preferred jumping to b5 with threats on the queenside. The text move is fine, but it lets Black simplify and gain a little ease.\n\nOn the board: The knight jumps to b5.","best":"c3b5","script":{"say":"Rapport retreated with 10.Nge4, offering a trade of knights. The computer preferred jumping to b5 with threats on the queenside. The text move is fine, but it lets Black simplify and gain a little ease.","show":[{"title":"The knight jumps to b5","line":{"fen":"r3kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n2n1p/4p1N1/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 0 10","depth":24,"score_cp":0,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White could have kept more tension by putting a knight on b5.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nb5","uci":"c3b5","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n2n1p/1N2p1N1/2Q5/6P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 1 10","comment":"10.Nb5 attacks the a7 pawn and sets up annoying threats.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rc8","uci":"a8c8","fen_after":"2r1kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n2n1p/1N2p1N1/2Q5/6P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w k - 2 11","comment":"10...Rc8 steps out of the way and puts the rook opposite the queen.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Ne4","uci":"g5e4","fen_after":"2r1kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n2n1p/1N2p3/2Q1N3/6P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b k - 3 11","comment":"11.Ne4 now brings the other knight into the game with a threat on f6.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nxe4","uci":"f6e4","fen_after":"2r1kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/1N2p3/2Q1n3/6P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w k - 0 12","comment":"11...Nxe4 trades the knights, and White recaptures with the queen next.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White could have kept more tension by putting a knight on b5.","takeaway":"This line keeps things level, while the game move leaves Black a touch more comfortable."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":41,"until":202,"brush":"red","from":"e4","to":"f6"},{"type":"arrow","at":41,"until":202,"brush":"yellow","from":"f6","to":"e4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"10.Nb5","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r3kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n2n1p/4p1N1/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 0 10","depth":24,"score_cp":0,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nb5","uci":"c3b5","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n2n1p/1N2p1N1/2Q5/6P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 1 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rc8","uci":"a8c8","fen_after":"2r1kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n2n1p/1N2p1N1/2Q5/6P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w k - 2 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Ne4","uci":"g5e4","fen_after":"2r1kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n2n1p/1N2p3/2Q1N3/6P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b k - 3 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nxe4","uci":"f6e4","fen_after":"2r1kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/1N2p3/2Q1n3/6P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w k - 0 12","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Qxe4","uci":"c4e4","fen_after":"2r1kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/1N2p3/4Q3/6P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b k - 0 12","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"h5","uci":"h6h5","fen_after":"2r1kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n5/1N2p2p/4Q3/6P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w k - 0 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"10.Nf3","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"r3kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n2n1p/4p1N1/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 0 10","depth":24,"score_cp":-35,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nf3","uci":"g5f3","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n2n1p/4p3/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 1 10","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"O-O-O","uci":"e8a8","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n2n1p/4p3/2Q5/2N2NP1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 2 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":3,"san":"d3","uci":"d2d3","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n2n1p/4p3/2Q5/2NP1NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 b - - 0 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Na5","uci":"c6a5","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/5n1p/n3p3/2Q5/2NP1NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 1 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nd5","uci":"c3d5","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/5n1p/n2Np3/2Q5/3P1NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 b - - 2 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nxc4","uci":"a5c4","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/5n1p/3Np3/2n5/3P1NP1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 0 13","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":20,"san":"10...Nxe4","quality":"best","text":"10...Nxe4 trades off the active knight. With fewer pieces on the board, Black's solid structure starts to count for more.\n\nOn the board: Castling before the trade.","best":"f6e4","script":{"say":"10...Nxe4 trades off the active knight. With fewer pieces on the board, Black's solid structure starts to count for more.","show":[{"title":"Castling before the trade","line":{"fen":"r3kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n2n1p/4p3/2Q1N3/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 1 10","depth":24,"score_cp":0,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black did not have to take on e4 at once.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"O-O-O","uci":"e8a8","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n2n1p/4p3/2Q1N3/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 2 11","comment":"10...O-O-O castles first and leaves the trade to White.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxf6","uci":"e4f6","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n2N1p/4p3/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b - - 0 11","comment":"11.Nxf6 takes the knight on f6.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Qxf6","uci":"e7f6","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppb1pp1/2n2q1p/4p3/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 0 12","comment":"11...Qxf6 recaptures with the queen.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppb1pp1/2n2q1p/4p3/1PQ5/2N3P1/P2PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b - - 0 12","comment":"12.b4 pushes the b-pawn up the board.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Black did not have to take on e4 at once.","takeaway":"The computer sees this as completely level, while Caruana's trade keeps a small edge."}}],"after":""},"alternatives":[{"title":"10...O-O-O","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r3kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n2n1p/4p3/2Q1N3/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 1 10","depth":24,"score_cp":0,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"O-O-O","uci":"e8a8","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n2n1p/4p3/2Q1N3/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 2 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxf6","uci":"e4f6","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n2N1p/4p3/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b - - 0 11","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Qxf6","uci":"e7f6","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppb1pp1/2n2q1p/4p3/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 0 12","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppb1pp1/2n2q1p/4p3/1PQ5/2N3P1/P2PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b - - 0 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nd4","uci":"c6d4","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppb1pp1/5q1p/4p3/1PQn4/2N3P1/P2PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 1 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bb2","uci":"c1b2","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppb1pp1/5q1p/4p3/1PQn4/2N3P1/PB1PPPBP/R4RK1 b - - 2 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"10...a5","score":"White is a little better","line":{"fen":"r3kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n2n1p/4p3/2Q1N3/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 1 10","depth":24,"score_cp":46,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a5","uci":"a7a5","fen_after":"r3kb1r/1ppbqpp1/2n2n1p/p3p3/2Q1N3/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxf6+","uci":"e4f6","fen_after":"r3kb1r/1ppbqpp1/2n2N1p/p3p3/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Qxf6","uci":"e7f6","fen_after":"r3kb1r/1ppb1pp1/2n2q1p/p3p3/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 0 12","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"d3","uci":"d2d3","fen_after":"r3kb1r/1ppb1pp1/2n2q1p/p3p3/2Q5/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 0 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bd6","uci":"f8d6","fen_after":"r3k2r/1ppb1pp1/2nb1q1p/p3p3/2Q5/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 1 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Be3","uci":"c1e3","fen_after":"r3k2r/1ppb1pp1/2nb1q1p/p3p3/2Q5/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 b kq - 2 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":21,"san":"11.Qxe4","quality":"best","text":"11.Qxe4 recaptures with the queen in the centre. It is the best choice, and the queen eyes the knight on c6 from there.","best":"c4e4","script":{"say":"11.Qxe4 recaptures with the queen in the centre. It is the best choice, and the queen eyes the knight on c6 from there.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":86,"until":119,"brush":"red","from":"e4","to":"c6"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"11.Bxe4","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"r3kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/2Q1n3/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 0 11","depth":21,"score_cp":-109,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bxe4","uci":"g2e4","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/2Q1B3/2N3P1/PP1PPP1P/R1B2RK1 b kq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"O-O-O","uci":"e8a8","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/2Q1B3/2N3P1/PP1PPP1P/R1B2RK1 w - - 1 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":3,"san":"Bg2","uci":"e4g2","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b - - 2 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nd4","uci":"c6d4","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/7p/4p3/2Qn4/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 3 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rd1","uci":"f1d1","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/7p/4p3/2Qn4/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1BR2K1 b - - 4 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Qf6","uci":"e7f6","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppb1pp1/5q1p/4p3/2Qn4/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1BR2K1 w - - 5 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"11.Nxe4","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"r3kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/2Q1n3/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 0 11","depth":21,"score_cp":-109,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nxe4","uci":"c3e4","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/2Q1N3/6P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 0 11","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"O-O-O","uci":"e8a8","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/2Q1N3/6P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 1 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":true},{"ply":3,"san":"Nc3","uci":"e4c3","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/2Q5/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b - - 2 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nd4","uci":"c6d4","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/7p/4p3/2Qn4/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 3 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rd1","uci":"f1d1","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/7p/4p3/2Qn4/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1BR2K1 b - - 4 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Qf6","uci":"e7f6","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppb1pp1/5q1p/4p3/2Qn4/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1BR2K1 w - - 5 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":22,"san":"11...O-O-O","quality":"best","text":"11...O-O-O castles long, putting the king on the queenside and the rook on the d-file. Black's next plan is the f-pawn push, hitting the queen.\n\nOn the board: Offering the queens.","best":"e8a8","script":{"say":"11...O-O-O castles long, putting the king on the queenside and the rook on the d-file. Black's next plan is the f-pawn push, hitting the queen.","show":[{"title":"Offering the queens","line":{"fen":"r3kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/4Q3/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 0 11","depth":24,"score_cp":-3,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black could have simplified at once by offering an exchange of queens.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Qb4","uci":"e7b4","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pppb1pp1/2n4p/4p3/1q2Q3/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 1 12","comment":"11...Qb4 offers the queens.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Qxb4","uci":"e4b4","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pppb1pp1/2n4p/4p3/1Q6/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 0 12","comment":"12.Qxb4 takes.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bxb4","uci":"f8b4","fen_after":"r3k2r/pppb1pp1/2n4p/4p3/1b6/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 0 13","comment":"12...Bxb4 recaptures with the bishop.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"a3","uci":"a2a3","fen_after":"r3k2r/pppb1pp1/2n4p/4p3/1b6/P1N3P1/1P1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 0 13","comment":"13.a3 attacks the bishop with a pawn.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Be7","uci":"b4e7","fen_after":"r3k2r/pppbbpp1/2n4p/4p3/8/P1N3P1/1P1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 1 14","comment":"13...Be7 retreats and the position is level.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Black could have simplified at once by offering an exchange of queens.","takeaway":"This simplification is dead level; Caruana's castling keeps a little more tension."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":108,"until":143,"brush":"green","from":"f7","to":"f5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"11...f5","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r3kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/4Q3/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 0 11","depth":24,"score_cp":-6,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"f5","uci":"f7f5","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pppbq1p1/2n4p/4pp2/4Q3/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 0 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Qc2","uci":"e4c2","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pppbq1p1/2n4p/4pp2/8/2N3P1/PPQPPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 1 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Qf7","uci":"e7f7","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pppb1qp1/2n4p/4pp2/8/2N3P1/PPQPPPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 2 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nb5","uci":"c3b5","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pppb1qp1/2n4p/1N2pp2/8/6P1/PPQPPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 3 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rc8","uci":"a8c8","fen_after":"2r1kb1r/pppb1qp1/2n4p/1N2pp2/8/6P1/PPQPPPBP/R1B2RK1 w k - 4 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"a3","uci":"a2a3","fen_after":"2r1kb1r/pppb1qp1/2n4p/1N2pp2/8/P5P1/1PQPPPBP/R1B2RK1 b k - 0 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"11...Qb4","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r3kb1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/4Q3/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 0 11","depth":24,"score_cp":-3,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Qb4","uci":"e7b4","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pppb1pp1/2n4p/4p3/1q2Q3/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 1 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Qxb4","uci":"e4b4","fen_after":"r3kb1r/pppb1pp1/2n4p/4p3/1Q6/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 0 12","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bxb4","uci":"f8b4","fen_after":"r3k2r/pppb1pp1/2n4p/4p3/1b6/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 0 13","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"a3","uci":"a2a3","fen_after":"r3k2r/pppb1pp1/2n4p/4p3/1b6/P1N3P1/1P1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 0 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Be7","uci":"b4e7","fen_after":"r3k2r/pppbbpp1/2n4p/4p3/8/P1N3P1/1P1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w kq - 1 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"r3k2r/pppbbpp1/2n4p/4p3/1P6/P1N3P1/3PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b kq - 0 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":23,"san":"12.d3","quality":"good","text":"12.d3 opens the diagonal for the bishop on c1 and shores up the centre. It is a little slow, and Black gets the chance to push on the kingside.\n\nOn the board: Rook to b1 and the b-pawn.","best":"a1b1","script":{"say":"12.d3 opens the diagonal for the bishop on c1 and shores up the centre. It is a little slow, and Black gets the chance to push on the kingside.","show":[{"title":"Rook to b1 and the b-pawn","line":{"fen":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/4Q3/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 1 12","depth":22,"score_cp":-25,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White had a more active plan on the queenside.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rb1","uci":"a1b1","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/4Q3/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/1RB2RK1 b - - 2 12","comment":"12.Rb1 puts the rook behind the b-pawn.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Qe6","uci":"e7e6","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppb1pp1/2n1q2p/4p3/4Q3/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/1RB2RK1 w - - 3 13","comment":"12...Qe6 moves the queen to a more active square.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppb1pp1/2n1q2p/4p3/1P2Q3/2N3P1/P2PPPBP/1RB2RK1 b - - 0 13","comment":"13.b4 starts the queenside advance.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"f5","uci":"f7f5","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppb2p1/2n1q2p/4pp2/1P2Q3/2N3P1/P2PPPBP/1RB2RK1 w - - 0 14","comment":"13...f5 hits the queen on e4.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Qe3","uci":"e4e3","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppb2p1/2n1q2p/4pp2/1P6/2N1Q1P1/P2PPPBP/1RB2RK1 b - - 1 14","comment":"14.Qe3 steps away and keeps the queen safe.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White had a more active plan on the queenside.","takeaway":"The computer prefers this plan, since White's queenside play has more bite than the quiet pawn move."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":12,"until":143,"brush":"green","from":"c1","to":"h6"},{"type":"arrow","at":127,"until":143,"brush":"yellow","from":"f7","to":"f5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"12.Rb1","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/4Q3/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 1 12","depth":22,"score_cp":-25,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rb1","uci":"a1b1","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/4Q3/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/1RB2RK1 b - - 2 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Qe6","uci":"e7e6","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppb1pp1/2n1q2p/4p3/4Q3/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/1RB2RK1 w - - 3 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppb1pp1/2n1q2p/4p3/1P2Q3/2N3P1/P2PPPBP/1RB2RK1 b - - 0 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"f5","uci":"f7f5","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppb2p1/2n1q2p/4pp2/1P2Q3/2N3P1/P2PPPBP/1RB2RK1 w - - 0 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Qe3","uci":"e4e3","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppb2p1/2n1q2p/4pp2/1P6/2N1Q1P1/P2PPPBP/1RB2RK1 b - - 1 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kb8","uci":"c8b8","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppb2p1/2n1q2p/4pp2/1P6/2N1Q1P1/P2PPPBP/1RB2RK1 w - - 2 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"12.b3","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/4Q3/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 1 12","depth":22,"score_cp":-62,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"b3","uci":"b2b3","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/4Q3/1PN3P1/P2PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b - - 0 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kb8","uci":"c8b8","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/4Q3/1PN3P1/P2PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 1 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bb2","uci":"c1b2","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/4Q3/1PN3P1/PB1PPPBP/R4RK1 b - - 2 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"f5","uci":"f7f5","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq1p1/2n4p/4pp2/4Q3/1PN3P1/PB1PPPBP/R4RK1 w - - 0 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Qe3","uci":"e4e3","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq1p1/2n4p/4pp2/8/1PN1Q1P1/PB1PPPBP/R4RK1 b - - 1 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Qf7","uci":"e7f7","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppb1qp1/2n4p/4pp2/8/1PN1Q1P1/PB1PPPBP/R4RK1 w - - 2 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"12.Qe3","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/4Q3/2N3P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 1 12","depth":22,"score_cp":-69,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Qe3","uci":"e4e3","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/8/2N1Q1P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b - - 2 12","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kb8","uci":"c8b8","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/8/2N1Q1P1/PP1PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 3 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"b3","uci":"b2b3","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/8/1PN1Q1P1/P2PPPBP/R1B2RK1 b - - 0 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nd4","uci":"c6d4","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbqpp1/7p/4p3/3n4/1PN1Q1P1/P2PPPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 1 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bb2","uci":"c1b2","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbqpp1/7p/4p3/3n4/1PN1Q1P1/PB1PPPBP/R4RK1 b - - 2 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bc6","uci":"d7c6","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/ppp1qpp1/2b4p/4p3/3n4/1PN1Q1P1/PB1PPPBP/R4RK1 w - - 3 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":null},{"ply":24,"san":"12...f5","quality":"best","text":"12...f5 hits the queen and grabs more space. White's queen must move and Black has a clear plan of gaining ground in the centre and on the king's side.","best":"f7f5","script":{"say":"12...f5 hits the queen and grabs more space. White's queen must move and Black has a clear plan of gaining ground in the centre and on the king's side.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":13,"until":151,"brush":"red","square":"e4"},{"type":"arrow","at":69,"until":151,"brush":"green","from":"e4","to":"a4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"12...g5","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/4Q3/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 b - - 0 12","depth":23,"score_cp":-45,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbqp2/2n4p/4p1p1/4Q3/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 0 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bd2","uci":"c1d2","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbqp2/2n4p/4p1p1/4Q3/2NP2P1/PP1BPPBP/R4RK1 b - - 1 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"f5","uci":"f7f5","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbq3/2n4p/4ppp1/4Q3/2NP2P1/PP1BPPBP/R4RK1 w - - 0 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Qc4","uci":"e4c4","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbq3/2n4p/4ppp1/2Q5/2NP2P1/PP1BPPBP/R4RK1 b - - 1 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kb8","uci":"c8b8","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq3/2n4p/4ppp1/2Q5/2NP2P1/PP1BPPBP/R4RK1 w - - 2 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rac1","uci":"a1c1","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq3/2n4p/4ppp1/2Q5/2NP2P1/PP1BPPBP/2R2RK1 b - - 3 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"12...Kb8","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"2kr1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/4Q3/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 b - - 0 12","depth":23,"score_cp":-38,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Kb8","uci":"c8b8","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/4Q3/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 1 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bd2","uci":"c1d2","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbqpp1/2n4p/4p3/4Q3/2NP2P1/PP1BPPBP/R4RK1 b - - 2 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"f5","uci":"f7f5","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq1p1/2n4p/4pp2/4Q3/2NP2P1/PP1BPPBP/R4RK1 w - - 0 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Qc4","uci":"e4c4","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq1p1/2n4p/4pp2/2Q5/2NP2P1/PP1BPPBP/R4RK1 b - - 1 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq3/2n4p/4ppp1/2Q5/2NP2P1/PP1BPPBP/R4RK1 w - - 0 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rac1","uci":"a1c1","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq3/2n4p/4ppp1/2Q5/2NP2P1/PP1BPPBP/2R2RK1 b - - 1 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":25,"san":"13.Qa4","quality":"best","text":"13.Qa4 gets the queen out of the way and lines it up on the a-file against the a7 pawn, close to the black king. It is the most resilient square, and the king will step aside with Kb8.","best":"e4a4","script":{"say":"13.Qa4 gets the queen out of the way and lines it up on the a-file against the a7 pawn, close to the black king. It is the most resilient square, and the king will step aside with Kb8.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":75,"until":184,"brush":"red","from":"a4","to":"a7"},{"type":"arrow","at":175,"until":184,"brush":"green","from":"c8","to":"b8"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"13.Qd5","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"2kr1b1r/pppbq1p1/2n4p/4pp2/4Q3/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 0 13","depth":22,"score_cp":-89,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Qd5","uci":"e4d5","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbq1p1/2n4p/3Qpp2/8/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 b - - 1 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kb8","uci":"c8b8","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq1p1/2n4p/3Qpp2/8/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 2 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Qb3","uci":"d5b3","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq1p1/2n4p/4pp2/8/1QNP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 b - - 3 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Be6","uci":"d7e6","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/ppp1q1p1/2n1b2p/4pp2/8/1QNP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 4 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Qd1","uci":"b3d1","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/ppp1q1p1/2n1b2p/4pp2/8/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1BQ1RK1 b - - 5 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Qd7","uci":"e7d7","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppq2p1/2n1b2p/4pp2/8/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1BQ1RK1 w - - 6 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"13.Qe3","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"2kr1b1r/pppbq1p1/2n4p/4pp2/4Q3/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 0 13","depth":22,"score_cp":-117,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Qe3","uci":"e4e3","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbq1p1/2n4p/4pp2/8/2NPQ1P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 b - - 1 13","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nd4","uci":"c6d4","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbq1p1/7p/4pp2/3n4/2NPQ1P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 2 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"b3","uci":"b2b3","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbq1p1/7p/4pp2/3n4/1PNPQ1P1/P3PPBP/R1B2RK1 b - - 0 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"h5","uci":"h6h5","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbq1p1/8/4pp1p/3n4/1PNPQ1P1/P3PPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 0 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bb2","uci":"c1b2","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppbq1p1/8/4pp1p/3n4/1PNPQ1P1/PB2PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 1 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Qd6","uci":"e7d6","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppb2p1/3q4/4pp1p/3n4/1PNPQ1P1/PB2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 2 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":26,"san":"13...Kb8","quality":"best","text":"13...Kb8 tucks the king into the corner. A useful safety move that also guards the a7 pawn the queen was eyeing, and White's last piece is heading out.","best":"c8b8","script":{"say":"13...Kb8 tucks the king into the corner. A useful safety move that also guards the a7 pawn the queen was eyeing, and White's last piece is heading out.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":139,"until":151,"brush":"blue","from":"c1","to":"e3"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"13...a6","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"2kr1b1r/pppbq1p1/2n4p/4pp2/Q7/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 b - - 1 13","depth":24,"score_cp":-40,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a6","uci":"a7a6","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/1ppbq1p1/p1n4p/4pp2/Q7/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 0 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rb1","uci":"a1b1","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/1ppbq1p1/p1n4p/4pp2/Q7/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/1RB2RK1 b - - 1 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nd4","uci":"c6d4","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/1ppbq1p1/p6p/4pp2/Q2n4/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/1RB2RK1 w - - 2 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Qd1","uci":"a4d1","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/1ppbq1p1/p6p/4pp2/3n4/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/1RBQ1RK1 b - - 3 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Qe6","uci":"e7e6","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/1ppb2p1/p3q2p/4pp2/3n4/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/1RBQ1RK1 w - - 4 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"e3","uci":"e2e3","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/1ppb2p1/p3q2p/4pp2/3n4/2NPP1P1/PP3PBP/1RBQ1RK1 b - - 0 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"13...Qb4","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"2kr1b1r/pppbq1p1/2n4p/4pp2/Q7/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 b - - 1 13","depth":24,"score_cp":-17,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Qb4","uci":"e7b4","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppb2p1/2n4p/4pp2/Qq6/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 2 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Qxb4","uci":"a4b4","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppb2p1/2n4p/4pp2/1Q6/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 b - - 0 14","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nxb4","uci":"c6b4","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppb2p1/7p/4pp2/1n6/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 0 15","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"b3","uci":"b2b3","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/pppb2p1/7p/4pp2/1n6/1PNP2P1/P3PPBP/R1B2RK1 b - - 0 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bc6","uci":"d7c6","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/ppp3p1/2b4p/4pp2/1n6/1PNP2P1/P3PPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 1 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"h4","uci":"h2h4","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/ppp3p1/2b4p/4pp2/1n5P/1PNP2P1/P3PPB1/R1B2RK1 b - - 0 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":27,"san":"14.Be3","quality":"best","text":"14.Be3 develops the last minor piece and eyes the queenside along the diagonal to a7. White is a little worse but has a sound position, and Black's knight will block it by jumping to d4.","best":"c1e3","script":{"say":"14.Be3 develops the last minor piece and eyes the queenside along the diagonal to a7. White is a little worse but has a sound position, and Black's knight will block it by jumping to d4.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":66,"until":186,"brush":"green","from":"e3","to":"a7"},{"type":"arrow","at":169,"until":186,"brush":"yellow","from":"c6","to":"d4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"14.Qb3","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq1p1/2n4p/4pp2/Q7/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 2 14","depth":21,"score_cp":-101,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Qb3","uci":"a4b3","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq1p1/2n4p/4pp2/8/1QNP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 b - - 3 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Be6","uci":"d7e6","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/ppp1q1p1/2n1b2p/4pp2/8/1QNP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 4 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Qd1","uci":"b3d1","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/ppp1q1p1/2n1b2p/4pp2/8/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1BQ1RK1 b - - 5 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Qd7","uci":"e7d7","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppq2p1/2n1b2p/4pp2/8/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1BQ1RK1 w - - 6 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bd2","uci":"c1d2","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppq2p1/2n1b2p/4pp2/8/2NP2P1/PP1BPPBP/R2Q1RK1 b - - 7 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppq4/2n1b2p/4ppp1/8/2NP2P1/PP1BPPBP/R2Q1RK1 w - - 0 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"14.Qd1","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq1p1/2n4p/4pp2/Q7/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1B2RK1 w - - 2 14","depth":21,"score_cp":-107,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Qd1","uci":"a4d1","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq1p1/2n4p/4pp2/8/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1BQ1RK1 b - - 3 14","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq3/2n4p/4ppp1/8/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1BQ1RK1 w - - 0 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq3/2n4p/4ppp1/1P6/2NP2P1/P3PPBP/R1BQ1RK1 b - - 0 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"h5","uci":"h6h5","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq3/2n5/4pppp/1P6/2NP2P1/P3PPBP/R1BQ1RK1 w - - 0 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"b5","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq3/2n5/1P2pppp/8/2NP2P1/P3PPBP/R1BQ1RK1 b - - 0 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nd4","uci":"c6d4","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq3/8/1P2pppp/3n4/2NP2P1/P3PPBP/R1BQ1RK1 w - - 1 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":28,"san":"14...Nd4","quality":"best","text":"14...Nd4 lands the knight on a strong central square, d4. White can trade it, but Black keeps the initiative and the better pawn structure, while the queen heads to a5.\n\nOn the board: A waiting move first.","best":"c6d4","script":{"say":"14...Nd4 lands the knight on a strong central square, d4. White can trade it, but Black keeps the initiative and the better pawn structure, while the queen heads to a5.","show":[{"title":"A waiting move first","line":{"fen":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq1p1/2n4p/4pp2/Q7/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 3 14","depth":22,"score_cp":5,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black had a quieter try, covering b5 before the knight jumps.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a6","uci":"a7a6","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/1ppbq1p1/p1n4p/4pp2/Q7/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 0 15","comment":"14...a6 is a waiting move that covers b5.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/1ppbq1p1/p1n4p/4pp2/QP6/2NPB1P1/P3PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 0 15","comment":"15.b4 pushes the pawn at the queenside.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nd4","uci":"c6d4","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/1ppbq1p1/p6p/4pp2/QP1n4/2NPB1P1/P3PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 1 16","comment":"15...Nd4 jumps in anyway.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Qa5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/1ppbq1p1/p6p/Q3pp2/1P1n4/2NPB1P1/P3PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 2 16","comment":"16.Qa5 lines up on the e5 pawn.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Qxb4","uci":"e7b4","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/1ppb2p1/p6p/Q3pp2/1q1n4/2NPB1P1/P3PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 0 17","comment":"16...Qxb4 grabs the pawn.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Qxe5","uci":"a5e5","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/1ppb2p1/p6p/4Qp2/1q1n4/2NPB1P1/P3PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 0 17","comment":"17.Qxe5 takes the e5 pawn, and the game stays level.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Black had a quieter try, covering b5 before the knight jumps.","takeaway":"This gives White the better chances, so 14...Nd4 was the right moment to jump in."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":54,"until":168,"brush":"green","square":"d4"},{"type":"arrow","at":76,"until":168,"brush":"yellow","from":"e3","to":"d4"},{"type":"arrow","at":162,"until":168,"brush":"yellow","from":"a4","to":"a5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"14...a6","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq1p1/2n4p/4pp2/Q7/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 3 14","depth":22,"score_cp":5,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a6","uci":"a7a6","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/1ppbq1p1/p1n4p/4pp2/Q7/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 0 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/1ppbq1p1/p1n4p/4pp2/QP6/2NPB1P1/P3PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 0 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Nd4","uci":"c6d4","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/1ppbq1p1/p6p/4pp2/QP1n4/2NPB1P1/P3PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 1 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Qa5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/1ppbq1p1/p6p/Q3pp2/1P1n4/2NPB1P1/P3PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 2 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Qxb4","uci":"e7b4","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/1ppb2p1/p6p/Q3pp2/1q1n4/2NPB1P1/P3PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 0 17","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Qxe5","uci":"a5e5","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/1ppb2p1/p6p/4Qp2/1q1n4/2NPB1P1/P3PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 0 17","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"14...Qb4","score":"White is better","line":{"fen":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq1p1/2n4p/4pp2/Q7/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 3 14","depth":22,"score_cp":96,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Qb4","uci":"e7b4","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppb2p1/2n4p/4pp2/Qq6/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 4 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bxc6","uci":"g2c6","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppb2p1/2B4p/4pp2/Qq6/2NPB1P1/PP2PP1P/R4RK1 b - - 0 15","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bxc6","uci":"d7c6","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/ppp3p1/2b4p/4pp2/Qq6/2NPB1P1/PP2PP1P/R4RK1 w - - 0 16","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Qxa7+","uci":"a4a7","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/Qpp3p1/2b4p/4pp2/1q6/2NPB1P1/PP2PP1P/R4RK1 b - - 0 16","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kc8","uci":"b8c8","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/Qpp3p1/2b4p/4pp2/1q6/2NPB1P1/PP2PP1P/R4RK1 w - - 1 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"a3","uci":"a2a3","fen_after":"2kr1b1r/Qpp3p1/2b4p/4pp2/1q6/P1NPB1P1/1P2PP1P/R4RK1 b - - 0 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":29,"san":"15.Qa5","quality":"best","text":"15.Qa5 keeps the queen active, eyeing the a7 pawn and the c7 pawn next to the black king.","best":"a4a5","script":{"say":"15.Qa5 keeps the queen active, eyeing the a7 pawn and the c7 pawn next to the black king.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":38,"until":89,"brush":"red","from":"a5","to":"a7"},{"type":"ray","at":54,"until":89,"brush":"red","from":"a5","to":"c7"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"15.Qd1","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq1p1/7p/4pp2/Q2n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 4 15","depth":20,"score_cp":-119,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Qd1","uci":"a4d1","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq1p1/7p/4pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R2Q1RK1 b - - 5 15","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq3/7p/4ppp1/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R2Q1RK1 w - - 0 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rc1","uci":"a1c1","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq3/7p/4ppp1/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/2RQ1RK1 b - - 1 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Qe6","uci":"e7e6","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppb4/4q2p/4ppp1/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/2RQ1RK1 w - - 2 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppb4/4q2p/4ppp1/1P1n4/2NPB1P1/P3PPBP/2RQ1RK1 b - - 0 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bc6","uci":"d7c6","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/ppp5/2b1q2p/4ppp1/1P1n4/2NPB1P1/P3PPBP/2RQ1RK1 w - - 1 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":30,"san":"15...Qc5","quality":"good","text":"15...Qc5 offers the queen swap on Black's terms. Caruana is happy to head into an endgame where his pieces are better placed and he can press for small advantages.\n\nOn the board: Chasing the queen with b6.","best":"b7b6","script":{"say":"15...Qc5 offers the queen swap on Black's terms. Caruana is happy to head into an endgame where his pieces are better placed and he can press for small advantages.","show":[{"title":"Chasing the queen with b6","line":{"fen":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq1p1/7p/Q3pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 5 15","depth":27,"score_cp":-72,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black could have hit the queen with a pawn instead of offering the trade.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"b6","uci":"b7b6","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/p1pbq1p1/1p5p/Q3pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 0 16","comment":"15...b6 attacks the queen on a5 with a pawn.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Qa6","uci":"a5a6","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/p1pbq1p1/Qp5p/4pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 1 16","comment":"16.Qa6 runs to a6.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bc8","uci":"d7c8","fen_after":"1kbr1b1r/p1p1q1p1/Qp5p/4pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 2 17","comment":"16...Bc8 attacks the queen again.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Qa4","uci":"a6a4","fen_after":"1kbr1b1r/p1p1q1p1/1p5p/4pp2/Q2n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 3 17","comment":"17.Qa4 retreats once more.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Black could have hit the queen with a pawn instead of offering the trade.","takeaway":"This chases the queen around, but the computer slightly prefers the queen swap that Caruana chose."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":16,"until":163,"brush":"yellow","from":"a5","to":"c5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"15...b6","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq1p1/7p/Q3pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 5 15","depth":27,"score_cp":-72,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"b6","uci":"b7b6","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/p1pbq1p1/1p5p/Q3pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 0 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Qa6","uci":"a5a6","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/p1pbq1p1/Qp5p/4pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 1 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bc8","uci":"d7c8","fen_after":"1kbr1b1r/p1p1q1p1/Qp5p/4pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 2 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Qa4","uci":"a6a4","fen_after":"1kbr1b1r/p1p1q1p1/1p5p/4pp2/Q2n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 3 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Qd7","uci":"e7d7","fen_after":"1kbr1b1r/p1pq2p1/1p5p/4pp2/Q2n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 4 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Qxd7","uci":"a4d7","fen_after":"1kbr1b1r/p1pQ2p1/1p5p/4pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"15...Bc8","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r1b1r/pppbq1p1/7p/Q3pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 5 15","depth":27,"score_cp":-58,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bc8","uci":"d7c8","fen_after":"1kbr1b1r/ppp1q1p1/7p/Q3pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 6 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rac1","uci":"a1c1","fen_after":"1kbr1b1r/ppp1q1p1/7p/Q3pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/2R2RK1 b - - 7 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Qc5","uci":"e7c5","fen_after":"1kbr1b1r/ppp3p1/7p/Q1q1pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/2R2RK1 w - - 8 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Qa4","uci":"a5a4","fen_after":"1kbr1b1r/ppp3p1/7p/2q1pp2/Q2n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/2R2RK1 b - - 9 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Qb4","uci":"c5b4","fen_after":"1kbr1b1r/ppp3p1/7p/4pp2/Qq1n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/2R2RK1 w - - 10 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Qd1","uci":"a4d1","fen_after":"1kbr1b1r/ppp3p1/7p/4pp2/1q1n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/2RQ1RK1 b - - 11 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":31,"san":"16.Qxc5","quality":"only move","text":"Rapport takes the queen with 16.Qxc5, and it is the only move. Black will recapture with the bishop. The tempting alternative, moving the queen away, runs into trouble because the knight on d4 is so strong. Trading queens leaves White a little worse but safe.\n\nOn the board: Dodging the trade.","best":"a5c5","script":{"say":"Rapport takes the queen with 16.Qxc5, and it is the only move. Black will recapture with the bishop. The tempting alternative, moving the queen away, runs into trouble because the knight on d4 is so strong. Trading queens leaves White a little worse but safe.","show":[{"title":"Dodging the trade","line":{"fen":"1k1r1b1r/pppb2p1/7p/Q1q1pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 6 16","depth":20,"score_cp":-368,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White could try to keep queens on with a queen move to a3.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Qa3","uci":"a5a3","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppb2p1/7p/2q1pp2/3n4/Q1NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 7 16","comment":"16.Qa3 avoids the exchange and keeps the queen on the board.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Qb6","uci":"c5b6","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppb2p1/1q5p/4pp2/3n4/Q1NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 8 17","comment":"16...Qb6 steps aside and hits the b2 pawn.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bxd4","uci":"e3d4","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppb2p1/1q5p/4pp2/3B4/Q1NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 0 17","comment":"17.Bxd4 trades off the strong knight.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"exd4","uci":"e5d4","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppb2p1/1q5p/5p2/3p4/Q1NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 0 18","comment":"17...exd4 attacks the knight on c3 and White has real problems.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White could try to keep queens on with a queen move to a3.","takeaway":"The computer says Black would be clearly better after that, so the queen trade was necessary."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":74,"until":259,"brush":"red","from":"f8","to":"c5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"16.Qa3","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"1k1r1b1r/pppb2p1/7p/Q1q1pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 6 16","depth":20,"score_cp":-368,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Qa3","uci":"a5a3","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppb2p1/7p/2q1pp2/3n4/Q1NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 7 16","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Qb6","uci":"c5b6","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppb2p1/1q5p/4pp2/3n4/Q1NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 8 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bxd4","uci":"e3d4","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppb2p1/1q5p/4pp2/3B4/Q1NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 0 17","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"exd4","uci":"e5d4","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppb2p1/1q5p/5p2/3p4/Q1NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nd5","uci":"c3d5","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppb2p1/1q5p/3N1p2/3p4/Q2P2P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 1 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Qb5","uci":"b6b5","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppb2p1/7p/1q1N1p2/3p4/Q2P2P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 2 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":32,"san":"16...Bxc5","quality":"only move","text":"16...Bxc5 recaptures and puts the bishop on a fine diagonal. Black's pieces are all active and White has no easy targets.","best":"f8c5","script":{"say":"16...Bxc5 recaptures and puts the bishop on a fine diagonal. Black's pieces are all active and White has no easy targets.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":59,"until":121,"brush":"green","from":"c5","to":"a3"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"16...Nxe2+","score":"White is winning","line":{"fen":"1k1r1b1r/pppb2p1/7p/2Q1pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 0 16","depth":18,"score_cp":536,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nxe2+","uci":"d4e2","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppb2p1/7p/2Q1pp2/8/2NPB1P1/PP2nPBP/R4RK1 w - - 0 17","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxe2","uci":"c3e2","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppb2p1/7p/2Q1pp2/8/3PB1P1/PP2NPBP/R4RK1 b - - 0 17","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"16...Nc6","score":"White is winning","line":{"fen":"1k1r1b1r/pppb2p1/7p/2Q1pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 0 16","depth":18,"score_cp":630,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Nc6","uci":"d4c6","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppb2p1/2n4p/2Q1pp2/8/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 1 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Qd5","uci":"c5d5","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppb2p1/2n4p/3Qpp2/8/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 2 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppb4/2n4p/3Qppp1/8/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nb5","uci":"c3b5","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/pppb4/2n4p/1N1Qppp1/8/3PB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 1 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"a6","uci":"a7a6","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/1ppb4/p1n4p/1N1Qppp1/8/3PB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 0 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nxc7","uci":"b5c7","fen_after":"1k1r1b1r/1pNb4/p1n4p/3Qppp1/8/3PB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 b - - 0 19","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":33,"san":"17.Rfc1","quality":"good","text":"17.Rfc1 puts a rook on the c-file, behind the knight on c3, ready for the day the file opens. It's a reasonable move, though it doesn't change the balance much, and White's bishop can now trade off the strong knight.\n\nOn the board: The other rook to b1.","best":"a1b1","script":{"say":"17.Rfc1 puts a rook on the c-file, behind the knight on c3, ready for the day the file opens. It's a reasonable move, though it doesn't change the balance much, and White's bishop can now trade off the strong knight.","show":[{"title":"The other rook to b1","line":{"fen":"1k1r3r/pppb2p1/7p/2b1pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 0 17","depth":23,"score_cp":-75,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White had a plan with the b-pawn instead of the c-file.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rab1","uci":"a1b1","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb2p1/7p/2b1pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/1R3RK1 b - - 1 17","comment":"17.Rab1 puts the rook behind the b-pawn.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb4/7p/2b1ppp1/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/1R3RK1 w - - 0 18","comment":"17...g5 starts Black's kingside advance.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb4/7p/2b1ppp1/1P1n4/2NPB1P1/P3PPBP/1R3RK1 b - - 0 18","comment":"18.b4 chases the bishop on c5.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bd6","uci":"c5d6","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb4/3b3p/4ppp1/1P1n4/2NPB1P1/P3PPBP/1R3RK1 w - - 1 19","comment":"18...Bd6 steps back to a safe square.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White had a plan with the b-pawn instead of the c-file.","takeaway":"The computer rates this a little better for White than the game move, so the b-pawn plan was more useful."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":188,"until":216,"brush":"red","from":"e3","to":"d4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"17.Rab1","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r3r/pppb2p1/7p/2b1pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 0 17","depth":23,"score_cp":-75,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rab1","uci":"a1b1","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb2p1/7p/2b1pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/1R3RK1 b - - 1 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb4/7p/2b1ppp1/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/1R3RK1 w - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb4/7p/2b1ppp1/1P1n4/2NPB1P1/P3PPBP/1R3RK1 b - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bd6","uci":"c5d6","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb4/3b3p/4ppp1/1P1n4/2NPB1P1/P3PPBP/1R3RK1 w - - 1 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb4/3b3p/4ppp1/1P1n4/2NPB1PP/P3PPB1/1R3RK1 b - - 0 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Be6","uci":"d7e6","fen_after":"1k1r3r/ppp5/3bb2p/4ppp1/1P1n4/2NPB1PP/P3PPB1/1R3RK1 w - - 1 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"17.Rac1","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"1k1r3r/pppb2p1/7p/2b1pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 0 17","depth":23,"score_cp":-81,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rac1","uci":"a1c1","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb2p1/7p/2b1pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/2R2RK1 b - - 1 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb4/7p/2b1ppp1/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/2R2RK1 w - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rfe1","uci":"f1e1","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb4/7p/2b1ppp1/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/2R1R1K1 b - - 1 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bd6","uci":"c5d6","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb4/3b3p/4ppp1/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/2R1R1K1 w - - 2 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bd2","uci":"e3d2","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb4/3b3p/4ppp1/3n4/2NP2P1/PP1BPPBP/2R1R1K1 b - - 3 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rhf8","uci":"h8f8","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb4/3b3p/4ppp1/3n4/2NP2P1/PP1BPPBP/2R1R1K1 w - - 4 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"17.Rfe1","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"1k1r3r/pppb2p1/7p/2b1pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R4RK1 w - - 0 17","depth":23,"score_cp":-82,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rfe1","uci":"f1e1","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb2p1/7p/2b1pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R3R1K1 b - - 1 17","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bd6","uci":"c5d6","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb2p1/3b3p/4pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R3R1K1 w - - 2 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rac1","uci":"a1c1","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb2p1/3b3p/4pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/2R1R1K1 b - - 3 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb4/3b3p/4ppp1/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/2R1R1K1 w - - 0 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bd2","uci":"e3d2","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb4/3b3p/4ppp1/3n4/2NP2P1/PP1BPPBP/2R1R1K1 b - - 1 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rhf8","uci":"h8f8","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb4/3b3p/4ppp1/3n4/2NP2P1/PP1BPPBP/2R1R1K1 w - - 2 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":null},{"ply":34,"san":"17...Rhf8","quality":"good","text":"17...Rhf8 brings the second rook behind the f5 pawn, ready to back up its advance. Black is happy with his setup.","best":"g7g5","script":{"say":"17...Rhf8 brings the second rook behind the f5 pawn, ready to back up its advance. Black is happy with his setup.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":70,"until":113,"brush":"green","from":"f5","to":"f4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"17...g5","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"1k1r3r/pppb2p1/7p/2b1pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 b - - 1 17","depth":22,"score_cp":-90,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb4/7p/2b1ppp1/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 w - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kf1","uci":"g1f1","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb4/7p/2b1ppp1/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R1R2K2 b - - 1 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Be7","uci":"c5e7","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppbb3/7p/4ppp1/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R1R2K2 w - - 2 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nd5","uci":"c3d5","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppbb3/7p/3Nppp1/3n4/3PB1P1/PP2PPBP/R1R2K2 b - - 3 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bd6","uci":"e7d6","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb4/3b3p/3Nppp1/3n4/3PB1P1/PP2PPBP/R1R2K2 w - - 4 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bd2","uci":"e3d2","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb4/3b3p/3Nppp1/3n4/3P2P1/PP1BPPBP/R1R2K2 b - - 5 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"17...Bb4","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r3r/pppb2p1/7p/2b1pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 b - - 1 17","depth":22,"score_cp":-77,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bb4","uci":"c5b4","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb2p1/7p/4pp2/1b1n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 w - - 2 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bxd4","uci":"e3d4","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb2p1/7p/4pp2/1b1B4/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 b - - 0 18","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"exd4","uci":"e5d4","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb2p1/7p/5p2/1b1p4/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 w - - 0 19","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Nb1","uci":"c3b1","fen_after":"1k1r3r/pppb2p1/7p/5p2/1b1p4/3P2P1/PP2PPBP/RNR3K1 b - - 1 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rhe8","uci":"h8e8","fen_after":"1k1rr3/pppb2p1/7p/5p2/1b1p4/3P2P1/PP2PPBP/RNR3K1 w - - 2 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"a3","uci":"a2a3","fen_after":"1k1rr3/pppb2p1/7p/5p2/1b1p4/P2P2P1/1P2PPBP/RNR3K1 b - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":3},{"ply":35,"san":"18.Bxd4","quality":"good","text":"18.Bxd4 removes the strong knight. White has been uncomfortable with it for a while, and trading it is a sensible decision. Black recaptures next.","best":"a1b1","script":{"say":"18.Bxd4 removes the strong knight. White has been uncomfortable with it for a while, and trading it is a sensible decision. Black recaptures next.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":130,"until":146,"brush":"yellow","from":"c5","to":"d4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"18.Rab1","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/2b1pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 w - - 2 18","depth":20,"score_cp":-69,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rab1","uci":"a1b1","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/2b1pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/1RR3K1 b - - 3 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/2b1p3/3n1p2/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/1RR3K1 w - - 0 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bxd4","uci":"e3d4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/2b1p3/3B1p2/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/1RR3K1 b - - 0 19","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bxd4","uci":"c5d4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/4p3/3b1p2/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/1RR3K1 w - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bf3","uci":"g2f3","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/4p3/3b1p2/2NP1BP1/PP2PP1P/1RR3K1 b - - 1 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb4/7p/4p1p1/3b1p2/2NP1BP1/PP2PP1P/1RR3K1 w - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"18.Re1","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/2b1pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 w - - 2 18","depth":20,"score_cp":-108,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Re1","uci":"c1e1","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/2b1pp2/3n4/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R3R1K1 b - - 3 18","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/2b1p3/3n1p2/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R3R1K1 w - - 0 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bxd4","uci":"e3d4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/2b1p3/3B1p2/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R3R1K1 b - - 0 19","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bxd4","uci":"c5d4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/4p3/3b1p2/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R3R1K1 w - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"e3","uci":"e2e3","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/4p3/3b1p2/2NPP1P1/PP3PBP/R3R1K1 b - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bxc3","uci":"d4c3","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/4p3/5p2/2bPP1P1/PP3PBP/R3R1K1 w - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":36,"san":"18...Bxd4","quality":"best","text":"18...Bxd4 recaptures with the bishop, keeping the pawn structure intact, and from the centre the bishop eyes the knight on c3. White's answer will be to kick it.\n\nOn the board: Recapturing with the pawn.","best":"c5d4","script":{"say":"18...Bxd4 recaptures with the bishop, keeping the pawn structure intact, and from the centre the bishop eyes the knight on c3. White's answer will be to kick it.","show":[{"title":"Recapturing with the pawn","line":{"fen":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/2b1pp2/3B4/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 b - - 0 18","depth":23,"score_cp":-59,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black could have taken back with the e-pawn instead of the bishop.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"exd4","uci":"e5d4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/2b2p2/3p4/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 w - - 0 19","comment":"18...exd4 takes the bishop with the pawn and attacks the knight on c3.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nb5","uci":"c3b5","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/1Nb2p2/3p4/3P2P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 b - - 1 19","comment":"19.Nb5 jumps the knight out of the pawn's reach.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bb6","uci":"c5b6","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/1b5p/1N3p2/3p4/3P2P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 w - - 2 20","comment":"19...Bb6 keeps the bishop safe.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Na3","uci":"b5a3","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/1b5p/5p2/3p4/N2P2P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 b - - 3 20","comment":"20.Na3 sends the knight back toward the queenside.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Black could have taken back with the e-pawn instead of the bishop.","takeaway":"The computer rates this almost the same as the game move, so Black had two good ways to recapture."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":104,"until":161,"brush":"green","from":"d4","to":"c3"},{"type":"arrow","at":150,"until":161,"brush":"red","from":"e2","to":"e3"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"18...exd4","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/2b1pp2/3B4/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 b - - 0 18","depth":23,"score_cp":-59,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"exd4","uci":"e5d4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/2b2p2/3p4/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 w - - 0 19","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nb5","uci":"c3b5","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/1Nb2p2/3p4/3P2P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 b - - 1 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bb6","uci":"c5b6","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/1b5p/1N3p2/3p4/3P2P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 w - - 2 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Na3","uci":"b5a3","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/1b5p/5p2/3p4/N2P2P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 b - - 3 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rde8","uci":"d8e8","fen_after":"1k2rr2/pppb2p1/1b5p/5p2/3p4/N2P2P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 w - - 4 21","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rc2","uci":"c1c2","fen_after":"1k2rr2/pppb2p1/1b5p/5p2/3p4/N2P2P1/PPR1PPBP/R5K1 b - - 5 21","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"18...Bd6","score":"White is winning","line":{"fen":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/2b1pp2/3B4/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 b - - 0 18","depth":23,"score_cp":620,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bd6","uci":"c5d6","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/3b3p/4pp2/3B4/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 w - - 1 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Be3","uci":"d4e3","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/3b3p/4pp2/8/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 b - - 2 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb4/3b3p/4ppp1/8/2NPB1P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 w - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb4/3b3p/4ppp1/1P6/2NPB1P1/P3PPBP/R1R3K1 b - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"g4","uci":"g5g4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb4/3b3p/4pp2/1P4p1/2NPB1P1/P3PPBP/R1R3K1 w - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"d4","uci":"d3d4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb4/3b3p/4pp2/1P1P2p1/2N1B1P1/P3PPBP/R1R3K1 b - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":37,"san":"19.e3","quality":"best","text":"19.e3 kicks the bishop away from d4 at once, before it can settle there. It will retreat to b6.","best":"e2e3","script":{"say":"19.e3 kicks the bishop away from d4 at once, before it can settle there. It will retreat to b6.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":81,"until":95,"brush":"yellow","from":"d4","to":"b6"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"19.Rc2","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/4pp2/3b4/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 w - - 0 19","depth":17,"score_cp":-109,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rc2","uci":"c1c2","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/4pp2/3b4/2NP2P1/PPR1PPBP/R5K1 b - - 1 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"a6","uci":"a7a6","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1ppb2p1/p6p/4pp2/3b4/2NP2P1/PPR1PPBP/R5K1 w - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rf1","uci":"a1f1","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1ppb2p1/p6p/4pp2/3b4/2NP2P1/PPR1PPBP/5RK1 b - - 1 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1ppb4/p6p/4ppp1/3b4/2NP2P1/PPR1PPBP/5RK1 w - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Nb1","uci":"c3b1","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1ppb4/p6p/4ppp1/3b4/3P2P1/PPR1PPBP/1N3RK1 b - - 1 21","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1ppb4/p6p/4p1p1/3b1p2/3P2P1/PPR1PPBP/1N3RK1 w - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"19.Rab1","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/4pp2/3b4/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/R1R3K1 w - - 0 19","depth":17,"score_cp":-111,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rab1","uci":"a1b1","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/4pp2/3b4/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/1RR3K1 b - - 1 19","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Be6","uci":"d7e6","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/ppp3p1/4b2p/4pp2/3b4/2NP2P1/PP2PPBP/1RR3K1 w - - 2 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"e3","uci":"e2e3","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/ppp3p1/4b2p/4pp2/3b4/2NPP1P1/PP3PBP/1RR3K1 b - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bc5","uci":"d4c5","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/ppp3p1/4b2p/2b1pp2/8/2NPP1P1/PP3PBP/1RR3K1 w - - 1 21","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/ppp3p1/4b2p/2b1pp2/1P6/2NPP1P1/P4PBP/1RR3K1 b - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Be7","uci":"c5e7","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/ppp1b1p1/4b2p/4pp2/1P6/2NPP1P1/P4PBP/1RR3K1 w - - 1 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":38,"san":"19...Bb6","quality":"good","text":"19...Bb6 retreats the bishop to a safe diagonal, where it still eyes the e3 pawn. White's knight now heads to d5.\n\nOn the board: Trading the bishop for the knight.","best":"d4c5","script":{"say":"19...Bb6 retreats the bishop to a safe diagonal, where it still eyes the e3 pawn. White's knight now heads to d5.","show":[{"title":"Trading the bishop for the knight","line":{"fen":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/4pp2/3b4/2NPP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 b - - 0 19","depth":20,"score_cp":-13,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black could have given up the bishop for the knight immediately.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bxc3","uci":"d4c3","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/4pp2/8/2bPP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 w - - 0 20","comment":"19...Bxc3 trades the bishop for the knight at once.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxc3","uci":"c1c3","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/4pp2/8/2RPP1P1/PP3PBP/R5K1 b - - 0 20","comment":"20.Rxc3 recaptures with the rook and keeps the structure.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rf7","uci":"f8f7","fen_after":"1k1r4/pppb1rp1/7p/4pp2/8/2RPP1P1/PP3PBP/R5K1 w - - 1 21","comment":"20...Rf7 shuffles the rook over.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rac1","uci":"a1c1","fen_after":"1k1r4/pppb1rp1/7p/4pp2/8/2RPP1P1/PP3PBP/2R3K1 b - - 2 21","comment":"21.Rac1 doubles the rooks on the c-file.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Black could have given up the bishop for the knight immediately.","takeaway":"The computer gives Black less here than the game's bishop retreat, so keeping the bishop was better."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":58,"until":113,"brush":"green","from":"b6","to":"e3"},{"type":"arrow","at":101,"until":113,"brush":"yellow","from":"c3","to":"d5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"19...Bc5","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/4pp2/3b4/2NPP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 b - - 0 19","depth":20,"score_cp":-75,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bc5","uci":"d4c5","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/2b1pp2/8/2NPP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 w - - 1 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nb5","uci":"c3b5","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/1Nb1pp2/8/3PP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 b - - 2 20","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bb6","uci":"c5b6","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/1b5p/1N2pp2/8/3PP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 w - - 3 21","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Na3","uci":"b5a3","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/1b5p/4pp2/8/N2PP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 b - - 4 21","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"c6","uci":"c7c6","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pp1b2p1/1bp4p/4pp2/8/N2PP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 w - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Nc4","uci":"a3c4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pp1b2p1/1bp4p/4pp2/2N5/3PP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 b - - 1 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"19...Bxc3","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/4pp2/3b4/2NPP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 b - - 0 19","depth":20,"score_cp":-13,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bxc3","uci":"d4c3","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/4pp2/8/2bPP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 w - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxc3","uci":"c1c3","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/7p/4pp2/8/2RPP1P1/PP3PBP/R5K1 b - - 0 20","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rf7","uci":"f8f7","fen_after":"1k1r4/pppb1rp1/7p/4pp2/8/2RPP1P1/PP3PBP/R5K1 w - - 1 21","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rac1","uci":"a1c1","fen_after":"1k1r4/pppb1rp1/7p/4pp2/8/2RPP1P1/PP3PBP/2R3K1 b - - 2 21","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Be8","uci":"d7e8","fen_after":"1k1rb3/ppp2rp1/7p/4pp2/8/2RPP1P1/PP3PBP/2R3K1 w - - 3 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"h4","uci":"h2h4","fen_after":"1k1rb3/ppp2rp1/7p/4pp2/7P/2RPP1P1/PP3PB1/2R3K1 b - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":39,"san":"20.Nd5","quality":"best","text":"20.Nd5 plants the knight in the middle of the board, offering a trade and aiming at the bishop on b6. Black can answer by moving the bishop to e6.","best":"c3d5","script":{"say":"20.Nd5 plants the knight in the middle of the board, offering a trade and aiming at the bishop on b6. Black can answer by moving the bishop to e6.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":81,"until":146,"brush":"red","from":"d5","to":"b6"},{"type":"arrow","at":122,"until":146,"brush":"yellow","from":"d7","to":"e6"}]},"alternatives":[],"playedRank":1},{"ply":40,"san":"20...Be6","quality":"good","text":"20...Be6 brings the bishop to a better square and attacks the knight. Black is happy to challenge it and see the trade through.\n\nOn the board: A pawn hits the knight.","best":"g7g5","script":{"say":"20...Be6 brings the bishop to a better square and attacks the knight. Black is happy to challenge it and see the trade through.","show":[{"title":"A pawn hits the knight","line":{"fen":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/1b5p/3Npp2/8/3PP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 b - - 2 20","depth":20,"score_cp":-36,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black could have kicked the knight with a pawn.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"c6","uci":"c7c6","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pp1b2p1/1bp4p/3Npp2/8/3PP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 w - - 0 21","comment":"20...c6 attacks the knight on d5 with a pawn.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxb6","uci":"d5b6","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pp1b2p1/1Np4p/4pp2/8/3PP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 b - - 0 21","comment":"21.Nxb6 takes the bishop first.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"axb6","uci":"a7b6","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1p1b2p1/1pp4p/4pp2/8/3PP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 w - - 0 22","comment":"21...axb6 recaptures with the a-pawn.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"a4","uci":"a2a4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1p1b2p1/1pp4p/4pp2/P7/3PP1P1/1P3PBP/R1R3K1 b - - 0 22","comment":"22.a4 pushes the pawn forward.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Black could have kicked the knight with a pawn.","takeaway":"The computer sees almost no difference from the game move."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":58,"until":127,"brush":"yellow","from":"e6","to":"d5"},{"type":"arrow","at":109,"until":127,"brush":"red","from":"d5","to":"b6"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"20...g5","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/1b5p/3Npp2/8/3PP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 b - - 2 20","depth":20,"score_cp":-41,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb4/1b5p/3Nppp1/8/3PP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 w - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxb6","uci":"d5b6","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pppb4/1N5p/4ppp1/8/3PP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 b - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"axb6","uci":"a7b6","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1ppb4/1p5p/4ppp1/8/3PP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 w - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"a4","uci":"a2a4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1ppb4/1p5p/4ppp1/P7/3PP1P1/1P3PBP/R1R3K1 b - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1ppb4/1p5p/4p1p1/P4p2/3PP1P1/1P3PBP/R1R3K1 w - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Be4","uci":"g2e4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1ppb4/1p5p/4p1p1/P3Bp2/3PP1P1/1P3P1P/R1R3K1 b - - 1 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"20...c6","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r1r2/pppb2p1/1b5p/3Npp2/8/3PP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 b - - 2 20","depth":20,"score_cp":-36,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"c6","uci":"c7c6","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pp1b2p1/1bp4p/3Npp2/8/3PP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 w - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nxb6","uci":"d5b6","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pp1b2p1/1Np4p/4pp2/8/3PP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 b - - 0 21","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"axb6","uci":"a7b6","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1p1b2p1/1pp4p/4pp2/8/3PP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 w - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"a4","uci":"a2a4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1p1b2p1/1pp4p/4pp2/P7/3PP1P1/1P3PBP/R1R3K1 b - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Be6","uci":"d7e6","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1p4p1/1pp1b2p/4pp2/P7/3PP1P1/1P3PBP/R1R3K1 w - - 1 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rc3","uci":"c1c3","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1p4p1/1pp1b2p/4pp2/P7/2RPP1P1/1P3PBP/R5K1 b - - 2 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":3},{"ply":41,"san":"21.Nxb6","quality":"best","text":"21.Nxb6 removes Black's good bishop. It's a fair trade, since the bishop was one of Black's most useful pieces, and the a-pawn recaptures.","best":"d5b6","script":{"say":"21.Nxb6 removes Black's good bishop. It's a fair trade, since the bishop was one of Black's most useful pieces, and the a-pawn recaptures.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":127,"until":138,"brush":"yellow","from":"a7","to":"b6"}]},"alternatives":[],"playedRank":1},{"ply":42,"san":"21...axb6","quality":"best","text":"21...axb6 recaptures with the a-pawn and opens the a-file for a rook. Black's pawns are a bit scattered now, but his pieces are active. White's plan is a rook lift.","best":"a7b6","script":{"say":"21...axb6 recaptures with the a-pawn and opens the a-file for a rook. Black's pawns are a bit scattered now, but his pieces are active. White's plan is a rook lift.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":152,"until":164,"brush":"yellow","from":"c1","to":"c3"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"21...cxb6","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"1k1r1r2/ppp3p1/1N2b2p/4pp2/8/3PP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 b - - 0 21","depth":22,"score_cp":-13,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"cxb6","uci":"c7b6","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pp4p1/1p2b2p/4pp2/8/3PP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 w - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rd1","uci":"c1d1","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/pp4p1/1p2b2p/4pp2/8/3PP1P1/PP3PBP/R2R2K1 b - - 1 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rd6","uci":"d8d6","fen_after":"1k3r2/pp4p1/1p1rb2p/4pp2/8/3PP1P1/PP3PBP/R2R2K1 w - - 2 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bh3","uci":"g2h3","fen_after":"1k3r2/pp4p1/1p1rb2p/4pp2/8/3PP1PB/PP3P1P/R2R2K1 b - - 3 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k3r2/pp6/1p1rb2p/4ppp1/8/3PP1PB/PP3P1P/R2R2K1 w - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"e4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"1k3r2/pp6/1p1rb2p/4ppp1/4P3/3P2PB/PP3P1P/R2R2K1 b - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"21...Rxd3","score":"White is winning","line":{"fen":"1k1r1r2/ppp3p1/1N2b2p/4pp2/8/3PP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 b - - 0 21","depth":22,"score_cp":548,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rxd3","uci":"d8d3","fen_after":"1k3r2/ppp3p1/1N2b2p/4pp2/8/3rP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 w - - 0 22","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Nc4","uci":"b6c4","fen_after":"1k3r2/ppp3p1/4b2p/4pp2/2N5/3rP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 b - - 1 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"e4","uci":"e5e4","fen_after":"1k3r2/ppp3p1/4b2p/5p2/2N1p3/3rP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 w - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"1k3r2/ppp3p1/4b2p/5p2/1PN1p3/3rP1P1/P4PBP/R1R3K1 b - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k3r2/ppp5/4b2p/5pp1/1PN1p3/3rP1P1/P4PBP/R1R3K1 w - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bf1","uci":"g2f1","fen_after":"1k3r2/ppp5/4b2p/5pp1/1PN1p3/3rP1P1/P4P1P/R1R2BK1 b - - 1 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":43,"san":"22.Rc3","quality":"best","text":"22.Rc3 lifts the rook to the third rank, ready to swing along it or double on the c-file. White is looking for counterplay, and Black will answer with a rook lift of his own.","best":"c1c3","script":{"say":"22.Rc3 lifts the rook to the third rank, ready to swing along it or double on the c-file. White is looking for counterplay, and Black will answer with a rook lift of his own.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":65,"until":174,"brush":"green","from":"c3","to":"a3"},{"type":"arrow","at":139,"until":174,"brush":"yellow","from":"d8","to":"d6"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"22.Bf1","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r1r2/1pp3p1/1p2b2p/4pp2/8/3PP1P1/PP3PBP/R1R3K1 w - - 0 22","depth":23,"score_cp":-54,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bf1","uci":"g2f1","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1pp3p1/1p2b2p/4pp2/8/3PP1P1/PP3P1P/R1R2BK1 b - - 1 22","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1pp5/1p2b2p/4ppp1/8/3PP1P1/PP3P1P/R1R2BK1 w - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"a4","uci":"a2a4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1pp5/1p2b2p/4ppp1/P7/3PP1P1/1P3P1P/R1R2BK1 b - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"c6","uci":"c7c6","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1p6/1pp1b2p/4ppp1/P7/3PP1P1/1P3P1P/R1R2BK1 w - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"a5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1p6/1pp1b2p/P3ppp1/8/3PP1P1/1P3P1P/R1R2BK1 b - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"b5","uci":"b6b5","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1p6/2p1b2p/Pp2ppp1/8/3PP1P1/1P3P1P/R1R2BK1 w - - 0 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":44,"san":"22...Rd6","quality":"good","text":"22...Rd6 lifts the rook to the sixth rank, where it protects the b6 pawn and makes room for the other rook on the d-file. A well-organised move.","best":"c7c6","script":{"say":"22...Rd6 lifts the rook to the sixth rank, where it protects the b6 pawn and makes room for the other rook on the d-file. A well-organised move.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":61,"until":144,"brush":"yellow","square":"b6"},{"type":"arrow","at":120,"until":144,"brush":"green","from":"f8","to":"d8"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"22...c6","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r1r2/1pp3p1/1p2b2p/4pp2/8/2RPP1P1/PP3PBP/R5K1 b - - 1 22","depth":18,"score_cp":-43,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"c6","uci":"c7c6","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1p4p1/1pp1b2p/4pp2/8/2RPP1P1/PP3PBP/R5K1 w - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"a4","uci":"a2a4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1p4p1/1pp1b2p/4pp2/P7/2RPP1P1/1P3PBP/R5K1 b - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1p4p1/1pp1b2p/4p3/P4p2/2RPP1P1/1P3PBP/R5K1 w - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Be4","uci":"g2e4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1p4p1/1pp1b2p/4p3/P3Bp2/2RPP1P1/1P3P1P/R5K1 b - - 1 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"fxe3","uci":"f4e3","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1p4p1/1pp1b2p/4p3/P3B3/2RPp1P1/1P3P1P/R5K1 w - - 0 25","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"fxe3","uci":"f2e3","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1p4p1/1pp1b2p/4p3/P3B3/2RPP1P1/1P5P/R5K1 b - - 0 25","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"22...g5","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r1r2/1pp3p1/1p2b2p/4pp2/8/2RPP1P1/PP3PBP/R5K1 b - - 1 22","depth":18,"score_cp":-37,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1pp5/1p2b2p/4ppp1/8/2RPP1P1/PP3PBP/R5K1 w - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"a4","uci":"a2a4","fen_after":"1k1r1r2/1pp5/1p2b2p/4ppp1/P7/2RPP1P1/1P3PBP/R5K1 b - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":3},{"ply":45,"san":"23.a4","quality":"good","text":"23.a4 starts a pawn push on the queenside, trying to open lines against the black king.\n\nOn the board: Breaking with f4.","best":"f2f4","script":{"say":"23.a4 starts a pawn push on the queenside, trying to open lines against the black king.","show":[{"title":"Breaking with f4","line":{"fen":"1k3r2/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/4pp2/8/2RPP1P1/PP3PBP/R5K1 w - - 2 23","depth":23,"score_cp":-34,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White could have opened the centre with the f-pawn instead.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"f4","uci":"f2f4","fen_after":"1k3r2/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/4pp2/5P2/2RPP1P1/PP4BP/R5K1 b - - 0 23","comment":"23.f4 challenges the e5 pawn.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"exf4","uci":"e5f4","fen_after":"1k3r2/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/5p2/5p2/2RPP1P1/PP4BP/R5K1 w - - 0 24","comment":"23...exf4 takes the pawn.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"exf4","uci":"e3f4","fen_after":"1k3r2/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/5p2/5P2/2RP2P1/PP4BP/R5K1 b - - 0 24","comment":"24.exf4 recaptures and White's pawns line up on f4 and g3.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rfd8","uci":"f8d8","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/5p2/5P2/2RP2P1/PP4BP/R5K1 w - - 1 25","comment":"24...Rfd8 doubles the rooks on the d-file.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White could have opened the centre with the f-pawn instead.","takeaway":"The computer rates this a little better for White than the a-pawn push."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":41,"until":87,"brush":"yellow","from":"a4","to":"a5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"23.f4","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k3r2/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/4pp2/8/2RPP1P1/PP3PBP/R5K1 w - - 2 23","depth":23,"score_cp":-34,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"f4","uci":"f2f4","fen_after":"1k3r2/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/4pp2/5P2/2RPP1P1/PP4BP/R5K1 b - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"exf4","uci":"e5f4","fen_after":"1k3r2/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/5p2/5p2/2RPP1P1/PP4BP/R5K1 w - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"exf4","uci":"e3f4","fen_after":"1k3r2/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/5p2/5P2/2RP2P1/PP4BP/R5K1 b - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rfd8","uci":"f8d8","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/5p2/5P2/2RP2P1/PP4BP/R5K1 w - - 1 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bf1","uci":"g2f1","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/5p2/5P2/2RP2P1/PP5P/R4BK1 b - - 2 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1rb2p/5pp1/5P2/2RP2P1/PP5P/R4BK1 w - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"23.h3","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k3r2/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/4pp2/8/2RPP1P1/PP3PBP/R5K1 w - - 2 23","depth":23,"score_cp":-49,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"1k3r2/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/4pp2/8/2RPP1PP/PP3PB1/R5K1 b - - 0 23","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"c5","uci":"c7c5","fen_after":"1k3r2/1p4p1/1p1rb2p/2p1pp2/8/2RPP1PP/PP3PB1/R5K1 w - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"a3","uci":"a2a3","fen_after":"1k3r2/1p4p1/1p1rb2p/2p1pp2/8/P1RPP1PP/1P3PB1/R5K1 b - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rfd8","uci":"f8d8","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p4p1/1p1rb2p/2p1pp2/8/P1RPP1PP/1P3PB1/R5K1 w - - 1 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bf1","uci":"g2f1","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p4p1/1p1rb2p/2p1pp2/8/P1RPP1PP/1P3P2/R4BK1 b - - 2 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"e4","uci":"e5e4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p4p1/1p1rb2p/2p2p2/4p3/P1RPP1PP/1P3P2/R4BK1 w - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":46,"san":"23...Rfd8","quality":"best","text":"23...Rfd8 doubles the rooks on the d-file, adding pressure on the d3 pawn and keeping every piece in the game. White will defend it with the bishop.","best":"f8d8","script":{"say":"23...Rfd8 doubles the rooks on the d-file, adding pressure on the d3 pawn and keeping every piece in the game. White will defend it with the bishop.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":62,"until":148,"brush":"red","from":"d6","to":"d3"},{"type":"arrow","at":122,"until":148,"brush":"yellow","from":"g2","to":"f1"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"23...c6","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k3r2/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/4pp2/P7/2RPP1P1/1P3PBP/R5K1 b - - 0 23","depth":25,"score_cp":-44,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"c6","uci":"c7c6","fen_after":"1k3r2/1p4p1/1pprb2p/4pp2/P7/2RPP1P1/1P3PBP/R5K1 w - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"1k3r2/1p4p1/1pprb2p/4pp2/PP6/2RPP1P1/5PBP/R5K1 b - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rfd8","uci":"f8d8","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p4p1/1pprb2p/4pp2/PP6/2RPP1P1/5PBP/R5K1 w - - 1 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Raa3","uci":"a1a3","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p4p1/1pprb2p/4pp2/PP6/R1RPP1P1/5PBP/6K1 b - - 2 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Ka7","uci":"b8a7","fen_after":"3r4/kp4p1/1pprb2p/4pp2/PP6/R1RPP1P1/5PBP/6K1 w - - 3 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"3r4/kp4p1/1pprb2p/4pp2/PP6/R1RPP1PP/5PB1/6K1 b - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"23...g5","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k3r2/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/4pp2/P7/2RPP1P1/1P3PBP/R5K1 b - - 0 23","depth":25,"score_cp":-43,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k3r2/1pp5/1p1rb2p/4ppp1/P7/2RPP1P1/1P3PBP/R5K1 w - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"a5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"1k3r2/1pp5/1p1rb2p/P3ppp1/8/2RPP1P1/1P3PBP/R5K1 b - - 0 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rfd8","uci":"f8d8","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1rb2p/P3ppp1/8/2RPP1P1/1P3PBP/R5K1 w - - 1 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bf1","uci":"g2f1","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1rb2p/P3ppp1/8/2RPP1P1/1P3P1P/R4BK1 b - - 2 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bd5","uci":"e6d5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/P2bppp1/8/2RPP1P1/1P3P1P/R4BK1 w - - 3 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/P2bppp1/1P6/2RPP1P1/5P1P/R4BK1 b - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":47,"san":"24.Bf1","quality":"best","text":"24.Bf1 defends the d3 pawn with the bishop and keeps the rooks free. A solid, if passive, choice. Black has a strong reply in the bishop to d5.","best":"g2f1","script":{"say":"24.Bf1 defends the d3 pawn with the bishop and keeps the rooks free. A solid, if passive, choice. Black has a strong reply in the bishop to d5.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":126,"until":143,"brush":"green","from":"e6","to":"d5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"24.Rd1","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/4pp2/P7/2RPP1P1/1P3PBP/R5K1 w - - 1 24","depth":17,"score_cp":-67,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rd1","uci":"a1d1","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/4pp2/P7/2RPP1P1/1P3PBP/3R2K1 b - - 2 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"24.Raa3","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/4pp2/P7/2RPP1P1/1P3PBP/R5K1 w - - 1 24","depth":17,"score_cp":-71,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Raa3","uci":"a1a3","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/4pp2/P7/R1RPP1P1/1P3PBP/6K1 b - - 2 24","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"e4","uci":"e5e4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/5p2/P3p3/R1RPP1P1/1P3PBP/6K1 w - - 0 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bf1","uci":"g2f1","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/5p2/P3p3/R1RPP1P1/1P3P1P/5BK1 b - - 1 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1rb2p/5pp1/P3p3/R1RPP1P1/1P3P1P/5BK1 w - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Be2","uci":"f1e2","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1rb2p/5pp1/P3p3/R1RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/6K1 b - - 1 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"c6","uci":"c7c6","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1pprb2p/5pp1/P3p3/R1RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/6K1 w - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":48,"san":"24...Bd5","quality":"good","text":"24...Bd5 puts the bishop in the centre, on the long diagonal toward g2 and h1, right next to White's king. It is a strong post. White will bring the bishop to e2.","best":"f5f4","script":{"say":"24...Bd5 puts the bishop in the centre, on the long diagonal toward g2 and h1, right next to White's king. It is a strong post. White will bring the bishop to e2.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":43,"until":162,"brush":"green","from":"d5","to":"h1"},{"type":"arrow","at":139,"until":162,"brush":"yellow","from":"f1","to":"e2"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"24...f4","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/4pp2/P7/2RPP1P1/1P3P1P/R4BK1 b - - 2 24","depth":21,"score_cp":-65,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/4p3/P4p2/2RPP1P1/1P3P1P/R4BK1 w - - 0 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"f3","uci":"f2f3","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/4p3/P4p2/2RPPPP1/1P5P/R4BK1 b - - 0 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rf8","uci":"d8f8","fen_after":"1k3r2/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/4p3/P4p2/2RPPPP1/1P5P/R4BK1 w - - 1 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"gxf4","uci":"g3f4","fen_after":"1k3r2/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/4p3/P4P2/2RPPP2/1P5P/R4BK1 b - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"exf4","uci":"e5f4","fen_after":"1k3r2/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/8/P4p2/2RPPP2/1P5P/R4BK1 w - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"e4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"1k3r2/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/8/P3Pp2/2RP1P2/1P5P/R4BK1 b - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":null},{"ply":49,"san":"25.Be2","quality":"good","text":"25.Be2 brings the bishop to cover f3, a square on that long diagonal, and it still guards d3. White has little choice but to wait, while Black starts a pawn storm.\n\nOn the board: Counterplay with b4.","best":"b2b4","script":{"say":"25.Be2 brings the bishop to cover f3, a square on that long diagonal, and it still guards d3. White has little choice but to wait, while Black starts a pawn storm.","show":[{"title":"Counterplay with b4","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1r3p/3bpp2/P7/2RPP1P1/1P3P1P/R4BK1 w - - 3 25","depth":25,"score_cp":-24,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White could have gone for queenside play instead of waiting.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1r3p/3bpp2/PP6/2RPP1P1/5P1P/R4BK1 b - - 0 25","comment":"25.b4 pushes the b-pawn to start queenside play.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bf3","uci":"d5f3","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1r3p/4pp2/PP6/2RPPbP1/5P1P/R4BK1 w - - 1 26","comment":"25...Bf3 jumps the bishop to f3.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"b5","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1r3p/1P2pp2/P7/2RPPbP1/5P1P/R4BK1 b - - 0 26","comment":"26.b5 keeps pushing.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/1P2ppp1/P7/2RPPbP1/5P1P/R4BK1 w - - 0 27","comment":"26...g5 starts the kingside storm.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White could have gone for queenside play instead of waiting.","takeaway":"The computer prefers this active plan for White, but only by a very small margin."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":143,"until":163,"brush":"yellow","from":"g7","to":"g5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"25.b4","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1r3p/3bpp2/P7/2RPP1P1/1P3P1P/R4BK1 w - - 3 25","depth":25,"score_cp":-24,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1r3p/3bpp2/PP6/2RPP1P1/5P1P/R4BK1 b - - 0 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bf3","uci":"d5f3","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1r3p/4pp2/PP6/2RPPbP1/5P1P/R4BK1 w - - 1 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"b5","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1r3p/1P2pp2/P7/2RPPbP1/5P1P/R4BK1 b - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/1P2ppp1/P7/2RPPbP1/5P1P/R4BK1 w - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rac1","uci":"a1c1","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/1P2ppp1/P7/2RPPbP1/5P1P/2R2BK1 b - - 1 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"c5","uci":"c7c5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1p1r3p/1Pp1ppp1/P7/2RPPbP1/5P1P/2R2BK1 w - c6 0 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"25.f4","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1r3p/3bpp2/P7/2RPP1P1/1P3P1P/R4BK1 w - - 3 25","depth":25,"score_cp":-33,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"f4","uci":"f2f4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1r3p/3bpp2/P4P2/2RPP1P1/1P5P/R4BK1 b - - 0 25","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"exf4","uci":"e5f4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1r3p/3b1p2/P4p2/2RPP1P1/1P5P/R4BK1 w - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"exf4","uci":"e3f4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1r3p/3b1p2/P4P2/2RP2P1/1P5P/R4BK1 b - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"c6","uci":"c7c6","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p4p1/1ppr3p/3b1p2/P4P2/2RP2P1/1P5P/R4BK1 w - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Re1","uci":"a1e1","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p4p1/1ppr3p/3b1p2/P4P2/2RP2P1/1P5P/4RBK1 b - - 1 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bg8","uci":"d5g8","fen_after":"1k1r2b1/1p4p1/1ppr3p/5p2/P4P2/2RP2P1/1P5P/4RBK1 w - - 2 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":50,"san":"25...g5","quality":"best","text":"25...g5 begins a kingside pawn storm. Black has more space and wants to use it to create a second front with the f-pawn.","best":"g7g5","script":{"say":"25...g5 begins a kingside pawn storm. Black has more space and wants to use it to create a second front with the f-pawn.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":109,"until":120,"brush":"green","from":"f5","to":"f4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"25...f4","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1r3p/3bpp2/P7/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R5K1 b - - 4 25","depth":26,"score_cp":-20,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1r3p/3bp3/P4p2/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R5K1 w - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"e4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1r3p/3bp3/P3Pp2/2RP2P1/1P2BP1P/R5K1 b - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Be6","uci":"d5e6","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/4p3/P3Pp2/2RP2P1/1P2BP1P/R5K1 w - - 1 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"a5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1rb2p/P3p3/4Pp2/2RP2P1/1P2BP1P/R5K1 b - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1rb2p/P3p1p1/4Pp2/2RP2P1/1P2BP1P/R5K1 w - - 0 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"f3","uci":"f2f3","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1rb2p/P3p1p1/4Pp2/2RP1PP1/1P2B2P/R5K1 b - - 0 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"25...Bc6","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1p1r3p/3bpp2/P7/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R5K1 b - - 4 25","depth":26,"score_cp":-16,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bc6","uci":"d5c6","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1pbr3p/4pp2/P7/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R5K1 w - - 5 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"f3","uci":"f2f3","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1pbr3p/4pp2/P7/2RPPPP1/1P2B2P/R5K1 b - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1pbr3p/4p3/P4p2/2RPPPP1/1P2B2P/R5K1 w - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"e4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp3p1/1pbr3p/4p3/P3Pp2/2RP1PP1/1P2B2P/R5K1 b - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"g5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1pbr3p/4p1p1/P3Pp2/2RP1PP1/1P2B2P/R5K1 w - - 0 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kf2","uci":"g1f2","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1pbr3p/4p1p1/P3Pp2/2RP1PP1/1P2BK1P/R7 b - - 1 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":51,"san":"26.Kf1","quality":"good","text":"26.Kf1 brings the king toward the centre, where it can help protect the pawns and the bishop. Black's pawn keeps rolling.","best":"f2f3","script":{"say":"26.Kf1 brings the king toward the centre, where it can help protect the pawns and the bishop. Black's pawn keeps rolling.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":107,"until":121,"brush":"yellow","from":"g5","to":"g4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"26.f3","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/3bppp1/P7/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R5K1 w - - 0 26","depth":26,"score_cp":-36,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"f3","uci":"f2f3","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/3bppp1/P7/2RPPPP1/1P2B2P/R5K1 b - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/3bp1p1/P4p2/2RPPPP1/1P2B2P/R5K1 w - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"e4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/3bp1p1/P3Pp2/2RP1PP1/1P2B2P/R5K1 b - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bf7","uci":"d5f7","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp2b2/1p1r3p/4p1p1/P3Pp2/2RP1PP1/1P2B2P/R5K1 w - - 1 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"a5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp2b2/1p1r3p/P3p1p1/4Pp2/2RP1PP1/1P2B2P/R5K1 b - - 0 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rc6","uci":"d6c6","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp2b2/1pr4p/P3p1p1/4Pp2/2RP1PP1/1P2B2P/R5K1 w - - 1 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"26.b4","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/3bppp1/P7/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R5K1 w - - 0 26","depth":26,"score_cp":-50,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/3bppp1/PP6/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/R5K1 b - - 0 26","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"c6","uci":"c7c6","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr3p/3bppp1/PP6/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/R5K1 w - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"h3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr3p/3bppp1/PP6/2RPP1PP/4BP2/R5K1 b - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Ka7","uci":"b8a7","fen_after":"3r4/kp6/1ppr3p/3bppp1/PP6/2RPP1PP/4BP2/R5K1 w - - 1 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"f3","uci":"f2f3","fen_after":"3r4/kp6/1ppr3p/3bppp1/PP6/2RPPPPP/4B3/R5K1 b - - 0 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Be6","uci":"d5e6","fen_after":"3r4/kp6/1pprb2p/4ppp1/PP6/2RPPPPP/4B3/R5K1 w - - 1 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":52,"san":"26...g4","quality":"best","text":"26...g4 cramps White further, taking the f3 square away from the bishop and keeping the king's side pinned down. The king will step back to e1.\n\nOn the board: Bishop to c6 first.","best":"g5g4","script":{"say":"26...g4 cramps White further, taking the f3 square away from the bishop and keeping the king's side pinned down. The king will step back to e1.","show":[{"title":"Bishop to c6 first","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/3bppp1/P7/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R4K2 b - - 1 26","depth":25,"score_cp":-17,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black could have moved the bishop before pushing the pawn.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bc6","uci":"d5c6","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1pbr3p/4ppp1/P7/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R4K2 w - - 2 27","comment":"26...Bc6 pulls the bishop back first.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Ke1","uci":"f1e1","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1pbr3p/4ppp1/P7/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R3K3 b - - 3 27","comment":"27.Ke1 steps the king back.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1pbr3p/4p1p1/P4p2/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R3K3 w - - 0 28","comment":"27...f4 pushes the f-pawn.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1pbr3p/4p1p1/PP3p2/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/R3K3 b - - 0 28","comment":"28.b4 starts the queenside advance.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Black could have moved the bishop before pushing the pawn.","takeaway":"The computer gives Black a smaller edge here than the game's pawn push, so 26...g4 was the stronger choice."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":37,"until":143,"brush":"red","square":"f3"},{"type":"arrow","at":127,"until":143,"brush":"yellow","from":"f1","to":"e1"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"26...f4","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/3bppp1/P7/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R4K2 b - - 1 26","depth":25,"score_cp":-28,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/3bp1p1/P4p2/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R4K2 w - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/3bp1p1/PP3p2/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/R4K2 b - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"f3","uci":"f4f3","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/3bp1p1/PP6/2RPPpP1/4BP1P/R4K2 w - - 0 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bd1","uci":"e2d1","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/3bp1p1/PP6/2RPPpP1/5P1P/R2B1K2 b - - 1 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"g4","uci":"g5g4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/3bp3/PP4p1/2RPPpP1/5P1P/R2B1K2 w - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Ke1","uci":"f1e1","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/3bp3/PP4p1/2RPPpP1/5P1P/R2BK3 b - - 1 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"26...c6","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/3bppp1/P7/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R4K2 b - - 1 26","depth":25,"score_cp":-28,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"c6","uci":"c7c6","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr3p/3bppp1/P7/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R4K2 w - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"f3","uci":"f2f3","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr3p/3bppp1/P7/2RPPPP1/1P2B2P/R4K2 b - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bf7","uci":"d5f7","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p3b2/1ppr3p/4ppp1/P7/2RPPPP1/1P2B2P/R4K2 w - - 1 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"a5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p3b2/1ppr3p/P3ppp1/8/2RPPPP1/1P2B2P/R4K2 b - - 0 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"b5","uci":"b6b5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p3b2/2pr3p/Pp2ppp1/8/2RPPPP1/1P2B2P/R4K2 w - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rc5","uci":"c3c5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p3b2/2pr3p/PpR1ppp1/8/3PPPP1/1P2B2P/R4K2 b - - 1 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":53,"san":"27.Ke1","quality":"best","text":"27.Ke1 slides the king back toward the queenside, where it guards d2 and backs up the bishop. Black adds another pawn push.","best":"f1e1","script":{"say":"27.Ke1 slides the king back toward the queenside, where it guards d2 and backs up the bishop. Black adds another pawn push.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":105,"until":123,"brush":"yellow","from":"h6","to":"h5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"27.a5","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/3bpp2/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R4K2 w - - 0 27","depth":20,"score_cp":-49,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/P2bpp2/6p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R4K2 b - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"b5","uci":"b6b5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/3r3p/Pp1bpp2/6p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R4K2 w - - 0 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rc5","uci":"c3c5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/3r3p/PpRbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/1P2BP1P/R4K2 b - - 1 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"c6","uci":"c7c6","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/2pr3p/PpRbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/1P2BP1P/R4K2 w - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Ke1","uci":"f1e1","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/2pr3p/PpRbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/1P2BP1P/R3K3 b - - 1 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Ka7","uci":"b8a7","fen_after":"3r4/kp6/2pr3p/PpRbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/1P2BP1P/R3K3 w - - 2 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"27.e4","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/3bpp2/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R4K2 w - - 0 27","depth":20,"score_cp":-57,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"e4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/3bpp2/P3P1p1/2RP2P1/1P2BP1P/R4K2 b - - 0 27","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Be6","uci":"d5e6","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1rb2p/4pp2/P3P1p1/2RP2P1/1P2BP1P/R4K2 w - - 1 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"exf5","uci":"e4f5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1rb2p/4pP2/P5p1/2RP2P1/1P2BP1P/R4K2 b - - 0 28","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bxf5","uci":"e6f5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/4pb2/P5p1/2RP2P1/1P2BP1P/R4K2 w - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rc4","uci":"c3c4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/4pb2/P1R3p1/3P2P1/1P2BP1P/R4K2 b - - 1 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"h5","uci":"h6h5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r4/4pb1p/P1R3p1/3P2P1/1P2BP1P/R4K2 w - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":54,"san":"27...h5","quality":"best","text":"27...h5 brings another pawn forward. Black keeps adding space on the kingside, and White's pieces have little to do except double rooks.","best":"h6h5","script":{"say":"27...h5 brings another pawn forward. Black keeps adding space on the kingside, and White's pieces have little to do except double rooks.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":123,"until":136,"brush":"yellow","from":"a1","to":"c1"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"27...c6","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/3bpp2/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R3K3 b - - 1 27","depth":18,"score_cp":-45,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"c6","uci":"c7c6","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr3p/3bpp2/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R3K3 w - - 0 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rd1","uci":"a1d1","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr3p/3bpp2/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/3RK3 b - - 1 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Be6","uci":"d5e6","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1pprb2p/4pp2/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/3RK3 w - - 2 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"f3","uci":"f2f3","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1pprb2p/4pp2/P5p1/2RPPPP1/1P2B2P/3RK3 b - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1pprb2p/4p3/P4pp1/2RPPPP1/1P2B2P/3RK3 w - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kf2","uci":"e1f2","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1pprb2p/4p3/P4pp1/2RPPPP1/1P2BK1P/3R4 b - - 1 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"27...R8d7","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r3p/3bpp2/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R3K3 b - - 1 27","depth":18,"score_cp":-27,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"R8d7","uci":"d8d7","fen_after":"1k6/1ppr4/1p1r3p/3bpp2/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R3K3 w - - 2 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"a5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"1k6/1ppr4/1p1r3p/P2bpp2/6p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R3K3 b - - 0 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"h5","uci":"h6h5","fen_after":"1k6/1ppr4/1p1r4/P2bpp1p/6p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R3K3 w - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"e4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"1k6/1ppr4/1p1r4/P2bpp1p/4P1p1/2RP2P1/1P2BP1P/R3K3 b - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"fxe4","uci":"f5e4","fen_after":"1k6/1ppr4/1p1r4/P2bp2p/4p1p1/2RP2P1/1P2BP1P/R3K3 w - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"dxe4","uci":"d3e4","fen_after":"1k6/1ppr4/1p1r4/P2bp2p/4P1p1/2R3P1/1P2BP1P/R3K3 b - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":55,"san":"28.Rac1","quality":"good","text":"28.Rac1 doubles the rooks on the c-file. White wants to use the c-file as the one source of counterplay, and Black closes it.\n\nOn the board: Pushing the a-pawn.","best":"a4a5","script":{"say":"28.Rac1 doubles the rooks on the c-file. White wants to use the c-file as the one source of counterplay, and Black closes it.","show":[{"title":"Pushing the a-pawn","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r4/3bpp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R3K3 w - - 0 28","depth":22,"score_cp":-38,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White could have hit the b6 pawn at once.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r4/P2bpp1p/6p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R3K3 b - - 0 28","comment":"28.a5 attacks the b6 pawn.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r4/P2bp2p/5pp1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R3K3 w - - 0 29","comment":"28...f4 pushes on in the centre.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"gxf4","uci":"g3f4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r4/P2bp2p/5Pp1/2RPP3/1P2BP1P/R3K3 b - - 0 29","comment":"29.gxf4 takes the pawn.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"exf4","uci":"e5f4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r4/P2b3p/5pp1/2RPP3/1P2BP1P/R3K3 w - - 0 30","comment":"29...exf4 recaptures.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r4/P2b3p/1P3pp1/2RPP3/4BP1P/R3K3 b - - 0 30","comment":"30.b4 keeps the queenside pawns rolling.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White could have hit the b6 pawn at once.","takeaway":"The computer prefers this to the rook doubling, so Rapport's move was slightly less accurate."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":39,"until":125,"brush":"red","from":"c3","to":"c7"},{"type":"arrow","at":115,"until":125,"brush":"yellow","from":"c7","to":"c6"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"28.a5","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r4/3bpp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R3K3 w - - 0 28","depth":22,"score_cp":-38,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r4/P2bpp1p/6p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R3K3 b - - 0 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r4/P2bp2p/5pp1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R3K3 w - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"gxf4","uci":"g3f4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r4/P2bp2p/5Pp1/2RPP3/1P2BP1P/R3K3 b - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"exf4","uci":"e5f4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r4/P2b3p/5pp1/2RPP3/1P2BP1P/R3K3 w - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r4/P2b3p/1P3pp1/2RPP3/4BP1P/R3K3 b - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"bxa5","uci":"b6a5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/3r4/p2b3p/1P3pp1/2RPP3/4BP1P/R3K3 w - - 0 31","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"28.b4","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r4/3bpp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R3K3 w - - 0 28","depth":22,"score_cp":-47,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r4/3bpp1p/PP4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/R3K3 b - - 0 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"c6","uci":"c7c6","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp1p/PP4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/R3K3 w - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"a5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr4/P2bpp1p/1P4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/R3K3 b - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"b5","uci":"b6b5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/2pr4/Pp1bpp1p/1P4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/R3K3 w - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rc5","uci":"c3c5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/2pr4/PpRbpp1p/1P4p1/3PP1P1/4BP1P/R3K3 b - - 1 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"e4","uci":"e5e4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/2pr4/PpRb1p1p/1P2p1p1/3PP1P1/4BP1P/R3K3 w - - 0 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"28.Kd2","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r4/3bpp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/R3K3 w - - 0 28","depth":22,"score_cp":-58,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Kd2","uci":"e1d2","fen_after":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r4/3bpp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P1KBP1P/R7 b - - 1 28","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"c6","uci":"c7c6","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P1KBP1P/R7 w - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Re1","uci":"a1e1","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P1KBP1P/4R3 b - - 1 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kc7","uci":"b8c7","fen_after":"3r4/1pk5/1ppr4/3bpp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P1KBP1P/4R3 w - - 2 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kc1","uci":"d2c1","fen_after":"3r4/1pk5/1ppr4/3bpp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/2K1R3 b - - 3 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Be6","uci":"d5e6","fen_after":"3r4/1pk5/1pprb3/4pp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/2K1R3 w - - 4 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":null},{"ply":56,"san":"28...c6","quality":"best","text":"28...c6 backs up the bishop on d5 with a pawn, so the doubled rooks find little to hit on the c-file. White's reply is the b-pawn.","best":"c7c6","script":{"say":"28...c6 backs up the bishop on d5 with a pawn, so the doubled rooks find little to hit on the c-file. White's reply is the b-pawn.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":119,"until":130,"brush":"yellow","from":"b2","to":"b4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"28...R6d7","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r4/3bpp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 1 28","depth":20,"score_cp":-59,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"R6d7","uci":"d6d7","fen_after":"1k1r4/1ppr4/1p6/3bpp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 2 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1ppr4/1p6/3bpp1p/PP4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"c6","uci":"c7c6","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p1r4/1pp5/3bpp1p/PP4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"b5","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p1r4/1pp5/1P1bpp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kc7","uci":"b8c7","fen_after":"3r4/1pkr4/1pp5/1P1bpp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 1 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"bxc6","uci":"b5c6","fen_after":"3r4/1pkr4/1pP5/3bpp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 0 31","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"28...R8d7","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1pp5/1p1r4/3bpp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 1 28","depth":20,"score_cp":-47,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"R8d7","uci":"d8d7","fen_after":"1k6/1ppr4/1p1r4/3bpp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 2 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"1k6/1ppr4/1p1r4/3bpp1p/PP4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 0 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"c6","uci":"c7c6","fen_after":"1k6/1p1r4/1ppr4/3bpp1p/PP4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"b5","uci":"b4b5","fen_after":"1k6/1p1r4/1ppr4/1P1bpp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rd8","uci":"d7d8","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr4/1P1bpp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 1 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"bxc6","uci":"b5c6","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1pPr4/3bpp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 0 31","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":57,"san":"29.b4","quality":"best","text":"29.b4 pushes on with the queenside pawns, trying to open lines against Black's king. Black will bring a rook to the h-file.","best":"b2b4","script":{"say":"29.b4 pushes on with the queenside pawns, trying to open lines against Black's king. Black will bring a rook to the h-file.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":96,"until":123,"brush":"yellow","from":"d8","to":"h8"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"29.Kd2","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 0 29","depth":22,"score_cp":-73,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Kd2","uci":"e1d2","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P1KBP1P/2R5 b - - 1 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr4/3bp2p/P4pp1/2RPP1P1/1P1KBP1P/2R5 w - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr4/3bp2p/PP3pp1/2RPP1P1/3KBP1P/2R5 b - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Be4","uci":"d5e4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr4/4p2p/PP2bpp1/2RPP1P1/3KBP1P/2R5 w - - 1 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"gxf4","uci":"g3f4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr4/4p2p/PP2bPp1/2RPP3/3KBP1P/2R5 b - - 0 31","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"exf4","uci":"e5f4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr4/7p/PP2bpp1/2RPP3/3KBP1P/2R5 w - - 0 32","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"29.Bd1","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P2BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 0 29","depth":22,"score_cp":-81,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bd1","uci":"e2d1","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp1p/P5p1/2RPP1P1/1P3P1P/2RBK3 b - - 1 29","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr4/3bp2p/P4pp1/2RPP1P1/1P3P1P/2RBK3 w - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"b4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr4/3bp2p/PP3pp1/2RPP1P1/5P1P/2RBK3 b - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bf7","uci":"d5f7","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p3b2/1ppr4/4p2p/PP3pp1/2RPP1P1/5P1P/2RBK3 w - - 1 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kd2","uci":"e1d2","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p3b2/1ppr4/4p2p/PP3pp1/2RPP1P1/3K1P1P/2RB4 b - - 2 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rf6","uci":"d6f6","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p3b2/1pp2r2/4p2p/PP3pp1/2RPP1P1/3K1P1P/2RB4 w - - 3 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":58,"san":"29...Rh8","quality":"good","text":"29...Rh8 slides the rook to the h-file, ready to back up the h-pawn's march on the kingside. Black is clearly the one setting the pace now, while White's a-pawn push is next.\n\nOn the board: Rook to h6.","best":"d6h6","script":{"say":"29...Rh8 slides the rook to the h-file, ready to back up the h-pawn's march on the kingside. Black is clearly the one setting the pace now, while White's a-pawn push is next.","show":[{"title":"Rook to h6","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp1p/PP4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 0 29","depth":21,"score_cp":-62,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black could have lifted the rook along the sixth rank instead.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rh6","uci":"d6h6","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1pp4r/3bpp1p/PP4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 1 30","comment":"29...Rh6 swings the rook over to the h-file.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kd2","uci":"e1d2","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1pp4r/3bpp1p/PP4p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP1P/2R5 b - - 2 30","comment":"30.Kd2 steps the king toward the queenside.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"h4","uci":"h5h4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1pp4r/3bpp2/PP4pp/2RPP1P1/3KBP1P/2R5 w - - 0 31","comment":"30...h4 pushes the h-pawn.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rf1","uci":"c1f1","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1pp4r/3bpp2/PP4pp/2RPP1P1/3KBP1P/5R2 b - - 1 31","comment":"31.Rf1 swings a rook over to f1.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Black could have lifted the rook along the sixth rank instead.","takeaway":"The computer rates this the same as the game move, so both rook moves work."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":57,"until":174,"brush":"blue","from":"h5","to":"h4"},{"type":"arrow","at":154,"until":174,"brush":"yellow","from":"a4","to":"a5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"29...Rh6","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp1p/PP4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 0 29","depth":21,"score_cp":-62,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rh6","uci":"d6h6","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1pp4r/3bpp1p/PP4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 1 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kd2","uci":"e1d2","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1pp4r/3bpp1p/PP4p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP1P/2R5 b - - 2 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"h4","uci":"h5h4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1pp4r/3bpp2/PP4pp/2RPP1P1/3KBP1P/2R5 w - - 0 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rf1","uci":"c1f1","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1pp4r/3bpp2/PP4pp/2RPP1P1/3KBP1P/5R2 b - - 1 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"hxg3","uci":"h4g3","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1pp4r/3bpp2/PP4p1/2RPP1p1/3KBP1P/5R2 w - - 0 32","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"hxg3","uci":"h2g3","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1pp4r/3bpp2/PP4p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP2/5R2 b - - 0 32","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"29...f4","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp1p/PP4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 0 29","depth":21,"score_cp":-51,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr4/3bp2p/PP3pp1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"gxf4","uci":"g3f4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr4/3bp2p/PP3Pp1/2RPP3/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 0 30","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"exf4","uci":"e5f4","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr4/3b3p/PP3pp1/2RPP3/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 0 31","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"a5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/1ppr4/P2b3p/1P3pp1/2RPP3/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 0 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"b5","uci":"b6b5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/2pr4/Pp1b3p/1P3pp1/2RPP3/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 0 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rc5","uci":"c3c5","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/2pr4/PpRb3p/1P3pp1/3PP3/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 1 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":59,"san":"30.a5","quality":"good","text":"30.a5 attacks the b6 pawn and tries to open the queenside, continuing White's plan. Black will take it.","best":"e1d2","script":{"say":"30.a5 attacks the b6 pawn and tries to open the queenside, continuing White's plan. Black will take it.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":95,"until":103,"brush":"red","from":"b6","to":"a5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"30.Kd2","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k5r/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp1p/PP4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 1 30","depth":25,"score_cp":-38,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Kd2","uci":"e1d2","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp1p/PP4p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP1P/2R5 b - - 2 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"h4","uci":"h5h4","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp2/PP4pp/2RPP1P1/3KBP1P/2R5 w - - 0 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rf1","uci":"c1f1","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp2/PP4pp/2RPP1P1/3KBP1P/5R2 b - - 1 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"hxg3","uci":"h4g3","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp2/PP4p1/2RPP1p1/3KBP1P/5R2 w - - 0 32","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"hxg3","uci":"h2g3","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp2/PP4p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP2/5R2 b - - 0 32","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rh2","uci":"h8h2","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp2/PP4p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 w - - 1 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"30.Rd1","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k5r/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp1p/PP4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 1 30","depth":25,"score_cp":-56,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rd1","uci":"c1d1","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp1p/PP4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/3RK3 b - - 2 30","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"h4","uci":"h5h4","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp2/PP4pp/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/3RK3 w - - 0 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Kd2","uci":"e1d2","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp2/PP4pp/2RPP1P1/3KBP1P/3R4 b - - 1 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"hxg3","uci":"h4g3","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp2/PP4p1/2RPP1p1/3KBP1P/3R4 w - - 0 32","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"hxg3","uci":"h2g3","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp2/PP4p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP2/3R4 b - - 0 32","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rh2","uci":"h8h2","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/1ppr4/3bpp2/PP4p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP1r/3R4 w - - 1 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":60,"san":"30...bxa5","quality":"good","text":"30...bxa5 takes the pawn. Once White takes back, the b-file opens up for White's rooks, with the b7 pawn as the target. Both sides have something to play for.\n\nOn the board: Stepping the king aside.","best":"b6b5","script":{"say":"30...bxa5 takes the pawn. Once White takes back, the b-file opens up for White's rooks, with the b7 pawn as the target. Both sides have something to play for.","show":[{"title":"Stepping the king aside","line":{"fen":"1k5r/1p6/1ppr4/P2bpp1p/1P4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 0 30","depth":21,"score_cp":-55,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black could have moved the king instead of taking the pawn.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Ka7","uci":"b8a7","fen_after":"7r/kp6/1ppr4/P2bpp1p/1P4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 1 31","comment":"30...Ka7 steps the king to a7.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"axb6+","uci":"a5b6","fen_after":"7r/kp6/1Ppr4/3bpp1p/1P4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 0 31","comment":"31.axb6+ takes the pawn with check.","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Kxb6","uci":"a7b6","fen_after":"7r/1p6/1kpr4/3bpp1p/1P4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 0 32","comment":"31...Kxb6 takes the pawn back.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Ra3","uci":"c3a3","fen_after":"7r/1p6/1kpr4/3bpp1p/1P4p1/R2PP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 1 32","comment":"32.Ra3 puts a rook on the a-file.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Black could have moved the king instead of taking the pawn.","takeaway":"The computer gives Black a little less here than the pawn capture, so taking on a5 was right."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":118,"until":158,"brush":"yellow","from":"b4","to":"a5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"30...b5","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k5r/1p6/1ppr4/P2bpp1p/1P4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 0 30","depth":21,"score_cp":-70,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"b5","uci":"b6b5","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/Pp1bpp1p/1P4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 0 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rc5","uci":"c3c5","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/PpRbpp1p/1P4p1/3PP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 1 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"h4","uci":"h5h4","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/PpRbpp2/1P4pp/3PP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 0 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kd2","uci":"e1d2","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/PpRbpp2/1P4pp/3PP1P1/3KBP1P/2R5 b - - 1 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"e4","uci":"e5e4","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/PpRb1p2/1P2p1pp/3PP1P1/3KBP1P/2R5 w - - 0 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"d4","uci":"d3d4","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/PpRb1p2/1P1Pp1pp/4P1P1/3KBP1P/2R5 b - - 0 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"30...Ka7","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k5r/1p6/1ppr4/P2bpp1p/1P4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 0 30","depth":21,"score_cp":-55,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Ka7","uci":"b8a7","fen_after":"7r/kp6/1ppr4/P2bpp1p/1P4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 1 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"axb6+","uci":"a5b6","fen_after":"7r/kp6/1Ppr4/3bpp1p/1P4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 0 31","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Kxb6","uci":"a7b6","fen_after":"7r/1p6/1kpr4/3bpp1p/1P4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 0 32","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Ra3","uci":"c3a3","fen_after":"7r/1p6/1kpr4/3bpp1p/1P4p1/R2PP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 1 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"h4","uci":"h5h4","fen_after":"7r/1p6/1kpr4/3bpp2/1P4pp/R2PP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 0 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kd2","uci":"e1d2","fen_after":"7r/1p6/1kpr4/3bpp2/1P4pp/R2PP1P1/3KBP1P/2R5 b - - 1 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":3},{"ply":61,"san":"31.bxa5","quality":"only move","text":"31.bxa5 is the only move. Anything else lets Black's a-pawn run, and Black would be clearly better. With the recapture, White keeps the balance, but Black has a plan: the h-pawn push.","best":"b4a5","script":{"say":"31.bxa5 is the only move. Anything else lets Black's a-pawn run, and Black would be clearly better. With the recapture, White keeps the balance, but Black has a plan: the h-pawn push.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":167,"until":183,"brush":"yellow","from":"h5","to":"h4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"31.Rb1","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/p2bpp1p/1P4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 0 31","depth":19,"score_cp":-251,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rb1","uci":"c1b1","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/p2bpp1p/1P4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/1R2K3 b - - 1 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"a4","uci":"a5a4","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/3bpp1p/pP4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/1R2K3 w - - 0 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"31.R3c2","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/p2bpp1p/1P4p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 0 31","depth":19,"score_cp":-312,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"R3c2","uci":"c3c2","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/p2bpp1p/1P4p1/3PP1P1/2R1BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 1 31","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"a4","uci":"a5a4","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/3bpp1p/pP4p1/3PP1P1/2R1BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 0 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Kd2","uci":"e1d2","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/3bpp1p/pP4p1/3PP1P1/2RKBP1P/2R5 b - - 1 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"h4","uci":"h5h4","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/3bpp2/pP4pp/3PP1P1/2RKBP1P/2R5 w - - 0 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Ra1","uci":"c1a1","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/3bpp2/pP4pp/3PP1P1/2RKBP1P/R7 b - - 1 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"b5","uci":"b7b5","fen_after":"1k5r/8/2pr4/1p1bpp2/pP4pp/3PP1P1/2RKBP1P/R7 w - - 0 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":62,"san":"31...h4","quality":"good","text":"31...h4 keeps up the pressure on the king's side. Caruana wants to open the h-file for his rook, and the pawn now threatens to take on g3. White's rook is looking at c5.\n\nOn the board: Pulling the rook back first.","best":"d6d8","script":{"say":"31...h4 keeps up the pressure on the king's side. Caruana wants to open the h-file for his rook, and the pawn now threatens to take on g3. White's rook is looking at c5.","show":[{"title":"Pulling the rook back first","line":{"fen":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp1p/6p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 0 31","depth":20,"score_cp":-26,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black could have tidied the rooks before pushing the pawn.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rdd8","uci":"d6d8","fen_after":"1k1r3r/1p6/2p5/P2bpp1p/6p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 1 32","comment":"31...Rdd8 retreats the rook on d6 to the back rank.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rb1","uci":"c1b1","fen_after":"1k1r3r/1p6/2p5/P2bpp1p/6p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/1R2K3 b - - 2 32","comment":"32.Rb1 puts a rook on the b-file.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"h4","uci":"h5h4","fen_after":"1k1r3r/1p6/2p5/P2bpp2/6pp/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/1R2K3 w - - 0 33","comment":"32...h4 now pushes the pawn.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kd2","uci":"e1d2","fen_after":"1k1r3r/1p6/2p5/P2bpp2/6pp/2RPP1P1/3KBP1P/1R6 b - - 1 33","comment":"33.Kd2 steps the king off the first rank.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Black could have tidied the rooks before pushing the pawn.","takeaway":"The computer rates this exactly the same as the game move, so both are fine."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":114,"until":169,"brush":"red","from":"h4","to":"g3"},{"type":"arrow","at":166,"until":169,"brush":"yellow","from":"c3","to":"c5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"31...Rdd8","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp1p/6p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 0 31","depth":20,"score_cp":-26,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rdd8","uci":"d6d8","fen_after":"1k1r3r/1p6/2p5/P2bpp1p/6p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 1 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rb1","uci":"c1b1","fen_after":"1k1r3r/1p6/2p5/P2bpp1p/6p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/1R2K3 b - - 2 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"h4","uci":"h5h4","fen_after":"1k1r3r/1p6/2p5/P2bpp2/6pp/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/1R2K3 w - - 0 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kd2","uci":"e1d2","fen_after":"1k1r3r/1p6/2p5/P2bpp2/6pp/2RPP1P1/3KBP1P/1R6 b - - 1 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kc7","uci":"b8c7","fen_after":"3r3r/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/6pp/2RPP1P1/3KBP1P/1R6 w - - 2 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Ra3","uci":"c3a3","fen_after":"3r3r/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/6pp/R2PP1P1/3KBP1P/1R6 b - - 3 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"31...Ka7","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp1p/6p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 0 31","depth":20,"score_cp":-24,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Ka7","uci":"b8a7","fen_after":"7r/kp6/2pr4/P2bpp1p/6p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 1 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kd2","uci":"e1d2","fen_after":"7r/kp6/2pr4/P2bpp1p/6p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP1P/2R5 b - - 2 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"h4","uci":"h5h4","fen_after":"7r/kp6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6pp/2RPP1P1/3KBP1P/2R5 w - - 0 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rc5","uci":"c3c5","fen_after":"7r/kp6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6pp/3PP1P1/3KBP1P/2R5 b - - 1 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rf6","uci":"d6f6","fen_after":"7r/kp6/2p2r2/P1Rbpp2/6pp/3PP1P1/3KBP1P/2R5 w - - 2 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kc3","uci":"d2c3","fen_after":"7r/kp6/2p2r2/P1Rbpp2/6pp/2KPP1P1/4BP1P/2R5 b - - 3 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":63,"san":"32.Rc5","quality":"inaccuracy","text":"Here Rapport slips. He had a calm 32.Kd2, bringing the king toward the centre where it is safe. Instead 32.Rc5 gets the rook out but does nothing about the h-pawn, which can now take on g3 and open the h-file for Black's rook.\n\nOn the board: The calm king move.","best":"e1d2","script":{"say":"Here Rapport slips. He had a calm 32.Kd2, bringing the king toward the centre where it is safe. Instead 32.Rc5 gets the rook out but does nothing about the h-pawn, which can now take on g3 and open the h-file for Black's rook.","show":[{"title":"The calm king move","line":{"fen":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6pp/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 0 32","depth":20,"score_cp":-45,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White could simply have tucked the king away on d2 and kept everything defended.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Kd2","uci":"e1d2","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6pp/2RPP1P1/3KBP1P/2R5 b - - 1 32","comment":"32.Kd2 gets the king off the first rank and away from checks.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"hxg3","uci":"h4g3","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6p1/2RPP1p1/3KBP1P/2R5 w - - 0 33","comment":"32...hxg3 opens the h-file for the rook.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"hxg3","uci":"h2g3","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP2/2R5 b - - 0 33","comment":"33.hxg3 recaptures and keeps the pawns together.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rh2","uci":"h8h2","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP1r/2R5 w - - 1 34","comment":"33...Rh2 invades along the second rank.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White could simply have tucked the king away on d2 and kept everything defended.","takeaway":"With the king already safe, Black's invasion has far less bite, and the game stays close to level."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":156,"until":226,"brush":"red","square":"h4"},{"type":"arrow","at":178,"until":226,"brush":"red","from":"h4","to":"g3"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"32.Kd2","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6pp/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 0 32","depth":20,"score_cp":-45,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Kd2","uci":"e1d2","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6pp/2RPP1P1/3KBP1P/2R5 b - - 1 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"hxg3","uci":"h4g3","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6p1/2RPP1p1/3KBP1P/2R5 w - - 0 33","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"hxg3","uci":"h2g3","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP2/2R5 b - - 0 33","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rh2","uci":"h8h2","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP1r/2R5 w - - 1 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rf1","uci":"c1f1","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 b - - 2 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rd8","uci":"d6d8","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/2p5/P2bpp2/6p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 w - - 3 35","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"32.Rd1","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6pp/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 0 32","depth":20,"score_cp":-105,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rd1","uci":"c1d1","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6pp/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/3RK3 b - - 1 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"hxg3","uci":"h4g3","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6p1/2RPP1p1/4BP1P/3RK3 w - - 0 33","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"hxg3","uci":"h2g3","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6p1/2RPP1P1/4BP2/3RK3 b - - 0 33","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rh2","uci":"h8h2","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6p1/2RPP1P1/4BP1r/3RK3 w - - 1 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"e4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/4P1p1/2RP2P1/4BP1r/3RK3 b - - 0 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rh1+","uci":"h2h1","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/4P1p1/2RP2P1/4BP2/3RK2r w - - 1 35","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"32.R3c2","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6pp/2RPP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 0 32","depth":20,"score_cp":-148,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"R3c2","uci":"c3c2","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6pp/3PP1P1/2R1BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 1 32","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"hxg3","uci":"h4g3","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6p1/3PP1p1/2R1BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 0 33","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"hxg3","uci":"h2g3","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/2R1BP2/2R1K3 b - - 0 33","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rh2","uci":"h8h2","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/2R1BP1r/2R1K3 w - - 1 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rb2","uci":"c2b2","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/1R2BP1r/2R1K3 b - - 2 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Ka7","uci":"b8a7","fen_after":"8/kp6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/1R2BP1r/2R1K3 w - - 3 35","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":null},{"ply":64,"san":"32...hxg3","quality":"best","text":"32...hxg3 opens the h-file at once. Caruana follows the plan: trade the pawn, then put a rook on the second rank. White has to take back.","best":"h4g3","script":{"say":"32...hxg3 opens the h-file at once. Caruana follows the plan: trade the pawn, then put a rook on the second rank. White has to take back.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":34,"until":137,"brush":"green","from":"h8","to":"h2"},{"type":"arrow","at":127,"until":137,"brush":"green","from":"h2","to":"g3"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"32...Rf6","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6pp/3PP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 1 32","depth":27,"score_cp":-53,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rf6","uci":"d6f6","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2p2r2/P1Rbpp2/6pp/3PP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 2 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kd2","uci":"e1d2","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2p2r2/P1Rbpp2/6pp/3PP1P1/3KBP1P/2R5 b - - 3 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"hxg3","uci":"h4g3","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2p2r2/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1p1/3KBP1P/2R5 w - - 0 34","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"hxg3","uci":"h2g3","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2p2r2/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP2/2R5 b - - 0 34","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rh2","uci":"h8h2","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2p2r2/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/2R5 w - - 1 35","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rf1","uci":"c1f1","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2p2r2/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 b - - 2 35","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"32...Rdd8","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6pp/3PP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 b - - 1 32","depth":27,"score_cp":-52,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rdd8","uci":"d6d8","fen_after":"1k1r3r/1p6/2p5/P1Rbpp2/6pp/3PP1P1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 2 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kd2","uci":"e1d2","fen_after":"1k1r3r/1p6/2p5/P1Rbpp2/6pp/3PP1P1/3KBP1P/2R5 b - - 3 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"hxg3","uci":"h4g3","fen_after":"1k1r3r/1p6/2p5/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1p1/3KBP1P/2R5 w - - 0 34","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"hxg3","uci":"h2g3","fen_after":"1k1r3r/1p6/2p5/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP2/2R5 b - - 0 34","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rh2","uci":"h8h2","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/2p5/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/2R5 w - - 1 35","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rf1","uci":"c1f1","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/2p5/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 b - - 2 35","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":65,"san":"33.hxg3","quality":"only move","text":"33.hxg3 is the only move here. Any other recapture lets Black's pawn run, and the position collapses quickly. The whole h-file is open now, and the rook on h8 wants it.","best":"h2g3","script":{"say":"33.hxg3 is the only move here. Any other recapture lets Black's pawn run, and the position collapses quickly. The whole h-file is open now, and the rook on h8 wants it.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":120,"until":168,"brush":"green","from":"h8","to":"h1"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"33.fxg3","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1p1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 0 33","depth":18,"score_cp":-334,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"fxg3","uci":"f2g3","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/4B2P/2R1K3 b - - 0 33","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxh2","uci":"h8h2","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/4B2r/2R1K3 w - - 0 34","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"e4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/4P1p1/3P2P1/4B2r/2R1K3 b - - 0 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"fxe4","uci":"f5e4","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbp3/4p1p1/3P2P1/4B2r/2R1K3 w - - 0 35","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"dxe4","uci":"d3e4","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbp3/4P1p1/6P1/4B2r/2R1K3 b - - 0 35","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bxe4","uci":"d5e4","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1R1p3/4b1p1/6P1/4B2r/2R1K3 w - - 0 36","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"33.h4","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1p1/4BP1P/2R1K3 w - - 0 33","depth":18,"score_cp":-503,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"h4","uci":"h2h4","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6pP/3PP1p1/4BP2/2R1K3 b - h3 0 33","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"gxh3","uci":"g4h3","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/8/3PP1pp/4BP2/2R1K3 w - - 0 34","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"fxg3","uci":"f2g3","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/8/3PP1Pp/4B3/2R1K3 b - - 0 34","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"h2","uci":"h3h2","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/8/3PP1P1/4B2p/2R1K3 w - - 0 35","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kf2","uci":"e1f2","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/8/3PP1P1/4BK1p/2R5 b - - 1 35","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"h1=Q","uci":"h2h1q","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/8/3PP1P1/4BK2/2R4q w - - 0 36","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":66,"san":"33...Rh1+","quality":"inaccuracy","text":"A surprise. Caruana plays 33...Rh1+, a check that looks natural but gives away much of his advantage. The quiet 33...Rh2 was much stronger, putting the rook on the second rank and keeping White tied down. Now the king must step aside.\n\nOn the board: Straight to the second rank.","best":"h8h2","script":{"say":"A surprise. Caruana plays 33...Rh1+, a check that looks natural but gives away much of his advantage. The quiet 33...Rh2 was much stronger, putting the rook on the second rank and keeping White tied down. Now the king must step aside.","show":[{"title":"Straight to the second rank","line":{"fen":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/4BP2/2R1K3 b - - 0 33","depth":20,"score_cp":-188,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Instead of checking, Black could have invaded at once and kept the advantage.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rh2","uci":"h8h2","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/4BP1r/2R1K3 w - - 1 34","comment":"33...Rh2 puts the rook on the second rank, hitting f2.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"R5c2","uci":"c5c2","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/2R1BP1r/2R1K3 b - - 2 34","comment":"34.R5c2 brings the rook back to cover the second rank.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rdh6","uci":"d6h6","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2p4r/P2bpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/2R1BP1r/2R1K3 w - - 3 35","comment":"34...Rdh6 doubles the rooks on the h-file and piles up the pressure.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rb2","uci":"c2b2","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2p4r/P2bpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/1R2BP1r/2R1K3 b - - 4 35","comment":"35.Rb2 shifts the other rook along the second rank, but White is passive.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Instead of checking, Black could have invaded at once and kept the advantage.","takeaway":"That keeps Black clearly better, while the check lets White's king step out of trouble."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":112,"until":234,"brush":"yellow","square":"h2"},{"type":"arrow","at":223,"until":234,"brush":"yellow","from":"e1","to":"d2"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"33...Rh2","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/4BP2/2R1K3 b - - 0 33","depth":20,"score_cp":-188,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rh2","uci":"h8h2","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/4BP1r/2R1K3 w - - 1 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"R5c2","uci":"c5c2","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P2bpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/2R1BP1r/2R1K3 b - - 2 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rdh6","uci":"d6h6","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2p4r/P2bpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/2R1BP1r/2R1K3 w - - 3 35","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rb2","uci":"c2b2","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2p4r/P2bpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/1R2BP1r/2R1K3 b - - 4 35","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Ka7","uci":"b8a7","fen_after":"8/kp6/2p4r/P2bpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/1R2BP1r/2R1K3 w - - 5 36","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"e4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"8/kp6/2p4r/P2bpp2/4P1p1/3P2P1/1R2BP1r/2R1K3 b - - 0 36","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"33...Rf6","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/4BP2/2R1K3 b - - 0 33","depth":20,"score_cp":-49,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rf6","uci":"d6f6","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2p2r2/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/4BP2/2R1K3 w - - 1 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kd2","uci":"e1d2","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2p2r2/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP2/2R5 b - - 2 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rh2","uci":"h8h2","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2p2r2/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/2R5 w - - 3 35","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rf1","uci":"c1f1","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2p2r2/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 b - - 4 35","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rf8","uci":"f6f8","fen_after":"1k3r2/1p6/2p5/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 w - - 5 36","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rc3","uci":"c5c3","fen_after":"1k3r2/1p6/2p5/P2bpp2/6p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 b - - 6 36","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"33...Rdd8","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/4BP2/2R1K3 b - - 0 33","depth":20,"score_cp":-45,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rdd8","uci":"d6d8","fen_after":"1k1r3r/1p6/2p5/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/4BP2/2R1K3 w - - 1 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kd2","uci":"e1d2","fen_after":"1k1r3r/1p6/2p5/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP2/2R5 b - - 2 34","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rh2","uci":"h8h2","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/2p5/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/2R5 w - - 3 35","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rf1","uci":"c1f1","fen_after":"1k1r4/1p6/2p5/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 b - - 4 35","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kc7","uci":"b8c7","fen_after":"3r4/1pk5/2p5/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 w - - 5 36","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rc3","uci":"c5c3","fen_after":"3r4/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/6p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 b - - 6 36","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":null},{"ply":67,"san":"34.Kd2","quality":"best","text":"34.Kd2 simply walks out of the check and heads toward the centre, next to the second rank. Black's rook will drop back to h2.","best":"e1d2","script":{"say":"34.Kd2 simply walks out of the check and heads toward the centre, next to the second rank. Black's rook will drop back to h2.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":119,"until":125,"brush":"yellow","from":"h1","to":"h2"}]},"alternatives":[],"playedRank":1},{"ply":68,"san":"34...Rh2","quality":"good","text":"34...Rh2 lands on the second rank anyway and pressures f2. Black regains most of the initiative, and White's rook will come to defend.\n\nOn the board: Pulling the rook back.","best":"h1h5","script":{"say":"34...Rh2 lands on the second rank anyway and pressures f2. Black regains most of the initiative, and White's rook will come to defend.","show":[{"title":"Pulling the rook back","line":{"fen":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP2/2R4r b - - 2 34","depth":20,"score_cp":-6,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black had a way to keep more pieces in the game, but it gives White an easy path.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rh8","uci":"h1h8","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP2/2R5 w - - 3 35","comment":"34...Rh8 pulls the rook all the way back.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"e4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/4P1p1/3P2P1/3KBP2/2R5 b - - 0 35","comment":"35.e4 hits the bishop on d5.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"fxe4","uci":"f5e4","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbp3/4p1p1/3P2P1/3KBP2/2R5 w - - 0 36","comment":"35...fxe4 takes the pawn.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"dxe4","uci":"d3e4","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbp3/4P1p1/6P1/3KBP2/2R5 b - - 0 36","comment":"36.dxe4 recaptures.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bxe4+","uci":"d5e4","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1R1p3/4b1p1/6P1/3KBP2/2R5 w - - 0 37","comment":"36...Bxe4+ takes the pawn with check.","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Black had a way to keep more pieces in the game, but it gives White an easy path.","takeaway":"The computer says this leaves the game level, so the rook to h2 was much stronger."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":55,"until":134,"brush":"red","from":"h2","to":"f2"},{"type":"arrow","at":119,"until":134,"brush":"green","from":"c1","to":"f1"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"34...Rh5","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP2/2R4r b - - 2 34","depth":20,"score_cp":-19,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rh5","uci":"h1h5","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp1r/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP2/2R5 w - - 3 35","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kc3","uci":"d2c3","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp1r/6p1/2KPP1P1/4BP2/2R5 b - - 4 35","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Kc7","uci":"b8c7","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P1Rbpp1r/6p1/2KPP1P1/4BP2/2R5 w - - 5 36","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Re1","uci":"c1e1","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P1Rbpp1r/6p1/2KPP1P1/4BP2/4R3 b - - 6 36","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rh2","uci":"h5h2","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/2KPP1P1/4BP1r/4R3 w - - 7 37","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rf1","uci":"e1f1","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/2KPP1P1/4BP1r/5R2 b - - 8 37","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"34...Rh8","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP2/2R4r b - - 2 34","depth":20,"score_cp":-6,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rh8","uci":"h1h8","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP2/2R5 w - - 3 35","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"e4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/4P1p1/3P2P1/3KBP2/2R5 b - - 0 35","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"fxe4","uci":"f5e4","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbp3/4p1p1/3P2P1/3KBP2/2R5 w - - 0 36","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"dxe4","uci":"d3e4","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbp3/4P1p1/6P1/3KBP2/2R5 b - - 0 36","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bxe4+","uci":"d5e4","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1R1p3/4b1p1/6P1/3KBP2/2R5 w - - 0 37","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Ke3","uci":"d2e3","fen_after":"1k5r/1p6/2pr4/P1R1p3/4b1p1/4K1P1/4BP2/2R5 b - - 1 37","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":69,"san":"35.Rf1","quality":"best","text":"35.Rf1 defends the f2 pawn and offers some relief. It was the only sensible way to keep the position together, and now Black can improve the king with Kc7.","best":"c1f1","script":{"say":"35.Rf1 defends the f2 pawn and offers some relief. It was the only sensible way to keep the position together, and now Black can improve the king with Kc7.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":151,"until":155,"brush":"yellow","from":"b8","to":"c7"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"35.Ke1","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/2R5 w - - 3 35","depth":20,"score_cp":-229,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Ke1","uci":"d2e1","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/4BP1r/2R1K3 b - - 4 35","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Ka7","uci":"b8a7","fen_after":"8/kp6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/4BP1r/2R1K3 w - - 5 36","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rd1","uci":"c1d1","fen_after":"8/kp6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/4BP1r/3RK3 b - - 6 36","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rd8","uci":"d6d8","fen_after":"3r4/kp6/2p5/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/4BP1r/3RK3 w - - 7 37","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rdc1","uci":"d1c1","fen_after":"3r4/kp6/2p5/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/4BP1r/2R1K3 b - - 8 37","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rdh8","uci":"d8h8","fen_after":"7r/kp6/2p5/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/4BP1r/2R1K3 w - - 9 38","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"35.e4","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/2R5 w - - 3 35","depth":20,"score_cp":-445,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"e4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/4P1p1/3P2P1/3KBP1r/2R5 b - - 0 35","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bxe4","uci":"d5e4","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1R1pp2/4b1p1/3P2P1/3KBP1r/2R5 w - - 0 36","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Kc3","uci":"d2c3","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1R1pp2/4b1p1/2KP2P1/4BP1r/2R5 b - - 1 36","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bd5","uci":"e4d5","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/2KP2P1/4BP1r/2R5 w - - 2 37","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rf1","uci":"c1f1","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/2KP2P1/4BP1r/5R2 b - - 3 37","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kc7","uci":"b8c7","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/2KP2P1/4BP1r/5R2 w - - 4 38","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":70,"san":"35...Kc7","quality":"good","text":"35...Kc7 steps the king toward the centre. With rooks on the board, it is a safe place and helps connect the pieces. White's rook will drop back to c2.","best":"d6f6","script":{"say":"35...Kc7 steps the king toward the centre. With rooks on the board, it is a safe place and helps connect the pieces. White's rook will drop back to c2.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":135,"until":151,"brush":"yellow","from":"c5","to":"c2"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"35...Rf6","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 b - - 4 35","depth":44,"score_cp":0,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rf6","uci":"d6f6","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2p2r2/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 w - - 5 36","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kc3","uci":"d2c3","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2p2r2/P1Rbpp2/6p1/2KPP1P1/4BP1r/5R2 b - - 6 36","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rf7","uci":"f6f7","fen_after":"1k6/1p3r2/2p5/P1Rbpp2/6p1/2KPP1P1/4BP1r/5R2 w - - 7 37","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"e4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"1k6/1p3r2/2p5/P1Rbpp2/4P1p1/2KP2P1/4BP1r/5R2 b - - 0 37","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"fxe4","uci":"f5e4","fen_after":"1k6/1p3r2/2p5/P1Rbp3/4p1p1/2KP2P1/4BP1r/5R2 w - - 0 38","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"dxe4","uci":"d3e4","fen_after":"1k6/1p3r2/2p5/P1Rbp3/4P1p1/2K3P1/4BP1r/5R2 b - - 0 38","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"35...Ka7","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 b - - 4 35","depth":44,"score_cp":0,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Ka7","uci":"b8a7","fen_after":"8/kp6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 w - - 5 36","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kc3","uci":"d2c3","fen_after":"8/kp6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/2KPP1P1/4BP1r/5R2 b - - 6 36","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Re6","uci":"d6e6","fen_after":"8/kp6/2p1r3/P1Rbpp2/6p1/2KPP1P1/4BP1r/5R2 w - - 7 37","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"e4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"8/kp6/2p1r3/P1Rbpp2/4P1p1/2KP2P1/4BP1r/5R2 b - - 0 37","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"fxe4","uci":"f5e4","fen_after":"8/kp6/2p1r3/P1Rbp3/4p1p1/2KP2P1/4BP1r/5R2 w - - 0 38","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bxg4","uci":"e2g4","fen_after":"8/kp6/2p1r3/P1Rbp3/4p1B1/2KP2P1/5P1r/5R2 b - - 0 38","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"35...Bg2","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 b - - 4 35","depth":44,"score_cp":0,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bg2","uci":"d5g2","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1R1pp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBPbr/5R2 w - - 5 36","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Ra1","uci":"f1a1","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1R1pp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBPbr/R7 b - - 6 36","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bd5","uci":"g2d5","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/R7 w - - 7 37","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rf1","uci":"a1f1","fen_after":"1k6/1p6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 b - - 8 37","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Ka7","uci":"b8a7","fen_after":"8/kp6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 w - - 9 38","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kc3","uci":"d2c3","fen_after":"8/kp6/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/2KPP1P1/4BP1r/5R2 b - - 10 38","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":null},{"ply":71,"san":"36.Rc2","quality":"good","text":"36.Rc2 retreats the rook to c2, where it still watches the c-file. Black's answer is a quiet rook step.\n\nOn the board: Striking with e4.","best":"e3e4","script":{"say":"36.Rc2 retreats the rook to c2, where it still watches the c-file. Black's answer is a quiet rook step.","show":[{"title":"Striking with e4","line":{"fen":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 w - - 5 36","depth":22,"score_cp":-3,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White could have hit the bishop with the e-pawn right away.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"e4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/4P1p1/3P2P1/3KBP1r/5R2 b - - 0 36","comment":"36.e4 attacks the bishop on d5.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"fxe4","uci":"f5e4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P1Rbp3/4p1p1/3P2P1/3KBP1r/5R2 w - - 0 37","comment":"36...fxe4 takes the pawn.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"dxe4","uci":"d3e4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P1Rbp3/4P1p1/6P1/3KBP1r/5R2 b - - 0 37","comment":"37.dxe4 recaptures and opens the d-file.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bc4+","uci":"d5c4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P1R1p3/2b1P1p1/6P1/3KBP1r/5R2 w - - 1 38","comment":"37...Bc4+ moves the bishop with a discovered check from the rook on d6.","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Ke1","uci":"d2e1","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P1R1p3/2b1P1p1/6P1/4BP1r/4KR2 b - - 2 38","comment":"38.Ke1 steps out of check.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White could have hit the bishop with the e-pawn right away.","takeaway":"The computer sees this as about equal, a touch better for White than the game move."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":47,"until":103,"brush":"green","from":"c2","to":"c6"},{"type":"arrow","at":93,"until":103,"brush":"yellow","from":"d6","to":"d8"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"36.e4","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 w - - 5 36","depth":22,"score_cp":-3,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"e4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/4P1p1/3P2P1/3KBP1r/5R2 b - - 0 36","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"fxe4","uci":"f5e4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P1Rbp3/4p1p1/3P2P1/3KBP1r/5R2 w - - 0 37","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"dxe4","uci":"d3e4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P1Rbp3/4P1p1/6P1/3KBP1r/5R2 b - - 0 37","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bc4+","uci":"d5c4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P1R1p3/2b1P1p1/6P1/3KBP1r/5R2 w - - 1 38","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Ke1","uci":"d2e1","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P1R1p3/2b1P1p1/6P1/4BP1r/4KR2 b - - 2 38","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bxe2","uci":"c4e2","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P1R1p3/4P1p1/6P1/4bP1r/4KR2 w - - 0 39","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"36.Kc3","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 w - - 5 36","depth":22,"score_cp":-6,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Kc3","uci":"d2c3","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/2KPP1P1/4BP1r/5R2 b - - 6 36","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rf6","uci":"d6f6","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p2r2/P1Rbpp2/6p1/2KPP1P1/4BP1r/5R2 w - - 7 37","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Kb4","uci":"c3b4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p2r2/P1Rbpp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/4BP1r/5R2 b - - 8 37","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kd6","uci":"c7d6","fen_after":"8/1p6/2pk1r2/P1Rbpp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/4BP1r/5R2 w - - 9 38","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"e4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"8/1p6/2pk1r2/P1Rbpp2/1K2P1p1/3P2P1/4BP1r/5R2 b - - 0 38","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"fxe4","uci":"f5e4","fen_after":"8/1p6/2pk1r2/P1Rbp3/1K2p1p1/3P2P1/4BP1r/5R2 w - - 0 39","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":3},{"ply":72,"san":"36...Rd8","quality":"best","text":"36...Rd8 steps the rook back along the d-file, keeping it safe, with the a-file in mind as the next stop. White's king will walk up the board.","best":"d6d8","script":{"say":"36...Rd8 steps the rook back along the d-file, keeping it safe, with the a-file in mind as the next stop. White's king will walk up the board.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":88,"until":142,"brush":"yellow","from":"d8","to":"a8"},{"type":"arrow","at":124,"until":142,"brush":"yellow","from":"d2","to":"c3"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"36...Bg2","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P2bpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/2RKBP1r/5R2 b - - 6 36","depth":22,"score_cp":-29,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bg2","uci":"d5g2","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P3pp2/6p1/3PP1P1/2RKBPbr/5R2 w - - 7 37","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Ra1","uci":"f1a1","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P3pp2/6p1/3PP1P1/2RKBPbr/R7 b - - 8 37","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bd5","uci":"g2d5","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P2bpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/2RKBP1r/R7 w - - 9 38","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rf1","uci":"a1f1","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P2bpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/2RKBP1r/5R2 b - - 10 38","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rd8","uci":"d6d8","fen_after":"3r4/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/2RKBP1r/5R2 w - - 11 39","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rc3","uci":"c2c3","fen_after":"3r4/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/6p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 b - - 12 39","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"36...Rd7","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"8/1pk5/2pr4/P2bpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/2RKBP1r/5R2 b - - 6 36","depth":22,"score_cp":-27,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rd7","uci":"d6d7","fen_after":"8/1pkr4/2p5/P2bpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/2RKBP1r/5R2 w - - 7 37","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rb2","uci":"c2b2","fen_after":"8/1pkr4/2p5/P2bpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/1R1KBP1r/5R2 b - - 8 37","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Be6","uci":"d5e6","fen_after":"8/1pkr4/2p1b3/P3pp2/6p1/3PP1P1/1R1KBP1r/5R2 w - - 9 38","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rfb1","uci":"f1b1","fen_after":"8/1pkr4/2p1b3/P3pp2/6p1/3PP1P1/1R1KBP1r/1R6 b - - 10 38","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kc8","uci":"c7c8","fen_after":"2k5/1p1r4/2p1b3/P3pp2/6p1/3PP1P1/1R1KBP1r/1R6 w - - 11 39","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rf1","uci":"b1f1","fen_after":"2k5/1p1r4/2p1b3/P3pp2/6p1/3PP1P1/1R1KBP1r/5R2 b - - 12 39","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":73,"san":"37.Kc3","quality":"good","text":"37.Kc3 steps the king up the board, hoping it can help on the queenside, but it also drifts a little far from the kingside action. Black's rook swings to the a-file next, and the king heads to b4.\n\nOn the board: Rook to c3.","best":"c2c3","script":{"say":"37.Kc3 steps the king up the board, hoping it can help on the queenside, but it also drifts a little far from the kingside action. Black's rook swings to the a-file next, and the king heads to b4.","show":[{"title":"Rook to c3","line":{"fen":"3r4/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/2RKBP1r/5R2 w - - 7 37","depth":20,"score_cp":-34,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White could have kept the king at home and lifted the rook instead.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rc3","uci":"c2c3","fen_after":"3r4/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/6p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 b - - 8 37","comment":"37.Rc3 lifts the rook to the third rank.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bh1","uci":"d5h1","fen_after":"3r4/1pk5/2p5/P3pp2/6p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP1r/5R1b w - - 9 38","comment":"37...Bh1 slides the bishop into the corner.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Ra3","uci":"c3a3","fen_after":"3r4/1pk5/2p5/P3pp2/6p1/R2PP1P1/3KBP1r/5R1b b - - 10 38","comment":"38.Ra3 swings the rook to the a-file.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bg2","uci":"h1g2","fen_after":"3r4/1pk5/2p5/P3pp2/6p1/R2PP1P1/3KBPbr/5R2 w - - 11 39","comment":"38...Bg2 attacks the rook on f1.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rb1","uci":"f1b1","fen_after":"3r4/1pk5/2p5/P3pp2/6p1/R2PP1P1/3KBPbr/1R6 b - - 12 39","comment":"39.Rb1 moves the rook out of the way.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White could have kept the king at home and lifted the rook instead.","takeaway":"The computer rates this a bit better for White than the king walk, which gave Black a little more."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":144,"until":196,"brush":"yellow","from":"d8","to":"a8"},{"type":"arrow","at":190,"until":196,"brush":"yellow","from":"c3","to":"b4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"37.Rc3","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"3r4/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/2RKBP1r/5R2 w - - 7 37","depth":20,"score_cp":-34,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rc3","uci":"c2c3","fen_after":"3r4/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/6p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 b - - 8 37","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bh1","uci":"d5h1","fen_after":"3r4/1pk5/2p5/P3pp2/6p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP1r/5R1b w - - 9 38","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Ra3","uci":"c3a3","fen_after":"3r4/1pk5/2p5/P3pp2/6p1/R2PP1P1/3KBP1r/5R1b b - - 10 38","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bg2","uci":"h1g2","fen_after":"3r4/1pk5/2p5/P3pp2/6p1/R2PP1P1/3KBPbr/5R2 w - - 11 39","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rb1","uci":"f1b1","fen_after":"3r4/1pk5/2p5/P3pp2/6p1/R2PP1P1/3KBPbr/1R6 b - - 12 39","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bd5","uci":"g2d5","fen_after":"3r4/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/6p1/R2PP1P1/3KBP1r/1R6 w - - 13 40","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"37.Rc5","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"3r4/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/2RKBP1r/5R2 w - - 7 37","depth":20,"score_cp":-72,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rc5","uci":"c2c5","fen_after":"3r4/1pk5/2p5/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 b - - 8 37","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kd6","uci":"c7d6","fen_after":"3r4/1p6/2pk4/P1Rbpp2/6p1/3PP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 w - - 9 38","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rc3","uci":"c5c3","fen_after":"3r4/1p6/2pk4/P2bpp2/6p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 b - - 10 38","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Ra8","uci":"d8a8","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pk4/P2bpp2/6p1/2RPP1P1/3KBP1r/5R2 w - - 11 39","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"e4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pk4/P2bpp2/4P1p1/2RP2P1/3KBP1r/5R2 b - - 0 39","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"fxe4","uci":"f5e4","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pk4/P2bp3/4p1p1/2RP2P1/3KBP1r/5R2 w - - 0 40","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":3},{"ply":74,"san":"37...Ra8","quality":"good","text":"37...Ra8 swings the rook to the a-file to go after the a5 pawn. A neat shift of targets, and White's king will rush to defend it.","best":"d8f8","script":{"say":"37...Ra8 swings the rook to the a-file to go after the a5 pawn. A neat shift of targets, and White's king will rush to defend it.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":51,"until":129,"brush":"red","from":"a8","to":"a5"},{"type":"arrow","at":111,"until":129,"brush":"yellow","from":"c3","to":"b4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"37...Rf8","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"3r4/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/6p1/2KPP1P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 b - - 8 37","depth":24,"score_cp":-62,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rf8","uci":"d8f8","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/6p1/2KPP1P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 9 38","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rb2","uci":"c2b2","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/6p1/2KPP1P1/1R2BP1r/5R2 b - - 10 38","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Ra8","uci":"f8a8","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/6p1/2KPP1P1/1R2BP1r/5R2 w - - 11 39","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kb4","uci":"c3b4","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/1R2BP1r/5R2 b - - 12 39","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kd6","uci":"c7d6","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pk4/P2bpp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/1R2BP1r/5R2 w - - 13 40","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"d4","uci":"d3d4","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pk4/P2bpp2/1K1P2p1/4P1P1/1R2BP1r/5R2 b - - 0 40","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"37...Rg8","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"3r4/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/6p1/2KPP1P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 b - - 8 37","depth":24,"score_cp":-26,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rg8","uci":"d8g8","fen_after":"6r1/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/6p1/2KPP1P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 9 38","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"d4","uci":"d3d4","fen_after":"6r1/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/3P2p1/2K1P1P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 b - - 0 38","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"exd4+","uci":"e5d4","fen_after":"6r1/1pk5/2p5/P2b1p2/3p2p1/2K1P1P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 0 39","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"exd4","uci":"e3d4","fen_after":"6r1/1pk5/2p5/P2b1p2/3P2p1/2K3P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 b - - 0 39","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"f4","uci":"f5f4","fen_after":"6r1/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/3P1pp1/2K3P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 0 40","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bd3","uci":"e2d3","fen_after":"6r1/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/3P1pp1/2KB2P1/2R2P1r/5R2 b - - 1 40","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":75,"san":"38.Kb4","quality":"best","text":"38.Kb4 pushes the king even further forward to protect the a5 pawn. It looks brave and holds for the moment, while Black breaks with the f-pawn.","best":"c3b4","script":{"say":"38.Kb4 pushes the king even further forward to protect the a5 pawn. It looks brave and holds for the moment, while Black breaks with the f-pawn.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":55,"until":144,"brush":"yellow","square":"a5"},{"type":"arrow","at":121,"until":144,"brush":"green","from":"f5","to":"f4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"38.e4","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/6p1/2KPP1P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 9 38","depth":22,"score_cp":-154,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"e4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/4P1p1/2KP2P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 b - - 0 38","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"fxe4","uci":"f5e4","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2bp3/4p1p1/2KP2P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 0 39","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"dxe4","uci":"d3e4","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2bp3/4P1p1/2K3P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 b - - 0 39","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bxe4","uci":"d5e4","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P3p3/4b1p1/2K3P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 0 40","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Ra2","uci":"c2a2","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P3p3/4b1p1/2K3P1/R3BP1r/5R2 b - - 1 40","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bd5","uci":"e4d5","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2bp3/6p1/2K3P1/R3BP1r/5R2 w - - 2 41","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":76,"san":"38...f4","quality":"good","text":"38...f4 opens the kingside again, giving the bishop and the rooks more room. Caruana starts to break up the pawn chain, and the pawn hits e3 while White can take on f4 with the g-pawn.\n\nOn the board: King to d6.","best":"d5g2","script":{"say":"38...f4 opens the kingside again, giving the bishop and the rooks more room. Caruana starts to break up the pawn chain, and the pawn hits e3 while White can take on f4 with the g-pawn.","show":[{"title":"King to d6","line":{"fen":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 b - - 10 38","depth":23,"score_cp":-19,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black could have brought the king to the centre first.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Kd6","uci":"c7d6","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pk4/P2bpp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 11 39","comment":"38...Kd6 centralises the king.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bd1","uci":"e2d1","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pk4/P2bpp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/2R2P1r/3B1R2 b - - 12 39","comment":"39.Bd1 retreats the bishop.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Be6","uci":"d5e6","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pkb3/P3pp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/2R2P1r/3B1R2 w - - 13 40","comment":"39...Be6 pulls the bishop back from d5.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"f4","uci":"f2f4","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pkb3/P3pp2/1K3Pp1/3PP1P1/2R4r/3B1R2 b - f3 0 40","comment":"40.f4 challenges the e5 pawn.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rh3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pkb3/P3pp2/1K3Pp1/3PP1Pr/2R5/3B1R2 w - - 1 41","comment":"40...Rh3 attacks the pawn on g3.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Black could have brought the king to the centre first.","takeaway":"The computer sees this as about equal, so Black had several good plans."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":133,"until":184,"brush":"red","from":"f4","to":"e3"},{"type":"arrow","at":168,"until":184,"brush":"green","from":"g3","to":"f4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"38...Bg2","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 b - - 10 38","depth":23,"score_cp":-23,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bg2","uci":"d5g2","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P3pp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/2R1BPbr/5R2 w - - 11 39","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rg1","uci":"f1g1","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P3pp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/2R1BPbr/6R1 b - - 12 39","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bd5","uci":"g2d5","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/2R1BP1r/6R1 w - - 13 40","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rf1","uci":"g1f1","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 b - - 14 40","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kd6","uci":"c7d6","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pk4/P2bpp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 15 41","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bd1","uci":"e2d1","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pk4/P2bpp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/2R2P1r/3B1R2 b - - 16 41","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"38...Re8","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 b - - 10 38","depth":23,"score_cp":-20,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Re8","uci":"a8e8","fen_after":"4r3/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 11 39","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bd1","uci":"e2d1","fen_after":"4r3/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/2R2P1r/3B1R2 b - - 12 39","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Kd6","uci":"c7d6","fen_after":"4r3/1p6/2pk4/P2bpp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/2R2P1r/3B1R2 w - - 13 40","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rb2","uci":"c2b2","fen_after":"4r3/1p6/2pk4/P2bpp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/1R3P1r/3B1R2 b - - 14 40","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Ra8","uci":"e8a8","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pk4/P2bpp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/1R3P1r/3B1R2 w - - 15 41","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rc2","uci":"b2c2","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pk4/P2bpp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/2R2P1r/3B1R2 b - - 16 41","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"38...Kd6","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2bpp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 b - - 10 38","depth":23,"score_cp":-19,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Kd6","uci":"c7d6","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pk4/P2bpp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 11 39","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bd1","uci":"e2d1","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pk4/P2bpp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/2R2P1r/3B1R2 b - - 12 39","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Be6","uci":"d5e6","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pkb3/P3pp2/1K4p1/3PP1P1/2R2P1r/3B1R2 w - - 13 40","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"f4","uci":"f2f4","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pkb3/P3pp2/1K3Pp1/3PP1P1/2R4r/3B1R2 b - f3 0 40","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rh3","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pkb3/P3pp2/1K3Pp1/3PP1Pr/2R5/3B1R2 w - - 1 41","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"fxe5+","uci":"f4e5","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pkb3/P3Pp2/1K4p1/3PP1Pr/2R5/3B1R2 b - - 0 41","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":null},{"ply":77,"san":"39.gxf4","quality":"good","text":"39.gxf4 takes the pawn and opens the position. It is a decent choice, though Black's pieces are now more active. The rook on h2 now presses on f2 and the e-pawn will recapture.","best":"e3e4","script":{"say":"39.gxf4 takes the pawn and opens the position. It is a decent choice, though Black's pieces are now more active. The rook on h2 now presses on f2 and the e-pawn will recapture.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":132,"until":176,"brush":"red","from":"h2","to":"f2"},{"type":"arrow","at":166,"until":176,"brush":"green","from":"e5","to":"f4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"39.e4","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2bp3/1K3pp1/3PP1P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 0 39","depth":24,"score_cp":-6,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"e4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2bp3/1K2Ppp1/3P2P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 b - - 0 39","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Be6","uci":"d5e6","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p1b3/P3p3/1K2Ppp1/3P2P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 1 40","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"gxf4","uci":"g3f4","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p1b3/P3p3/1K2PPp1/3P4/2R1BP1r/5R2 b - - 0 40","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"exf4","uci":"e5f4","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/1K2Ppp1/3P4/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 0 41","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"d4","uci":"d3d4","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/1K1PPpp1/8/2R1BP1r/5R2 b - - 0 41","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kd6","uci":"c7d6","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pkb3/P7/1K1PPpp1/8/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 1 42","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"39.Bd1","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2bp3/1K3pp1/3PP1P1/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 0 39","depth":24,"score_cp":-23,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bd1","uci":"e2d1","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2bp3/1K3pp1/3PP1P1/2R2P1r/3B1R2 b - - 1 39","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rf8","uci":"a8f8","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P2bp3/1K3pp1/3PP1P1/2R2P1r/3B1R2 w - - 2 40","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rg1","uci":"f1g1","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P2bp3/1K3pp1/3PP1P1/2R2P1r/3B2R1 b - - 3 40","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"f3","uci":"f4f3","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P2bp3/1K4p1/3PPpP1/2R2P1r/3B2R1 w - - 0 41","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rf1","uci":"g1f1","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P2bp3/1K4p1/3PPpP1/2R2P1r/3B1R2 b - - 1 41","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"e4","uci":"e5e4","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/1K2p1p1/3PPpP1/2R2P1r/3B1R2 w - - 0 42","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":78,"san":"39...exf4","quality":"best","text":"39...exf4 recaptures, and the pawn on f4 now hits the pawn on e3. White will take it back.","best":"e5f4","script":{"say":"39...exf4 recaptures, and the pawn on f4 now hits the pawn on e3. White will take it back.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":45,"until":90,"brush":"red","from":"f4","to":"e3"},{"type":"arrow","at":77,"until":90,"brush":"yellow","from":"e3","to":"f4"}]},"alternatives":[],"playedRank":1},{"ply":79,"san":"40.exf4","quality":"inaccuracy","text":"This is the real mistake. White had to play 40.e4, challenging the centre. Rapport took with 40.exf4 instead, and that leaves the f4 pawn weak while Black's bishop rakes the long diagonal. Black's rook will hit it next. From here Black is clearly better.\n\nOn the board: Challenge the bishop.","best":"e3e4","script":{"say":"This is the real mistake. White had to play 40.e4, challenging the centre. Rapport took with 40.exf4 instead, and that leaves the f4 pawn weak while Black's bishop rakes the long diagonal. Black's rook will hit it next. From here Black is clearly better.","show":[{"title":"Challenge the bishop","line":{"fen":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/1K3pp1/3PP3/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 0 40","depth":24,"score_cp":-42,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White's best idea was to hit the centre with the e-pawn before taking anything.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"e4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/1K2Ppp1/3P4/2R1BP1r/5R2 b - - 0 40","comment":"40.e4 hits the bishop and breaks Black's grip on the centre.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Be6","uci":"d5e6","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/1K2Ppp1/3P4/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 1 41","comment":"40...Be6 retreats and keeps the bishop in the game.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"d4","uci":"d3d4","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/1K1PPpp1/8/2R1BP1r/5R2 b - - 0 41","comment":"41.d4 grabs space in the middle.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kd6","uci":"c7d6","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pkb3/P7/1K1PPpp1/8/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 1 42","comment":"41...Kd6 steps toward the centre to support the pawns.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White's best idea was to hit the centre with the e-pawn before taking anything.","takeaway":"This keeps things balanced, while the game move leaves White with real structural problems."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":157,"until":254,"brush":"green","from":"d5","to":"h1"},{"type":"arrow","at":207,"until":254,"brush":"yellow","from":"a8","to":"f8"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"40.e4","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/1K3pp1/3PP3/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 0 40","depth":24,"score_cp":-42,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"e4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/1K2Ppp1/3P4/2R1BP1r/5R2 b - - 0 40","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Be6","uci":"d5e6","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/1K2Ppp1/3P4/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 1 41","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"d4","uci":"d3d4","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/1K1PPpp1/8/2R1BP1r/5R2 b - - 0 41","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kd6","uci":"c7d6","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pkb3/P7/1K1PPpp1/8/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 1 42","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bd3","uci":"e2d3","fen_after":"r7/1p6/2pkb3/P7/1K1PPpp1/3B4/2R2P1r/5R2 b - - 2 42","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rd8","uci":"a8d8","fen_after":"3r4/1p6/2pkb3/P7/1K1PPpp1/3B4/2R2P1r/5R2 w - - 3 43","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"40.Bxg4","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/1K3pp1/3PP3/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 0 40","depth":24,"score_cp":-249,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bxg4","uci":"e2g4","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/1K3pB1/3PP3/2R2P1r/5R2 b - - 0 40","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"fxe3","uci":"f4e3","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/1K4B1/3Pp3/2R2P1r/5R2 w - - 0 41","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rb2","uci":"c2b2","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/1K4B1/3Pp3/1R3P1r/5R2 b - - 1 41","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rf8","uci":"a8f8","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/1K4B1/3Pp3/1R3P1r/5R2 w - - 2 42","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kc5","uci":"b4c5","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P1Kb4/6B1/3Pp3/1R3P1r/5R2 b - - 3 42","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rhxf2","uci":"h2f2","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P1Kb4/6B1/3Pp3/1R3r2/5R2 w - - 0 43","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":null},{"ply":80,"san":"40...Rf8","quality":"only move","text":"40...Rf8 is the only move and a good one. It attacks the f4 pawn and keeps Black's advantage intact. White's king steps aside.","best":"a8f8","script":{"say":"40...Rf8 is the only move and a good one. It attacks the f4 pawn and keeps Black's advantage intact. White's king steps aside.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":53,"until":126,"brush":"red","from":"f8","to":"f4"},{"type":"arrow","at":114,"until":126,"brush":"yellow","from":"b4","to":"c3"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"40...Be6","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/1K3Pp1/3P4/2R1BP1r/5R2 b - - 0 40","depth":20,"score_cp":-27,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Be6","uci":"d5e6","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/1K3Pp1/3P4/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 1 41","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"f5","uci":"f4f5","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p1b3/P4P2/1K4p1/3P4/2R1BP1r/5R2 b - - 0 41","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bxf5","uci":"e6f5","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P4b2/1K4p1/3P4/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 0 42","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rc5","uci":"c2c5","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P1R2b2/1K4p1/3P4/4BP1r/5R2 b - - 1 42","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rf8","uci":"a8f8","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P1R2b2/1K4p1/3P4/4BP1r/5R2 w - - 2 43","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kc3","uci":"b4c3","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P1R2b2/6p1/2KP4/4BP1r/5R2 b - - 3 43","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"40...Rh4","score":"The game is level","line":{"fen":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/1K3Pp1/3P4/2R1BP1r/5R2 b - - 0 40","depth":20,"score_cp":-24,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The game is level","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rh4","uci":"h2h4","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/1K3Ppr/3P4/2R1BP2/5R2 w - - 1 41","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"d4","uci":"d3d4","fen_after":"r7/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/1K1P1Ppr/8/2R1BP2/5R2 b - - 0 41","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rf8","uci":"a8f8","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/1K1P1Ppr/8/2R1BP2/5R2 w - - 1 42","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bc4","uci":"e2c4","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/1KBP1Ppr/8/2R2P2/5R2 b - - 2 42","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rh5","uci":"h4h5","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P2b3r/1KBP1Pp1/8/2R2P2/5R2 w - - 3 43","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Ra1","uci":"f1a1","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P2b3r/1KBP1Pp1/8/2R2P2/R7 b - - 4 43","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":81,"san":"41.Kc3","quality":"good","text":"41.Kc3 steps out of the line of the rook, which would give check on the fourth rank if it took on f4. Black simply takes the pawn.\n\nOn the board: Rook to b2 first.","best":"c2b2","script":{"say":"41.Kc3 steps out of the line of the rook, which would give check on the fourth rank if it took on f4. Black simply takes the pawn.","show":[{"title":"Rook to b2 first","line":{"fen":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/1K3Pp1/3P4/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 1 41","depth":20,"score_cp":-302,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White could have moved the rook before the king.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rb2","uci":"c2b2","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/1K3Pp1/3P4/1R2BP1r/5R2 b - - 2 41","comment":"41.Rb2 puts the rook on the b-file.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxf4+","uci":"f8f4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/1K3rp1/3P4/1R2BP1r/5R2 w - - 0 42","comment":"41...Rxf4+ takes the pawn with check.","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Kc3","uci":"b4c3","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/5rp1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/5R2 b - - 1 42","comment":"42.Kc3 steps out of check.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Ra4","uci":"f4a4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/r5p1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/5R2 w - - 2 43","comment":"42...Ra4 swings the other rook to the a-file.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White could have moved the rook before the king.","takeaway":"The computer rates this a little worse for White than the game move, so the king step was a touch better."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":115,"until":130,"brush":"red","from":"f8","to":"f4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"41.Rb2","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/1K3Pp1/3P4/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 1 41","depth":20,"score_cp":-302,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rb2","uci":"c2b2","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/1K3Pp1/3P4/1R2BP1r/5R2 b - - 2 41","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxf4+","uci":"f8f4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/1K3rp1/3P4/1R2BP1r/5R2 w - - 0 42","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Kc3","uci":"b4c3","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/5rp1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/5R2 b - - 1 42","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Ra4","uci":"f4a4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/r5p1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/5R2 w - - 2 43","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kd2","uci":"c3d2","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/r5p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/5R2 b - - 3 43","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"g3","uci":"g4g3","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/r7/3P2p1/1R1KBP1r/5R2 w - - 0 44","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":82,"san":"41...Rxf4","quality":"only move","text":"41...Rxf4 wins a pawn and is the only accurate move. Black is a pawn up, and both rooks are the more active pieces. Black's rook now swings to the a-file, while White's rook goes to b2.","best":"f8f4","script":{"say":"41...Rxf4 wins a pawn and is the only accurate move. Black is a pawn up, and both rooks are the more active pieces. Black's rook now swings to the a-file, while White's rook goes to b2.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":133,"until":185,"brush":"green","from":"f4","to":"a4"},{"type":"arrow","at":174,"until":185,"brush":"yellow","from":"c2","to":"b2"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"41...Be6","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/5Pp1/2KP4/2R1BP1r/5R2 b - - 2 41","depth":21,"score_cp":-46,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Be6","uci":"d5e6","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/5Pp1/2KP4/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 3 42","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bd1","uci":"e2d1","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/5Pp1/2KP4/2R2P1r/3B1R2 b - - 4 42","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rxf4","uci":"f8f4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/5rp1/2KP4/2R2P1r/3B1R2 w - - 0 43","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Re1","uci":"f1e1","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/5rp1/2KP4/2R2P1r/3BR3 b - - 1 43","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bd7","uci":"e6d7","fen_after":"8/1pkb4/2p5/P7/5rp1/2KP4/2R2P1r/3BR3 w - - 2 44","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rce2","uci":"c2e2","fen_after":"8/1pkb4/2p5/P7/5rp1/2KP4/4RP1r/3BR3 b - - 3 44","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"41...Rg2","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/5Pp1/2KP4/2R1BP1r/5R2 b - - 2 41","depth":21,"score_cp":-42,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rg2","uci":"h2g2","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/5Pp1/2KP4/2R1BPr1/5R2 w - - 3 42","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rh1","uci":"f1h1","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/5Pp1/2KP4/2R1BPr1/7R b - - 4 42","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rxf4","uci":"f8f4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/5rp1/2KP4/2R1BPr1/7R w - - 0 43","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bd1","uci":"e2d1","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/5rp1/2KP4/2R2Pr1/3B3R b - - 1 43","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Ra4","uci":"f4a4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/r5p1/2KP4/2R2Pr1/3B3R w - - 2 44","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rh7+","uci":"h1h7","fen_after":"8/1pk4R/2p5/P2b4/r5p1/2KP4/2R2Pr1/3B4 b - - 3 44","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":83,"san":"42.Rb2","quality":"best","text":"42.Rb2 puts the rook on the b-file, aiming at the b7 pawn and starting counterplay. Black's rook heads for the a-pawn.","best":"c2b2","script":{"say":"42.Rb2 puts the rook on the b-file, aiming at the b7 pawn and starting counterplay. Black's rook heads for the a-pawn.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":46,"until":118,"brush":"red","from":"b2","to":"b7"},{"type":"arrow","at":97,"until":118,"brush":"green","from":"f4","to":"a4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"42.Rcc1","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/5rp1/2KP4/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 0 42","depth":20,"score_cp":-232,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rcc1","uci":"c2c1","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/5rp1/2KP4/4BP1r/2R2R2 b - - 1 42","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Ra4","uci":"f4a4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/r5p1/2KP4/4BP1r/2R2R2 w - - 2 43","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rce1","uci":"c1e1","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/r5p1/2KP4/4BP1r/4RR2 b - - 3 43","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Ra3+","uci":"a4a3","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/6p1/r1KP4/4BP1r/4RR2 w - - 4 44","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kd2","uci":"c3d2","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/6p1/r2P4/3KBP1r/4RR2 b - - 5 44","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Ra2+","uci":"a3a2","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/6p1/3P4/r2KBP1r/4RR2 w - - 6 45","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"42.Bd1","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/5rp1/2KP4/2R1BP1r/5R2 w - - 0 42","depth":20,"score_cp":-237,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Bd1","uci":"e2d1","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/5rp1/2KP4/2R2P1r/3B1R2 b - - 1 42","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Ra4","uci":"f4a4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/r5p1/2KP4/2R2P1r/3B1R2 w - - 2 43","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"a6","uci":"a5a6","fen_after":"8/1pk5/P1p5/3b4/r5p1/2KP4/2R2P1r/3B1R2 b - - 0 43","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"b5","uci":"b7b5","fen_after":"8/2k5/P1p5/1p1b4/r5p1/2KP4/2R2P1r/3B1R2 w - - 0 44","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"a7","uci":"a6a7","fen_after":"8/P1k5/2p5/1p1b4/r5p1/2KP4/2R2P1r/3B1R2 b - - 0 44","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rg2","uci":"h2g2","fen_after":"8/P1k5/2p5/1p1b4/r5p1/2KP4/2R2Pr1/3B1R2 w - - 1 45","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":84,"san":"42...Ra4","quality":"best","text":"42...Ra4 goes after the a5 pawn. White's king will step back to d2.","best":"f4a4","script":{"say":"42...Ra4 goes after the a5 pawn. White's king will step back to d2.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":20,"until":67,"brush":"red","from":"a4","to":"a5"},{"type":"arrow","at":51,"until":67,"brush":"yellow","from":"c3","to":"d2"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"42...Be6","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/5rp1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/5R2 b - - 1 42","depth":22,"score_cp":-241,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Be6","uci":"d5e6","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/5rp1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/5R2 w - - 2 43","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"f3","uci":"f2f3","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/5rp1/2KP1P2/1R2B2r/5R2 b - - 0 43","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"g3","uci":"g4g3","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/5r2/2KP1Pp1/1R2B2r/5R2 w - - 0 44","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rg1","uci":"f1g1","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/5r2/2KP1Pp1/1R2B2r/6R1 b - - 1 44","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"g2","uci":"g3g2","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/5r2/2KP1P2/1R2B1pr/6R1 w - - 0 45","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"d4","uci":"d3d4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/3P1r2/2K2P2/1R2B1pr/6R1 b - - 0 45","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"42...Rg2","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/5rp1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/5R2 b - - 1 42","depth":22,"score_cp":-178,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rg2","uci":"h2g2","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/5rp1/2KP4/1R2BPr1/5R2 w - - 2 43","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rfb1","uci":"f1b1","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/5rp1/2KP4/1R2BPr1/1R6 b - - 3 43","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rgxf2","uci":"g2f2","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/5rp1/2KP4/1R2Br2/1R6 w - - 0 44","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rxb7+","uci":"b2b7","fen_after":"8/1Rk5/2p5/P2b4/5rp1/2KP4/4Br2/1R6 b - - 0 44","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kd6","uci":"c7d6","fen_after":"8/1R6/2pk4/P2b4/5rp1/2KP4/4Br2/1R6 w - - 1 45","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bd1","uci":"e2d1","fen_after":"8/1R6/2pk4/P2b4/5rp1/2KP4/5r2/1R1B4 b - - 2 45","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":85,"san":"43.Kd2","quality":"best","text":"43.Kd2 steps off the third rank, where a rook check from a3 was possible. White's position is tough, but this is the most resilient move. The bishop drops back next.\n\nOn the board: Rook to g1.","best":"c3d2","script":{"say":"43.Kd2 steps off the third rank, where a rook check from a3 was possible. White's position is tough, but this is the most resilient move. The bishop drops back next.","show":[{"title":"Rook to g1","line":{"fen":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/r5p1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/5R2 w - - 2 43","depth":20,"score_cp":-364,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White could have gone after the g4 pawn.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rg1","uci":"f1g1","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/r5p1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/6R1 b - - 3 43","comment":"43.Rg1 puts the rook on the g-file against the g4 pawn.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Be6","uci":"d5e6","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/r5p1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/6R1 w - - 4 44","comment":"43...Be6 defends the g4 pawn.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"a6","uci":"a5a6","fen_after":"8/1pk5/P1p1b3/8/r5p1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/6R1 b - - 0 44","comment":"44.a6 pushes the a-pawn.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"b5","uci":"b7b5","fen_after":"8/2k5/P1p1b3/1p6/r5p1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/6R1 w - - 0 45","comment":"44...b5 blocks it.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White could have gone after the g4 pawn.","takeaway":"The computer rates this about the same as the game move, so Rapport had few better tries."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":149,"until":165,"brush":"yellow","from":"d5","to":"e6"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"43.Rg1","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/r5p1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/5R2 w - - 2 43","depth":20,"score_cp":-364,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rg1","uci":"f1g1","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/r5p1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/6R1 b - - 3 43","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Be6","uci":"d5e6","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/r5p1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/6R1 w - - 4 44","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"a6","uci":"a5a6","fen_after":"8/1pk5/P1p1b3/8/r5p1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/6R1 b - - 0 44","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"b5","uci":"b7b5","fen_after":"8/2k5/P1p1b3/1p6/r5p1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/6R1 w - - 0 45","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rb4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"8/2k5/P1p1b3/1p6/rR4p1/2KP4/4BP1r/6R1 b - - 1 45","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Ra3+","uci":"a4a3","fen_after":"8/2k5/P1p1b3/1p6/1R4p1/r1KP4/4BP1r/6R1 w - - 2 46","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"43.a6","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/r5p1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/5R2 w - - 2 43","depth":20,"score_cp":-430,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a6","uci":"a5a6","fen_after":"8/1pk5/P1p5/3b4/r5p1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/5R2 b - - 0 43","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"b5","uci":"b7b5","fen_after":"8/2k5/P1p5/1p1b4/r5p1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/5R2 w - - 0 44","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"a7","uci":"a6a7","fen_after":"8/P1k5/2p5/1p1b4/r5p1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/5R2 b - - 0 44","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rg2","uci":"h2g2","fen_after":"8/P1k5/2p5/1p1b4/r5p1/2KP4/1R2BPr1/5R2 w - - 1 45","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rb4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"8/P1k5/2p5/1p1b4/rR4p1/2KP4/4BPr1/5R2 b - - 2 45","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rxa7","uci":"a4a7","fen_after":"8/r1k5/2p5/1p1b4/1R4p1/2KP4/4BPr1/5R2 w - - 0 46","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":86,"san":"43...Be6","quality":"good","text":"43...Be6 repositions the bishop on the diagonal toward a2. The computer rates it as a good move. White will bring the other rook to the b-file.","best":"g4g3","script":{"say":"43...Be6 repositions the bishop on the diagonal toward a2. The computer rates it as a good move. White will bring the other rook to the b-file.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":48,"until":143,"brush":"green","from":"e6","to":"a2"},{"type":"arrow","at":108,"until":143,"brush":"yellow","from":"f1","to":"b1"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"43...g3","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/r5p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/5R2 b - - 3 43","depth":22,"score_cp":-395,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"g3","uci":"g4g3","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/r7/3P2p1/1R1KBP1r/5R2 w - - 0 44","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"fxg3","uci":"f2g3","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/r7/3P2P1/1R1KB2r/5R2 b - - 0 44","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rxa5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/r2b4/8/3P2P1/1R1KB2r/5R2 w - - 0 45","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kc3","uci":"d2c3","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/r2b4/8/2KP2P1/1R2B2r/5R2 b - - 1 45","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Ra3+","uci":"a5a3","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/3b4/8/r1KP2P1/1R2B2r/5R2 w - - 2 46","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kd4","uci":"c3d4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/3b4/3K4/r2P2P1/1R2B2r/5R2 b - - 3 46","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"43...Rxa5","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b4/r5p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/5R2 b - - 3 43","depth":22,"score_cp":-214,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rxa5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/r2b4/6p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/5R2 w - - 0 44","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bxg4","uci":"e2g4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/r2b4/6B1/3P4/1R1K1P1r/5R2 b - - 0 44","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Ra4","uci":"a5a4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/3b4/r5B1/3P4/1R1K1P1r/5R2 w - - 1 45","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bd1","uci":"g4d1","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/3b4/r7/3P4/1R1K1P1r/3B1R2 b - - 2 45","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Ra1","uci":"a4a1","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/3b4/8/3P4/1R1K1P1r/r2B1R2 w - - 3 46","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kc3","uci":"d2c3","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/3b4/8/2KP4/1R3P1r/r2B1R2 b - - 4 46","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":87,"san":"44.Rfb1","quality":"best","text":"44.Rfb1 puts both rooks on the b-file, hitting b7. It is White's best practical chance to create some counterplay, and the bishop will guard the pawn.\n\nOn the board: Offering the a-pawn.","best":"f1b1","script":{"say":"44.Rfb1 puts both rooks on the b-file, hitting b7. It is White's best practical chance to create some counterplay, and the bishop will guard the pawn.","show":[{"title":"Offering the a-pawn","line":{"fen":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/r5p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/5R2 w - - 4 44","depth":20,"score_cp":-477,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White could have pushed the a-pawn instead of doubling rooks.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a6","uci":"a5a6","fen_after":"8/1pk5/P1p1b3/8/r5p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/5R2 b - - 0 44","comment":"44.a6 pushes the pawn, offering it.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxa6","uci":"a4a6","fen_after":"8/1pk5/r1p1b3/8/6p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/5R2 w - - 0 45","comment":"44...Rxa6 takes it.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rfb1","uci":"f1b1","fen_after":"8/1pk5/r1p1b3/8/6p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/1R6 b - - 1 45","comment":"45.Rfb1 doubles the rooks on the b-file.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"b5","uci":"b7b5","fen_after":"8/2k5/r1p1b3/1p6/6p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/1R6 w - - 0 46","comment":"45...b5 pushes the pawn forward.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White could have pushed the a-pawn instead of doubling rooks.","takeaway":"The computer says this is clearly worse for White than the rook move, so the game move was right."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":47,"until":150,"brush":"red","from":"b2","to":"b7"},{"type":"arrow","at":135,"until":150,"brush":"green","from":"e6","to":"c8"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"44.a6","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/r5p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/5R2 w - - 4 44","depth":20,"score_cp":-477,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a6","uci":"a5a6","fen_after":"8/1pk5/P1p1b3/8/r5p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/5R2 b - - 0 44","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxa6","uci":"a4a6","fen_after":"8/1pk5/r1p1b3/8/6p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/5R2 w - - 0 45","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rfb1","uci":"f1b1","fen_after":"8/1pk5/r1p1b3/8/6p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/1R6 b - - 1 45","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"b5","uci":"b7b5","fen_after":"8/2k5/r1p1b3/1p6/6p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/1R6 w - - 0 46","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Ke3","uci":"d2e3","fen_after":"8/2k5/r1p1b3/1p6/6p1/3PK3/1R2BP1r/1R6 b - - 1 46","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Ra8","uci":"a6a8","fen_after":"r7/2k5/2p1b3/1p6/6p1/3PK3/1R2BP1r/1R6 w - - 2 47","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"44.Ke3","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/r5p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/5R2 w - - 4 44","depth":20,"score_cp":-510,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Ke3","uci":"d2e3","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/r5p1/3PK3/1R2BP1r/5R2 b - - 5 44","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxa5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/r7/6p1/3PK3/1R2BP1r/5R2 w - - 0 45","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rb4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/r7/1R4p1/3PK3/4BP1r/5R2 b - - 1 45","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rh3+","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/r7/1R4p1/3PK2r/4BP2/5R2 w - - 2 46","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kf4","uci":"e3f4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/r7/1R3Kp1/3P3r/4BP2/5R2 b - - 3 46","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rf5+","uci":"a5f5","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/5r2/1R3Kp1/3P3r/4BP2/5R2 w - - 4 47","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":88,"san":"44...Bc8","quality":"best","text":"44...Bc8 guards the b7 pawn with the bishop. Simple and solid. White's rook will attack the rook on a4.","best":"e6c8","script":{"say":"44...Bc8 guards the b7 pawn with the bishop. Simple and solid. White's rook will attack the rook on a4.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":16,"until":103,"brush":"green","square":"b7"},{"type":"arrow","at":81,"until":103,"brush":"yellow","from":"b2","to":"b4"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"44...Kd6","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/r5p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/1R6 b - - 5 44","depth":17,"score_cp":-77,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Kd6","uci":"c7d6","fen_after":"8/1p6/2pkb3/P7/r5p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/1R6 w - - 6 45","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxb7","uci":"b2b7","fen_after":"8/1R6/2pkb3/P7/r5p1/3P4/3KBP1r/1R6 b - - 0 45","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"44...Rxf2","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/r5p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/1R6 b - - 5 44","depth":17,"score_cp":-57,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rxf2","uci":"h2f2","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/r5p1/3P4/1R1KBr2/1R6 w - - 0 45","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxb7+","uci":"b2b7","fen_after":"8/1Rk5/2p1b3/P7/r5p1/3P4/3KBr2/1R6 b - - 0 45","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Kd6","uci":"c7d6","fen_after":"8/1R6/2pkb3/P7/r5p1/3P4/3KBr2/1R6 w - - 1 46","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Ke3","uci":"d2e3","fen_after":"8/1R6/2pkb3/P7/r5p1/3PK3/4Br2/1R6 b - - 2 46","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rg2","uci":"f2g2","fen_after":"8/1R6/2pkb3/P7/r5p1/3PK3/4B1r1/1R6 w - - 3 47","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"R7b4","uci":"b7b4","fen_after":"8/8/2pkb3/P7/rR4p1/3PK3/4B1r1/1R6 b - - 4 47","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":89,"san":"45.Rb4","quality":"good","text":"45.Rb4 attacks the rook on a4 and keeps the pressure going. White is looking for a trade to ease the burden, but Black has a check on hand.","best":"d2e3","script":{"say":"45.Rb4 attacks the rook on a4 and keeps the pressure going. White is looking for a trade to ease the burden, but Black has a check on hand.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":30,"until":139,"brush":"red","from":"a4","to":"b4"},{"type":"arrow","at":131,"until":139,"brush":"green","from":"a4","to":"a2"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"45.Ke3","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/r5p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/1R6 w - - 6 45","depth":17,"score_cp":-179,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Ke3","uci":"d2e3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/r5p1/3PK3/1R2BP1r/1R6 b - - 7 45","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxa5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/r7/6p1/3PK3/1R2BP1r/1R6 w - - 0 46","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rb4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/r7/1R4p1/3PK3/4BP1r/1R6 b - - 1 46","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Re5+","uci":"a5e5","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/4r3/1R4p1/3PK3/4BP1r/1R6 w - - 2 47","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Re4","uci":"b4e4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/4r3/4R1p1/3PK3/4BP1r/1R6 b - - 3 47","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rh3+","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/4r3/4R1p1/3PK2r/4BP2/1R6 w - - 4 48","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"45.a6","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/r5p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/1R6 w - - 6 45","depth":17,"score_cp":-279,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a6","uci":"a5a6","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/P1p5/8/r5p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/1R6 b - - 0 45","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxa6","uci":"a4a6","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/r1p5/8/6p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/1R6 w - - 0 46","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":2},{"ply":90,"san":"45...Ra2+","quality":"only move","text":"45...Ra2+ is the only move. A check on the second rank forces White to block with the rook, and after the trade Black picks up the f2 pawn. White's likely reply is the rook to b2.","best":"a4a2","script":{"say":"45...Ra2+ is the only move. A check on the second rank forces White to block with the rook, and after the trade Black picks up the f2 pawn. White's likely reply is the rook to b2.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":118,"until":179,"brush":"green","from":"h2","to":"f2"},{"type":"arrow","at":164,"until":179,"brush":"yellow","from":"b1","to":"b2"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"45...Rxa5","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/rR4p1/3P4/3KBP1r/1R6 b - - 7 45","depth":20,"score_cp":-92,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rxa5","uci":"a4a5","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/r7/1R4p1/3P4/3KBP1r/1R6 w - - 0 46","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bxg4","uci":"e2g4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/r7/1R4B1/3P4/3K1P1r/1R6 b - - 0 46","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rxf2+","uci":"h2f2","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/r7/1R4B1/3P4/3K1r2/1R6 w - - 0 47","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Ke3","uci":"d2e3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/r7/1R4B1/3PK3/5r2/1R6 b - - 1 47","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rf7","uci":"f2f7","fen_after":"2b5/1pk2r2/2p5/r7/1R4B1/3PK3/8/1R6 w - - 2 48","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bf3","uci":"g4f3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk2r2/2p5/r7/1R6/3PKB2/8/1R6 b - - 3 48","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"45...Ra3","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/rR4p1/3P4/3KBP1r/1R6 b - - 7 45","depth":20,"score_cp":-52,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Ra3","uci":"a4a3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R4p1/r2P4/3KBP1r/1R6 w - - 8 46","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Ke3","uci":"d2e3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R4p1/r2PK3/4BP1r/1R6 b - - 9 46","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rh3+","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R4p1/r2PK2r/4BP2/1R6 w - - 10 47","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kf4","uci":"e3f4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R3Kp1/r2P3r/4BP2/1R6 b - - 11 47","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rh4","uci":"h3h4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R3Kpr/r2P4/4BP2/1R6 w - - 12 48","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kg3","uci":"f4g3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R4pr/r2P2K1/4BP2/1R6 b - - 13 48","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":91,"san":"46.R1b2","quality":"best","text":"46.R1b2 blocks the check and offers a rook trade. White is under pressure, and swapping a pair of rooks is the most practical way to cut down Black's attacking chances. Black will take on b2.","best":"b1b2","script":{"say":"46.R1b2 blocks the check and offers a rook trade. White is under pressure, and swapping a pair of rooks is the most practical way to cut down Black's attacking chances. Black will take on b2.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":180,"until":191,"brush":"red","from":"a2","to":"b2"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"46.Ke3","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R4p1/3P4/r2KBP1r/1R6 w - - 8 46","depth":17,"score_cp":-239,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Ke3","uci":"d2e3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R4p1/3PK3/r3BP1r/1R6 b - - 9 46","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rh3+","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R4p1/3PK2r/r3BP2/1R6 w - - 10 47","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"f3","uci":"f2f3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R4p1/3PKP1r/r3B3/1R6 b - - 0 47","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"g3","uci":"g4g3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R6/3PKPpr/r3B3/1R6 w - - 0 48","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"d4","uci":"d3d4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R1P4/4KPpr/r3B3/1R6 b - - 0 48","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rxa5","uci":"a2a5","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/r7/1R1P4/4KPpr/4B3/1R6 w - - 0 49","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"46.R4b2","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R4p1/3P4/r2KBP1r/1R6 w - - 8 46","depth":17,"score_cp":-327,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"R4b2","uci":"b4b2","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/6p1/3P4/rR1KBP1r/1R6 b - - 9 46","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxa5","uci":"a2a5","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/r7/6p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/1R6 w - - 0 47","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rf1","uci":"b1f1","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/r7/6p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/5R2 b - - 1 47","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Re5","uci":"a5e5","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/4r3/6p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/5R2 w - - 2 48","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kc3","uci":"d2c3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/4r3/6p1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/5R2 b - - 3 48","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kd6","uci":"c7d6","fen_after":"2b5/1p6/2pk4/4r3/6p1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/5R2 w - - 4 49","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":92,"san":"46...Rxb2+","quality":"best","text":"46...Rxb2+ accepts the trade with check. It is the best move and keeps the pressure on, and White must take back.","best":"a2b2","script":{"say":"46...Rxb2+ accepts the trade with check. It is the best move and keeps the pressure on, and White must take back.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":103,"until":113,"brush":"red","from":"b4","to":"b2"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"46...Rxa5","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R4p1/3P4/rR1KBP1r/8 b - - 9 46","depth":18,"score_cp":-149,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rxa5","uci":"a2a5","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/r7/1R4p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/8 w - - 0 47","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rf4","uci":"b4f4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/r7/5Rp1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/8 b - - 1 47","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bf5","uci":"c8f5","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/r4b2/5Rp1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/8 w - - 2 48","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kc3","uci":"d2c3","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/r4b2/5Rp1/2KP4/1R2BP1r/8 b - - 3 48","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rg2","uci":"h2g2","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/r4b2/5Rp1/2KP4/1R2BPr1/8 w - - 4 49","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bf1","uci":"e2f1","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/r4b2/5Rp1/2KP4/1R3Pr1/5B2 b - - 5 49","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"46...Ra3","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R4p1/3P4/rR1KBP1r/8 b - - 9 46","depth":18,"score_cp":-85,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Ra3","uci":"a2a3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R4p1/r2P4/1R1KBP1r/8 w - - 10 47","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rf4","uci":"b4f4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/5Rp1/r2P4/1R1KBP1r/8 b - - 11 47","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":93,"san":"47.Rxb2","quality":"only move","text":"47.Rxb2 is the only move. Anything else drops a rook or lets Black's pieces run riot. Black's other rook now grabs the f2 pawn.","best":"b4b2","script":{"say":"47.Rxb2 is the only move. Anything else drops a rook or lets Black's pieces run riot. Black's other rook now grabs the f2 pawn.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":109,"until":127,"brush":"red","from":"h2","to":"f2"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"47.Ke3","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R4p1/3P4/1r1KBP1r/8 w - - 0 47","depth":16,"score_cp":-776,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Ke3","uci":"d2e3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R4p1/3PK3/1r2BP1r/8 b - - 1 47","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxb4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1r4p1/3PK3/4BP1r/8 w - - 0 48","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"a6","uci":"a5a6","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/P1p5/8/1r4p1/3PK3/4BP1r/8 b - - 0 48","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"bxa6","uci":"b7a6","fen_after":"2b5/2k5/p1p5/8/1r4p1/3PK3/4BP1r/8 w - - 0 49","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bf1","uci":"e2f1","fen_after":"2b5/2k5/p1p5/8/1r4p1/3PK3/5P1r/5B2 b - - 1 49","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kd8","uci":"c7d8","fen_after":"2bk4/8/p1p5/8/1r4p1/3PK3/5P1r/5B2 w - - 2 50","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"47.Kc3","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R4p1/3P4/1r1KBP1r/8 w - - 0 47","depth":16,"score_cp":-869,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Kc3","uci":"d2c3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R4p1/2KP4/1r2BP1r/8 b - - 1 47","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxe2","uci":"b2e2","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R4p1/2KP4/4rP1r/8 w - - 0 48","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Ra4","uci":"b4a4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/R5p1/2KP4/4rP1r/8 b - - 1 48","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rhxf2","uci":"h2f2","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/R5p1/2KP4/4rr2/8 w - - 0 49","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"a6","uci":"a5a6","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/P1p5/8/R5p1/2KP4/4rr2/8 b - - 0 49","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"bxa6","uci":"b7a6","fen_after":"2b5/2k5/p1p5/8/R5p1/2KP4/4rr2/8 w - - 0 50","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":94,"san":"47...Rxf2","quality":"only move","text":"47...Rxf2 grabs another pawn and is the only move. Black is now a pawn up, and the rook attacks the bishop on e2, which only the king defends. White's king will come up the board.","best":"h2f2","script":{"say":"47...Rxf2 grabs another pawn and is the only move. Black is now a pawn up, and the rook attacks the bishop on e2, which only the king defends. White's king will come up the board.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":96,"until":179,"brush":"red","square":"e2"},{"type":"arrow","at":161,"until":179,"brush":"yellow","from":"d2","to":"e3"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"47...Be6","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/6p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/8 b - - 0 47","depth":18,"score_cp":-65,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Be6","uci":"c8e6","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/6p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/8 w - - 1 48","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Ke3","uci":"d2e3","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/6p1/3PK3/1R2BP1r/8 b - - 2 48","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rh5","uci":"h2h5","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P6r/6p1/3PK3/1R2BP2/8 w - - 3 49","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rb4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P6r/1R4p1/3PK3/4BP2/8 b - - 4 49","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rxa5","uci":"h5a5","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/r7/1R4p1/3PK3/4BP2/8 w - - 0 50","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bxg4","uci":"e2g4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/r7/1R4B1/3PK3/5P2/8 b - - 0 50","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"47...Rg2","score":"Black is a little better","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/6p1/3P4/1R1KBP1r/8 b - - 0 47","depth":18,"score_cp":-60,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is a little better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rg2","uci":"h2g2","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/6p1/3P4/1R1KBPr1/8 w - - 1 48","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Ke1","uci":"d2e1","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/6p1/3P4/1R2BPr1/4K3 b - - 2 48","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"g3","uci":"g4g3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/8/3P2p1/1R2BPr1/4K3 w - - 0 49","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"fxg3","uci":"f2g3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/8/3P2P1/1R2B1r1/4K3 b - - 0 49","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rxg3","uci":"g2g3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/8/3P2r1/1R2B3/4K3 w - - 0 50","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rb4","uci":"b2b4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R6/3P2r1/4B3/4K3 b - - 1 50","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":95,"san":"48.Ke3","quality":"good","text":"48.Ke3 attacks the rook on f2 and defends the bishop. White is looking for counterplay, but the situation is tough. The rook will slide away along the second rank.","best":"a5a6","script":{"say":"48.Ke3 attacks the rook on f2 and defends the bishop. White is looking for counterplay, but the situation is tough. The rook will slide away along the second rank.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":15,"until":163,"brush":"red","square":"f2"},{"type":"arrow","at":130,"until":163,"brush":"yellow","from":"f2","to":"h2"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"48.a6","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/6p1/3P4/1R1KBr2/8 w - - 0 48","depth":21,"score_cp":-461,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a6","uci":"a5a6","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/P1p5/8/6p1/3P4/1R1KBr2/8 b - - 0 48","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"bxa6","uci":"b7a6","fen_after":"2b5/2k5/p1p5/8/6p1/3P4/1R1KBr2/8 w - - 0 49","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rb1","uci":"b2b1","fen_after":"2b5/2k5/p1p5/8/6p1/3P4/3KBr2/1R6 b - - 1 49","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rf7","uci":"f2f7","fen_after":"2b5/2k2r2/p1p5/8/6p1/3P4/3KB3/1R6 w - - 2 50","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rg1","uci":"b1g1","fen_after":"2b5/2k2r2/p1p5/8/6p1/3P4/3KB3/6R1 b - - 3 50","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rg7","uci":"f7g7","fen_after":"2b5/2k3r1/p1p5/8/6p1/3P4/3KB3/6R1 w - - 4 51","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"48.Rb1","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/6p1/3P4/1R1KBr2/8 w - - 0 48","depth":21,"score_cp":-469,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rb1","uci":"b2b1","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/6p1/3P4/3KBr2/1R6 b - - 1 48","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rf7","uci":"f2f7","fen_after":"2b5/1pk2r2/2p5/P7/6p1/3P4/3KB3/1R6 w - - 2 49","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rg1","uci":"b1g1","fen_after":"2b5/1pk2r2/2p5/P7/6p1/3P4/3KB3/6R1 b - - 3 49","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rg7","uci":"f7g7","fen_after":"2b5/1pk3r1/2p5/P7/6p1/3P4/3KB3/6R1 w - - 4 50","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Ke3","uci":"d2e3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk3r1/2p5/P7/6p1/3PK3/4B3/6R1 b - - 5 50","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rg5","uci":"g7g5","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P5r1/6p1/3PK3/4B3/6R1 w - - 6 51","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":3},{"ply":96,"san":"48...Rh2","quality":"inaccuracy","text":"Caruana slips a little with 48...Rh2. Simply moving the rook to f7 would have kept everything under control. Now 49.Rb4 hits the g4 pawn with rook and bishop, and the evaluation fell from about minus five to minus two. The rook on h2 also stares at the bishop.\n\nOn the board: The simple retreat.","best":"f2f7","script":{"say":"Caruana slips a little with 48...Rh2. Simply moving the rook to f7 would have kept everything under control. Now 49.Rb4 hits the g4 pawn with rook and bishop, and the evaluation fell from about minus five to minus two. The rook on h2 also stares at the bishop.","show":[{"title":"The simple retreat","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/6p1/3PK3/1R2Br2/8 b - - 1 48","depth":24,"score_cp":-491,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black could have pulled the rook back along the f-file and kept the full advantage.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rf7","uci":"f2f7","fen_after":"2b5/1pk2r2/2p5/P7/6p1/3PK3/1R2B3/8 w - - 2 49","comment":"48...Rf7 steps back along the f-file.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"a6","uci":"a5a6","fen_after":"2b5/1pk2r2/P1p5/8/6p1/3PK3/1R2B3/8 b - - 0 49","comment":"49.a6 tries to open the queenside with a pawn break aimed at b7.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"bxa6","uci":"b7a6","fen_after":"2b5/2k2r2/p1p5/8/6p1/3PK3/1R2B3/8 w - - 0 50","comment":"49...bxa6 takes the pawn.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"d4","uci":"d3d4","fen_after":"2b5/2k2r2/p1p5/8/3P2p1/4K3/1R2B3/8 b - - 0 50","comment":"50.d4 grabs space in the centre, but Black remains a clear pawn up.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Black could have pulled the rook back along the f-file and kept the full advantage.","takeaway":"That would have kept Black at a winning level, while the game move lets White back into the fight a little."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":120,"until":260,"brush":"red","from":"b2","to":"b4"},{"type":"ray","at":234,"until":260,"brush":"red","from":"h2","to":"e2"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"48...Rf7","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/6p1/3PK3/1R2Br2/8 b - - 1 48","depth":24,"score_cp":-491,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rf7","uci":"f2f7","fen_after":"2b5/1pk2r2/2p5/P7/6p1/3PK3/1R2B3/8 w - - 2 49","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"a6","uci":"a5a6","fen_after":"2b5/1pk2r2/P1p5/8/6p1/3PK3/1R2B3/8 b - - 0 49","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"bxa6","uci":"b7a6","fen_after":"2b5/2k2r2/p1p5/8/6p1/3PK3/1R2B3/8 w - - 0 50","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"d4","uci":"d3d4","fen_after":"2b5/2k2r2/p1p5/8/3P2p1/4K3/1R2B3/8 b - - 0 50","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kd6","uci":"c7d6","fen_after":"2b5/5r2/p1pk4/8/3P2p1/4K3/1R2B3/8 w - - 1 51","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rb8","uci":"b2b8","fen_after":"1Rb5/5r2/p1pk4/8/3P2p1/4K3/4B3/8 b - - 2 51","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"48...Rf8","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/6p1/3PK3/1R2Br2/8 b - - 1 48","depth":24,"score_cp":-474,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rf8","uci":"f2f8","fen_after":"2b2r2/1pk5/2p5/P7/6p1/3PK3/1R2B3/8 w - - 2 49","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"d4","uci":"d3d4","fen_after":"2b2r2/1pk5/2p5/P7/3P2p1/4K3/1R2B3/8 b - - 0 49","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Be6","uci":"c8e6","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/2p1b3/P7/3P2p1/4K3/1R2B3/8 w - - 1 50","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"a6","uci":"a5a6","fen_after":"5r2/1pk5/P1p1b3/8/3P2p1/4K3/1R2B3/8 b - - 0 50","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"bxa6","uci":"b7a6","fen_after":"5r2/2k5/p1p1b3/8/3P2p1/4K3/1R2B3/8 w - - 0 51","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bxa6","uci":"e2a6","fen_after":"5r2/2k5/B1p1b3/8/3P2p1/4K3/1R6/8 b - - 0 51","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"48...Rf6","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/6p1/3PK3/1R2Br2/8 b - - 1 48","depth":24,"score_cp":-467,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rf6","uci":"f2f6","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p2r2/P7/6p1/3PK3/1R2B3/8 w - - 2 49","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rb1","uci":"b2b1","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p2r2/P7/6p1/3PK3/4B3/1R6 b - - 3 49","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Re6+","uci":"f6e6","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p1r3/P7/6p1/3PK3/4B3/1R6 w - - 4 50","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kd2","uci":"e3d2","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p1r3/P7/6p1/3P4/3KB3/1R6 b - - 5 50","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rg6","uci":"e6g6","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p3r1/P7/6p1/3P4/3KB3/1R6 w - - 6 51","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bf1","uci":"e2f1","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p3r1/P7/6p1/3P4/3K4/1R3B2 b - - 7 51","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":null},{"ply":97,"san":"49.Rb4","quality":"best","text":"49.Rb4 hits the g4 pawn along the fourth rank, and the bishop on e2 attacks it too. Black's rook will step to h5.","best":"b2b4","script":{"say":"49.Rb4 hits the g4 pawn along the fourth rank, and the bishop on e2 attacks it too. Black's rook will step to h5.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":24,"until":113,"brush":"red","from":"b4","to":"g4"},{"type":"arrow","at":102,"until":113,"brush":"yellow","from":"h2","to":"h5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"49.Ra2","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/6p1/3PK3/1R2B2r/8 w - - 2 49","depth":24,"score_cp":-222,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Ra2","uci":"b2a2","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/6p1/3PK3/R3B2r/8 b - - 3 49","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rh5","uci":"h2h5","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P6r/6p1/3PK3/R3B3/8 w - - 4 50","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"d4","uci":"d3d4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P6r/3P2p1/4K3/R3B3/8 b - - 0 50","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kd6","uci":"c7d6","fen_after":"2b5/1p6/2pk4/P6r/3P2p1/4K3/R3B3/8 w - - 1 51","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Ra4","uci":"a2a4","fen_after":"2b5/1p6/2pk4/P6r/R2P2p1/4K3/4B3/8 b - - 2 51","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rh3+","uci":"h5h3","fen_after":"2b5/1p6/2pk4/P7/R2P2p1/4K2r/4B3/8 w - - 3 52","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":98,"san":"49...Rh5","quality":"best","text":"49...Rh5 pulls the rook to h5, where it eyes the fifth rank and the a5 pawn. It also readies a check on e5.\n\nOn the board: Checking first.","best":"h2h5","script":{"say":"49...Rh5 pulls the rook to h5, where it eyes the fifth rank and the a5 pawn. It also readies a check on e5.","show":[{"title":"Checking first","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R4p1/3PK3/4B2r/8 b - - 3 49","depth":20,"score_cp":-248,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black could have checked before moving the rook up.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rh3+","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R4p1/3PK2r/4B3/8 w - - 4 50","comment":"49...Rh3+ checks the king along the third rank.","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kf4","uci":"e3f4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R3Kp1/3P3r/4B3/8 b - - 5 50","comment":"50.Kf4 steps up the board.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rh5","uci":"h3h5","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P6r/1R3Kp1/3P4/4B3/8 w - - 6 51","comment":"50...Rh5 swings the rook to h5.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Black could have checked before moving the rook up.","takeaway":"The computer says the plain rook move is clearly stronger, since the early check lets White's king step forward."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":60,"until":107,"brush":"green","from":"h5","to":"a5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"49...Rh3+","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R4p1/3PK3/4B2r/8 b - - 3 49","depth":20,"score_cp":-248,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rh3+","uci":"h2h3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R4p1/3PK2r/4B3/8 w - - 4 50","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Kf4","uci":"e3f4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/1R3Kp1/3P3r/4B3/8 b - - 5 50","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rh5","uci":"h3h5","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P6r/1R3Kp1/3P4/4B3/8 w - - 6 51","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Ra4","uci":"b4a4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P6r/R4Kp1/3P4/4B3/8 b - - 7 51","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rf5+","uci":"h5f5","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P4r2/R4Kp1/3P4/4B3/8 w - - 8 52","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kg3","uci":"f4g3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P4r2/R5p1/3P2K1/4B3/8 b - - 9 52","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":99,"san":"50.Rf4","quality":"good","text":"50.Rf4 offers some activity, attacking the pawn on g4 and eyeing the f-file. Black has a check ready: the rook to e5.","best":"a5a6","script":{"say":"50.Rf4 offers some activity, attacking the pawn on g4 and eyeing the f-file. Black has a check ready: the rook to e5.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":102,"until":117,"brush":"red","from":"h5","to":"e5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"50.a6","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P6r/1R4p1/3PK3/4B3/8 w - - 4 50","depth":21,"score_cp":-456,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"a6","uci":"a5a6","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/P1p5/7r/1R4p1/3PK3/4B3/8 b - - 0 50","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"bxa6","uci":"b7a6","fen_after":"2b5/2k5/p1p5/7r/1R4p1/3PK3/4B3/8 w - - 0 51","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Re4","uci":"b4e4","fen_after":"2b5/2k5/p1p5/7r/4R1p1/3PK3/4B3/8 b - - 1 51","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rg5","uci":"h5g5","fen_after":"2b5/2k5/p1p5/6r1/4R1p1/3PK3/4B3/8 w - - 2 52","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bf1","uci":"e2f1","fen_after":"2b5/2k5/p1p5/6r1/4R1p1/3PK3/8/5B2 b - - 3 52","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"a5","uci":"a6a5","fen_after":"2b5/2k5/2p5/p5r1/4R1p1/3PK3/8/5B2 w - - 0 53","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"50.Ra4","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P6r/1R4p1/3PK3/4B3/8 w - - 4 50","depth":21,"score_cp":-465,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Ra4","uci":"b4a4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P6r/R5p1/3PK3/4B3/8 b - - 5 50","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Re5+","uci":"h5e5","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P3r3/R5p1/3PK3/4B3/8 w - - 6 51","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Re4","uci":"a4e4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P3r3/4R1p1/3PK3/4B3/8 b - - 7 51","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rg5","uci":"e5g5","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P5r1/4R1p1/3PK3/4B3/8 w - - 8 52","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"a6","uci":"a5a6","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/P1p5/6r1/4R1p1/3PK3/4B3/8 b - - 0 52","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"bxa6","uci":"b7a6","fen_after":"2b5/2k5/p1p5/6r1/4R1p1/3PK3/4B3/8 w - - 0 53","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"50.Re4","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P6r/1R4p1/3PK3/4B3/8 w - - 4 50","depth":21,"score_cp":-465,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Re4","uci":"b4e4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P6r/4R1p1/3PK3/4B3/8 b - - 5 50","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rg5","uci":"h5g5","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P5r1/4R1p1/3PK3/4B3/8 w - - 6 51","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bf1","uci":"e2f1","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P5r1/4R1p1/3PK3/8/5B2 b - - 7 51","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rxa5","uci":"g5a5","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/r7/4R1p1/3PK3/8/5B2 w - - 0 52","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Re7+","uci":"e4e7","fen_after":"2b5/1pk1R3/2p5/r7/6p1/3PK3/8/5B2 b - - 1 52","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kd6","uci":"c7d6","fen_after":"2b5/1p2R3/2pk4/r7/6p1/3PK3/8/5B2 w - - 2 53","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":null},{"ply":100,"san":"50...Re5+","quality":"best","text":"50...Re5+ checks the king and forces it back. Black keeps his extra pawn and keeps pushing. The king will go to the second rank.\n\nOn the board: Checking on the third rank.","best":"h5e5","script":{"say":"50...Re5+ checks the king and forces it back. Black keeps his extra pawn and keeps pushing. The king will go to the second rank.","show":[{"title":"Checking on the third rank","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P6r/5Rp1/3PK3/4B3/8 b - - 5 50","depth":16,"score_cp":-109,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black had a different check, but it gives White time.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rh3+","uci":"h5h3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/5Rp1/3PK2r/4B3/8 w - - 6 51","comment":"50...Rh3+ checks the king along the third rank.","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Ke4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/4KRp1/3P3r/4B3/8 b - - 7 51","comment":"51.Ke4 steps up the board.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rh4","uci":"h3h4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/4KRpr/3P4/4B3/8 w - - 8 52","comment":"51...Rh4 defends the g4 pawn.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rf7+","uci":"f4f7","fen_after":"2b5/1pk2R2/2p5/P7/4K1pr/3P4/4B3/8 b - - 9 52","comment":"52.Rf7+ checks the king along the seventh rank.","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"Black had a different check, but it gives White time.","takeaway":"The computer says this gives away most of Black's edge, so the check on e5 was much stronger."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":106,"until":128,"brush":"yellow","from":"e3","to":"f2"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"50...Rg5","score":"Black is clearly better","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P6r/5Rp1/3PK3/4B3/8 b - - 5 50","depth":16,"score_cp":-344,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is clearly better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rg5","uci":"h5g5","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P5r1/5Rp1/3PK3/4B3/8 w - - 6 51","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rf1","uci":"f4f1","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P5r1/6p1/3PK3/4B3/5R2 b - - 7 51","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"g3","uci":"g4g3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P5r1/8/3PK1p1/4B3/5R2 w - - 0 52","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kf4","uci":"e3f4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P5r1/5K2/3P2p1/4B3/5R2 b - - 1 52","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rg7","uci":"g5g7","fen_after":"2b5/1pk3r1/2p5/P7/5K2/3P2p1/4B3/5R2 w - - 2 53","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Bf3","uci":"e2f3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk3r1/2p5/P7/5K2/3P1Bp1/8/5R2 b - - 3 53","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"50...Rh3+","score":"Black is better","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P6r/5Rp1/3PK3/4B3/8 b - - 5 50","depth":16,"score_cp":-109,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is better","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rh3+","uci":"h5h3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/5Rp1/3PK2r/4B3/8 w - - 6 51","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Ke4","uci":"e3e4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/4KRp1/3P3r/4B3/8 b - - 7 51","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rh4","uci":"h3h4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/4KRpr/3P4/4B3/8 w - - 8 52","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rf7+","uci":"f4f7","fen_after":"2b5/1pk2R2/2p5/P7/4K1pr/3P4/4B3/8 b - - 9 52","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kb8","uci":"c7b8","fen_after":"1kb5/1p3R2/2p5/P7/4K1pr/3P4/4B3/8 w - - 10 53","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rf8","uci":"f7f8","fen_after":"1kb2R2/1p6/2p5/P7/4K1pr/3P4/4B3/8 b - - 11 53","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":101,"san":"51.Kf2","quality":"good","text":"51.Kf2 steps toward the corner, trying to stop the passed pawn from running further. It does not work, because the pawn pushes with check.\n\nOn the board: King to d2.","best":"f4e4","script":{"say":"51.Kf2 steps toward the corner, trying to stop the passed pawn from running further. It does not work, because the pawn pushes with check.","show":[{"title":"King to d2","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P3r3/5Rp1/3PK3/4B3/8 w - - 6 51","depth":20,"score_cp":-498,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"White could have stepped away from the check to the other side.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Kd2","uci":"e3d2","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P3r3/5Rp1/3P4/3KB3/8 b - - 7 51","comment":"51.Kd2 steps away from the check toward the queenside.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rg5","uci":"e5g5","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P5r1/5Rp1/3P4/3KB3/8 w - - 8 52","comment":"51...Rg5 supports the pawn on g4.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rf1","uci":"f4f1","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P5r1/6p1/3P4/3KB3/5R2 b - - 9 52","comment":"52.Rf1 retreats the rook.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Be6","uci":"c8e6","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P5r1/6p1/3P4/3KB3/5R2 w - - 10 53","comment":"52...Be6 brings the bishop out.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"White could have stepped away from the check to the other side.","takeaway":"The computer rates this a little better for White than the king move that let the pawn advance with check."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":120,"until":138,"brush":"red","from":"g4","to":"g3"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"51.Re4","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P3r3/5Rp1/3PK3/4B3/8 w - - 6 51","depth":20,"score_cp":-491,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Re4","uci":"f4e4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P3r3/4R1p1/3PK3/4B3/8 b - - 7 51","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rg5","uci":"e5g5","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P5r1/4R1p1/3PK3/4B3/8 w - - 8 52","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"a6","uci":"a5a6","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/P1p5/6r1/4R1p1/3PK3/4B3/8 b - - 0 52","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"bxa6","uci":"b7a6","fen_after":"2b5/2k5/p1p5/6r1/4R1p1/3PK3/4B3/8 w - - 0 53","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bf1","uci":"e2f1","fen_after":"2b5/2k5/p1p5/6r1/4R1p1/3PK3/8/5B2 b - - 1 53","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rg6","uci":"g5g6","fen_after":"2b5/2k5/p1p3r1/8/4R1p1/3PK3/8/5B2 w - - 2 54","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"51.Kd2","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P3r3/5Rp1/3PK3/4B3/8 w - - 6 51","depth":20,"score_cp":-498,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Kd2","uci":"e3d2","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P3r3/5Rp1/3P4/3KB3/8 b - - 7 51","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rg5","uci":"e5g5","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P5r1/5Rp1/3P4/3KB3/8 w - - 8 52","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rf1","uci":"f4f1","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P5r1/6p1/3P4/3KB3/5R2 b - - 9 52","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Be6","uci":"c8e6","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P5r1/6p1/3P4/3KB3/5R2 w - - 10 53","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Ke3","uci":"d2e3","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P5r1/6p1/3PK3/4B3/5R2 b - - 11 53","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Re5+","uci":"g5e5","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P3r3/6p1/3PK3/4B3/5R2 w - - 12 54","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":3},{"ply":102,"san":"51...g3+","quality":"best","text":"51...g3+ pushes the pawn with check and drives the king away. The passed pawn is a huge asset now, and White's king will step to f3.","best":"g4g3","script":{"say":"51...g3+ pushes the pawn with check and drives the king away. The passed pawn is a huge asset now, and White's king will step to f3.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"circle","at":66,"until":132,"brush":"green","square":"g3"},{"type":"arrow","at":121,"until":132,"brush":"yellow","from":"f2","to":"f3"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"51...Rxa5","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P3r3/5Rp1/3P4/4BK2/8 b - - 7 51","depth":21,"score_cp":-458,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rxa5","uci":"e5a5","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/r7/5Rp1/3P4/4BK2/8 w - - 0 52","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bxg4","uci":"e2g4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/r7/5RB1/3P4/5K2/8 b - - 0 52","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Bxg4","uci":"c8g4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/r7/5Rb1/3P4/5K2/8 w - - 0 53","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rxg4","uci":"f4g4","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/r7/6R1/3P4/5K2/8 b - - 0 53","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Re5","uci":"a5e5","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/4r3/6R1/3P4/5K2/8 w - - 1 54","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Rg7+","uci":"g4g7","fen_after":"8/1pk3R1/2p5/4r3/8/3P4/5K2/8 b - - 2 54","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"51...Rg5","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P3r3/5Rp1/3P4/4BK2/8 b - - 7 51","depth":21,"score_cp":-449,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Rg5","uci":"e5g5","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P5r1/5Rp1/3P4/4BK2/8 w - - 8 52","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Ra4","uci":"f4a4","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P5r1/R5p1/3P4/4BK2/8 b - - 9 52","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"g3+","uci":"g4g3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P5r1/R7/3P2p1/4BK2/8 w - - 0 53","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kg1","uci":"f2g1","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P5r1/R7/3P2p1/4B3/6K1 b - - 1 53","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rb5","uci":"g5b5","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/Pr6/R7/3P2p1/4B3/6K1 w - - 2 54","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Ra1","uci":"a4a1","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/Pr6/8/3P2p1/4B3/R5K1 b - - 3 54","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":1},{"ply":103,"san":"52.Kf3","quality":"inaccuracy","text":"52.Kf3 is a slip. White should have simply taken the pawn with the king, which gives Black more to do. After the game move, the pawn goes on to g2 and becomes a real problem, and the evaluation fell from about minus four to minus seven. Black's rook will support it.\n\nOn the board: Take the pawn.","best":"f2g3","script":{"say":"52.Kf3 is a slip. White should have simply taken the pawn with the king, which gives Black more to do. After the game move, the pawn goes on to g2 and becomes a real problem, and the evaluation fell from about minus four to minus seven. Black's rook will support it.","show":[{"title":"Take the pawn","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P3r3/5R2/3P2p1/4BK2/8 w - - 0 52","depth":16,"score_cp":-442,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"The king could have taken the pawn at once and removed the danger.","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Kxg3","uci":"f2g3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P3r3/5R2/3P2K1/4B3/8 b - - 0 52","comment":"52.Kxg3 removes the dangerous pawn.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxe2","uci":"e5e2","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/5R2/3P2K1/4r3/8 w - - 0 53","comment":"52...Rxe2 wins the bishop for a pawn.","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rf7+","uci":"f4f7","fen_after":"2b5/1pk2R2/2p5/P7/8/3P2K1/4r3/8 b - - 1 53","comment":"53.Rf7+ forces the king back with a check.","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bd7","uci":"c8d7","fen_after":"8/1pkb1R2/2p5/P7/8/3P2K1/4r3/8 w - - 2 54","comment":"53...Bd7 blocks the check with the bishop.","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":true,"intro":"The king could have taken the pawn at once and removed the danger.","takeaway":"Black is still clearly better, but the passed pawn is gone and White gets some play."}}],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":144,"until":266,"brush":"red","from":"g3","to":"g2"},{"type":"arrow","at":255,"until":266,"brush":"yellow","from":"e5","to":"g5"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"52.Kxg3","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P3r3/5R2/3P2p1/4BK2/8 w - - 0 52","depth":16,"score_cp":-442,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Kxg3","uci":"f2g3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P3r3/5R2/3P2K1/4B3/8 b - - 0 52","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxe2","uci":"e5e2","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/5R2/3P2K1/4r3/8 w - - 0 53","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rf7+","uci":"f4f7","fen_after":"2b5/1pk2R2/2p5/P7/8/3P2K1/4r3/8 b - - 1 53","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Bd7","uci":"c8d7","fen_after":"8/1pkb1R2/2p5/P7/8/3P2K1/4r3/8 w - - 2 54","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Kf3","uci":"g3f3","fen_after":"8/1pkb1R2/2p5/P7/8/3P1K2/4r3/8 b - - 3 54","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Re1","uci":"e2e1","fen_after":"8/1pkb1R2/2p5/P7/8/3P1K2/8/4r3 w - - 4 55","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"52.Kg2","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P3r3/5R2/3P2p1/4BK2/8 w - - 0 52","depth":16,"score_cp":-484,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Kg2","uci":"f2g2","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P3r3/5R2/3P2p1/4B1K1/8 b - - 1 52","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rxe2+","uci":"e5e2","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/5R2/3P2p1/4r1K1/8 w - - 0 53","comment":"","capture":true,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Kxg3","uci":"g2g3","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P7/5R2/3P2K1/4r3/8 b - - 0 53","comment":"","capture":true,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Re8","uci":"e2e8","fen_after":"2b1r3/1pk5/2p5/P7/5R2/3P2K1/8/8 w - - 1 54","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Rf7+","uci":"f4f7","fen_after":"2b1r3/1pk2R2/2p5/P7/8/3P2K1/8/8 b - - 2 54","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kb8","uci":"c7b8","fen_after":"1kb1r3/1p3R2/2p5/P7/8/3P2K1/8/8 w - - 3 55","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":3},{"ply":104,"san":"52...Rg5","quality":"good","text":"52...Rg5 protects the pawn and brings the rook to the strong g-file. Black is gradually tightening the net, and White's bishop will drop back to f1.","best":"g3g2","script":{"say":"52...Rg5 protects the pawn and brings the rook to the strong g-file. Black is gradually tightening the net, and White's bishop will drop back to f1.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":132,"until":148,"brush":"green","from":"e2","to":"f1"}]},"alternatives":[{"title":"52...g2","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P3r3/5R2/3P1Kp1/4B3/8 b - - 1 52","depth":38,"score_cp":-755,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"g2","uci":"g3g2","fen_after":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P3r3/5R2/3P1K2/4B1p1/8 w - - 0 53","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Rf7+","uci":"f4f7","fen_after":"2b5/1pk2R2/2p5/P3r3/8/3P1K2/4B1p1/8 b - - 1 53","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Kb8","uci":"c7b8","fen_after":"1kb5/1p3R2/2p5/P3r3/8/3P1K2/4B1p1/8 w - - 2 54","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Rg7","uci":"f7g7","fen_after":"1kb5/1p4R1/2p5/P3r3/8/3P1K2/4B1p1/8 b - - 3 54","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bh3","uci":"c8h3","fen_after":"1k6/1p4R1/2p5/P3r3/8/3P1K1b/4B1p1/8 w - - 4 55","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"a6","uci":"a5a6","fen_after":"1k6/1p4R1/P1p5/4r3/8/3P1K1b/4B1p1/8 b - - 0 55","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}},{"title":"52...Be6","score":"Black is winning","line":{"fen":"2b5/1pk5/2p5/P3r3/5R2/3P1Kp1/4B3/8 b - - 1 52","depth":38,"score_cp":-748,"score_mate":null,"verdict":"Black is winning","moves":[{"ply":1,"san":"Be6","uci":"c8e6","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P3r3/5R2/3P1Kp1/4B3/8 w - - 2 53","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":2,"san":"Bf1","uci":"e2f1","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P3r3/5R2/3P1Kp1/8/5B2 b - - 3 53","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":3,"san":"Rg5","uci":"e5g5","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P5r1/5R2/3P1Kp1/8/5B2 w - - 4 54","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":4,"san":"Kg2","uci":"f3g2","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p1b3/P5r1/5R2/3P2p1/6K1/5B2 b - - 5 54","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":5,"san":"Bd5+","uci":"e6d5","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b2r1/5R2/3P2p1/6K1/5B2 w - - 6 55","comment":"","capture":false,"check":true,"checkmate":false,"castle":false},{"ply":6,"san":"Kg1","uci":"g2g1","fen_after":"8/1pk5/2p5/P2b2r1/5R2/3P2p1/8/5BK1 b - - 7 55","comment":"","capture":false,"check":false,"checkmate":false,"castle":false}],"narrated":false}}],"playedRank":3},{"ply":105,"san":"53.Bf1","quality":"best","text":"53.Bf1 tucks the bishop back, where it covers the g2 square in front of the pawn. Black's bishop will come out to e6.","best":"e2f1","script":{"say":"53.Bf1 tucks the bishop back, where it covers the g2 square in front of the pawn. Black's bishop will come out to e6.","show":[],"after":"","sayMarks":[{"type":"arrow","at":46,"until":117,"brush":"red","from":"f1","to":"g2"},{"type":"arrow","at":102,"until":117,"brush":"green","from":"c8","to":"e6"}]},"alternatives":[],"playedRank":1},{"ply":106,"san":"53...Be6","quality":"best","text":"53...Be6 puts the bishop on the long diagonal toward a2, and the pawn on g3 is ready to march to g2. The computer sees Black as clearly winning, and the game ends here with a win for Caruana.\n\nThe game ended here: Caruana won with Black. The lesson: Small slips add up in the endgame: one king move that left the passed pawn alive let Black's extra material take over. When you are worse, take away the opponent's best plan first before seeking counterplay of your own.","best":"c8e6","script":{"say":"53...Be6 puts the bishop on the long diagonal toward a2, and the pawn on g3 is ready to march to g2. The computer sees Black as clearly winning, and the game ends here with a win for Caruana.","show":[],"after":"The game ended here: Caruana won with Black. The lesson: Small slips add up in the endgame: one king move that left the passed pawn alive let Black's extra material take over. When you are worse, take away the opponent's best plan first before seeking counterplay of your own.","sayMarks":[{"type":"ray","at":46,"until":191,"brush":"green","from":"e6","to":"a2"},{"type":"arrow","at":88,"until":191,"brush":"red","from":"g3","to":"g2"}]},"alternatives":[],"playedRank":1}],"engine":"Deep computer analysis (median depth 22)","start":{"openPly":91,"keyPly":96,"autoTo":106}}